insta360 GO 3S vs GoPro Hero 4K

Learn Film Photography
93 followers
If you want the smallest action camera then up until now Insta360 have dominated that part of
the market with their Go series. The question is does the new tiny GoPro Hero 4K offer a better
alternative? There's a lot of stuff in here about this camera that you may not know and you'll find
surprising. I'm going to be comparing which camera is best looking at design, mounting options,
battery life, stabilization and lots more along the way so you can decide which camera is best
for you. Insta360 went down the road of making their Go cameras bigger every time they updated
them with the end result being the Go 3S which is a GoPro sized camera with a flip out LCD screen
where you can use the camera in or out of the action pod. The Hero is substantially smaller
than the Go 3S when the Go 3S is in the action pod and it's much lighter but with an LCD screen
that is only slightly smaller. If we look at the design and mounting capability of the Go 3S
straight out of the box in the action pod you can't actually attach it to anything because
there are no mounting options, there's no finger mounts, no threads, nothing. It does come with
several attachments of pivot mount, cap mount and a pendant mount but on its own you just can't
attach it to anything. The Hero on the other hand straight out of the box has these built-in finger
mounts underneath which neatly fold away so you can attach this to any mount with a GoPro finger
design. Surprisingly though this camera doesn't have the integrated quarter inch thread underneath
which we do see on their larger action cameras and even more surprisingly the new quick release
magnet mount which released at the same time as the GoPro 13 is not compatible with the Hero camera
but at least we have got these finger mounts. Of course with the Go 3S you can take the camera
out of the action pod and use it independently and it's the size of the camera when we use it
which has always been the major selling point of this design. So straight out of the box this is
magnetic so you can at least mount it to magnetic surfaces without the need for any other mounts
but using the magnet on the back is very limiting and there's no other way of attaching this to any
other mounts, there's no screw threads and no finger mounts. One other really cool thing when
you use the camera out of the pod like this is that you can then use the action pod as a viewing
screen and a remote control for the camera and this is done via bluetooth and works up to about
five meters away. So if we compare the sizes of these two cameras the Go 3S is half the size and
half the weight of the Hero but obviously now with the Go 3S because it's out of the action pod we
now don't have the LCD screen and both cameras also have removable lens guards. If you want to
mount the camera by itself or in the action pod then it does come with this quick release mount
in the box and this is on a swivel head with a quarter inch thread or you can buy this action
mount which is also quick release and it has fold-out fingers as well as a quarter inch thread
underneath and with the action mount attached underneath this is now a similar design to the
Hero camera so we've got the fold-out fingers and the quarter inch thread but now with the finger
mount attached the Go 3S is even bigger. This quick release mount is actually a really good
design it attaches to the action pod, quick releases and it also attaches independently to
the camera as well. My preferred way of using the Go 3S though is out of the action pod using these
cradle mounts which are optional extras but I really like them because they keep the camera
so much more compact. GoPro have taken a really interesting approach to this camera and they've
kept it simple. There are only three shooting modes to choose from. You have slow-mo video at 2.7k
60 frames per second, you have normal video which by default is set to 4k 30 frames per second
and then you have photo mode which is 12 megapixels. So from a beginner perspective in particular this
camera is dead simple to use. Even the menu is stripped right back and there's hardly anything
in there. You can turn on quick capture and choose your default mode which is a nice feature to have
as well as voice activation and there's also a battery saving mode and then this switches the
video recording to 1080 instead of 4k to save battery and you can choose your region as well
so power or NTSC which can then change your frame rate from 30 frames per second to 25 frames per
second. On the other hand if we look at the Go 3S there are a ton of features, a ton of shooting
modes and loads of customization that you can do. If you include pre-recording mode, time capture and
webcam mode there are 13 different shooting modes to choose from and slow motion is at 2.7k 100
frames per second so double that of the Hero's. This is great but you could argue that this is
unnecessary and overwhelming and it would be really nice if Insta360 could include a basic
menu mode option as well that's stripped right back with less options. If we dive deeper into
the Go 3S menu though you can adjust picture profile, shoot in manual or auto, change the
settings, select from different resolutions, use gesture mode, program various quick presets,
change the aspect ratio and there's even a digital zoom on the touch screen and lots lots more. It
really is a camera packed with loads of features. So how does the image quality compare? The Go 3 has
better contrast and holds on to more detail in the clouds in most of these tests. The Hero has
punchier colors and after this shot I set the Go 3S to vivid color profile. When the contrast is
more extreme both cameras look a bit mushy but in a lot of these shots the results are pretty close.
