Why It’s Actually Good to “Settle” in Love | Feat. Oliver Burkeman

Heart Talks
3 followers
Welcome everybody to the Love Life podcast with me, Matthew Hussey.
For those of you that are new here, I've been working for 17 years helping people find love
through increased confidence and relational intelligence.
And today I bring you a very special guest.
His name is Oliver Berkman.
I have been wanting to get Oliver on the podcast since I read his book, 4,000 Weeks.
It is one of my favorite books in recent years.
And it's not a love life book.
It's a book about time and how we use our time and how we approach our lives.
And I absolutely loved it.
Oliver just wrote a brand new book called Meditation for Mortals,
4 Weeks to Embrace Your Limitations and Make Time for What Counts.
I have read this cover to cover already.
It is a fantastic book.
I'm a giant fan of Oliver.
I am having so much fun in this conversation.
I think you will too.
He has such an insightful and often counterintuitive way of looking at things.
For those of you that don't know Oliver, he worked for many years at The Guardian
where he wrote a popular weekly column on psychology.
This Column Will Change Your Life was the name of the column.
His books include the New York Times bestseller, 4,000 Weeks,
and The Antidote, Happiness for People Who Can't Stand Positive Thinking.
His new book is this one, Meditation for Mortals.
And I'm really excited to introduce both the book and him to you today.
For those of you, by the way, who haven't tried it yet,
make sure you go and give Matthew AI a go.
If you've got a question you want to ask me about your life or your love life,
Matthew AI can answer that question for you.
It also answers it in my voice like a real phone call that you're having with me.
And you can try it for free by going to askmh.com.
So check that out if you haven't already.
Well, without further delay, I would like to present to you
the wonderful, the insightful Oliver Berkman.
Oliver Berkman, hello.
Hi.
I have to start by, I suppose, letting you know what a fan I am.
I read your first, well, not your first book, of course.
I know you've been a writer for many years,
but the first book of yours that I was aware of, 4,000 Weeks,
that instantly I went around telling everybody
this is one of the most important books I have read in years.
I would describe my experience of 4,000 Weeks
as being this sort of incredibly emotional encounter
with something that gave me a giant sigh of relief.
And I also had that wonderful feeling you have when you read a writer
and you feel that you share a decent amount of DNA.
So I want to thank you because I really,
I really, that was a tremendous piece of work.
And your new book, Meditation for Mortals,
which for anyone who has not heard about this yet or hasn't got a copy,
the subtitle is 4 Weeks to Embrace Your Limitations
and Make Time for What Counts.
What's funny, Oliver, is I had wanted to talk to you about this book
before I knew whether you would have the time or say yes.
And I had long since pre-ordered the book for myself,
for my own purposes.
And it was lovely when your team reached out and said,
we'll send you a book.
I said, don't worry, I've already got that covered.
So I've read it cover to cover
and it's just another beautiful, beautiful piece of work.
So I'm sorry for the long-winded intro,
but I really am grateful for the work that you do.
Please do not feel that you need to apologize
for saying a large number of nice things about me.
I'm happy with that.
No, it's great to be here.
I think you're truly one of the really fresh voices out there
I don't even know whether to call it what you do,
because I know that there's a productivity tilt to your background,
but it's so far transcended that to be something
that I would recommend to anyone I love
for getting more out of life and for truly living life.
I'm going to really work to get through all of my questions.
I know we have an hour.
To what extent you're aware of me or my work, Oliver, I don't know,
but I will say a huge amount of our audience
are people who would really like to find a meaningful relationship.
I almost want to start there and then come on to a wider lens
for some of the things you talk about
in dealing with our overwhelming life in general
and the kinds of lives that lead us feeling anxious and stressed and unhappy.
But to begin with, one of the things that struck me even in 4,000 weeks,
and you kind of actually continue in this book
with a chapter that relates specifically to commitment,
you said in 4,000 weeks that your advice to people in their love lives
is that they absolutely should settle
and that they should stop seeing that as some kind of derogatory idea.
Could you explain what you mean by that?
Yeah, I will.
And let me just say by way of beginning
that I've only just started reading your book, which you sent me.
I'm very glad I've started reading it.
I'm certainly going to keep going.
And I think, yeah, I mean, one thing that really is clear to me
from that and from other conversations is that to some extent,
we're all sort of targeting the same big stuff here,
whether we're doing it through the lens of romantic relationships,
relationships in a broader sense,
or apparently I'm doing it through how you organise your to-do list
and your daily schedule, right?
But somehow it is all about how we sort of show up in the world.
And it all comes back down to the same stuff.
So I think it's a good conversation.
I mean, the point I was making when I ventured to give
the only romantic advice I feel qualified to give there
was just that, in a sense,
all that settling could ever possibly really mean
when you think about it deeply is accepting a trade-off, right?
