1400km (870 mile) EV v Diesel challenge! There was just $5 between them...the results surprised!

Cars Arena
18 followers
G'day, I'm Paul. So you've heard from everyone, EVs, range anxiety, you can't drive them long
distance. Well I wanted to put that theory to the test and today we're going to drive
an EV, a diesel Audi and also a hybrid support car from Adelaide to Sydney which is a long
distance and we want to see exactly how inconvenient it is. Come into this shot,
Elbors. Elbors, our co-founder of CarXpert, is going to be joining me. Elbors has a collection
of supercars and knows absolutely nothing about driving gently. This is correct, this is correct,
which is why they've given me the diesel long range which I've turned off the air con for
and I've put the pressure up as high as they possibly go because I cannot lose to this man.
Yes, so part of our aim today is to figure out exactly how much longer it's going to take me to
do the trip in an EV. The EV that we have is a Kia EV6 Long Range, it's the base model and this is
it is basically the entry level to the Q5 range but it also has a 70 litre tank,
it averages less than 5 litres per 100km, so it's going to be really interesting to see how it goes
and exactly how much time I have to waste as part of this. So yeah, the whole thing, we're going to
film as much as we can along the way but we will sit down later on to go through the results and
give you a better idea of exactly how long everything has taken and how inconvenient
the charging infrastructure has been. So as Alborz mentioned, we've checked tyre pressures,
what did you go up to? Look, they started on 31, they're now 46. 31? My god, that is bad.
It was very comfortable, now it's not so much. Okay, well the theory behind that is high tyre
pressure, less rolling resistance, more range. With the EV6, I've left it at 36 which is the
recommended tyre pressure simply because I want to see how it goes. You've brimmed that,
that's at 100%. I've got my M&Ms and Red Bull, let's get out of here. Yes, quite a lot of that
stuff actually. We've packed enough for about three weeks away so we'll see how we go.
So one thing I just realised is you may not actually know Adelaide all that well and if
you don't, Adelaide is like at sea level but to get onto the freeway out of Adelaide, you go up
these like super steep hills for a long time and obviously that is killing my consumption here. I
was at sort of around 17 kilowatt hours per 100km in and around Adelaide but now I'm sort of
sitting around that 22 marker and it's dropped my range slightly as well but I am trying to
use, oh god, here's the 100 sign. I'm just gradually grouping up from 60 to 100 here.
One of the tools I use during the trip is an awesome website called A Better Route Planner.
It's a free site that takes weather, topology and realistic EV driving range into account
to give you an idea of where and how often you're going to need a charge.
I'll be using it as a guide for this trip to figure out where and when I need to stop.
So one thing I didn't realise about this Audi is that it doesn't have active cruise control. Now
that's because this is the absolute base model. However, that kind of ruins my plans so this is
now the real test of my right foot. Now, elbows, I deliberately picked the inland route because
it gets us as close as possible to his realistic driving range.
For him to make the 1400km trip, he needs to consume less than 5 litres of fuel per 100km.
Yes, he can obviously stop anywhere to fill up his car pretty quickly, unlike me in the EV,
but he is taking the challenge seriously and to make sure he doesn't run out of fuel,
he has decided to drive a little slower to make sure he actually makes it to Sydney.
Okay, so we are charging. This is a 350kW charger. This is capable of charging 800v
and up to about 250kW peak. Now these are interesting because these actually have
liquid cooled cables. That's why when you put your hand on that, you can actually feel it
vibrating a bit because it is putting fluid through this cable to keep it nice and cool.
So we plugged in at 80% and it's even pulling like 80 or 90kW there at 80% which is pretty
impressive. So the suggestion here is to take us to about 95% and this should be enough to
get us to our next stop which is a little while away.
So we are on the road. I just thought I'd just say how much I love this country. It is,
yeah, I love doing road trips like this because you get to see,
you get to see Australia and you get to see exactly what it's all about.
How are we travelling? So I have jacked the speed up a little bit. When we were leaving
Adelaide obviously it was quite hilly and a lot of speed cameras and stuff like that. So
what I've done now is put the speed up to real speed. When I say that I'm not using the indicated
speed on the speedometer, I'm using a GPS speed here and that is not only increasing the energy
consumption, it's decreasing our range. So we're now currently averaging 22kWh per 100k since we
charged. That figure is 20.1kWh since we left Adelaide. So you can see that things are picking
up a little bit now. But yeah, it's all going well so far. Really quite comfortable in this.
The local ride and handling tune they did on EV6 compared to Ioniq 5 that missed out and all that
stuff, I think it's pretty evident. And here in country Australia where you're getting much,
a greater variety of road conditions, this feels far more at home than something like an Ioniq 5
does. So yeah, pretty impressed with it so far and I think Alvorz has been cheating.
And there is a fast approaching electric Kia.
Is that you ahead of me?
That's right, I'm saving fuel.
Well, I'm going to not save fuel and go around you.
