"Socrates was born in Athens, Greece, around 470 BC, during a time of great intellectual and cultural flourishing. Little is known of his early life, but he was the son of Sophroniscus, a stonemason, and Phaenarete, a midwife. He was likely trained in his father's craft, but his interest soon turned towards philosophy, a pursuit that would define his life.
Socrates lived through the Golden Age of Athens, experiencing both the height of its cultural achievements and the turmoil of the Peloponnesian War. He served as a hoplite (infantry soldier) in the Athenian military during several campaigns, demonstrating bravery and resilience, which he often referenced in his teachings about virtue and personal integrity.
Philosophical Method and Beliefs Socrates is perhaps best known for the Socratic Method, a form of cooperative dialogue involving questions and answers designed to stimulate critical thinking and illuminate ideas. His approach was characterized by asking probing questions to challenge assumptions, expose contradictions, and encourage deeper understanding.
Ethics and Virtue: Socrates' philosophy centered around the idea that the pursuit of virtue is the highest aim of human life. He believed that true knowledge leads to virtuous behavior, and that those who act wrongly do so out of ignorance, not malice. His famous assertion, ""The unexamined life is not worth living,"" reflects his belief in the importance of self-reflection and the pursuit of wisdom. Knowledge and Ignorance: Socrates often claimed that he was wise only because he recognized his own ignorance. Unlike others who believed themselves knowledgeable, Socrates understood the limits of his own understanding. This humility formed the core of his teaching, emphasizing that genuine wisdom begins with acknowledging one's ignorance. Confrontation with Athenian Society Socrates was a vocal critic of Athenian society, questioning everything from politics to popular opinion, which earned him both followers and detractors. He was particularly skeptical of democracy, as he believed that decision-making should be based on expertise and rational inquiry, not the whims of the uninformed masses.
His public debates with prominent Athenians often exposed their lack of true understanding, making him an unpopular figure among those in power. Socrates' relentless questioning and disregard for conventional wisdom ultimately made him a controversial figure in Athens.
Trial and Death In 399 BC, Socrates was brought to trial on charges of corrupting the youth of Athens and impiety—failing to acknowledge the city's gods and introducing new deities. His accusers, Meletus, Anytus, and Lycon, argued that his teachings undermined traditional values and posed a threat to the stability of the state.
At his trial, as recorded by Plato in the ""Apology,"" Socrates defended himself eloquently but defiantly, refusing to abandon his mission of seeking truth and questioning established norms. He was ultimately found guilty by a jury of his peers and sentenced to death by drinking hemlock.
Execution: Socrates spent his final days in prison, engaging in philosophical discussions with his followers, as described in Plato’s dialogue ""Phaedo."" He remained composed and committed to his ideals until the end, accepting his fate with calmness. His death marked a profound moment in Western philosophy, symbolizing the conflict between free thought and societal conformity. Legacy and Influence Though Socrates wrote nothing himself, his influence is primarily known through the dialogues of Plato and the writings of Xenophon. Plato, in particular, used Socrates as a central character in many of his dialogues, preserving his mentor's ideas and methods for future generations.
Philosophical Impact: Socrates’ emphasis on critical thinking, ethics, and the pursuit of self-knowledge laid the foundation for much of Western philosophy. He is considered the father of moral philosophy and inspired both his contemporaries and later thinkers to explore questions of virtue, justice, and the nature of knowledge. The Socratic Legacy: Socrates’ influence extended beyond philosophy; he became an enduring symbol of the quest for intellectual integrity and the courage to question authority. His willingness to die for his beliefs has inspired countless others to stand up for truth and justice, making his life and death a powerful example of personal conviction.
Information sourced from Wiki, Gutenburg, JSTOR, primary and secondary sources. All information is congruent with archaeological and history evidence at the time of recording."