It means deciding to do one thing,
to enter a relationship with one person
instead of the other people you could enter a relationship with.
It's the same in your job.
It's the same in where you choose to live.
You have to turn down possibilities,
at least hypothetical possibilities,
in order to do anything.
That's just built in to being a human.
It's not the same as saying that you should sort of, you know,
commit to a relationship with somebody
that you don't think is right for you
because some guy on an interview said that you should settle.
But it's that idea that there isn't like a...
There's no option at any point open to us as humans
that doesn't involve putting up with some kind of downside.
And I think that when somebody is sort of stuck in commitment phobia,
a state of which I have plenty of experience earlier in my adulthood...
Me too.
Part of what's keeping that going
is the sense that you're not settling.
You're not burning a bridge.
You're not closing a door.
But actually, of course, you are, right?
Because we're always doing it.
And what you're doing if you decide to spend several years
not entering a committed relationship
when you could have had that option
is you're deciding to spend those years
not in a committed relationship.
And that might be right for some people at certain life stages,
but it's not.
It's still like, you know, life is finite.
Time is ticking away.
You're using that part of your life for that purpose.
And then it's going to be gone forever,
and you'll be on to the next part of your life.
So it's really just another way of getting at this whole thing
that I'm always banging on about, basically,
which is that we are finite in our time
and our amount of control over our time and many other ways.
And we invest a lot of energy trying to feel like we're not.
But we are.
And in a sense, what gives a commitment,
especially in a relationship context,
what gives a commitment its value
is precisely that you're shutting down other possibilities, right?
I mean, it's the act of saying no to all those other life paths
that gives meaning to the one you choose.
Because if we lived for eternity,
or we could be in a thousand places at once,
it would not be of any great value
that you were in a committed long-term relationship
in one of those realities, right?
It would be like, well, sure,
but what about all the other ones?
But we only have one to choose from,
and that's what gives it its meaning.
How do you think about, you know,
I get asked the question a lot,
I would paraphrase the question as,
what do I do with the 70 to 80% right partner?
You know, they, sure, they have a lot of great things.
I do feel like I'm missing some important things
or some things that I would like,
but, you know, they're pretty great.
Or they're great in other ways.
How do you think about making choices in those moments
when it does feel like there's this impossible question of,
well, time is ticking,
but do I give it another five years
to try to find my right person?
Or do I make this the best I can by leaning into it?
Do you have any models or frames
that could help people in that situation?
It's such a good question.
And I apologize in advance
if there's a pattern in our conversation
where you're asking the big questions
about deep human relationships,
and I'm somehow managing to pull it back
to productivity advice,
where I feel more comfortable.
Not at all.
Maybe we can find an interface between these things.
The truth is, I think the excitement of having you here
is that you're bringing a kind of,
a different way of thinking to this
that I think directly applies.
I read 4,000 Weeks
to your point earlier,
this could just as easily be a book about finding love
or dating if you apply it through that lens.
So actually, I'm very happy to hear you talk from that angle.
Cool.
I mean, the question about sort of 70%, 80%
good enough situations,
it's such a good question
because obviously, on the one hand,
that feels like far too imperfect a situation
to settle for if 100% is on the horizon.
And yet, on the other hand,
we know in all sorts of other areas of life
that if you write a novel
and it's 70% as good as the best novel ever written,
that is like an insanely good novel.
So in lots of other areas,
we're sort of more comfortable
with that level of sort of good enoughness.
I guess in terms of what I really think
is that there is a really severe limit
to how far we can reason our way
into any conclusion in this area.
And a big part of my own journey
into sort of confronting
and getting comfortable with my limitations
has been being a kind of a brain on a stick type person
who thinks that who's got a good sharp intellect
and therefore thinks I ought to be able to use it
to figure out the whole of my life
and gradually coming to see that intuition
as an alternative way of navigating is a real thing
and you can trust it to a certain extent
and it's not just totally woo-woo.
And so two perspectives
that I think are really helpful here.
One is to ask the right question
that will connect you to your intuitions
and one of those that I've written about before
comes from James Hollis,
the Jungian psychotherapist,
an extremely wise man
but also very sort of humane
and funny writer and person
who recommends asking this question,
does the path I'm on enlarge me or diminish me?
Really as an alternative to asking
will this make me happy or not
which is a very, very troublesome question
that we're terrible at answering
and all sorts of pitfalls involved
and I think that a lot of people find
that connecting to that intuitive sense of like
is this like a path of growth?
Can I feel that this is enlarging me?
This is something that has really been of great help to me.
I mean the first time I was navigating this way
I think early in what was to become my marriage
I wasn't doing it having encountered this question.
