Caravaggio's 'Judith and Holofernes' | Jones Gallery Lecture Series

Timeless Tapestry
4 followers
Welcome to the Jones Gallery lecture series. I'm Sarah Jones, the curator at Jones Gallery.
We're a contemporary art gallery in St. John, New Brunswick. Our core mandate is to present work by
contemporary Canadian artists, but art education is also important to us, and we think that art
history should be accessible, understandable, and free. That's why we hold public lectures
at the gallery and produce videos like these. To keep this series free and open, we rely on
the donations of our viewers. If you would like to support our efforts, please donate at
jonesgallery.ca slash arthistory. The link will be below, and that's also where you can find
all of our other art history videos, or on our channel. You can subscribe.
Okay, up today is Caravaggio's Judith Beheading Holofernes. What a painting.
So this is in the collection of the Palazzo Barberini
in Rome. It's one of his paintings, Caravaggio's paintings, that you can experience
in more or less a museum setting. The Palazzo Barberini is a museum in Rome.
No one goes to the Palazzo Barberini. You should, if you are in Rome, please, please go.
They have this painting. It's worth it just to see this painting in person.
You will have it to yourself. You will have the entire room to yourself. No one will be there.
It's just a wonderful... This is great. Okay, I'm looking forward to talking about this with
all of you. Oh, and as I said, Caravaggio's large religious works in Rome are kind of the big ones.
I'm thinking about the Matthew Cycle and the Crucifixion of Peter, the Conversion of Paul.
They're installed in churches, and it's difficult to really get a good look. You often kind of can't
get into the chapel, so you kind of have to lean around and try to get a good look at them.
They're a little more famous, especially the Matthew paintings. So there's always kind of a
crowd. The lights go off, so some sucker in the crowd has to go put coins in the little light box
and turn the lights back on. Anyway, it's interesting. I like... I mean, that experience is
worth it, but also it is nice to see a work like this in a more museum-like setting where the
lights are on and you can kind of look undisturbed. That's the case with this one,
like I said, at the Palazzo Barberini. Take thee to the Palazzo Barberini. Okay,
so this is a relatively early painting for Caravaggio. This is completed before
those Matthew paintings, before the paintings at the Piazza del Popolo.
It's a story from the Book of Judith. It's not kind of a well-known story,
a really rather obscure figure in the Old Testament. It's kind of the bare bones of the
story. Holofernes is an Assyrian general, and he's coming to invade the town of Judith,
who's the young female figure in the center. And she kind of deploys herself and talks him into
letting her into his tent. Holofernes becomes inebriated and falls asleep. And while he's
asleep, well, he's not asleep anymore, she decapitates his head. And typically in the
story and in the depictions, there is a maid servant who is ready to pop his head into a bag
or a basket. And then Judith becomes a hero figure in the story and saves her city. So that's
what we have here. This narrative is a popular one for artists. It does come up kind of again and
again. This version by Caravaggio is probably the most famous. There's another video I'm doing
about this scene by a contemporary, slightly after, of Caravaggio, Gentileschi,
who depicted the scene in a very interesting way also. Okay, but today we're talking about this
one. So as always with Caravaggio, I apologize if you're watching my Caravaggio videos in a row,
this will be a bit of a repeat. But typically with Caravaggio, we see he chooses the moment of
the most kind of climactic or the most excitement or the most action. So there's always a sense that
if time moved forward or back slightly, that the scene would change. There's always
movement and high drama. And that's obviously what we're seeing here. So
Judith is depicted as a youthful woman. She is clasping Holofernes' hair with her left hand and
with her right hand. She has a short sword and she is severing his head from his body.
She's about mid-sever and the blood is spurting from his neck. Can't get much more climactic than
that. Holofernes has been awoken, unfortunately, by this action. And you can see he's still in his
bed. He's grasping the bedclothes, cloth sheets, that's what they're called. And he's twisting up
in agony and his mouth is open with this audible cry coming from him. And so we can see that it's
the interior of a tent. So again, once again, typical of Caravaggio, the scene is reduced to
its most basic elements. We have the three figures. There is a strong source of light
coming from the left, illuminating the faces, especially that of Judith.
We're inside a tent. We get a little bit of the red tent in the background or kind of a
red cloth. I don't know if it's the tent. Maybe it's the drapery. Anyway, it has the effect of a
tent. And then her elderly maid to the right. So just keep this scene in mind, this moment,
the moment that he, there's always innumerable decisions that go into the creation of a painting
or a composition. And artists have to choose, okay, so we're depicting, we've been commissioned
to depict Judith and Holofernes. When in time, is it prior to the decapitation, during the
decapitation, after the decapitation? How is the scene going to be composed? Where is Judith in
relation to Holofernes? Where is the maid? What will be Holofernes' reaction? I mean, you know,
within reason. So innumerable decisions go into this. So it's always interesting to compare
other artists' approach to the same scene. And I've done this kind of repeatedly
comparing an earlier version of the same scene with the work done by Caravaggio.