With closer shots the Hero definitely holds on to more details whereas the Go 3S starts to look a
bit soft. Overall the colors look much more natural with the Hero. You may have noticed already that
the Hero is much wider and that's because all of these shots haven't been stabilized as there's
no in-camera stabilization. So all your shots have to go through the app. For smooth terrain
and movement this is fine but for anything more than that the shot starts to look a bit messy.
And another thing to point out here is that there's no indication when you're using the
battery saving mode. So I accidentally left it on for these riding shots and shot them in 1080
instead of 4k. The Hero only has a bit rate of 50 megabits per second compared to 120 megabits
per second of the Go 3S. This does seem incredibly low but even the new DJI Action 5 Pro was released
with a bit rate of 60 megabits per second. I have read that DJI are offering a higher bit rate option
with their next firmware update so maybe this is something that GoPro could do as well. But does
bit rate matter as much nowadays when most videos are watched on your phone? Let me know what you
think in the comments. With the Go 3S you can shoot in 16 by 9 by placing the camera horizontally
and you can switch it to 9 by 16 simply by switching it to portrait mode like this.
You can also choose to shoot in free frame mode in this camera and free frame mode then allows
you in the app to choose from 9 by 16 or 16 by 9. If you're getting value from this video I'd
really appreciate it if you could subscribe and give it a thumbs up it really does help.
So when you finish filming both the GoPro app and the Insta360 app are really easy to use.
The interfaces are obviously different. GoPro's is more simplistic but very slick and fast and
you just select your clips and then you can automatically create and edit with music and
transitions. The Insta360 app is also very fast and slick but has so many more themes to choose
from. Around 38 and you just select your theme and then drop your clips in and it edits your
video with music and transitions. The Go 3S out of the action pod is waterproof to 10 meters,
the action pod isn't waterproof. The Hero camera is waterproof to 5 meters.
A great thing with the Hero that the Go 3S doesn't have and that's a memory card slot.
Open this door up here and you can use a micro sd card. The Go 3S has built-in memory and you
have to choose how much memory you want when you buy the camera. So you can select between 64
gigabyte and 128 gigabytes. Both cameras have a built-in battery and in my test the Hero camera
had a much longer battery life compared to the Go 3S when it was on its own and it ran for three
times as long. But in the action pod the Go 3S battery lasted around 20 minutes longer. The
action pod can be used to charge the Go 3S camera as well so when this camera is dead you just place
it in the action pod and it acts as like a power bank and recharges your camera. The Hero for me
is so close to being the better camera. I much prefer the design and the simplistic menu. Yes
it is slightly bigger than the Go 3S but the finger mounts and the LCD screen make it so much
easier to use straight out of the box and it's small enough that you can place it pretty much
anywhere. That lack of stabilization though, not sure but maybe they can change that with an update.
The Go 3S, I absolutely love the camera when it's out of the action pod. It's just so cool having a
camera this tiny which is just slightly bigger than my thumb. It would be great though to have
a longer battery life when you use it out of the action pod like this. I'm not really a big fan of
the action pod and the elaborate menu. I think it over complicates where this camera came from and
how simple it used to be. GoPro have the right price point with this camera at £199 which is
the same price of the original Insta360 Go camera. The Go 3S camera is £349 with a 64GB memory
and this is almost double the price of the Hero. Despite some of the shortfalls of the Hero I think
it will win over some new customers just because of that low price point. Let me know which is your
favourite in the comments and to find out the different shooting styles between the X4 and
the GoPro 13 you'll want to watch this video next and I'll see you over there.