Oh, there he goes.
Because I'm going to go to the charger and hopefully by the time I get there,
I can have some juice before you turn up and for us to have some lunch.
Well, I'm considering increasing my average speed to 91 just to get that extra one kilometre.
I wasn't even speeding that much either. Good idea. Well, I will see you at Oyun and
we'll see how we go. Enjoy looking at the back of the EV6.
Oyun is the next stop on our charging journey. The only issue here is that the charger is a
pretty slow charger for a DC charger and it's going to take a little while for the EV6 to
actually get to its full charge and the recommended charge capacity to reach our
overnight stop in Hague, which is in New South Wales.
I might just keep going.
Because you're just going to have to wait all that extra time you've made up.
After discovering there was nothing open for food in Oyun,
Alvorz ditched us and I decided to pull the plug a little early to catch up to him.
This is totally unexpected, but the road to Sydney from where we were is actually closed.
They've now told me to go back like 38 kilometres to another town to go on this
insane detour, which I cannot work out where it is and I'm wasting incredibly precious
millilitres of my premium diesel fuel.
So as Alvorz started explaining, the bridge crossing the Murray River in Piangel was closed.
That closed at about 10 minutes before we arrived, so our detour added about 70 kilometres to the
trip after having to drive south to Naya to cross the river and then back again to connect to the
original road that we're on. After getting around the road closure, I finally caught up with Alvorz
again. He was pretty hungry, again, so I threw him a banana.
As we got closer, the range kept creeping down thanks to the cold weather.
I have 2% battery left and five kilometres range and I have four kilometres left to drive.
My nav is basically taking me direct to the charger and I will arrive with
virtually nothing left in the tank, so yeah.
Hey, it was our overnight stay and there was a slow-ish DC charger in town.
Thankfully, there was nobody there at that time of night and we were able to plug the EV6 up to
charge at 50 kilowatts while we went to the truck stop to eat dinner. Literally two kilometres range,
1% battery left. Yeah, that detour really screwed us. So average ended up being 20.8
kilowatt hours per 100km. The decision to take the car off the charger a little earlier probably
wasn't the best idea because if we, I guess, had kept it in a little bit longer, we wouldn't be in
this situation. And in addition to that, if the roadworks weren't happening and the road wasn't
closed, we also wouldn't be in this situation either. But yes, it is one of the benefits of
having many fuel stations. You can just fill up a car, whereas with an EV, you literally have to
make it to the destination. Otherwise, you're going to find a power plug in a random spot to
So it's the last day. I just thought I'd just mention something here. So I'm brimming the car
now to get it up to 100% just to make sure we're all good for the rest of the trip. The rest of the
trip is actually all very fast charges. So it means I'll only be stopping for short periods of
time and there's less range anxiety because we're getting closer to Sydney and there's more and more
infrastructure. But I think this is just a good example. Last night we got here with 1% and there
was one charger in this town. So had I have basically arrived here needing the charge and
there was other EVs waiting here, I probably would be out of luck to be honest. So yeah,
this is part of the problem with EV infrastructure in Australia. There are just limited fast charging
stations around. And it does mean that on busy weekends and stuff like that, you may actually
be waiting instead of just being able to turn up and plug up like we've been able to.
My strategy yesterday was to stick to about 90 kilometers an hour to keep the fuel usage down.
I've managed to do about 4.7 litres per 100 so far. We had a bit of a detour which added about
60km to the journey, which is really frustrating because that was my buffer zone. And I'm going
to have to find a truck today to basically just coast behind as close as legally possible all
the way to Sydney to really reduce my aerodynamic drag. And hopefully that'll give me another
one or two litres of fuel, which is what this is going to come down to. But no matter what happens,
With a little over 700km to go, things get better here for me because all of the
charges from here on in are 350kW fast chargers. And according to a better route planner,
we don't actually need to stop for very long with each of these charging stops.
We are just rolling into Tarkata. So a funny point or interesting point,
this is the midway point between Melbourne and Sydney. So there you go. Irrelevant for
our Adelaide to Sydney journey, but just a fun fact. So part of the problem is because
these cables are so short and there's so much tension on them, there's a locking mechanism
in the car that locks the cable in position. And then if there is tension on it, it basically
doesn't allow it to lock and it means it won't start. So you can see now it's actually locked
in properly. That should actually kick off. So this should actually really pick up a bit
of pace because we're at 20% state of charge. The ramp profile here is quite strong.
And also because this is like the proper 350kW charging setup, the battery's already
warm because we've been driving sort of all day. It should really start to pick up some steam.
Yet again, Alborz decided to leave the second he finished his Chico roll instead of waiting for us,
but it didn't take long for me to reel him in again and pass him as we got closer to Sydney.
Next stop for us is Sutton Forest for a quick top-up. This will be our last stop before
arriving in Sydney and brimming both the Q5 and the EV6. So let's quickly talk about inconvenience.
