Value Hole in Health Insurance Plan Design

Smart Insurance Choices
22 followers
Hello, this is Dr. Eric Bricker, and thank you for watching A Health Care Z.
Today's topic is the value hole in health plan design.
Now we're going to talk about two specific parts of plan design today, and those are
the deductible and the out-of-pocket max.
Because frankly, the way that most health plans are designed today, the cost share across
the plan design is incredibly lumpy.
In fact, that lumpiness in the cost share actually leads to poor performance of the
health plan in terms of both the care and the outcomes for the patient, and then also
for the overall cost for the plan.
Now what do I specifically mean?
As it relates to the deductible, the lump in terms of the out-of-pocket cost is really
front-loaded into the plan, right?
And then in terms of the out-of-pocket max, once you reach that out-of-pocket max, then
that side of the health plan is super low.
And so that has significant consequences, again, in terms of the clinical and the financial
performance of the plan.
And let me relate how that relates specifically to the health care industry with a couple
examples.
So the first one is from this JustHealthcare newsletter, and JustHealthcare is a hospital
consulting firm.
I'll leave a link to the newsletter in the show notes.
It's fantastic.
I encourage you to subscribe to it.
Now, they share their conversations anonymously, they share their conversations with hospital
executives.
And the most recent newsletter talks about how a hospital executive said that, listen,
they totally see an increase in services in the last six months of the year because people
have delayed care until they've met their deductible, either through their prescriptions
or through office visits or what have you.
And then once they've met their deductible, then they get more services in the back half
of the year.
Which the hospital is actually saying, well, that's good for the hospital.
We'd like to see more services, and we tend to see more services in the back half of the
year.
Now, here's the problem.
Disease doesn't wait for the second half of the year.
So for people who have out of control diabetes, they are waiting.
For people that have painful degenerative joint disease, who need to have some sort
of procedure, they're waiting.
For people who potentially have a cancer diagnosis, they're waiting.
And if they had their deductible structured differently, i.e. less, they wouldn't wait.
And that might be a good thing.
Number two, John Tauranis, who wrote the book, The Company That Solved Healthcare, that I've
spoken about previously, and his company, Serigraph, kept his employee health plan costs
flat for nine years.
Specifically, he addressed the out-of-pocket max issue because he said, well, once employees
on our plan hit $6,000 of out-of-pocket costs, then they no longer have any cost share.
And so they don't care if there's any cost difference for the hugely expensive procedures.
And he specifically calls out spinal fusion, where at one facility, it's $30,000, and at
another facility, it's $54,000.
And at both facilities, the employee would reach their $6,000 out-of-pocket max.
So they don't care which place they go to.
And so he then changed the structure of his plan design so that the employees were still
incented to seek the lower-cost, higher-value facility for more expensive procedures like
spinal fusions.
Okay.
So now, let's get into a couple of specific strategies that are used.
So one is to just lower or even eliminate the deductible.
In fact, I know of a major national employee benefits consulting firm that absolutely uses
this strategy.
It's very popular.
They win a lot of business with it because, of course, employers and employees are like,
great.
I can lower the deductible.
People are going to like that.
And that's done also for clinical purposes because it decreases people preventing or
delaying care when they need it.
In other words, you want to catch things and treat things earlier because they're just
going to be more expensive down the road if you delay.
And the University of Chicago even did a study about that, where they found that 80% of patients
actually delayed care because of out-of-pocket costs.
And 79% of the patients specifically called out the deductible as the reason why they
delayed care.
So the next approach ... Okay, so fine.
So in terms of like flattening out that lumpiness in the beginning, you can reduce or eliminate
the deductible.
Okay.
But on the back half, you don't want to have it be zero.
You want to have the employees still be cost-conscious.
You don't want to have to have them spend $24,000, but you still want them to be cost-conscious.
As it relates to the cost share for these very high-cost procedures.
And this can be done in a variety of ways.
So what John Tortoise did is he gave cash back.
He said, look, if you go to the more cost-effective place that's $30,000 instead of $54,000, we'll
cut you a check for $2,000.
So there, they are financially rewarded for going to the $30,000 Spinal Fusion instead
of the $54,000 by getting $2,000.
Likewise, there are employers that are now structuring their plans so that they have
co-pays that are not egregious amount, but there are still co-pay differentials that
are based upon the overall cost for these high-cost procedures.
In other words, it's a lower co-pay for a $30,000 Spinal Fusion, and it is a higher
co-pay for a $54,000 Spinal Fusion.
So now, as it relates to the overall cost of the plan, again, remember that 5% of the
claimants drive 50% of the cost, and 80% of the costs are driven by 20% of the claimants,
and they typically fall into three diagnostic categories of musculoskeletal, cardiovascular,
and cancer.
And so it's those really high-cost claims where there is an opportunity, especially
in the elective musculoskeletal, in your joint replacements, and in your spinal surgeries,
to lower the threshold so that people actually get in early and get the care that they need
so that it's not this catastrophic disaster.
And then likewise, they are still conscious about the value differentials that could cost
the employer $24,000 through either getting cash back or through variable co-pays.
And that's much more important than bickering over like $200 office visits because you've
got some high-deductible or HSA-compatible health plan.
So we're kind of missing the forest for the trees here.
So instead of nickel and diamond, folks, about $200 office visits, then we can structure
the plan in a way that actually encourages earlier care, which is a good thing, and at
the same time encourages better stewardship for these large dollar amounts.
And that's the point I wanted to make today.
Thank you for watching A Health Care C.
