Imperial Collapse (461 - 476)

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
12 Video Views·Nov 30, 2024
The death of Majorian left Ricamar in effective control of the Roman Empire.
He decided to install a new puppet emperor through which he could exercise control,
settling on an unassuming man named Livius Severus, whom he had elevated by the Senate in 461.
But just because Ricamar said so did not mean that this guy really was the emperor of Rome.
The governor of Gaul, Aegidius, certainly did not think so. Nor did Marcellinus in Dalmatia.
Both revolted against Ricamar's authority, leaving the puppet Livius Severus in control of nothing
else but Italy. The barbarian peoples reconquered all of their old territory after the death of
Majorian. The Goths again swarmed Hispania. And the Burgundians made aggressive moves
into southern France once again. During the reign of Severus, Italy was ravaged
by the raids of the Vandals. The empire had no fleet to fight off the raiders,
who disembarked and pillaged the countryside before sailing away with incredible swiftness.
Ricamar was the real power behind the throne. But he showed no interest in campaigning,
neglecting to reassemble the Roman army into a meaningful fighting force.
In 465, Livius Severus died, having done literally nothing.
There was a succession crisis in the aftermath. Gaiseric and Ricamar had a preferred candidate,
a man named Olibrius. But the eastern emperor Leo I eventually had his way,
promoting a senator named Anthemius and sending him to the west.
With the support of Marcellinus, Anthemius marched into Rome in 467 and was declared
emperor. Ricamar, who could not risk war with the eastern empire, accepted the new emperor
and married Anthemius' daughter. With the rulers of the western and eastern
empires on good terms, Leo decided to solve Rome's most troublesome problem.
The Vandals. He organized an unprecedented campaign to destroy Gaiseric's kingdom.
The fleet was mostly constructed in the ports of the eastern cities, but the west made major
contributions to the land forces that were to land in Africa. In total, there were perhaps
100,000 soldiers and sailors taking part in the expedition. In 468, this massive fleet set sail.
Suffice it to say that disaster struck at the Battle of Cape Bon. As the Romans were attempting
to land, Vandal fireships fell upon their position and threw their fleet into chaos.
The Vandal ships then swept in and sunk much of the Roman fleet,
killing tens of thousands of Roman soldiers. The expedition retreated in disarray,
having suffered a defeat of catastrophic proportions.
This defeat was the end of the western empire's hopes of existing in any form. After the final
failure of collaboration between the east and west, the eastern emperors abandoned the west
as a lost cause, and at that point its days were numbered. The western treasury was out of money,
the western army was now missing thousands of soldiers, and the Vandals remained a terror
on the seas. Anthemius did attempt some campaigns against the Goths in 470. However, the Goths had
become too powerful. When the Romans crossed into regions of Gaul that were occupied by the Goths,
the Roman army was outmaneuvered and completely destroyed by Gothic forces.
Ricomer, who had moved to northern Italy with a separate army of foreign federate soldiers,
maintained a separate center of power. In 472, after relations broke down with Anthemius,
Ricomer called upon the Burgundians, who were ruled by a friendly king named Gundabad,
to help him overthrow the emperor. They marched into Italy, and together with Ricomer's forces,
they overwhelmed Anthemius' soldiers on the outskirts of Rome. The emperor was captured
and beheaded. Ricomer had Olybrius promoted as his puppet emperor in July. He had no time to enjoy
his power though, dying just a month later. The puppet Olybrius also died in late 472.
With Ricomer gone, his ally Gundabad became the supreme authority in the west,
elevating a man named Glycarius in 473. He only reigned for a year though, because Leo again sent
a favored candidate named Julius Nepos with an army, and Glycarius was forced to abdicate in 474.
