Grading My 2024 Breakout Picks!

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Well, here we go again. Last spring, for the fourth year in a row, I put out my five pitchers I like,
five hitters I like, and five players I dislike season predictions on this very channel. And,
for the fourth year in a row, I got every single one correct! They're all right, 100% accurate,
guaranteed! As per usual, we'll be grading these picks with my extremely complicated
two-thumbs-up, one-thumbs-up, neutral, one-thumb-down, two-thumbs-down system.
We'll start with the five pitchers I liked for 2024. I try to pick at least one player who
hadn't yet played in MLB, and this year it was Shota Imanaga, who signed a four-year,
$53 million deal with the Cubs last offseason. It may have been just one-sixth of the record
breaker set by fellow countryman Yoshinobu Yamamoto of the Dodgers, but Big Mike Imanaga
had the better rookie year. He had a sub-three ERA across 173 innings, he was an all-star,
he started a no-hitter, and he led the National League in strikeout-to-walk ratio. This is a win
for pitch data and pitch grading, which showed me that Imanaga had an outlier fastball with regards
to the release point and induced vertical break. He pounded the zone with it all year,
and he ended up with the fifth-best ERA among qualified pitchers.
I crushed this pick, and because I crushed this pick, I don't just award myself one thumbs up,
I award myself two thumbs up. Way to go, Shota Imanaga.
I'm not into sports betting culture, I avoid doing gambling ads for a reason,
but man, I could've made you all rich with a preseason Chris Sale Cy Young wager.
He was a long shot as a talented but seemingly injury-prone 35-year-old who had tossed 151
innings in the last four years, but stayed healthy enough to toss 177 and win the NL Triple
Crown in the process. In some ways, it was risky to gamble on someone with his history,
in others, it wasn't a gamble at all. Injuries aren't as predictable as the average fan thinks,
and Sale was still striking out 30% of the batters he faced with Boston last year.
Now with the Cy Young season under his belt in Atlanta, he is back in Hall of Fame discussions,
and knowing that I made this pick in the preseason, but not having bragged about it until now,
has done wonders for my self-esteem. They called me a madman, but it's two thumbs up.
Is this the best pick I've ever made? Ooh, yeah, there's the splash of cold water.
Overall, my pitcher picks were incredible, but this one was a major whiff. Coming off a year
with a FIP and ERA over 5 as a starter, I still liked Louis Varland from Minnesota in 2024.
He came in a spring training showing improved velocity, and managed to grab a back of the
rotation spot, but it didn't last long, and he bounced back and forth between the bullpen and
rotation, as well as AAA in the majors, for most of the year. The end result? An ERA over 7. He
was plagued by the long ball once again, allowing 12 in 49 innings. Just a disastrous season,
and a disastrous pick. If I could blame one thing on this, it might be the elimination of his slider.
Pitters performed well against it in 2023, but it had plus movement in velo,
and probably shouldn't have been abandoned. This is an easy two thumbs down. My apologies
for the Louis Varland pick. Let's get back on track here with Brian Wu, who had a really good
and really weird year. Weird in the sense that it seemed like he was constantly injured,
opening the year on the injured list, leaving games early, having MRIs, but he still managed
to make 22 starts and toss 121 innings, and they were 121 really good innings, culminating in a 2.89
ERA, a major improvement over his 4.21 from his rookie year. This was actually the best ERA of
any Seattle starter, no small feat considering how excellent their rotation was. In 2023,
lefties OPSed over 900 against Brian Wu. In 2024, his OPS vs lefties was around 600. That was the
key that led to his breakout. These grades are relative to expectation, and Brian Wu definitely
far exceeded those expectations. If Chris Sale had had this year, it would have been one thumbs up,
but because it was Brian Wu, I'm gonna give it two. His ERA was more than a run below the
projections, and I think there was just enough volume here to justify it. For most of 2024's
half, I actually regretted making Ryan Walker my reliever breakout pick. Sure, he was dominating,
but he was dominating as a middle reliever, and with Camilo Doval at closer, it seemed like he
wouldn't be able to insert himself into that high leverage conversation. But Doval struggled and
ultimately lost his closing job to a committee headed by Walker, who picked up 10 saves to
in 80 innings. That ERA was powered by a 32% strikeout rate, 6% walk rate, and 47% ground
ball rate. Walker was already pretty good in his rookie year of 2023, but took a major step forward
while also pitching more important innings. In 2023, his WPA, win probability added, was plus
.4. This year, plus 3.7. Another two thumbs up, this time for Ryan Walker. I promise these grades
are gonna get more nuanced, it's just that these were all pretty clear cut. Overall, it was an
incredible showing in the 5 pitchers I like category, maybe the best I've done in any video,
only tainted by the Louis Varlan pick. Unfortunately, it's all downhill from here.