Imagine a life in dedication to questioning the very essence of virtue, justice, and what is good,
with nothing but voice and reason. This was the life of Socrates, born around 470 in Athens,
Greece, whose relentless pursuit of truth and ethical understanding lay the foundation for
Western philosophy. Renowned for his Socratic method, a form of dialogue that challenges
assumptions and fosters deep, critical thinking, Socrates revolutionized the way that we approach
knowledge and morality. Unlike many of his contemporaries, however, he left no written
records. Instead, these profound ideas were immortalized by his dedicated student, Plato,
ensuring that his teachings on justice, virtue, and the importance of an examined life
continue to resonate even to our modern age. But things were not all smooth sailing.
His unwavering commitments to his principles led to his trial in 399 BC,
where he was accused of impiety and corrupting the youth of Athens.
Choosing to accept his death sentence by drinking hemlock rather than renouncing his beliefs,
Socrates has become a martyr for intellectual freedom and ethical steadfastness.
Today, we go back to ancient Greece, and we talk about Socrates, no doubt a name that you've heard
of. Now, of course, we don't know too much about his life, mainly about his thoughts, which come
to us second hand. It's just the nature of the time period. And hopefully, we'll honor some
beautiful tablet with a full life story one day. But I'm not holding my breath. So with that in
mind, we'll begin with the biography, and a description of his trial and death. And then
we'll go into some specifics, discussing a few points of philosophy, which I assume is why you're
here. We'll try to get a good understanding of things like the Socratic method, Socratic ignorance,
the examined life, these kinds of things. So let us now begin. So Socrates, because he was born
to relatively well-off Athenians, being Sophroniscus, a stone worker, and Phanderate, a midwife,
in the Athenian deme of Allopace in 470 or 469. Socrates was naturally an Athenian citizen.
And that means a lot. Certainly the center of the world for a great many things around 470 BC.
Now, as was traditional, he lived near his father's family and received a portion of his
father's estate. And he did quite well for himself. This allowed him to live very comfortably,
without having having to worry about money, food, anything like that. The rules and practices of
Athens informed his upbringing, of course, there was a culture to be observed. And of course,
they had their own educational standards, especially among the well-off Athenians.
And just like them, he had his own private tutors in reading, poetry, writing,
and even gymnastics. Add to that a little bit of music, and you've got quite a well-rounded
intellectual. It is unclear which of his two marriages actually occurred first,
because he did have two of them. He wed Xanthippe in his 50s. And then he wed the
daughter of Aristides, a statesman from Athens. We're not quite sure exactly when.
We do know that his first wife did bless him with three sons. And according to Plato,
Socrates also served his country honorably during the Peloponnesian War, where he stood out in three
separate campaigns. Now the Athenians, particularly the younger ones, they were captivated by
Socrates. But his friends, close ones, who dared to say it, made fun of him quite a lot,
because of his famously unattractive features. Apparently he had bulging eyes, a large stomach,
and a flat, turned-up nose. I mean, you've seen the thumbnail. It's not very flattering.
Even Socrates' own comfort and physical attractiveness were things that did not
matter to him. He wore only one worn-out coat, barely showered, and went barefoot everywhere.
He didn't completely abstain from food, drink, and physical pleasures, but he did cut back.
Despite the widespread and acceptable attraction to youth in ancient Greece,
Socrates repressed his desire for young men, because, as Plato explains, he was more concerned
with educating their souls. Unlike many older men in Athens, Socrates refrained from seeking
relations with his followers. In the constant political squabble of Athens, he was critical
of both sides, the Democrats and the oligarchs. It is reasonable to assume that Plato's portrayal
of Socrates in the works Apology, Phaedo, Symposium, and Crito is a pretty accurate
representation of the real Socrates, because these works' depictions of Socrates are consistent with
other sources. Now, in 399 BC, Athens was subject to the death of Socrates, following his trial for
immorality and corrupting the youth. On his last days behind bars, he was summoned by admirers and
friends, who tried to get him to escape, but he wouldn't have a bar of it. Consistent with his
sentence, he consumed poison the night before he died, and the following morning he was gone.
The last thing he said was reportedly, Crito, we owe a rooster to Asclepius,
as recorded in Phaedo, and he wanted them to make sure that the debt was settled.
