What made the Ancient Egyptians Fat and Sick?
30 Video Views·Dec 1, 2024
What was making the ancient Egyptians fat? The architect Hemiunu's statue suggests that he
was overweight with a serious case of man boobs. National Geographic reported that King Tut had
large deposits of fat on his hips and breast-like fat clumps on his chest. And the mummy of Hatshepsut
was very fat and probably had diabetes. It was found as early as 1911 that Egyptian mummies had
In fact, more than half of the 43 middle-aged mummies examined had heart disease. What was
making them so sick? We'll get to that story but first we need to connect a few dots.
Imagine you're going on a date with someone you're really into. You've arrived at the restaurant 10
minutes early because you need to use the bathroom. After some time, unfortunately,
you lose your battle with constipation. You leave the toilet defeated and off you go to greet your
date bloated and gassy. Now imagine this uncomfortableness being a common occurrence for
10 years straight except it's far worse. Your gut is inflamed to the point that you have open wounds
and polyps on the lining of your intestines. You get stomach pain and cramps, diarrhea,
there's blood in your stool, and you're often drained and tired. This is a disease called
ulcerative colitis which a 71 year old man was suffering through. His health was pretty bad.
He was also taking insulin and pills for his diabetes and high blood pressure.
What's interesting about this man is the unconventional diet he used to actually put
both his ulcerative colitis and diabetes into remission, which by the way are both
diseases thought not to have a cure. What's also interesting is why his endocrinologist
recommended he stop that oddly magical diet and do a different one. I learned about this man
after interviewing Dr. Paul Mason of Sydney, Australia on Skype. The guidelines by and large
do not reflect evidence-based science. They're distorted facts, they're not based on science,
and following them does not lead to optimal health. Dr. Mason shared several surprising
and somewhat controversial points but this 71 year old man's story happens to back up each
of those points. So let's look at the new diet that drastically improved the man's health
and we'll look at how it came to be that a medical professional, his endocrinologist,
would recommend that he go back on the type of diet that probably made him sick in the first place.
So the 71 year old man's new diet had plenty of saturated fat, yet his endocrinologist
recommended he stop and eat a diet low in saturated fat. You've probably heard a lot
about saturated fat by now but let's look at the logic and history that led to health
professionals making this recommendation. At the time the logic was based on a flawed
hypothesis supported by junk science and that was what we call the diet heart hypothesis. It was by
a guy called Ancel Keys who was a physiologist and an epidemiologist and he had the hypothesis
that serum cholesterol and saturated fat were causally related to heart disease.
And this was based on some experimental data, for instance what happens if you feed rabbits which
are herbivorous a high saturated fat diet. So clearly this has no relevance for humans at all
and it's based on an epidemiological study which has now been well and truly debunked called the
seven countries study where he basically cherry picked data from some countries that he liked the
results of. Before Ancel Keys released the seven countries study he first presented a graph in 1953
showing data from six countries that found that the more fat a group of people ate the more heart
disease they had. It made for a very convincing chart. However just four years later in April 1957
biostatistics PhD Jacob Yeroshalmi and medical doctor Herman Hilleboe presented a strikingly
different chart using the same pool of data that Ancel Keys was using. Their chart showed that the
more fat people ate the less heart disease there was. How could that be? Well Ancel Keys didn't
have data for only six or seven countries there was data for 22 countries. When you look at the
data for all 22 countries there's no convincing relationship between fat and heart disease.
Regardless four years later a 1961 issue of Time magazine featured Ancel Keys and explained to the
public that eating saturated fat raises your cholesterol and this causes heart disease.
At the end of the article it says Keys' cholesterol was 209. That's funny because President Dwight
Eisenhower had a much lower cholesterol of only 165 when he had his heart attack in 1955.
A couple years later in a 1987 New York Times article competing for a real estate with a woman's
summer suit ad famous heart surgeon Dr Michael DeBakey said that his 30 years of experience
with over 15,000 patients led him to conclude that high cholesterol was not the cause of heart disease.
