Richard Meier - Architectural critics (32_36)

Honor Art
11 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 24, 2024
Lewis Mumford was an architectural critic, and a very important one. There are probably people between Mumford and Ada Louise Huxtable but I don’t know who they are. Ada Louise Huxtable changed, in the United States, the media’s interests and perception of architecture in the most profound way...
Lewis Mumford was an architectural critic, and a very important one.
There are probably people between Mumford and Ada Louise Huxtable, but I don't know who they are.
Ada Louise Huxtable changed, in the United States, the media's interest and perception of architecture in the most profound way.
She was the first, at least in my lifetime, the first serious, thoughtful, conscientious commentator and critic.
The New York Times, to some degree at least, appreciated the quality that she brought to the newspaper.
Other cities then, in fact, followed. In Los Angeles, they have architectural critics.
In Chicago, major cities have people writing about architecture, but rarely of the quality of Ada Louise Huxtable.
But nevertheless, they saw that there was something the public was interested in, and wanted to know about, and therefore found people to write about them.
More often than not, these were reporters more than critics, and so the writing took on more of a reportage aspect than a critical one,
although there are people writing for the Chicago Tribune, the Boston Globe, the Los Angeles Times,
that attempt architectural criticism, and attempt to try to raise the level of what is being built in their city.
For many, this has become, they feel it's almost like promotion, and therefore they try to get different people to write about their project.
Whether it's in the real estate section of the New York Times or something, just to give it notoriety and credibility.
So there's then this aspect of promotional writing as opposed to critical writing.
Sometimes it's hard to see whether something's on one side or another.
And then there are critics whose opinion you know is going to go in a certain direction, and they're going to write about certain kinds of things in a certain way, and other things in another kind of way.
But the general public probably doesn't have that level of discernibility, and therefore, at least I believe, most of the things I read in the newspaper I probably shouldn't,
because it's probably as distorted as everything else is.
But in architecture, I think what's happened is it's kind of promoted an awareness of what's happening, and that's very good.
But at a professional level, who would you say are the critics that really contribute the most?
Well, I happen to think that Nikolai Orosov is a good writer.
I don't always agree with what he says, but I think it's thoughtful and it's well put together.
I always liked Herbert Mouchamp as a critic and thought he was extremely good, but he was all over the place.
Paul Goldberger, in his attempt to, I think, try to be fair to whatever he's writing about, sort of keeps jumping back and forth from one side to another, and you never know quite where he stands as a result.
Because he's always saying, on the other hand.
But I think that he's certainly a thoughtful critic most of the time.
Who?
Well, Kenneth is really more a historian and critic than someone that you associate with what's going on.
He really is an extraordinary writer and critic, but is not...
Theoretician.
Huh?
Theoretician.
Yeah, he's more of a theoretician.
Kenneth's more of a theoretician than he is a critic.
And Joseph Rickward, I think, just has too many other interests.
Really, I mean, he can write about anything and be brilliant.
And architecture is one of the things that interests him, but it's not the only thing that interests Joseph.
And I think Joseph, were he to focus on architecture, would be much more influential than he is.
But unfortunately, there really aren't that many people who write well about architecture.
But I would say people like Frampton, for instance, made a large contribution to the development of architecture.
Thank you.
Yeah, that's true.
A new generation in the last 14 years.
A very important figure.
Yeah, no, no.
I think Kenneth Frampton has probably been the most important figure in architectural education and literature.
