Ghost in the Shell: Solid State Society - Movie Review

Movie Review
40 followers
Ghost in the Shell's stand-alone complex Solid State Society was not a theatrical film.
This is not Ghost in the Shell 3 as some people who aren't familiar with stand-alone complex
TV show think it is.
This is a continuation of that TV show, takes place after the second season of that show.
And with a title that long, it's no mystery that fans have just taken to calling this
thing G-I-T-S-S-S-S, because that's a long-ass title.
This is one of the more obscure Ghost in the Shell entries because it wasn't a theatrical
movie and so a lot of people have never seen this.
And you have to have seen stand-alone complex the show to fully appreciate this movie because
as I said, it is a continuation of that show.
So if you've seen the first two seasons of stand-alone complex, which by the way is a
pretty good show, then you're going to have more appreciation for this film than if you
just went into it blind.
And despite the fact that it wasn't theatrical, I'm reviewing it because I've reviewed every
single other Ghost in the Shell movie, including the new movie that was based off of the Arise
show.
And so without having this in there, it kind of feels like, you know, it kind of feels
like it's not complete.
You know, it's OCD, and I have OCD about completionism, completionists, isms.
I'm reviewing it.
So since this was not a movie made for theaters, I know going in that the animation is not
going to be on par with those first two movies.
All that being said, the digital-to-cell animation combined here I think is actually handled
better than Innocence.
Innocence was like, wow, we can do digital stuff and CG animation, and they relied on
that far too much in Innocence, and it was probably for me personally the weakest element
of that film.
Here, except for a few sequences on a highway with cars, which really did not look good
at all when it first came out, and especially not today, besides those sequences, the digital
animation is actually pretty good in this anime.
This film is very much so a tribute to Mamoru Oshii's first Ghost in the Shell film.
There's something called the Puppeteer that seems to be controlling people, making them
commit suicide.
Also, there's a ton of children that have gone missing that seem to be linked into some
strange thing that's involving elder care.
And all of this comes to a head with Togusa, who's now the leader of Section 9 as he works
with Bato to try to solve these crimes, and the Major's been gone from Section 9 for two
years, and there's even some suspicion about her involvement with all of these things.
There's a lot to love about Solid State Society, and a lot of fans really do love this movie,
especially if you're a big fan of stand-alone complex, The Show.
There's also a lot to complain about, and while I'm not too much of a hardcore complainer
when it comes to these movies, there's some elements of this film that really do get under
my skin.
But we're going to start with the positives first.
There's something that's actually really refreshing about this movie, and what it is when you
watch the first two, even though they're not really linked.
If you watch Ghost in the Shell 1 and Ghost in the Shell 2, and then watch Solid State
Society, the fact that this film is really more so a traditional action thriller is somewhat
of a breath of fresh air, because the first two are very sci-fi heavy.
This film is more like James Cameron's Aliens to Ridley Scott's Alien, which was far more
of a sci-fi monster movie, where Aliens was more of an action film.
This film has a lot of action in it when compared to the first two.
There's a lot of dialogue scenes too, and a lot of technobabble and very exposition
heavy sequences where you have to pay attention to every word and make sure that you are following
this plot that does get very heavy handed.
But this film is refreshingly more of just an action film, which was kind of fun to watch
because there's a lot of really intense sequences, there's a great sniper scene, there's a very
white knuckled scene involving Togusa and his daughter inside a hospital, and the entire
finale is extremely exciting and very fun.
And whenever the major shows up and kicks the lot of ass, well that's always awesome
to watch.
Also, one name, Yoko Kanno.
I've located him.
In regards to anime, she's my favorite composer of all time, and any of her songs in this
movie that involve lyrics and singing are really gorgeous, although I do think she falls
back too much on electronica here.
So in this film, there's a lot of suspicion about what exactly is making people commit
suicide.
Is the major involved in some way?
Is it an online hacker?
Or is it this?
First off, I got the medical results back on the 16 kids we ran checkups on, and there
were no signs that they'd been injected with micro-machines.
I just kept picturing the evil villain attempting to shove tiny toy cars into children.
For me, this film falters in two ways, the biggest one being that it has far too many
callbacks to the original Ghost in the Shell.
In the beginning of the film, the major jumps off of a ledge and then uses her thermoptic
camouflage, just like in the first film.
Even the final line of this movie, and if you've never seen it, no spoilers, is essentially
the exact same as the final line of the first film, and even the shot is the same.
And in the first film, the antagonist was known as the Puppet Master, and in this film,
it's known as the Puppeteer.
Japanese anime does this a lot.
They don't seem to have as much of a problem recreating various stories and repackaging
them into other movies.
Even Standalone Complex did that by releasing small OVAs, or Original Video Animations.
They were basically summations of the first two seasons of Standalone Complex.
And this movie kind of feels like a mishmash of Standalone Complex and the first Ghost
in the Shell.
And while it works sometimes, my biggest issue with this movie is its ending.
It doesn't seem to understand how to end.
There are so many unanswered questions, which a lot of hardcore Ghost in the Shell fans
have forgiven as very smart and clever, and sometimes you don't always get all the answers,
and sometimes things are just left up in the air.
But to me, I just see lazy screenwriting.
When you write a screenplay and you have no idea how to answer any of the interesting
questions that you've brought up throughout your film, and it just sort of ends like,
we'll never know, well that's just lazy screenwriting.
And trust me, I've seen this movie multiple times, and I've watched featurettes and anything
that I can really get my hands on from the creators talking about what their vision was
for this movie, and I've listened to tons of fan theories, but in the end, there are
a lot of unanswered questions in this film that leave you hanging, and not in a very
good way.
But in the end, I really appreciate the animation here, a lot of really fun action sequences.
I like seeing Togusa take the lead, it was a different turn for his character, and that
was a lot of fun.
And I love the interplay between Bato and the Major, because there's definitely something
going on there under the surface, but they're both sort of so self-righteous that they can't
admit it.
Most of Yoko Kanno's score is beautiful and really fun to listen to, and overall, if you're
a Ghost in the Shell fan, you can watch this movie, especially if you appreciate the standalone
complex show.
But in the end, this isn't good enough to become remarkable or a classic.
It's really just a nice companion piece with standalone complex.
I'm going to give this film a B minus.
Guys, thank you so much as always for watching my Ghost in the Shell series.
The new Ghost in the Shell film comes out very soon, let's hope it's good.
If you missed my other videos on the first two films, I'm going to have links for those
in a second here.
You guys are the best.
Thank you so much as always for watching, and if you like this, you can click right
here and get Stuckmanized.