So if we were to take saturated fat for instance there's been more than 10 systematic reviews and
which is where we actually compile all the data together looking at saturated fat and
polyunsaturated fats and on balance they find in favor of saturated fats.
Higher saturated fat consumption is not associated with worse health.
Another change that helped the 71 year old man fix his health was a drastic reduction in carbs.
His endocrinologist on the other hand after seeing his excellent lab results
recommended instead he eat more carbs like whole grains as well as fruits and vegetables.
This high carb high grain recommendation starts at least as early as 1977 when dietary goals for
the United States was released to the public thanks to George McGovern. These goals driven
by the idea that fat and cholesterol cause heart disease recommended reducing saturated fat to just
10% of the diet and raising carbohydrates to 60% of the diet. However there was plenty of
opposition to this at the time. I have pleaded in my report and will plead again orally here
for more research on the problem before we make announcements to the American public.
I said to the professor that I was working with you know this is not right. Animal fat's not
causing this and this is not what the data says. You know there were imminent scientists of the
time saying this is nonsense there is no good scientific evidence that either fat or cholesterol
you know is at the root of heart disease. Back in the early 80s Louise Light was the
leader of a group of top level nutritionists specifically hired by the USDA to develop an
eating guide. After pouring through all kinds of nutrition data with her team
Louise's guide recommended at most three to four servings of grains per day.
Not long after submitting the report she was shocked to see that they made some drastic
revisions like increasing the grains from three to four to six to eleven servings a day.
As she wrote in her book Louise told her boss the agency director that these changes would be
disastrous and would mean unleashing obesity and diabetes upon Americans. Despite her objections
they decided to stick with their version. What was the reason they gave her? Well it had nothing to
do with health. They said that jacking up the grain recommendation would cut costs for the
food stamp program. Fruits and vegetables were expensive grains were cheap. Despite Louise's
protests in 1991 the food pyramid was released recommending six to eleven servings of grains
every day. Even before this though the original high carb recommendation from 1977 was taking its
toll on people's health. If you look at the obesity trends people started to get fat pretty
much right when George McGovern issued his report recommending low-fat high-carbohydrate diets.
We replaced steak and pork chops for pasta, eggs and bacon for cereal with skim milk,
and grandma's all-butter cookies for Snackwell's low-fat cookies. And we became fatter than ever.
Are there any consequences you know domino effects of this idea that you should not eat saturated fat
you shouldn't eat you should cut this the fat off your steaks you shouldn't have full-fat yogurt
you need to have skim milk what are the downstream effects of that? Well I mean we've only got three
main sources of macronutrients which is you know carbohydrate protein and fat and you can only eat
so much protein I mean it's uh and you cut out the fat in the diet then that really leaves only
one thing and it means you have to increase your carbohydrate intake and what most people don't
realize is that carbohydrates are literally molecules of sugar joined together even the
complex carbohydrates you know the brown rice the sweet potato the wholemeal bread
they are literally chains of glucose sugar molecules joined together and when you ingest them
they get absorbed into your circulation you end up with what we call elevated blood sugar levels
and long-term and high levels of carbohydrate consumption we know are causally associated
with a condition called insulin resistance which eventually leads to diabetes. And what's the
problem in diabetes? Well everybody knows right it's having excess glucose this particular type
of sugar in the bloodstream and when we eat more carbohydrate we put more sugar in the bloodstream
that sugar's got to come from somewhere right so if I explain this to most of my patients you know
they'll often look at me and say so why don't I just stop eating carbohydrate and you know what
that is the solution it's it's really that simple this is uh treating diabetes 101 and yet this
concept that carbohydrates are made of glucose they cause a rise in our blood sugar therefore
they're not good for us is beyond the grasp of most doctors. Going back to the fat and sick
Egyptian mummies what did they eat? Well as Dr. Michael Eades explains a modern nutritionist would
say the ancient Egyptian diet was fantastic the basic ancient Egyptian diet had some plant oils
they also fished and ate some fowl and had the occasional serving of red meat but the diet was
mostly carbohydrates primarily bread they also had fruits vegetables and honey as explained in a paper
