Joining us today is Mark Clifford. He’s The president of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation (https://www.thecfhk.org/), and the author of the new book The Trouble Maker: How Jimmy Lai Became a Billionaire, Hong Kong's Greatest Dissident, and China's Most Feared Critic.
Don't forget to subscribe to the channel and hit that bell icon to get notified when new videos come out: https://bit.ly/3u1eKSZ
[Music]
wondering what you think of the what
what's happened to the media in Hong
Kong because you said you came at the
Far Eastern Economic Review and you've
been involved in some of the other
English language papers in Hong Kong
what what do you think is happening now
to the media well it's sad I mean
there's no free media I was the
editor-in-chief of of uh both the South
China Morning Post and the standard
where I was also the publisher and you
know I'd be lying if I said there was no
political pressure this was back in the
early 2000s but you know it was okay it
was tolerable you could you could have
pretty pretty gutsy and good reporting
by the way Apple Daily Jimmy lies
newspaper was a lot gutsier than the
English language uh press and well they
had a lot more people and they just they
just had an ethos of really pushing
under uncovering corruption you know
uncovering all sorts of wrongdoing as
well as pushing for democracy those days
are finished you know you can't there's
no real criticism um you know I don't
really want to names but if you look at
some of the coverage uh of um of Jimmy
Li's trial in the English language press
it's it's pathetic it's just so slanted
and um you know it's just you know it's
sounding like a government mouthpiece I
mean there was a an English language
publication was came out of China called
China Daily that was uh the English
language uh version was set up around
the time of the the Handover from
Britain to China in 1997 and look that's
fine it's a Chinese government paper you
read it you want to see what the
government line is that's fine
unfortunately the South China Morning
Post which was one of the leading
Publications one of the leading English
language newspapers in Asia has become a
lot more like it had Ambitions after it
was bought by Alibaba had Ambitions to
become a kind of Chinese language uh New
York Times well sorry to say it's become
a lot more like people's daily than the
New York Times yeah well I I actually do
like China Daily because they criticized
us as being disgraceful anti-china
garbage good you must be doing something
right I mean you know what the
government line is right uh we did put
that on a t-shirt um so for for uh there
are still some media companies that are
I guess maybe trying to do maybe not
exactly what Apple da is doing but like
I'm thinking of uh Hong Kong Free Press
which is in
English uh the The Epic Times which is
uh in Chinese there those are both not
pro Beijing right uh why have they not
been targeted as hard as Apple Daily or
have they been in we just it's it hasn't
been publicly reported very much well
let me say I mean you know I kind of
loath
to say too much except that I would say
that the people who are running those
Publications um are th are know feel
that they're skating on very thin ice
and they just they don't I mean when we
were running Apple Daily we didn't wake
up every morning thinking of you know we
push the button on this story it going
to mean that we're going to be shut down
I think uh there are unclear lines but
there are lines that you can't go beyond
now and I I think that uh there are
other places by the way in in Chinese um
that are are doing decent reporting good
reporting I think they're trying to keep
it more narrow trying to keep it away
from politics trying to be very factual
um and uh you know work within
constraints that um you know didn't
exist 10 years ago uh so I don't want to
make it sound like it's um
well it's not as bad as mainland China
but there's there's much much less room
for maneuver and I think dayto day these
these uh news organizations just you
know they just don't know how much
longer they they don't know when things
might end and that's the other thing
that's just you know quite unbelievable
uh uh we were killed when John Lee who
was now the chief executive or the mayor
was the secretary for security and he
sent a letter to us under his authority
as the secretary for security saying
that he had he suspected he had reason
to believe that we'd broken the National
Security Law no evidence didn't mention
a single article but he said because he
thought that he was going to freeze our
bank accounts so you know we had 600,000
think of it 600,000 digital subscribers
we were doing pretty well we were just
in the middle actually really were in
far along on the road of making the
transition from paper to digital
overnight zero cash coming in because
the banks were threatened with with jail
for their Executives if they processed
any credit card payments for for us um
we couldn't pay the electricity bill we
couldn't pay ink we couldn't do anything
and by the way that that case that John
Lee's beliefs have actually not been
tested in court they never found Apple
Daily guilty I guess that's in a way
implicitly what they're trying to do now
but you think of one man say so just
shut things down you know we've seen
Stan news and other Publications that
have just been shut down NOS shut down
under a variety of of legal or qu IL