It was more a gut feeling
but later the question really put it into perspective for me.
Just trying to connect to that felt sense
of whether this is kind of a growing path
or a shrinking path
and that's what's so helpful about that of course
is that when you're making those kinds of decisions
especially in the relationship context
there are certain kinds of difficult time
that you might have in a relationship
that are a huge red flag that you should get out immediately
and there are certain kinds of difficult time
that you can have in a relationship
which are the very substance of growing in a relationship
and learning more deeply how to be with another person
and I find that kind of James Hollis question
is great for distinguishing between those two
kinds of difficulty.
The good difficulty and the bad difficulty.
Then I think the other thing that is really helpful
and it's another sort of perspective
from Carl Jung and the Jungians
is that although it is also the subject of a song
sung by Anna in Frozen 2
so you can choose the source you wish
you only actually ever have to figure out the very next moment.
You only ever actually have to try to make the wisest choice
about what you're going to do with the next day
and the next day and the next day
and of course there are going to be days in a life
when that involves breaking up with someone
or proposing marriage to someone
but very, very often I find
and I'm thinking I guess more in other contexts and relationships
but I think it applies here too
when you narrow your field of focus
to what you as a limited human
actually have the right to kind of ask about
which is what's my next step
as opposed to where do I see myself in five years time or something
very often clarity arises from that
and it becomes clear that
the only reason you're continuing with the course of action is fear
or no, that you haven't got to the point yet
Those things really resonate with me
firstly on the level of the James Hollis question
because I really viscerally connect to that
in my memory of my early days dating my wife
where I felt resistant to commitment on some level
but I had become quite dissatisfied with being single and dating around
and that dissatisfaction met with a person of such incredible character and personality
that I felt like I was growing with every interaction
even in the early days where you know we would have an argument
which usually was my fault not hers
I would come away from that argument in some way enlarged
because I would feel like the way that it was handled from her side
was so competent and so kind and so compassionate
while also being very strong
that I couldn't
I remember coming away from argument
even arguments I would come away from going
oh god I think I'm the problem here
like I because I couldn't blame it on how her bad handling of the situation
or that I was just I came away going
I had this really deep sense of I'm gonna learn a lot here
right right
so it's not only that you were the problem
but that actually you were sort of excited to dig into addressing that problem
I truly saw this as the path that made me the best me
and that was really there was something very exhilarating about that to me
and so again I didn't have that question
you know specifically in my mind
of will this I think was it will this enlarge or diminish me
yeah yeah
I didn't literally have the question
but I definitely viscerally felt that sense of
I can't walk away here
because this is going to continue to enlarge me
and I felt like I was somehow now on a steep learning curve
right
that was really wonderful
so I completely relate to that idea
and and that idea I knew exactly where you were going
when you mentioned Frozen 2
because that that idea of the next
when I heard that song about you know taking the next best step you can
I remember having a visceral reaction to that idea
because there's something very manageable about that
and whether someone is you know
I think so many of us miss out on relationships
because we spend so much time obsessing over whether they're right or wrong
instead of saying
well look let me actually go on another date with this person in a different context
maybe show a little more of myself
maybe get a little more curious about them
and see if more data helps me
or if I've been in a relationship for five years
and I constantly just find myself doubting it
can I give myself three months of permission not to doubt it
and instead just to do all the things I would do
if I was earnestly sincerely trying to make this relationship work
and if at the end of those three months I feel no better off
well okay maybe I've gotten closer to a decision
or if my response to being told to do that
is that I really don't want to do all of that
then maybe I already have a kind of answer
so I relate to all of that
what do you say Oliver to people who
you know you talk in the book
Meditation for Mortals your new book
about this idea of waiting for life to start
and how in fact this right here now is life
life isn't going to start at some point in the future
and in the context in which I often speak
the classic example is of someone thinking that their life is going to start
once they find the relationship they're looking for
and that in a sense their life is on hold until that point
what would your perspective your advice be to someone
who is really struggling to enjoy their life now
before they've had this
what for some people is the number one goal in life is to find love
and it hasn't happened
how could people really connect to that idea
that life is happening right now
and that there's more enjoyment to be found there
I mean yeah it's so interesting to hear you talk about
this kind of idea of the provisionality of life
in the context of relationships
because I'm very often coming at it from other angles
but it's of course the same phenomenon
this notion that there's something that needs to happen
before life can really begin
and maybe for other people it's
when they've solved their procrastination problems
or when they've got the right promotion in their career or something
but it's the same idea
you can start sort of pushing back against this idea
just from an intellectual level
you can say for finite humans
meaning has to be now
because it's all we have is this succession of nows
I think if you're in your sort of early 20s
and you're thinking that it might be