The formal accusations against Socrates dated all the way back before 399 BC,
when he was accused of impiety, for failing to worship the gods of Athens, and for corrupting
the minds of the youth. Socrates' defense of the trial was, well, fruitless. After a majority
verdict from a jury of hundreds of male Athenians, they found him guilty.
He followed tradition. He suggested his own punishment. Either the state should pay for
his housing and food in exchange for the services he provided to the city, or he should be fined
one mina of silver, which was, in his estimation, all he had. But in spite of his offer, the jury
decided to go the more scorched earth route of just saying no, we're just going to execute you
instead. Times were different, I suppose. Well, the political atmosphere when Socrates was accused
was a highly charged one. The Spartans besieged Athens after defeating the Athenians in the
The democratic government was disposed and replaced by a pro-oligarchic regime known as the
Thirty Tyrants. The Tyrants' autocratic rule prompted some Athenians to band together in an
attempt to topple them. For a short while they succeeded, but the arrival of a plea for resistance
from the Thirty led to the pursuit of a compromise. However, the democratic faction in Athens took
advantage of the Spartans' second departure to assassinate the oligarchs and regain control of
the city. The poet Meletus sought the death penalty for Socrates on grounds of the impiety charge
which he himself had brought forth. Not only that, Annetus and Licon were also accused.
The trial began a month or two later, in the late spring or early summer, and lasted the
part of a day. The accusations based on religion came from two primary places. Socrates had already
rejected the anthropomorphism of classical Greek religion, stating that the gods were not fallible
and that they were just like mortals. And second, according to his accusers, he had appeared to have
At the outset of Plato's Apology, Socrates responds to the many accusations levelled at him.
There is talk that Socrates is a sophist, or an atheist natural philosopher of sorts,
the kind of figure shown in The Clouds of Aristophanes, and he must first dispel that
possibility. In response to claims that he had corrupted young people, Socrates said that he had
never deliberately corrupted anyone, because it would be illogical to do so, because corruption
in itself is bad. While regarding the second accusation, Socrates requests more information.
Socrates' atheism is levelled once again by Meletus in response. The worship of false
gods is incompatible with atheism, as Socrates points out. Since his actions ultimately benefit
Athens, he asserts that he is God's gift to the Athenians, and that the city stands to lose the
most if he is condemned to death. Following this, he implies that wealth and status are not as
important as people often believe. By saying that no one can achieve wisdom, pursuing it is the
greatest thing anyone can ever do. In the aftermath of his conviction, Socrates was granted the
opportunity to propose alternative forms of punishment, but of course he turned everything
down. The death penalty was his only choice. Academics are still divided on the subject of
what exactly prompted the Athenians to condemn Socrates. There are a few doubtful hypotheses
that exist. One holds that Socrates' conviction was based on his religious beliefs only,
while the other holds he was accused and found guilty due to political affiliations. Religion
and the state in ancient Athens were not completely distinct. The fact that the
accusations of impiety predominate the narratives of the trial by Plato and Xenophon lent credence
to the idea of a religious persecution. According to these narratives, Socrates
did not try to deny that he did not believe in the gods of Athens. The fact that numerous
atheist philosophers and skeptics of the period evaded prosecution is another counter to this
argument. There is an argument for political persecution that states Socrates was persecuted
because people saw him as simply an enemy of democracy. During the rule of the Thirty Tyrants,
Socrates and his students were largely opposed to democracy. The fact that the Athenians granted
amnesty to their citizens in 403 to prevent a civil war from breaking out following the fall
of the Thirty Tyrants typically casts doubt that it was a political persecution. The accusers may
have based their rhetoric on events that occurred before 403 BC, as shown in the trial text of
Socrates and other texts relating to it. Well, either way, he didn't get away with it, and
the hemlock went down. So with that out of the way, let's first discuss a few things about the
philosophical aspects, what he's really known for. First, we have a term that you're no doubt
familiar with. That is the Socratic method. We've all heard of it, but what exactly is it?
Well, his signature technique, the elenchus, is a defining feature of Plato's Socrates.