We've been here now for a little while waiting for this to charge, but it hasn't actually been
all that inconvenient, especially on the 350kW chargers. They're actually quite fast in terms of
how quickly they're plumbing energy back into the battery to give you enough range for that next
stretch. It really is only when you're on the 50kW chargers or the 75kW that it takes a little bit
more time. But even now, I've just arrived here, plugged up, gone inside to do a quick wee, and
back into the car. So yeah, pretty impressed with that so far. Next stop is going to be Sydney,
where I'm going to brim this and then we'll figure out exactly how much this has cost compared to the
diesel. Hey, we made it. I can't believe we made it actually. 80km left still in the tank and we're
in Sydney. Finally made it. So I found a charger here in this shopping centre. I'm going to fill
this thing up now. That last leg was fantastic because it was basically downhill from Sutton
Forest. It used like 14kWh per 100km, which is pretty remarkable. So we used barely any battery
at all. So I'm going to brim it now. We'll have a look at how much this costs compared to diesel.
We'll see who the winner is. So we've arrived back at the car expert office. People working
hard in the background there. It's time to go over our results. And before I do, I just want
to reiterate, yes, obviously, if you were driving an internal combustion car, you could have easily
stopped countless times. But I really did want to set a challenge here to Alborz to get to Sydney
in the hope that he did break down somewhere. But I think you wanted to set a challenge where
I would definitely lose and I didn't. That was the main thing. Yeah, it's very disappointing.
Now, in terms of how much everything cost, tell me how much it cost you to fuel your car because
we brimmed it at the start, brimmed it at the finish as well. And this will give us an indication
of exactly how much fuel you use for that trip. Yes. So I used sixty two point three three litres
and it cost one hundred and thirty dollars and eighty three cents. Now, I just want to point
out that diesel is super expensive at the moment. Yes. And under normal circumstances, it might not
have been that bad. OK, that means you averaged four point three eight litres per 100 k's.
Now, here's something surprising. My trip, I added up all of the charging stops that I had to make.
Keep in mind, one of the major charging stops, which was our stop at Hay, where the car almost
ran out of electricity, that was free of charge. So with without that one sort of charged included
at one hundred and twenty five dollars and fifty six cents. And I should point out also that I did
fourteen hundred and twenty point six kilometres. Yeah, right. And you were a little bit less than
that because I was a guinea pig finding all the routes that were closed. Yes. Yes. Where that
detour popped up, you had to go do some hunting. So you ended up doing 20 k's less than me.
More than me. Yeah. More than me. Sorry. Yeah. And it was only five dollars cheaper for me.
And I had a look at the numbers here. If we had to have charged at Hay on a fast charger and paid
for it, I would have actually used it would have cost me more to do that same trip, which really
surprised me, because the whole thing about EVs is they're meant to be cheaper. Lots of things keep
surprising you when they're so obvious. You paid more for the car and you paid more to charge it.
And you got to spend heaps of time waiting around while it kept going. Well, you know,
I didn't really wait around that long. So just to recap, it took probably the final time when we
stopped the stopwatch. It was 15 minutes between you filling and me charging. I think there was a
bit of pity stopping there for you along the way. I had to stop and eat because I wouldn't want him
to go hungry. So that is very interesting. I was, as I said, surprised by that. It shows you that
you can still drive an internal combustion car, whether it's an efficient diesel or a hybrid,
and it still be cheaper than an EV. But it also does show you that you can do this type of trip
in an EV as well. It is expensive, but you can actually go regional like we did and do a long
distance trip. Had we have gone the more popular way, which is closer to Melbourne, they're all
fast chargers and I wouldn't have had to stop anywhere near as long as I did at Odeon and Hay.
Always excuses. Always excuses. That is true. And I did like the EV6. It was quite nice.
Look, to be honest, my car was the base model of that Audi and it didn't even have active cruise.
I was surprised it had power windows. So if I had to pick which car I was in,
I would have definitely picked the Kia. I think you had a much more comfortable drive.
Yeah.
Something being overtaken about 30 times during that trip was very frustrating.
Yes. And while I was doing 90 k's an hour to make sure he actually made it to Sydney,
I would blast past him regularly at nearish the speed limit to make sure he didn't beat me.
Yeah. In a real world circumstance, I would do 110, which was the speed limit.
Yeah.
And I would have just stopped and refueled and I would have got there way faster than him.
It was still a fun challenge anyway. So let us know in the comments section below,
did you enjoy the video? What do you want to see us doing next? Because I quite enjoyed our road
trip. I liked assaulting you with a banana. I thought that was good fun.
I think it still hurts to be honest.
So let us know down there. If you did enjoy this video, please make sure you like it and
you share it with your mates. And if you haven't done so already, subscribe to
the channel and press the bell icon. But until next time, see you later.
See you later to that camera.
I did. I did. I did it first. I'm a consummate professional. I like you.
Thanks a lot.