that you're going to feel more secure in your relationships
by the end of your 20s
this is not something to beat yourself up about
this notion that you've got a goal
and the goal is very important to your well-being
I think the problem comes when you're sort of
when you're postponing engagement in the present
pending that thing
and of course what you find is that
it gets harder and harder to sort of
it gets more and more troublesome as you get older
because the idea that the moment of truth is coming later
is obviously a lot easier to believe in when you're 22
than when you're in your mid-40s
There are two distinct groups I have in mind
One is the group that especially women who
really want to have a biological family of their own
and there's a kind of
there's a very real time pressure there
and they see that window closing for some of them
and at the very least there's a fear of that window closing
and then there's people who are on the other side of that equation
who maybe they did have kids maybe they didn't
but either way maybe there's a long-term relationship that ended
maybe there's a marriage that ended in their 50s or 60s
they never thought that would happen
or maybe they've never had a long-term relationship
and they find themselves in that season of their life
still thinking, God I'm
you know life hasn't turned out the way I want
and it's terrifying
and this feels like it's at the heart of a good life
Again it's fascinating to sort of have the shift of
terrain for these same ideas
but I think it's
there is something really powerful
and beautiful about
certainly in that if your
your particular struggle is the sense that
something didn't
that things didn't go the way that you wanted them to go
and that it is in some sense too late
I think there is something really beautiful and powerful
in sort of really feeling that
and turning towards it
Let's see if I can sort of port this idea of playing in the ruins
into relationships
This comes, I've got to give full credit
from a writer called Sasha Chapin
who among other great pieces of writing
wrote a newsletter
an edition of his Substack newsletter
where he talks about
when he was in his early 20s
he really wanted to be a novelist
on a par with David Foster Wallace
and the worst thing that could happen in that domain
would be that he failed to become a novelist
on a par with David Foster Wallace
and then you know
some years later he realised that
that was not going to happen
he had failed
and how liberating this was
because now you no longer had to
he no longer had to tell himself all these stories
about what his life was going to become
he could just say
okay well what is my life
what is this scrap heap that I'm actually in
and what could I make of it
and I think there are all sorts of contexts
where you can understand that same idea
that there's a kind of a
there's a moment you can exhale
and a weight being lifted off your shoulders
when you really appreciate in depth
that this is where you are
either you know
in the situation of not having got something yet
that you think you still can soon
or especially in the position of thinking that
something has passed you by
or that you've
or that a relationship has failed to work out
in the way that you had planned
and in fact it's coming back to me now
that Chapin also writes about this
happening to him
after I think a fairly youthful divorce
it's like well
at least you're no longer putting
or have to put all this effort
into trying to never become a person who gets divorced right
that ship has kind of
definitively sailed
and you know
the same can come in sort of creative work I find
at least I no longer have to put any effort
into trying to be the person
who never puts a foot wrong
in my creative work
because I've done it plenty of times at this point
and there is a kind of a liberation in that
that is like okay
so here we are
and there's a
there's a zen writer called
oh his name is escaping me now
but he's a zen writer
and a sort of a chef and a bread maker
I'm sorry I can't
Edward S.P. Brown maybe
something like that
he writes very articulately
about how the sort of
one of the ultimate kind of spiritual questions
is to just look at your situation
or your ingredients
before you're preparing to cook a meal
or life you know
and say and ask the question
well like what have we here
and no longer you know
what do I wish this was
or what do I think I can make it into
if I really try hard
and get lucky in the next couple of years
but like what do we have here
and just to finish that thought off
I've got to also believe
I'm pretty sure it's true
that you know
that there isn't a trade-off
that you have to make here
a choice you have to make here
between enjoying yourself now
and working on bringing about
the life situation that you want
I mean it's an old cliche I know
but I'm sure it's as true
in romantic relationships as anywhere else
that actually if you are enjoying yourself
if you are making something of your life right now
that just turns you into the kind of person
who is going to find it easier
to you know
to find the relationship
that would complement that
it's you know
apart from anything else
it's just a more attractive trait
I think to be enjoying life
than not to be enjoying it
Absolutely
it's funny I wrote
that idea of what have we got here
as far as ingredients go
I wrote a part of my book
on having seen just the introduction
to the TV show Chopped
I don't know if you've ever watched it
but there was something fascinating to me
about the idea that the chefs
were given baskets of ingredients
they didn't know what was in there
and their job for the next 20 minutes
was to do something with those ingredients
and it always struck me
that there was something very true to life
about that concept
they may not have intended it to be
but the idea that you know
the show isn't about the chefs
opening the basket of ingredients
and then judging themselves
based on what ingredients
they happen to get in the basket
it's a show about chefs
it's a show about
what this person is able to do
with these very obscure
and sometimes you know
really difficult ingredients
and at the end they're judged
on how creative they can be with that
so I really love that the idea
of what have we here
what have we got here
really fits with that
I wonder if this is an interesting segue
to the concept you write about
in your book of