It shines brightest in Plato's earlier writings,
but what follows is the standard elenchus procedure. In Socrates' parables, a group of
young men and boys listen as he challenges an established authority on a given subject.
Through their exchanges, Socrates demonstrates how the experts' views and arguments are at
He poses the question,
and just as that, the conversation is kicked off.
Think about it. If somebody says that something is a thing, then you would ask them,
what does that mean? Let's just say if there's something in political discourse,
if we were to say that something is discrimination, Socrates would most likely reply,
define discrimination for me. Then we would move from there.
This does tend to trip people up in quite a lot of arguments. Try it next time. Watch them squirm.
Of course, we can use this in all different contexts. Now, as he pressures the issue
further, the interlocutor's responses ultimately run counter to the initial explanation.
So we can conclude that the expert had no real understanding of the term to begin with.
One or both of the parties to the conversation might propose alternative meanings.
Socratic inquiry then turns its attention to that revised definition.
Socrates and his interlocutor aim to get closer to the truth with each iteration of question and
answer. Frequently, they persist in showing their lack of knowledge, since the interlocutor's
definitions usually reflect the prevailing view on a subject. The debate casts doubt on that view
as it goes on. See, even Socrates uses the Socratic method to evaluate his own views.
Therefore, Socrates does not impart a dogmatic philosophy. Instead, while he and his students
and interlocutors seek the truth, he freely admits his own ignorance. Of course, everyone
chimes in with their own opinions, and academics have cast a bit of doubt on the Socratic method,
its authenticity, and really its precise characteristics. Ancient philosophy expert
Gregory Philastos asserted that the Socratic method does not work for determining whether
a proposition is true or false. Instead, it was a means to demonstrate the incoherence
of the interlocutor's beliefs. Whether or not we believe that Socrates is trying to disprove
an assertion determines the dominant school of thought on this point of view. The first school
of thought holds that Socrates is using this strategy to either affirm or refute a claim.
This strategy is known as the constructivist approach. The neoconstructivist view maintains
that all Socrates is trying to do is show how the original argument's premises and conclusion
are contradictory. Now, prioritizing the search for definitions is how Socrates begins most
discussions. We have questions like, what is justice? What is goodness? What is courage?
And it's these things that serve as that springboard for conversations,
and Socrates seeks a definition from an authority on the topic. Socrates sought out distinct
instances of virtue to illustrate its characteristics before attempting to even
define them. Socrates sought a definition in an attempt to exercise the atmosphere
from the radical skepticism of sophists, who, according to Guthrie, had questioned the
substance of many virtues during the time that Socrates lived. Some academics contend
that Socrates does not support the principle of definitional priority, since he does not support
it in all of his writings. Some have claimed that Plato, and not Socrates, is the one who
is responsible for this emphasis on definition. Although he acknowledges Socrates' support
for definition is paramount, philosopher Peter Geach deems that this method is flawed.
It is possible to know a proposition without knowing its precise words, he says.
Well, since he does not understand the nature of ethical concepts like arete, i.e. goodness,
courage, Plato of Socrates frequently admits that he is ignorant. Socrates asserts,
I thought even as a happy man, if he really possesses this art and teaches for such a
while his life is hanging in the balance during his trial. Without a doubt, I would take great
pride in myself if I were aware of these things. But alas, I am not. Even though he claims to be
ignorant, Socrates seems to have some knowledge in several of Plato's dialogues, and can come
across as quite opinionated. And then we find the Socratic paradox, which has multiple proposed
explanations, the most common of which is that Socrates is simply being inconsistent.
One possible interpretation is that Socrates is trying to teach his interlocutors something by
being ironic, or even modest. He doesn't want to hand him the answers to the philosophical questions,
so he basically just lets him think on his own account. The fact that Socrates has
different ideas about what knowledge means is another possible explanation.
