General Principles of Law | International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
Nov 25, 2024
Welcome back everybody to our studies in public international law. In this lesson what we're
going to do is spend a little bit of time looking at general principles of law as part of the broader
conceptualization of the sources of international law, something that we have been essentially going
through and going about unpacking over the last sort of three or four lessons, which has been of
an interesting amount of value theoretically to look at the various different sources of
public international law. We noted of course that we have the idea of the treaty within
international law and then we have this idea of customary international law and that these two
represent the major sources of international law with the more subsidiary sources of international
law, including things like general principles, including things like judicial decisions,
as well as the writings of highly qualified publicists. So let's get into general principles
of law and as I've noted already that the previous lesson took an introduction to this subject. It
took an introduction to the meaning of general principles of law as cited by the the ICJ
statute and this lesson is going to expand on this in more detail. So really we finished the
last lesson by exploring what could theoretically constitute a general principle of law, but we
didn't really go into the details that I would particularly like and I'm going to be citing a
in this lesson because general principles of law theoretically could derive from a variety of
different places, a quite broad and quite vast variety of different places from which we can
talk about and derive our general principles of law. And I would like to just draw your attention
firstly to the 9th edition of Oppenheim's International Law, volume one of which
cited from 1992. At page 40 they say here, quote, the acknowledgement of general principles of law
as a source of international law enables rules of law to exist which can fill in gaps or weaknesses
in the law which might otherwise be left by the operation of custom and treaty and provide a
background of legal principles in the light of which custom and treaties have been applied
and as such it may operate to modify their application. This gives us this idea of the
sources of international law, of course recognising the idea of treaty and the idea of customary
international law as being particularly important on the one hand, but then also recognising that
where these two sources of law may have weaknesses or may have gaps left from which there is no
legal justification or there is no understanding, the idea of a general principle of law could fill
in those gaps. That's one way in which we can justify the existence of these general principles
of law, to suggest that they are a source of international law which enables the rule of law
to exist which can fill in the gaps or weaknesses in the law. Now it also could theoretically provide
a background of legal principles in the light of which custom and treaties have to be applied
and so it may modify their application. This is also an interesting conceptualisation because
this theorises the idea of general principles of law as being a sort of permeating backdrop,
a permeating background of principles which can therefore inform the true and the correct
application of custom and or treaty. So whereas we would colloquially and we would generally
understand the idea of the idea of custom and treaty being quite paramount considerations
when it comes to the full application of international law, the concept of having
this sort of permeating principles, these permeating general principles of law that can
therefore help to correctly apply basic principles of customs and treaties and in some circumstances
may operate to modify their application could give a certain amount of quite normative,
quite a lot of normative value to the concept of general principles of law. This is something that
we can theorise just from this one passage of Oppenheim's International Law from 1992.
So this is one of the things that we can theorise and one of the things that we can think about
but it should also be noted that it does go on to suggest that general principles of
law are not just supplementary in terms of their role as a source of law either.
So whereas this passage gives us quite a passive role for general principles of law,
that general principles of law can maybe potentially be exercised in relation to
filling in the gaps and weaknesses which would have otherwise been left by the operation of
custom or treaty and also may provide background of legal principles, this presents general
principles of law as having quite a passive role, having quite a passive role of essentially being
responsive to the shortcomings of customs and treaties. But this is not necessarily something
that we should understand as being diminishing in the concept of and the conceptualisation of
general principles of law because it is also noted that they have the ability to be the creator of
rules as independent legal force. So just like custom creates law and just like treaties of
course create law, it is said to be the case that general principles of law will also be able to
create rules of independent legal force. And with that being in mind I would like to draw your
attention to what is known as the non-liquid doctrine. This is a doctrine or a principle
which essentially tells us that courts or tribunals may not find an admissible case,
particularly for reasons which relate to the lacking of existing law, in a situation where
there may not exist any applicable law. The theory of general principles could theoretically
have potential and provide potential to fill in the gaps of these areas. Now again, this is not
to suggest that general principles of law act as a backdrop in a situation where there is no law.
Even Oppenheim's International Law from 1992, when theorising the purpose of general principles
of law, doesn't just leave it at that, doesn't just leave it at this situation of
only being able to fill in the gaps where custom and treaty may not exist.
Because according to many, general principles of law are still formal and enforceable
sources of international law. So what could theoretically be said if we're talking about
international law from a theoretical perspective, talking about international legal theory in this
regard? You could suggest that general principles of law sit at something of a difficult and
complicated position, sort of at a crossroads, where for the most part, and generally speaking,
and in the minds and in the writings of many still, general principles of law are a formal
and enforceable source of international law, just like treaties and just like custom.
And that's one way in which we conceptualise general principles of law, but then another way
in which we conceptualise it is this idea of it being something of a passive or something of a
permeating set of principles which may essentially fill in the gaps or provide something to the
shortcomings of the custom and the treaty principles of international law as well.
And this sort of is an uneasy dichotomy, if you will, because you have on the one hand this idea
of a genuine, standalone, independent source of law which is capable of creating legal rules,
while also having this idea of it being something of a supportive role, if you will,
providing something of a supportive role for that of custom and treaties. I would like to finally
draw your attention to a case that is often cited, that we will be citing throughout this
series of lessons, the ICJ case relating to Barcelona Traction Light and Power Company Ltd,
this is the Belgium versus Spain from 1970, and I want to draw your attention to this particular
passage. It says, quote, such obligations derive, for example, in contemporary international law
from the outlawing of acts of aggression and of genocide, as also from principles and rules
concerning the basic right of human persons, including protection from slavery and racial
discrimination. Now, I'm asking this question here, is this clear? Is this clearly understood
and understanding of the general rules of international law and specifically the general
concept of general principles of law? And honestly, I would invite you to
comment down below if you can understand the meaning of this particular passage,
if you can get something from the meaning of this particular passage, in addition to the fact of
whether or not you would conceptualize general principles of law in the ways that have been
conceptualized previously, conceptualized by this principle here, as well as by Oppenheim's
conceptualization of international law, or at least specifically of general principles of law,
as being sort of an enabling rule of law, as well as providing something of a useful backdrop of
legal principles, something of a passive role compared to the more active roles of
custom and treaties, while also simultaneously and potentially contradictorily providing
legal rules of sources of international law that have the independence to create law in and of
itself.