legal pretext so I'm really happy that
things like Hong Kong Free Press epic
times and some some other ones are doing
what they can but the parameters are
much much narrower and their position is
much much more
perilous what was the moment that you
realized you needed to get out of Hong
Kong well I didn't actually and that's a
really interesting question because it
was something that people were talking
about after the national security law
was announced and even some some before
that I I had a monthly column in the in
South China Morning Post I was running a
group called The Asia Business Council
and people would say to me even some of
my board members at the Asia Business
Council um uh because I was doing a lot
publicly with with Jimmy especially
after the national security law came in
and they were very nice about it like
are you okay and I'm like I'm fine you
know but I think implicitly I realized
later they were like are you really okay
are you really sure what you're doing
and um I actually uh kind of randomly
but I thought maybe I should just kind
of lighten up a bit and I I've been in
Hong Kong 28 years and I I got a
shipment together and moved you know
kind of books and furniture and art just
in case I needed to leave in a hurry
then that shipment arrived and uh I
thought well I should go and you know
unload the shipment and it was during
covid so it you know kind of mixed up
with all the the covid material and then
a couple weeks later Jimmy's jailed and
they mentioned my name and honestly I
probably still would have gone back
except I didn't want to go through two
or three weeks of quarantine and then
you know of course after they raided
apple and and Rec there was no thought
of going back but um it's it's really F
funny um you know people often use the
analogy of a frog in boiling water as
the water gets warmer and warmer and the
Frog you know doesn't jump until it's
too late actually a lot of people have
done research on this frogs do jump they
actually get out really quickly it's
people that don't get out because you
can't believe that this is actually
happening I mean you look around seems
like the same people same judges same
courts they're wearing the wigs that's
all the same veneer of respectability
and then bam 250 people in a newsroom
take off your your leadership oh 6
months eight months later 500 you know
policed in The Newsroom you can't
believe it's so unreal and then all of a
sudden Jimmy lies in jail all of a
sudden 70 you know 75 people are dragged
away all of a sudden your newspaper shut
down I mean it's just like one thing at
a time and it's like you're in shock you
actually just can't process that you
can't imagine that a place that was this
free would just be throwing some of its
finest citizens in jail it's it's it's
you know so I can't claim any pre at all
actually you know if things have gone
another way maybe I wouldn't have left I
don't
know uh you so you when you were when
Abal Dy was raided by the Hong Kong
police you were not in Hong Kong anymore
the first time they were raided which
was August 10th um 2020 uh six five six
weeks after um the national security law
came in place I was in Hong Kong and um
we had at an emergency board of
directors meeting uh by phone um partly
because of covid partly because of where
people were during the course of this
emergency board meeting became clear I
was the only board meeting board member
in Hong Kong not in custody so that you
know does get you thinking um so um uh I
I but by the time that the newspaper was
closed in you so it was eight months
later I guess or 10 months later in June
2021 I was in the
states I know oh go ahead no no just it
was just again it's just surreal I was
watching the live streaming of yeah you
know first police coming in uh I didn't
see that live but you know as they were
as they were shutting the newspaper down
and and we we printed a million copies I
me we were trying to keep the any way we
could to keep the paper going but you
know couldn't pay the bills couldn't pay
the staff bills and then then the
government to their it's just
unbelievable they they went after us I
think I still have I don't know if
they're still open or not four different
investigations against us as directors
like we direct the company so I asked
some of the you know my persecutors like
you think we as directors didn't do a
good job of the company well what about
the fact that you know we couldn't have
access to our bank accounts what about
the fact that the labor department was
suing us because we didn't pay our
employees we had plenty of cash but we
couldn't access the bank account so the
government's like that's not our problem
you didn't pay pay your employees it's
this kind of petty lawfare where you use
you use the veneer of legality to to
accomplish a political end so it was
just unbelievable and and you know
horrific uh experience I mean it was
traumatic for me but more so you know
you have kind of survivors guilt I mean
besides Jimmy there's six other people
who Apple Daily colleagues apple and and
next digital the parent company who um
who've pled guilty and are essentially
being held hostage to Jimmy's trial um
uh I don't know why they haven't senten
then they've been holding them for three
plus years so yeah very very traumatic
even though me personally I don't didn't
really suffer in in this sense of you
know being jailed or anything