in the journal of Egyptian archaeology the most important food of the Egyptians was bread in fact
you can find several figurines depicting people grinding wheat as well as art depicting people
harvesting wheat or preparing bread Egyptians with their bread-based diet were essentially
following the 1991 USDA food pyramid some people have argued that well it was only the rich who
could afford to be mummified or have statues of their fat selves made and only the rich could
afford to buy and eat many saturated fat containing animal foods so that's why the mummies had heart
disease however scientists have a really interesting way to determine what ancient people ate
called stable isotope analysis by looking at how much of an isotope of nitrogen called nitrogen 15
is in the bones of a person or animal and then comparing that to the nitrogen 15 content of
plants in the area they can tell whether an animal or person's diet had more meat or more
plants in it Dr. Eades explains that this kind of stable isotope analysis found that the Egyptians
got only 29 to 19 percent of their protein from animal sources not only was most of their protein
coming from plants but their diet as a whole was mostly grains and plants which means very little
saturated fat the researchers described it as being close to a lacto-ovo-vegetarian diet and as
this paper explains there was a surprising lack of difference in the stable isotope composition
between social classes meaning that everyone rich or poor was generally eating a high carb
low saturated fat diet I remember when I was planning on doing a low carb diet a couple
people saying you can't just cut a whole food group out you can't just not eat pasta not eat
bread you need carbohydrates is that true do we is there a a biological requirement for dietary
carbohydrate so I will say right now and I'll say it explicitly there is no need for dietary
carbohydrate in other words the theoretical minimal consumption of carbohydrate that is
consistent with good health is zero now this doesn't mean that some tissues in our body don't
need to use carbohydrates they don't need to use glucose which is a carbohydrate but it means we
don't need to eat it because if our body needs it it can make it it can make it from certain amino
acids it can make it from the glycerol backbone which forms the triglyceride type of fat so we do
not need to eat carbohydrate the notion that we need at least 130 grams of carbohydrates a day to
support our neurological function is based on nothing but junk science so I will again say
we do not need to eat dietary carbohydrate it is not an essential nutrient that might be shocking
to hear that the requirement for dietary carbohydrate is zero yet again this 71 year
old man's case proves the point his diet had virtually zero carbohydrates his diet was in
fact an all meat diet no carbs no grains no fruits not even vegetables I know that for some of you
saying an all meat diet cured this man's diabetes and ulcerative colitis might sound like I just
said you could cure eczema and baldness by eating Elmer's glue but bear with me for a moment and
let's look at it in terms of what he's not eating as Dr. Paul Mason explained not eating carbohydrates
would be good for lowering his blood sugar which would improve his insulin resistance and improve
his diabetes in fact the endocrinologist even acknowledged in the report that the reason he
wouldn't need his diabetes medication metformin is because the reduction of carbs improved his
blood sugar but this man had a painful constipating bowel condition yet we all know that fiber is good
for our bowels it's good for pooping yet this man's new no fiber diet healed his bowel condition
well on the topic of carbohydrates what about fiber isn't that a carbohydrate that's good for
you it's good for your digestion well I mean technically yes so well yes it is a carbohydrate
but no it's actually not that good for you and that's going to surprise a lot of people so the
definition of fiber is that it's an indigestible carbohydrate indigestible as far as your body
goes it can't be absorbed or broken down by your body and there's a lot of myths surrounding fiber
it only comes from plant foods and it's often thought that it can prevent and treat constipation
which is the most common belief around it and it would surprise a lot of people to know
there's an absolute paucity of studies that actually support that so to my knowledge there's
been no randomized controlled studies on the effects of fiber on the symptoms of constipation
and I say that very precisely so the symptoms of constipation means things that bother people
things like pain and bloating and bleeding so there has been some evidence that shows that
having fiber can actually increase the bulk of your stool there have been some studies that show
that having fiber can actually increase what will reduce the transit time meaning that things transit
through your gastrointestinal tract a little bit quicker but when we actually have a look at the
symptoms that patients come and ask me about they say doc I've got bloating it hurts I've got pain