Quick sponsor shoutouts real quick, I promise Seeky Code Foolish gets you 20 bucks off your
first order. We're here looking at the NLDS between the Dodgers and the Padres, hot ticket item. This
isn't bad for 141, nice little view there if you sort by the deal score. Also, you can use it for
football, basketball, live music, what have you. Code Foolish, $20 off. And then StatHead as well,
Code Foolish 20 for 20% off your annual subscription. I was just looking at all the
famers with fewer career playoff homers than Kyle Higashioka. Next up, 5 hitters I liked for 2024.
Let's start with the good news. Mikel Garcia was an everyday player, led off often for a
postseason-bound Royals team, and he stole 37 bases to only 2-cont stealing. Sounds like this
was a great pick, right? Wrong. He had a .231 average, .281 on base, and .332 slug for a .72
OPS+, well below league average and well below even his 2023 rookie year. When he hit 3 home
runs in the first week of the season, I was already patting myself on the back for a job well done,
but he only hit 4 more the rest of the way. Ultimately, the exit velo and launch angle
potential he exhibited didn't lead to the power breakout I was expecting. I still like Mikel
Garcia as a player, his base running and defense give him a really nice floor, but this exercise
is called 5 hitters I like, and he simply didn't hit. Two thumbs down. This one hurts.
We know this was a good pick, but is it one thumbs up or two? Tyler O'Neal hit 31 home runs
after only combining for 23 the previous two seasons. His .132 OPS was excellent after being
a slightly below average hitter in 2022 and 2023, and although he didn't quite reach the heights of
his 2021 breakout year, he got pretty close. The Cardinals shipped him away for seemingly very
little last offseason, but this year's performance is going to make O'Neal an attractive free agent,
whether he signs back with Boston or seeks employment elsewhere. So, one thumbs up or two?
This is brutal, but I'm gonna go with just the one thumb. Injuries were still an issue for him
as he fell 30 plate appearances short of qualifying for the batting title, and he
finished the year on a 4 for 46 skid, which dropped his season OPS by about 50 points.
If either of those things don't happen, it's probably two thumbs up, but I'm trying to grade
critically, so it's just the one for me. Thankfully, I won't struggle to come up with
a grade for Nolan Gorman. After a .805 OPS in 2023, he fell to a .671 in 2024. Strikeouts were
a major issue, as he jumped up from an already poor 32% to an unplayable 38%. The barrel rates
and power potential that led me to Gorman weren't enough to act as a counterbalance.
19 homers in 107 games isn't terrible, but if that's all you do with the bat,
it's just not enough. Gorman actually finished the year with AAA Memphis due to his struggles,
and his long-term role with the club is now in question. He's not great defensively at second
base, so he'll need to really hit to be an everyday player again. Unfortunately, this is an
open and shut case. Two thumbs down, a real bummer of a season for Nolan Gorman. While Nolan Gorman
had high expectations for this year, Brendan Rogers didn't. He missed most of 2023 after
suffering a shoulder injury in spring training, and when he played, he didn't hit well, putting
up a 82 OPS plus in 46 games. OPS plus will be the key stat here, as it's park adjusted for the
high offensive environment of Coors Field. So, how did Rogers do in 2024? Fine. Normal.
.267 average, .314 on base, .407 slug, .94 OPS plus. A bounce back from last year for sure, but
still mostly in line with his overall career norms. He played enough to qualify for the batting title,
and didn't lose his starting job, but didn't quite manage to be an above average hitter.
Had he done that, I would have given him a thumbs up, but I'm not gonna give him a thumbs down
either. This is a neutral grade. Noticeably better than last year, so no punishment,
but still not good enough to be rewarded. I'm saved here by the low expectations.
Well, it wasn't pretty, but Shea Langeleers did it. A .224 average and .288 on base aren't great,
but he mashed 29 homers in 137 games, en route to slugging .450, and most importantly,
a .111 OPS plus in the A's final year in the pitcher-friendly coliseum. That .111 OPS plus
is the key here. He was firmly an above average hitter, and there aren't that many everyday
catchers who can say that in any given year. This was also a stellar improvement upon his
first two seasons in the big leagues, where he put up a sub .700 OPS and a .91 OPS plus in 175
games. His defense still isn't great, but he was one of the better offensive catchers in baseball
this year, and that's what matters here. I thought about giving this two thumbs up,
but I'll stick with just the one. It was a good pick, just not an awesome pick.