So this is a painting by Sabatini, a painter from Bologna, showing us the
same story. This is from about 30 or 40 years prior. And what Sabatini has elected to do is
show us the after effects, which are still gruesome. I mean, you can see the decapitation
has happened. So we see his headless body on the left. And there is blood shooting out from the,
I don't know how to describe this, the neck. Anyway, moving on. And the head has been placed
on the table. Sabatini has elected not to show us the maid. And he, Judith is depicted here
holding the sword. Her hands are bloody. But it's the moment after. So the climax has passed
of the narrative, that she has succeeded in this. There's no, we don't get a sense of
kind of a danger or, oh, you know, not know. I mean, we all know how the story is going to end
up. But just there's a sense more of like something could happen here potentially.
It's a more fraught, the tension is higher in this scene that Caravaggio has given us than the
Sabatini version. She's very, she's composed. I mean, again, granted, it's a grisly scene,
but she is composed. Her face is calm. Her body is making a triangular structure,
which is a very stable, kind of undramatic kind of pose here, kind of holding the sword upright
in triumph. So this to me is a more stable, a more calm, as it were, ignoring the grisly subject
matter, obviously, but there's a more stable kind of non-moving composition compared to that of
Caravaggio. I'd like to show you just a few details. So here's a detail of Holofernes.
And I mentioned this, but that open mouth, so the sense that there is a,
there's something audible here in Caravaggio's paintings. And he's used that,
that comes up from time to time. So this is another painting by Caravaggio of the Medusa.
And he's shown us here when she, when her head has been severed from her body.
This is a scene from Greek mythology. I won't get into the story, but here you can see that look,
her head has just been decapitated. And so there's that look of kind of shock and horror. And that
mouth, that open mouth. So if we can hear this, we can hear this painting and the sound that that's
making. So it's increasing the, again, that kind of theatricality or the drama, the impact of this,
that there are multiple senses that are potentially involved in this scene.
Notice how Judith is, is almost leaning away from the, from the body. So, so she's,
I don't know what kind of leverage she's getting here on, I don't know if one can decapitate a head
from, from this distance, but, but, but I think Caravaggio is just trying to give us the effect
that she is, she is kind of young and, and pure and untainted. And she is creating this or
undergoing this heinous act, is, is, is an act of self-sacrifice. And so she is,
she knows the, the, the gruesome nature of it. And she's, she's leaning as far away as she can.
And her, that look of concentration on her face,
the contrast in the kind of the, the white purity of her clothing with that of the,
the interior of the tent. They're kind of darker, kind of reds and greens.
Compare her stance with that of the, of her maid, who is in effect leaning in,
ready to, to pop the general's head in a bag. And, and, and, and notice a, Caravaggio often has a,
like a contrast in the figures. So, so Judith's kind of youth and beauty and innocence
is, is highlighted, or we, we, we, we read that more dramatically because of the, the depiction
of the, of the, the maid here. So very kind of grim and resigned face. She's ready. She's ready
to put his head in the bag. So youth and age and kind of revulsion and kind of resignation and
expectation. Yeah. She's, she's up for it. She's up for the, she's up for the task.
There's always a sense in, in Baroque art too, the theatrical. So it looks sometimes like we're,
we're, it's the drama is, is even exaggerated sometimes. And, and I'll often show this
painting to my students as, as an example of this, that we have a, we have a literal curtain
in, in the background here that's almost being pulled, pulled apart. So it's,
it's like, it's almost a, with, with Caravaggio, it's like we're seeing little
vignettes and the curtain is always being open for us at the moment of, of, of the,
the most tense, the most fraught moment. I kept repeating moment, but, but that's,
that's typical of the, of, of the Baroque approach here. So it's almost above, sometimes
it's, sometimes it's a little, you know, it's a little, a little overboard, but that's,
that's just, that's the nature of the, of the aesthetic in this, in this time period.
And yeah, and it's notable that we have, we have this curtain here, so it does create this,
this sense of a theater. We're seeing a scene. There is, once again, I've mentioned this in
other, looking at other Caravaggio paintings, but looking at the colors with Caravaggio,
and there always seems to be kind of three or four dominant colors and everything else is sort of
white or brown. And so we have the red curtain and the green blanket, and then the yellow dress,
and then, and then that, that triangle, those three colors, kind of basic colors are,
are pulling us like they, those create a sense of balance to this flurry of activity that's
happening here and, and frames in the composition. And there we have it, Judith.
And remember, it's at the Palazzo Barberini. So how you can support the lecture series,
you can donate at jonesgallery.ca slash art history. Technical support today by Caleb Jones,
and I'm Sarah Jones. Thank you for watching.