you know I've had some bleeding can you help me there's been no evidence at all that demonstrates
that fiber is beneficial in fact when we have a look at the best available evidence on this
there was an experimental study which was performed in 2012 and subjects with constipation
found that complete elimination of dietary fiber that is an intake of zero grams of dietary fiber
led to complete improvement in all the symptoms of constipation in 41 patients
so this this is absolutely you know absolutely staggering so the statistical significance
of this study was through the roof and these people were compared to people on various other
levels of fiber intake from high fiber moderate fiber and low fiber diets and you could see a
clear dose response relationship between the symptoms of fiber symptoms of constipation
and the amount of fiber intake and when you think about it logically so what is constipation so
effectively constipation is trouble passing fecal matter you're trying to pass something
through a small hole so is it really logical that making that something bigger is going to make it
easier to pass through a small hole when you think about it that's like adding more cars to a traffic
jam and expecting the traffic to suddenly clear it just defies logic now many people can handle
tons of fiber in their diet but some people just can't process fiber as well and in fact we
shouldn't expect high fiber to be the norm for humans if you dig into our evolutionary past
you'll see that our gut shrank significantly around the time when we got these huge brains
the brain is a very energy expensive organ so we needed to make things more efficient
to achieve this efficiency the gut shrank and the idea is that this happened as we began hunting
animals for nutrient dense meat and energy dense fat more calories and more nutrients in a smaller
package means we can sacrifice all that gut real estate and use resources on building a huge brain
the reason gorillas for example have these gigantic bloated bellies is because they are
packing their guts with difficult to digest fiber all day gorillas have a huge colon that is
specifically for fermenting fiber to produce short chain fatty acids these fatty acids are an energy
source in this way a lowland gorilla will get 30 to 60 percent of their energy needs just by
fermenting fiber in their big colon the human digestive tract shrunk so much that the small
human colon on the other hand can only provide at best two to nine percent of our energy needs
from fermenting fiber i guess one of this raises another important point is that we've often put
plants up on a pedestal as being uniquely nutritious and uniquely healthy and yet plant
they do contain things like oxalates and phytates and tannins and things that actually impair
nutrient absorption they're literally called anti-nutrients and they can cause these other
problems within the body so you know we have a look at wheat-based products and we know that gluten
actually increases what we call intestinal permeability in everybody now people with
celiac disease are more susceptible to the side effects because of the degree of intestinal
permeability that they already start with but everybody is vulnerable to these now i realize
how blasphemous it sounds to question the greatness of plants but oddly enough this 71
year old man went on a diet that had literally no plants and his health dramatically improved
in contrast many people do fine with tons of plants look at vegan triathlete rich roll for
example he seems to be doing pretty well but plants do have substances in them that not everyone can
handle you wouldn't give wheat bread to a celiac patient you wouldn't give a peanut to someone with
a peanut allergy some people are very sensitive to something called oxalates oxalates are compound
found in many plant foods for example leafy greens sally norton had been struggling with
chronic pain fatigue and other mysterious symptoms for 30 years since the age of 12
she finally went on a low oxalate diet simply cutting out unsuspecting plant foods like spinach
and almonds finally resolved these terrible problems she had been struggling with for decades
oxalate poisoning is actually something farmers have to deal with they have to prevent their
herds from eating too many oxalate containing plants the animals can develop issues as serious
as kidney failure from this humans are told that the brassica kale is a superfood but ranchers
caring for a herd of grazing animals are told to beware of the health risks of kale the point
is to say that we shouldn't expect all people to be perfectly able to handle all plants when we
when we actually have a look at some a lot of the nutrients in plant foods we have to have a look at
biological value so if we take iron for instance we get heme iron from animal foods and we get
non-heme iron from plant-based foods like spinach but there's really no comparison in terms of how
effective they are able to be utilized by the body so non-heme iron in spinach is is very difficult
for our body to actually assimilate and to deal with and we see this across the line across the