That's an aggregate of minus two for the five hitters I like category, not my finest showing.
So we're done with my breakout picks, but how about my breakdown picks? Here are the five
players I disliked coming into 2024. I tried something here. Nick Castellanos was a hitter
I liked back in 2021, and it worked out, so was I able to successfully fade him in 2024?
At first it seemed like I nailed the pick, as he OPSed about .600 through the first couple months
of the season, but then he got hot and stayed hot, OPSing over .800 the rest of the way to finish
with a .106 OPS plus. A bit worse than 2023, but still above average as a hitter. I didn't think
he'd do that. I didn't think he'd be an above average hitter. I thought the strikeout and
whiff rates were climbing too high, and the aging curve would not be kind to him. Instead,
he dropped his strikeout rate from 28% to 21%, while still managing to hit 23 home runs.
This is a thumbs down, but only the one. It'd be a two thumbs down if he somehow performed better
than he did in 2023, but that didn't quite happen. In many ways, my pick of Nolan Shonowell mirrors
the pick of Castellanos. About a .600 OPS through the first couple months of the season, but then
he turned it on the rest of the way to be an average to above average hitter. With 13 home
runs on the year, he generated just enough power to keep pitchers honest, which I didn't think
would happen. It wasn't an incredible season by any means. League average-ish bats who don't
contribute much defensively aren't inherently all that valuable, but it was a respectable rookie
season, even if it was well below some of the more optimistic projection systems. So, not amazing,
but he hit better than I thought, and it's that performance versus expectations that ultimately
matters. One thumbs down. Minus one. Tough one to grade here. Eduardo Rodriguez spent most of
the season injured, which is something I hadn't accounted for when making this pick. I guess the
question is, did he give us a large enough sample when he did pitch? He had an ERA just over 5 in
starts for Arizona, well above the 3.3 he had with Detroit last year, as well as his career
mark of about 4, so that would point to a negative result for E-Rod, and thus a positive result for
me. The pick was logically sound and well-reasoned, but I'd be lying if I said you can always draw
meaningful conclusions from a 50-inning sample. He missed 4 months and made his Diamondbacks
debut without a rehab assignment, after all. It's a debate between one thumbs up or neutral.
I'm gonna go with the one thumbs up. I punished myself for Tyler O'Neal's injuries,
I'll be nice to myself here. When I made the Dylan Seas pick,
he was still with the White Sox. I think escaping that situation before opening day and joining a
fun Padres team was a real difference maker. After a back and forth 2022 and 2023, his peripheral
numbers, like his always excellent strikeout rates, fell in line with his ERA, which had been
all over the place. A 3.47 ERA in 189 innings was the result, which makes this a pretty obvious
grade. My attempt to undercut those who are maybe a little too reliant on simple peripheral metrics
didn't really work. The strikeouts were up, the walks were down, Dylan Seas took advantage of the
new situation, and did good Dylan Seas things. A great season for Seas is a bad result for me.
Two thumbs down. Can I salvage this with my last pick? I'm sorry David Bednar. I'm sorry it had to
be you. After having a sub 3 ERA each of the past 3 seasons, and leading the National League in
saves in 2023, it all fell apart in 2024. The strikeout rate plummeted, the walk rate went up,
and the unsustainably low home run rate inflated as well. He struggled with oblique injuries
throughout the year, so that may be a partial culprit, but this was a dreadful season. His ERA
was close to 6, he blew 7 saves, and he ended up losing the 9th inning job by the end of the season.
Relievers are finicky, but this was a sharp turn for a 29 year old who had been one of the top
closers in the league. It's a simple and obvious conclusion. Two thumbs up for my pick. Obviously
I had an inkling he might stumble, but I didn't think it would be nearly this bad. That gives me
a minus 1 on aggregate for the players I disliked. I did really well in this category the past couple
years, but wasn't productive as a hater in 2024. So, with the plus 6 from the pitchers I liked,
minus 2 from the hitters I liked, and minus 1 from the players I disliked,
we end with a total score of plus 3. Better than last year's plus 1 for the sake of comparison,
and I also graded myself a little more critically. Not a bad year for me. I thought I made some
interesting picks, and even if they didn't all work out, I kept myself honest. The highlight was
clearly the 5 pitchers I liked. I don't think I've had a performance quite that good in all my years
of doing this. That's all for now, stay tuned for my reaction to the 2024 Foolish 50, coming soon.