He may consider himself knowledgeable in terms of lower level cognition, which he acknowledges
as part of his own knowledge, or in terms of a systemised understanding of an ethical topic,
which Socrates categorically denies any proficiency in. Well, whatever the case may be,
pretty much everyone agrees that Socrates gets the first step towards wisdom, is admitting that
one does not know anything. Of course, we have that famous phrase, I know that I know nothing.
And that sums up Socrates' denial of knowledge. Whether this is a real denial of knowledge,
or just a play on the Socratic ignorance, well, that's up for debate too. I suppose it depends
on the context. Despite the fact that this viewpoint appears elsewhere in Plato's early
works on Socrates, it is commonly ascribed to Socrates due to a statement in Plato's Apology.
But in other remarks, he suggests or even asserts that he is knowledgeable. This is
illustrated by his statement in the other section of Plato's Apology, that goes as thus,
but that to do injustice and disobey my superior, God or man, this I know be evil and base.
Of course, this is something that we do not need to describe evil and base. If our terms
for our definitions of evil and base are already defined, then we already know that injustice,
be evil, and disobeying a superior, be evil. Right? There is also another quote,
I know well that if you will agree with me on those things which my soul believes,
those things will be the very truth. He says these during his debate with Caligulis.
It is still debatable whether Socrates' presumption of ignorance was genuine or
whether it was an act, as I've mentioned, that Socratic ignorance. Many people think that he
really was acting modestly. But of course, a lot of statements, a lot of people simply take it
face value. There was also the other argument that it is more of an invitation to invite his
interlocutors to engage in the conversation with him. Usually people are quite delighted
when they have the opportunity to teach someone a subject which they, well, whether they are an
believe that they're an expert upon, they have this opportunity to convey it to another person.
This is, of course, usually where Socrates would ask those prodding questions.
And the person who believes that they were an expert by the end of the conversation
realizes that they know nothing of what they're talking about. He's quite good at it. Well,
there is sufficient evidence to disprove both of these assertions, I suppose, whether he's
acting modestly or just inviting others to conversation. Now, knowledge meaning certain
and knowledge meaning elenchus or the Socratic method. These are the two distinctions.
Well, knowledge C refers to facts that cannot be debated. While knowledge E, this is the
difference between certain and elenchus, is the information that came from Socrates' elenchus.
Socrates isn't just being truthful when he says he knows something, but he is really
knowing it when he says it in apology, for instance, that disobeying one's superiors are evil.
This is all according to the aforementioned Gregory Vlastos. Well, the semantic dualism
has not been accepted by all scholars, of course, but is certainly accepted by Vlastos himself.
Socrates supposedly said in several dialogues,
documento lacis major and hypias, that a word has a single meaning. According to James H.
Lesher, Socrates may have believed that individuals can know certain ethical propositions,
even though he asserted that he did not know anything about the essence of virtues. Oh,
I know, it's all complicated. And so the portrayal of Socrates by both Plato and Aristotle
has led a lot of people to believe that he was more of an ironist. The reader may wonder if
Socrates is trying to make a pun because his irony is so understated. And in some sections,
even slightly humorous. Socratic irony abounds in Plato's Euthyphro. Euthyphro, who remarks,
it is not, I think, any random person could do this, prosecute one's father correctly,
but surely one who is already far progressed in wisdom upon hearing the story for the first time.
Most important that I become your student is Socrates' response to Euthyphro's boast about
his knowledge of divinity. In addressing his interlocutors, or using flattering praise,
Socrates is often perceived as ironic. Opinions, of course, are among scholars divided regarding
Socrates' use of irony. One school of thought holds that Socratic irony has been around since
the Hellenistic era, and is used as a playful attention-getting device. According to an
alternative school of thinking, Socrates uses irony to obfuscate his philosophical message,
making it intelligible only to those who can discern which of his statements are ironic,
and which are not. A more nuanced pattern of irony in Socrates has been uncovered by Vlastos.
According to him, Socrates' statements can be interpreted in two ways—ironic
statements, and non-ironic statements. When he denies knowing anything, that's an example.