Nepos, after a brief reign, was forced to flee Italy when the general Orestes revolted,
placing his son Romulus Augustulus on the throne. Nepos fled to Dalmatia,
where he continued to rule as the emperor recognized by the east. A year later in 476,
another general named Odoacer launched his own revolt, killing Orestes and seizing control
of Italy's military forces. Finally looking to break the endless cycle, Odoacer decided
that he would not rule through a puppet emperor. He sent a proposal to Leo, offering to rule Italy
as the official agent of imperial authority. Romulus Augustulus was formally deposed on the
4th of September of the year 476, putting an end to the reign of emperors in the west.
To tie up some loose ends, Julius Nepos continued to rule in Dalmatia until 480,
when he was assassinated. The territories in northern Gaul held out until 486,
under a king named Cyagrius. After that, imperial authority in the west was truly gone.
So that's when the fall of the west ended. But when did it start? Why did it happen?
How did it happen? Could it have been prevented? So many questions. Let's try to answer some of
those questions. When did it start? Well, I'm honestly not sure. There are plenty of dates we
My answer is somewhere during the 3rd century. Before the crisis, the empire was unified and
stable and relatively unaffected by foreign invasions. During the crisis, foreign peoples
broke across the frontiers and began disrupting the Roman economy by destroying farmland,
ruining trade, and forcing people to adapt to a violent and unstable world. All of this eroded
the complex Roman economy. Currency became worthless, the volume of trade and exchange
collapsed, and the unified Roman world increasingly splintered into separate centers of power.
While the 4th century was a respite thanks to the decline in foreign invasions,
the issues that started plaguing Rome during the 3rd century never really went away,
and they all returned during the 5th century to bring the west down. Why did it happen?
That's a significantly more difficult question to answer, so I think it'll help just to discuss
some of Rome's problems. First, the splintering of central authority. This wasn't really a problem
in those days that Rome had peace because there was never more than one major military threat
at a time. When Marcus Aurelius spent a decade fighting the Marcomanni, there was not a single
revolt against his rule because his absence from the rest of the empire was not an issue.
Once multiple threats started facing the empire during the crisis period, the inadequacies of
central authorities became obvious when the emperors repeatedly failed to defend all threats
to the empire properly. Thus, many regions became more autonomous out of necessity, looking for
their own defense. This happened on a large scale as with the Gallic and Palmyrean empires forming
their own armies, and on a small scale, with dozens of small towns and cities investing vast
sums in constructing walls. Second, the rise of foreign threats. The wave of foreign invasions
during the crisis was bad, but it did not succeed in bringing down the Roman west, and it was dwarfed
by the wave of migrations that came in full force during the 5th century. Hundreds of thousands of
people sought new land to settle on and saw the rich Roman world as a healthy target. The Roman
empire had systems to integrate migrating peoples, but under such stress by so many people for so
many years, these systems collapsed and the peoples forced their way in. Third, the decline of the
economy. Even during the reign of the five good emperors, the silver purity of Roman coins was
declining. This was due to a massive trade imbalance with China, India, and the rest of the east.
Massive deposits of Roman coins have been found in India and Asia and even Japan. The same cannot
be said of Chinese coins in the Mediterranean. For centuries, precious metals were being sucked
out of the Mediterranean region, debasing the Roman coinage and harming the Roman economy.
More important than the loss of precious metals, though, was the destruction of the interconnected
Roman economy. This economy, with the Mediterranean serving as a superhighway,
allowed an unprecedented volume of goods to flow to and from previously disconnected
regions of the world. And the whole Roman world benefited from access to goods, services,
and ideas from thousands of miles away. Once violent threats came across the frontiers,
trade over long distances became far more dangerous and far less frequent, breaking down
the complex economic connections that sustained the Roman world.
Each of these problems made the other problems worse. It was a vicious cycle that eventually
led the Roman Empire to circle the drain to its doom. And while the Eastern Empire was
strong enough to survive, the Western Empire was not. As I have hopefully shown,
the deposition of the last emperor was merely a recognition of a reality that had already long
been in place. An imperial regime that had been powerless for years. An empire that had been
economically moribund for decades. A Roman world that had been falling apart for centuries.