board we we have vitamin a that comes in different forms and the the form of vitamin a we have from
animal foods is so much more biologically useful than what we get from plant foods
we're often told this or that fruit or vegetable is chock full of this or that nutrient leafy
greens have folate and calcium carrots have choline avocados have vitamin b6 beans have iron nuts have
zinc mushrooms have riboflavin that's great but an egg yolk has all of those sometimes the vitamins
in plants aren't what we think they are for example people often think carrots are a good
source of vitamin a because they refer to the beta carotene in carrots as vitamin a but the reality
is that that beta carotene needs to be converted in the human body into vitamin a so take a look
at my mom's blood test her beta carotene level is very high where her vitamin a is actually in the
low range what's going on well again beta carotene in plants isn't vitamin a how well you convert
that beta carotene into actual vitamin a depends on your genes some people say carrots are a good
source of vitamin a but at least when it comes to my mom and probably myself carrots are not
a good source of vitamin a but we've got in our head that plant-based foods are more nutrient
dense and essentially more nutritious than other foods and if we don't have a side of vegetables or
fruit on our plate then we must be missing out the simple fact is that's not the case animal
foods are more nutrient dense than plant-based foods by the way aside from those nutrients i
already mentioned an egg yolk has an egg yolk also has vitamin a and i mean actual vitamin a it
not to mention egg yolks also have vitamin d and e and thiamin and b12 and pantothenic acid
and betaine and phosphorus and selenium oh wait but we're not supposed to eat eggs especially
not egg yolks because of the cholesterol so to recap this man went on an all meat diet that
is high saturated fat no carbs no vegetables diet this strange diet mysteriously healed his
diabetes ulcerative colitis and high blood pressure despite the drastic health improvements
though his endocrinologist recommended he go back on a high carb reduced fat diet and limit his red
meat consumption essentially the endocrinologist recommendation was to do the opposite of the diet
that actually solved his health problems fruits and vegetables are perfectly fine for most people but
it was surprising to me that the endocrinologist didn't at least investigate why the new low carb
high fat high protein diet was so effective and instead gave him the same high carb low fat diet
advice that people have heard since the 1970s this wave of bad advice and close-mindedness
seems to stem entirely from Ancel Keys's diet heart hypothesis the idea that saturated fat
causes heart attacks this poorly supported idea is still taught as fact to doctors today
you were saying that essentially in the foundational teaching that people are given
when they are on their path to become a medical doctor they're taught this right that the diet
heart hypothesis is correct and this is what causes heart disease this is accepted as fact
certainly certainly it was when i was in medical school and i was actually
provided with some of the the curriculum notes from a local university here a couple of years ago
and i was quite surprised to see that the lipid heart hypothesis was still going strong then so
unless things have changed in the last two years and i'm almost certain they have not
then that would be the status quo today here's the problem if you start to understand the root
biochemical the root cause biochemistry of all of this you then have to understand that saturated
fats are not dangerous for our health and then the whole house of cards falls down i i think in a way
this uh the situation we're in with such atrocious dietary guidelines could never
have occurred if doctors had a better understanding of biochemistry
when you use a credit card to pay for something the merchant receives the money immediately
you're essentially making a promise to the credit card company that you'll pay them later
for the money they're dispersing on your behalf in general risk has been transferred from the
merchant to the credit card company all you need is the numbers associated with your credit card
account but can you think of a downside to using credit cards when shopping online this is a quiz
from brilliant's cryptocurrency course if you'd like to know the answer and learn more about the
rules of the world around you you'll have to check out brilliant if you're naturally curious or want
to build your problem solving or analytical abilities you'll enjoy brilliant's thought
provoking math science and computer science content designed to break complex scientific
concepts down into understandable chunks with over 60 interactive courses in math science and computer
science brilliant will grow your understanding of our modern world with a structured and engaging
approach check out brilliant.org slash wil and the first 200 people to follow my link
will get 20 off the annual subscription