When Socrates claims to be ignorant of ethical issues, Vlastos takes it as an ironic statement,
in the sense that knowledge refers to a baser kind of cognition, but in the other sense,
Socrates is being serious. There are a lot of other scholars who do disagree with this,
but it's well worth mentioning. All human action, whether directly or indirectly,
is motivated, according to Socrates, by the pursuit of eudaimonia. How closely Socrates
linked virtue and knowledge to eudaimonia is still up for debate, but he did think that they
were linked. A common interpretation of Socrates' teachings is that eudaimonia and virtue were
synonymous. On the other hand, the identical and sufficiency, these contend that virtue
is always a pathway to eudaimonia. The question of whether, according to Socrates, people want
what is good, or at least what they think is good, is another contentious issue.
Just quickly, eudaimonia is effectively a kind of... let's just compare it with hedonia. Hedonia
being from the word hedonic, being a kind of short-term happiness, short-term pursuit of
happiness. We think about low-value activities, playing a video game or watching a movie.
There are other ways of pursuing happiness, taking the very short-term route. These are hedonic
pursuits. And of course, in contrast, you have eudaimonia, which is a more long-term and virtue-
based chase of happiness. Whether you get happiness or not, that's also up for debate.
But you think about things like working on a project, building a house, building a career,
building a marriage, a family. These things are eudaimonic pursuits, requiring a lot more time
and effort. But you're better off in the long run. Knowledge, in general, plays a central role in
Socrates' moral intellectualism. He's known as a virtue intellectualist because he thought that
knowledge was the foundation of all virtue, and without knowledge there can be no virtue.
Also, according to his theory, motivational intellectualism,
people are led by their intellect to understand their desires rather than their impulses.
The idea that no one errs willingly, which Socrates alludes to in Plato's Protagoras,
has become symbolic of Socratic virtue intellectualism. Socrates de-emphasizes
irrational beliefs or passions in his moral philosophy, which places an emphasis on the
intellect as a path to a good life. In the Gorgias and Meno, two of Plato's dialogues,
Socrates explains to Meno his beliefs that no one wants bad things unless they do not know what is
bad. These dialogues primarily support Socrates' intellectual motivism.
And then, of course, there is the idea of akrasia, behaving irrationally, in opposition to one's
knowledge and beliefs. Most people think that Socrates didn't make room for illogical wants.
However, there are others who argue that Socrates did not recognize illogical motivations,
but he denied that they were the main factor in decision-making.
By refusing to conform to the religious norms of his day, Socrates questioned the authority
of his contemporaries and altered the course of religious debate for generations to come.
You see, religion in ancient Greece was, let's use the word, disjointed,
and observed only in the household, rites, or festivals honoring individual deities.
Like, for example, in the city Dionysia, there weren't actually any sacred texts that existed.
It was more a word-of-mouth thing, oral traditions, and just carried on through generations.
But this didn't mean that religion was not an integral part of people's lives. Of course it was.
Sacrifices were the primary means by which individuals fulfilled their religious obligations,
of which, well, the obligations would depend on who you were, where you were, and when it was.
Well, since the ancient times, people have still argued about whether Socrates was a religious man
or just a provocative atheist. Accusations of the impiety were leveled against him during his trial.
And this controversy still persists to this very day.
Alcibiades, Euthyphro, and Apology are where Socrates mostly addresses spirituality in the
afterlife. From the work, he says, then this part of her resembles God, and whoever looks at this
and comes to know all that is divine will gain thereby the best knowledge of himself.
Socrates concludes in Alcibiades that the human soul is connected to divinity.
In all of his talks about religion, he maintains a logical perspective,
far from the common practice of his day. Socrates concludes in Euthyphro that offering sacrifices
to the gods is really pointless, particularly when done in expectation of some kind of positive
return. He argues that philosophy and the quest for knowledge should take precedence as the
primary forms of devotion to the gods. His disapproval of conventional religious practices,
which he linked to material gain, suggested that the Athenians should look within for their
spiritual fulfillment. Regardless, Socrates, contrary to popular belief at the time,
maintained that the gods were essentially just and wise. Regarding the connection between
devotion and the dictates of a powerful deity, Socrates poses the following question to his
interlocutor. Is something good because it is God's will, or is it good because it is God's will?