I think you call it the life task
but this idea that your life
may be calling you to do something right now
I'll leave you to explain it
but the thing I really enjoyed
about this concept
and found very liberating
was this idea that your life task
will never be something
that's not possible for you
where you stand right now
could you just speak to that idea
of a life task
because I think it's actually really reassuring
wherever someone is starting from now
whether it's you know 65
and single again
in a way they never thought they would be
or 32
and wondering if they'll ever find love
there is something
applicable universally about that idea
yeah I mean this is just a notion
again it's from Jungian psychology really
it's the question of sort of asking
it's a sort of a reframing I suppose
it's a question of saying
instead of asking yourself
what do you want to get out of life
where do you want to go in your life
asking instead the question
of what life is asking of you in this moment
and I tell a story in the book about
how this happened to Carl Jung himself
as an adolescent
when life was asking him to
buckle down to his studies
after he'd spent six months
playing truant from school
but there are so many contexts
in which this is a really useful way
of kind of surfacing something
and of course it's still you
who's providing the answer right
but it's a deeper or less
more unconscious part of you
so it's really just that question you know
what is reality asking of me right now
and yeah there are these two criteria
that I think help you identify
what that life
if you're sort of dealing with a legitimate
genuine life task
the first as Jung says
is that it's something that
may well only be doable
by effort and with difficulty
or with effort and by the
by effort and with difficulty
I think he says
meaning it's not going to be the thing
that comes most easily
it's not going to be the sort of lazy option
it's not going to be the thing
that is just going with your instincts
and not finding any kind of self-discipline
but at the same time as you say
it's going to be something
that is doable
by you in the life situation
in which you find yourself
so the examples I give are
if you've only got $50 in the bank
it's not going to be something
that requires you to have
$10,000 worth of movie making equipment
that is where your sort of destiny lies
if you're not able to have biological children
another example I give
then it's not going to require that you do
because that's not something
that's open to you
and that is a very useful way
and I think you're right
reassuring way of distinguishing it
from all these kinds of ideas
of destiny and purpose
that clutter the self-help space
and very often give rise
to the sense people have
that there's something
they're meant to be doing on the planet
that they can't do
because of their situation
so it's like you're meant
to have a big family
but you can't find the person
to do that with
or you can't have children
you're meant to be
launching a certain kind of business
but you don't have
the financial resources
that it would require
and the idea of the life task
really pushes back against that
and says well no
it can't be the case
that you're meant to do something
that you can't do
it may be that there's something
very unexpected
and difficult
that you weren't thinking of
that is what you're meant to do
but it can't be the case
that you're meant to do something
that you cannot do
because that's not
what we're talking about here
we're talking about
how you respond to the reality
you're actually in
not the one that you think
you should be in
or that you wish you were in
You know you talk about sanity
being something that
can always feel like
it's out of reach
and defining sanity
as this I suppose
more of a feeling of equanimity
and not overwhelm
a sense that we can actually
connect to things
enjoy things
approach them with a lightness
as opposed to that heaviness of
oh my god I've got so much to do
and I'm so overwhelmed
and now we can't enjoy anything
because everything in our day
just becomes one giant
never-ending to-do list
that bleeds into the next day
and the next day
and waking up in deficit
every morning
feeling like we have to
earn our worth
by the end of the day
only to start the process
all over again the next day
I find these ideas so liberating
and the practical advice
you give in the book
for overcoming that trap
very liberating
in fact I actually wrote these down today
because I was like
god these are really going to help me
you know you talked about
freeing up time
by you know
one way to operate from sanity
and deal with the overwhelm
is to free up time
simply by renegotiating
existing commitments
not by planning to make
fewer ones in the future
which we can certainly do
but you can literally
reduce your overwhelm right now
by reducing your number of commitments
saying you can't go to the party
when you originally said you could
or you know
dropping a project
that maybe isn't as important
as you've been making it
or is certainly not more important
than your sanity
and so there's all these ideas in the book
that I find so liberating
I am curious Oliver
from your perspective
when we're writing a book
it's almost like
when we're actually in the chapters ourselves
we're never more close to the material than
then
and that's when it all feels very real to us
and I'm sure you must have it regularly
when you're writing something
and you breathe a sigh of relief
at the truth in what you're writing
and you feel very connected to it
and I think the great irony
is that when
an audience is reading our book for the first time
and we've been working on it
for the last couple of years
they're more connected
or we're in danger of our audience
being far more connected to the concepts than we are
because we're now talking about them
kind of almost in the abstract from the outside
and they're suddenly the ones on the inside
where I'm going with this is
it's sometimes with a sadness
that I read a book that I feel is changing me
or a fear that I read it
because I go
what if I don't connect to this a month from now
this is so helpful
what if a month from now I forget
what is your
do you have a system
for connecting and reconnecting and reconnecting
to the truths that you are writing about
and if so what is that system
or is it something that you rely on
sort of happening to you regularly enough
that it saves you?
