Tariffs would undue Fed's progress on inflation, says Capital Area Planning's Malcolm Ethridge

Thrifty Thinkers
9 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 27, 2024
Malcolm Ethridge, Capital Area Planning Group managing partner, and Stephen Stanley, Santander U.S. Capital Markets chief U.S. economist, join 'Power Lunch' to discuss Trump's tariff aims at Canada and Mexico.
And let's also bring in Malcolm Etheridge, managing partner of Capital Area Planning
Group and a CNBC contributor. Malcolm, the tariffs have long been telegraphed by Trump.
How's that for alliteration? What do you make of the targeting of Canada and Mexico in this case?
Yeah, Contessa, I am not as sure as Tyler and Eamon seemed to be just then in that last
conversation about the fact that it is 100% meant to be a bargaining chip.
And part of the reason I say that is the answer to your question, the fact that we're now
roping in Mexico and Canada into what, to this point, has been more of a conversation about
China. And I think the global market seemed to be a bit torn in response, too, right?
Traders in the US have been fairly muted today, maybe positive. I know the dollar's been rallying,
which is sort of the opposite impact, I imagine, that the incoming president wanted to have.
But currencies are steadily falling all across the other countries that we're talking about.
So Americans might be used to Trump and his hot and cold temperament and big proclamations
when it comes to negotiating. But the rest of the world obviously is not.
Let me push back a little bit on the bargaining chip point. I mean,
we raised the idea that raising the tariffs on China might be employed as a way to get China
to restrict the flow of fentanyl and its precursors into through Mexico into the United
States. But the same could be said here about tariffs being applied to Mexico. They want to
stop the fentanyl that's coming across the southern border in precursor form or in final
form. So that could be a bargaining chip there. And they also want to control the flow of
refugees and immigrants across the Mexican border. And an economic penalty that causes
pain in Mexico might induce the Mexican leadership, a new leader, by the way,
to take stronger steps to control immigration. So it's not merely economic tit for tat. It has to do
with these other let me call them, for lack of a better term, more social objectives.
The concern there that I would have as an investor are the implications that all of those tariffs
would have on inflation. Right. So the last two and a half, let's call it years, the Fed
has been doing the one thing that it can do to bring down inflation. And in the middle of us
easing, right, we're in the middle of a cutting cycle on interest rates. Everything that we're
discussing right now presumably would be inflationary. So I understand the idea that it
helps solve one piece of the agenda from a social perspective, but it also stands to undo a lot of
what has been done by Jerome Powell and crew. And so I think there has to be a balancing act.
Don't disagree about that. Do not disagree about that.
Stephen and I were having a conversation before we came out for power lunch. You talked to him
before. I did. I invited you. I couldn't find you here. But the conversation was about insurance,
which I cover fairly closely and all the complaints that we've been hearing about
premiums for car insurance and for homeowners insurance. Part of the reason those premiums
have skyrocketed is because of the cost of replacing house homes or your roof or repairing
your house, the cost of replacing your car or repairing your car. It all shot up. We can see
it in the CPI. And so my question was, is it inflationary even for an industry like insurance
if you're putting tariffs on cars and car parts and things like that that are coming from Mexico?
And you had a really interesting answer for me.
So, yeah, you have to if well, if you're an economist, a layperson will have a different
answer. But as an economist, you make a distinction between the level of prices
and the rate of change of prices, which is inflation. And the Fed has often said that
they tend to look through one time changes in prices. So if there's a one time tariff hike
that raises the level of prices, but it doesn't change the longer term trend of inflation.
So the Fed has said in the past they would look through that. I mean,
an oil shock would be a good example of that in the past.