So which comes first, the good or the God? Socratic thought diverges from this conventional
Greek theology, which presumed the lex talionis, the eye for an eye principle, to be self-evident.
Goodness, according to Socrates, does not depend on gods, and gods must be devout individuals
themselves. By telling the jurors that he acknowledged the gods more than his accusers,
Socrates affirms a belief in the gods in Plato's Apology. God's existence,
is presumed for Socrates in Plato's dialogues. He never questions their existence.
While Socrates' discussion of the great unknown after death in Apology lends credence to the
idea that he is at least agnostic, his dialogue with his students on the last day in Phaedo
expresses his firm belief in the soul's immortality. Oracles, divinations, and other messages from the
gods, seem to have been also believed by him. These portents did not give him hope for moral
matters, but rather foretold the bad things to come. Of course, a lot of people have different
beliefs on how Socrates' religious beliefs and his rigorous rationalism relate to one another.
Some people believe that Socrates confirmed every divine sign by interpreting it through
his own secular reason. According to Socrates, since virtue is a kind of knowledge,
there is really only one virtue. People are bad, according to Socrates, because they
don't know enough yet. They need to be enlightened. They're not bad, they just don't know any better.
A union of virtues, of course, flows from this unity of knowledge. The one and proverb
no one errs willingly is based on this principle. Socrates uses bravery as an example of a virtue
that can be united in protagoras. He argues that one can take the risk if they are aware
of the specific danger. While some sources claim that Socrates had sexual relations with
young people like Alcibiades, others maintain that his friendship with boys were purely platonic
and aimed at helping them grow as individuals. He boasts in Gourias that he was in love with both
philosophy and Alcibiades. In Protagoras, Menno, and Phaedrus, his flirtatiousness is on full
display. But the precise nature of his connection with Alcibiades remains a little unclear.
Though Socrates was renowned for his restraint, and Alcibiades confesses in the Symposium
to having attempted to woo Socrates without success. The majority of what is known about
Socrates' theory of love and affection comes from Lysas, in which he has a conversation
about love with Lysas and some friends at a wrestling school. Their conversation begins
with an examination of parental love and its manifestations in relation to parental control
over their children's activities, and in the limits that parents would impose upon them.
If Lysas is completely useless, Socrates thinks, not even his parents will love him.
Scholars generally agree that Socrates wrote Lysas with a comedic tone in mind,
but some have argued that this reveals his more egocentric view of love, which holds that we
should only love those who benefit us, which of course is a little bit selfish, but well,
the world is the way it is, isn't it? On the other hand, some academics contend
that Socrates' teachings allow for a love that isn't driven by egotism towards a spouse,
while others reject the idea that Socrates ever implies egotism. According to the argument
made in Symposium, parents are brought closer together by their children's mistaken belief
in immortality. Love, according to Socrates, is rational, at least that is the main idea
pointed out by scholars. Although Socrates generally admits ignorance, he breaks his
rule in Symposium by promising to reveal the truth about love, a lesson he picked up from a
clever woman, because he knows nothing else. It is conceivable that Diotima actually existed.
However, some scholars argue that Socrates spent his youth near Aspasia,
and that she is the inspiration for Diotima, the person Socrates credits with his concept
for love in Symposium, by the way. It is also challenging to pin down his precise political
philosophy, despite his prominence in public, cultural and political discussions.
He tells Callicles in Plato's Gorgias, I think I'm one of the few Athenians,
not the only one, but among our contemporaries, to take up the true political craft and practice
the true politics. Of course, what the true politics are, that is up to interpretation.
He also goes on to say, this is due to the fact that I always strive for excellence,
rather than satisfaction in my speeches. Since Socrates believes that politicians and rhetoricians
use tricks to mislead the public, his claim demonstrates his aversion to the established
democratic assemblies and procedures. For example, voting. He never proposed a bill,
or sought any public office. He instead sought to aid the city's prosperity by
improving its inhabitants. He did what he thought was right as a citizen. He did his job as a
soldier, fought in the Peloponnesian War in accordance with regulations, political decisions
at the time, like the Sicilian expedition, for example, pretty much absent from his dialogues.