Yeah great question
I've thought about it a lot
and I've sort of changed my
my answer
but where I'm at now is that
you know there's a lot of hunger for that kind of system
and ultimately I think it is another of these kinds of systems
that we long for
because it would just make everything so much simpler
if we could put in place that system
and you know if you spend any time
on YouTube
looking at sort of personal knowledge management
there's all these kind of people
with all these amazing systems
for memorizing everything that you read
and retaining every fact that you learn
and that's a part of the same urge I think
this idea that there must be a way to really like
install these insights or
you know epiphanies or whatever
once and for all
and I've sort of reached the point now
seeing that I think that's just another example of
sort of trying to be kind of perfectionistic
and to sort of do something
that it's not in our human gift to do
so really now I just think about
the importance of sort of marinating in this stuff
the importance of kind of circling back and back
and discovering new ways of articulating it
and discovering writers who articulate it in different ways
and in my own book you know in this new book
it's really a conscious effort
to create a book that leads people through this material
in a way that kind of resists any kind of system
or any kind of you know
attempt to store all this knowledge away
and then put it into practice perfectly
at some subsequent point
or it's really about this very topic I think
about how do you keep this stuff alive
because it's got this kind of four-week structure
short chapter for each day of the month
and the idea being you know
obviously I can't control how people read my book
but the idea might be that you would go at it
roughly a chapter a day
and that in so doing
you'd sort of increase the degree
to which you're sort of marinating in these ideas
and letting them seep under your skin
rather than trying to find the way
to kind of install them in a kind of plug and play
kind of fashion
and when it comes to my own creative work
yeah I just find that I have to be
writing, journaling, reading
sort of pretty much all the time in some way
I really feel it if too many days go by without that
and I think there's something very
there's a sort of ironic
but very important moment in personal growth
when you realize
and in creative work
when you realize that you're not heading towards
one specific point
when you will finally be there
which at first is very depressing
it was like what am I growing towards
if I'm not getting to this point
but actually I think that's actually the deeper
that's the deeper thing right
to sort of it's like a spiral
deepening spiral of re-engaging with all this stuff
which is a long-winded way of saying
maybe there are people who have sort of
a sudden and immediate spiritual transformation
and they're different from that moment on
and it never fades
but I don't think that's common
but for those of us mortals
who aren't that kind of person
you know I wonder
if there is any kind of a trigger for you
that you've been able to ingrain
because I would describe my life
in a way that I'm still ashamed
isn't nearly far enough along in this department
as these moments of just truth
where I feel really connected to everything
that you've written about here in this book
and I think you write about better than anyone I've read
and feeling like oh my god
this is my mind is the problem
my mind is the whole problem here
my standards for myself
are the cause of all of my suffering
my relentless urge to do more
to take on more
to fill any space in the diary
and I get that realization
but it's depressing how quickly
I can go back to that
either fight or flight mode
where it feels like something disastrous will happen
if I don't get this next webinar right
or if I don't do a great job
on the Oliver Berkman interview
which I've been looking forward to
you know that there will be some kind of
catastrophic consequences
but also this general feeling of
you know the days get filled with to-dos
where you feel on the outside of your life
where even the things that should in theory be pleasurable
just become another thing
to be scratched off of the to-do list
when you find yourself slipping back
into that way of being
or maybe you find that you've worked the muscle sufficiently
that you slip back less
but when you do
do you have any kind of a trigger
that kind of doesn't allow you to get too far gone
or doesn't allow you to realize
that you've been operating from
that place of obligation and drudgery for a month
before that truth revisits you again?
Such a great question
and I'm certainly not so
certainly haven't strengthened that muscle
to the degree that it doesn't happen frequently.
I have two thoughts
might be helpful
one of them in terms of a sort of a concrete practice
is that I think that any kind of journaling
or free writing or morning pages whatever
but this is a habit that
through all my years of trying out habits and routines
and getting sick of them within 24 hours
this is the thing that has stuck.
You know I do this pretty much every day of my life
spend 40 minutes in the morning
30 minutes writing
on three sides of a narrow-lined A5 journal.
What I think is really good about this
and there are other practices
that could fill the same gap
is this is something that those of us
who want to kind of follow rules
and have a routine
and stick to a certain protocol
can do because it's a thing
you have to sit down
do it for a certain amount of time
there's an action associated with it
it's very clear
but then what you do inside that space
is completely outside your control
it's completely sort of free form.
I think it's very very useful to follow the rule
if you're doing that
of that you don't ever stop writing
you can in the time for the time period
or the length of space
that you're trying to fill
doesn't mean you have to write fast
certainly doesn't mean you have to write eloquently
I think you can do it longhand
or on a keyboard
but just that notion
that you're going to keep going
and not allow the internal editor
to sort of pull down the drawbridge
or whatever you know on what you want to say
and I think anything like that is really amazing
because it puts this very sort of
formal boundary around something
but then what you're doing inside that space
is just letting and allowing and permitting
and you know things bubble up
and I find that that does bring me
back to these things
very often in the like last paragraph
of three sides of free journaling
right after a whole lot of rubbish
something surfaces
and I'm reminded of you know
the path that I want to be on
so that's one thought
and then just quickly
the other one
I'm sort of paraphrasing here
from the psychotherapist Bruce Tift
just listening to you talk about how
you know thinking of your own
seeing that your own mind is the problem
and all of this stuff
I think there's something to be aware of here
which is that you know
you can go a little adrift in this direction
if you think that
that there is a big problem to fix here
right that you
that because you're not spending
your whole life
in a sense of total communion
with the deepest truths of existence
that that's a big issue
that you need to fix
you can recapitulate that whole problem
of like postponing life
until you've fixed it
Bruce Tift has this great thought
experiment that I find very liberating
where he says that you know
take the thing that bothers you
the most about yourself
your procrastination
or your anxiety about commitment
or maybe it's your inability to
stay conscious of the things that you think
are the truest
ways of looking at the world
and just kind of imagine
what it would be like to know
that you were going to be afflicted
by some degree of that problem
for the whole of the rest of your life
you know maybe that'll just always be
maybe I'll always be prone to catastrophism
and too much anxiety about travel plans
when it just doesn't matter at all
if I miss the train or not really
you know all this stuff
and along with a lot of other people
I find that really freeing
like that thought was like
oh maybe maybe that's just part of me right
I mean maybe that's not something that
that needs to be got rid of
now of course you can sort of
it can circle around on itself right
because you can think well
how do I keep remembering that
but but I think it's it's very powerful
that sort of what if
what if part of my personality
is just that I have this kind of
you know adorable eccentricity
that you know
maybe the perfect person wouldn't have
but like who's perfect
and I think it's also Bruce Tift
who has just on that same
in that same vein
I think I've heard him say on a podcast
that he no longer experiences
any problems at all in his marriage
but only because he no longer defines
experiencing emotional disturbance
as a problem
because you know
getting wound up or getting triggered
is just like just part of the deal
so that's one way to get rid
of all relationship problems
is just not to see them as
problems
but there is
there is something so profound to that
because I'll always remember
when I first started jiu-jitsu
the jiu-jitsu you roll
that's the jiu-jitsu version of sparring
in boxing
and I remember being so unfit
stamina wise for the task
that after three minutes
I couldn't breathe
and the person coaching me at the time said
you know
sometimes we'll set a timer
between the professors
to just roll for an hour
and it was inconceivable to me
that what I had just done
for three minutes
that anyone could do for an hour
and I said
how do you do that for an hour?