There are a few fleeting mentions, but seems he didn't really want to speak too much about them.
In his conversations with ordinary people, including influential Athenians,
Socrates would probe their beliefs, and therefore point out their inconsistencies.
Because, in Socrates' view, philosophy, not electoral process, shaped the city's moral
landscape, he felt he was doing them a favour by standing in their way. The exact position
that Socrates held within the politically divided Athens, which was characterised by
oligarchs and democrats, is another matter of contention. Despite the lack of definitive
textual evidence, a popular interpretation maintains that Socrates had democratic
leanings. This is based on the following reasoning, that he defied one command from the
oligarchic Thirty Tyrants' government. He respected Athens' laws and political systems, which were
established by democratic thinkers of earlier times, and also his affinities for the ideals
of democratic Athens, and that was the main reason why he did not wish to evade execution
and prison. Protagoras displays anti-democratic traits. Socrates disdained the opinion of the
many, and was critical of the democratic process, and the majority of his friends
actually supported oligarchy. So, there is some evidence that Socrates had leant towards it a
little bit himself. According to an alternative, but admittedly less popular, theory, Socrates
was a supporter of democratic republicanism, which places more of an emphasis on citizen
engagement. Now, liberal ideology emerged during the Age of Enlightenment. We could probably trace
the roots back even further. Of course, another theory does hold that Socrates was a supporter
of these liberal values, ones that we might not find, too far removed from the Age of Enlightenment
or the Renaissance. He argues that the city and its inhabitants have an advantageous relationship
in Crito and Apology, which form the basis of the argument. Socrates argues that the city dwellers
have moral agency, and the option to leave at any time, but that remaining in the city signifies
submission to its authority and laws. Conversely, civil disobedience has Socrates as its progenitor,
which is kind of ironic. This line is suggested by Socrates' strong opposition to injustice,
as his refusal to obey the Thirty Tyrants' order to arrest Leon. In Critias, he states,
One ought to never act unjustly, even to repay a wrong that has been done to oneself.
Looking at the bigger picture, Socrates would say that people should obey the state's command,
unless, and here's the caveat, unless they believe them to be unjust and not within the confines of
which, of course, a conversation would obviously be started. What is virtue? How are we defining
the terms? You see how it just goes around and round in circles. Well, either way, following
his parsing, Socrates had a tremendous effect on the field of philosophy. I mean, obviously,
we're still talking about him. Almost every philosophical school of thinking that emerged
after Socrates had him as their antecedent, including, of course, the Academy of Plato,
the Lyceum of Aristotle, the Cynics, and the Stoics. But there is the exception
of the Pyrrhonists and the Epicureans. Socrates continued to garner more and more attention
right up until the third century AD. Philosophical schools differed substantially in their
interpretation of Socrates's ideas because he had not provided answers to the most basic of
questions. We're talking about the meaning of life and the character of virtue. He didn't provide
answers. He just left us with more questions. Of course, according to the popular belief,
he changed the emphasis of philosophy from studying nature to actually being a study of
human affairs. And of course, well, that is indeed what we view philosophy as now,
as far as I'm concerned. And with that, we can end our discussion on Socrates.
I hope you enjoyed it. I would like to thank my top-tier patrons and supporters,
Doug, Kerry, Kimberly, Amber, Ben, Britt, Charles, Aaron, James, Jeffrey, Melissa, Scott,
Stark Factory, Wendy, Jayden, Sherry, Jessica, Christine, Sally, Katiana, Christine, Fizzaba,
Legitimus, Maverick, Susan, Dr. Neuronerd, Cameron, Alexander, Daniel, JR, and Charlene.
Thank you very much, and thank you for listening all this way. I hope you've learned something,
a little bit about the Socratic method, and I will see you in the next video.
Good night, and lots of love to you all.