and he said
well when you know
that you're going to be doing it for an hour
you just
you strap in
and you start breathing differently
because
you know that
you know that the way that you scrambled around
for three minutes just now
you couldn't scramble like that for an hour
so you actually start to approach
the whole thing differently
because you know
that you're going to be doing it for the next hour
and
and that was a really big
realization for me
I think we do the same
even in dating
you know you can kind of
be anxious
because someone's not texting you back
or
something's
you know oh my god
do they like me
do they not like me
and if you
I always say to people
if you think about the fact that
if this works
you're going to be with this person
for decades
can you continue to
breathe like this
for decades
you know
or if you knew you were going to do this for decades
would you
would you actually breathe differently
and embrace it differently
and
yeah that's great
I think it's such a great point
I am wondering what to ask you as my last question
because I have at least a hundred more
but I will try and settle on one
I had made lots and lots of notes for this
and it was actually my own practice in finitude
and accepting finitude
to have to narrow the questions I wanted to ask down
it's all part of the point
but
I suppose I'll ask a selfish question
how do you Oliver
if you do
resist the urge to
do more
you strike me as
a person who
has settled on
some really core things that you value
and
have founded
a degree of peace and
happiness and fulfillment
in both the work you do
and the family life that you have
and I say that from a distance
but it does seem that way
for your world and my world
there's always more
if you want to start making videos every week
and you want to start doing
start your own podcast
and do this and do that
and there's always a
you know someone with your brain
could do all of that and more
and more would come
and it would lead to more
and I'm just wondering if it's easy for you
to not do those things
or to not
constantly be saying yes to the more
that sounds exciting and sounds like it
could get your work out there more
it could do this
whether you find that easy
or whether it's a constant struggle
and how you do say no when you say no
yeah I've got better at it
it's definitely still a
still a thing for me
and as per earlier parts of our conversation
I'm not sure it ever won't be
a thing
I think
on the level of sort of perspective shifts
what has helped
has been
everything we've been talking about
that real understanding on a deep level
that there will always be more
that by grabbing a bit more of the more
I will not actually reach the position of thinking
that I have enough of it
but that's never going to happen
but there will always be trade-offs
there's always going to be somebody disappointed
by the choice I make
or something I miss out on
that would have been good to have
this is just completely non-negotiable and given
and that makes it a lot easier
to pick some things
and not other things
I think thinking about it seasonally
has helped
right now I'm in a period of a lot of intense work
and you know
spreading the word about the new book
and all sorts of things
and it does take away from the time I have with my family
and the challenge for me is to make sure
that that doesn't just become
my life from here on out
but that it's a thing for a while
and then something else is a thing
for a while
and then just to be much more sort of practical about it
a sort of you know technique-based
it's really a matter of
one thing I do a lot is
sort of in the productivity side of things
for example you know
keeping a very long list of all the things that I want to do
of it on my plate
and understanding just how long it is
and that I can only pick a few things from it
onto my list of things I'm actually going to do
any practice like that
that sort of really brings me into contact
with the fact that
there will always be more
maybe this is harder to sort of make real
in the context of relationships
maybe that's where journaling would come in
but it's really sort of
really sinking into that awareness
that being a finite limited human just means
you could always do more and more and more
and that really breaks the spell
that whatever you don't have
must be going to be better
than where you are right now
Oliver's book Meditation for Mortals
is out right now
I think I was one of the first people in the world to get a copy
it's the subtitle is
Four Weeks to Embrace Your Limitations
and Make Time for What Counts
one of the really interesting things about this book
as Oliver said is that
it's designed to be a short chapter a day
to really let this seep in
and have it help you make real changes
in the way that you approach things
the way that you approach your life
your work and your thoughts
over the space of an entire month
and I think that's really really powerful
it's a great read
I would recommend every single person go out
and grab a copy of this book
and I say this without exaggeration
there will be many people in your lives
who you know are like me
can struggle with their own mind
and the way they approach things
and this book will help them
I literally said to my mum this morning
who has sat across from me
who wanted to sit here and listen to this
because she knew it would help her too
I said to her you have to get a copy of this book
I've just ordered one for my wife Audrey as well
because mine is littered with notes now
and my book if she reads it
is just going to tell her
what to think about everything in the book
so she needs her own copy
but it really is a tremendous book
and I recommend everyone grab a copy
from wherever books are sold
Oliver is there anywhere else before you go
that you would like people to visit of yours
or anywhere that they could benefit from
hearing your work
or is the book the place?
I think the book's the place
my website oliverburkman.com
is also where you can sign up for my newsletter
which I call the imperfectionist
so that's the other that's the other
which I am an avid reader of
so that's a great shout
the imperfectionist
is there a specific domain for the imperfectionist
or is that just on your website if people go there
the place to sign up is oliverburkman.com
okay yeah
so oliverburkman.com
Oliver writes regular articles
that I find really really helpful
so go check those out as well
Oliver it truly has been a privilege for me to speak with you
I hope we get to do it again
me too
what a lovely conversation and thank you
really appreciate it
thanks Oliver
be well and good luck with the rest of the uh
the book tour
I hope you enjoyed that interview
leave me a comment
let me know what you thought
if you're watching this on YouTube
if you're listening to it on the Love Life podcast
email us podcast at matthewhussey.com
pick up a copy of Oliver's book
I cannot recommend this book highly enough
I believe that it will make a measurable impact
on the life of anyone who reads this book
it certainly has on mine
and thank you Oliver for joining us
it really means a lot
for anyone who hasn't yet
if you're finishing with any kind of a question
you would like to ask me
about your love life
about your dating life
about a relationship
or just about your confidence in your life in general
go try out Matthew AI
it is an incredible way for you to access my answers
even if you haven't been able to reach me
or you haven't ever been able to ask me a question
Matthew AI has all of my content uploaded to it
so that the answer that Matthew AI gives
isn't just some generic answer
it's my answer
go check it out for free at askmh.com
think of what you want to ask
and go ask it now
and thank you as always for listening to the Love Life podcast
it means so much that you're here
and I can't wait to see you next time
