Demonstration of Field methods in Biological Anthropology

Archaeology Terrifying
3 followers
1 Video View·Nov 23, 2024
Research Methods and Fieldwork
Module : Demonstration of Field methods in Biological Anthropology
Hello students, I am Anup Kumar Kapoor from Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi.
Today I am going to speak on the module
Demonstration of Field Methods in Biological Anthropology
from the paper Research Methods and Fieldwork.
The learning outcomes of the modules are
First, to understand about the basic concept of fieldwork and fieldwork tradition in anthropology.
Second, to learn the basic idea of fieldwork in physical or biological anthropology.
And third one, to elucidate the information related to division of anthropometry
and the different anthropometric instruments in physical or biological anthropology.
First of all, we will introduce briefly on fieldwork and fieldwork tradition in anthropology.
Fieldwork, more than anything else, characterizes the discipline of anthropology.
It advocates face-to-face experience with its subjects.
One of the anthropologists in 1983 puts it brilliantly by stating that
there is due to anthropologist's desire to receive phenomenal thoughts,
his own senses, because there is great love of facts.
The concept of fieldwork in anthropology is different from the other social sciences.
Anthropology would not be what it is today but for the insights fed into it by intensive fieldwork.
It was not, however, always so.
Fieldwork was not what interested our founding fathers.
Anthropology in its early stages was mainly concerned with the study of primitive society.
In the absence of any scientifically collected data by professionals,
the image of primitive man was determined by description of such narrators as travelers and hunters.
Hence, there seems to have been a pendulum swing from extreme in speculation about primitive man.
First, he was little more than an animal who lived in poverty, violence and fear.
Then he was a gentle person who lived in plenty, peace and security.
First he was lawless, then he was a slave to law and custom.
First he was devoid of any religious feelings or beliefs,
and then he was entirely dominated by the sacred and immersed in ritual.
First he was an individualist who preyed on the weaker and held what he could.
Then he was a communist who held lands and goods in common.
First he was sexually prosumptuous, then he was a model of domestic virtue.
First he was lethargic and incorrigibly lazy.
Then he was alert and industrious, as given by Evan Sporchard in 1956.
There were all sorts of distortions and contradictions.
Subjectivity was sometimes stretched to absurdity and fantasy.
Among the pioneer field researchers, the man who did more than most others in defining the nature of fieldwork was Rivers.
He distinguished between intensive and survey work.
Intensive empirical studies form the core of anthropological studies today.
Rivers had himself engaged in both types of research.
Survey work in Melanesia and intensive fieldwork among the Toda tribes in India.
However, the early empirical research suffered from some weaknesses.
The short time researchers spent among the people they studied,
the ignorance of the subjects' language and their casual approach did not permit deep investigation.
Radcliffe Brown, a student of Rivers and Haddon, provided an important thrust to the anthropological fieldwork.
His fieldwork among the Andaman Islanders in India between 1906 to 1908
is considered to be the first genuinely intensive fieldwork in a primitive society
to describe the social life of a people in such a way as to bring out clearly what was significant in it for theorists.
He believed, or he lived among the Andaman Islanders intimately,
learned their language and collected the data through participant observation.
Malinowski, the great British anthropologist of Polish origin,
transformed the fieldwork in anthropology to such an extent that things could never be the same again.
As Sarna in 1983 correctly remarks,
with the publication of Malinowski,
argonauts of the Western Pacific emulated ethnography was totally eclipsed.
The ethnography field became a highly professionalized activity.
It was no more data collection.
It turned into deeper analysis of particular social structure and cultural patterns.
He was a thorough fieldworker.
He not only spent a longer period of time than any anthropologist before
or after him in a single study of a primitive people,
but he was also the first anthropologist to conduct his whole research through the native language.
It is he who proclaimed what may be called the philosophy of fieldwork
and there is little that has been added to the principles of fieldwork given by Malinowski.
Half a century ago.
We certainly use more technical aids today,
increasingly rely upon statistical tools,
but the essential definition of the nature of fieldwork remains substantially the same as.
The essential requirements and conditions of a good field work described in the preceding paragraph
may be covered within the parameters of two terms,
intensive fieldwork and participant observation,
so distinctive of anthropological studies.
Unfortunately, very few people have published their field experiences.
This implication of the general neglect would seem to be that
what matters are the results of fieldwork
rather than the techniques that one might employ for data collection.
So long as certain basic requirements of objective investigation have been met,
this is a pity because the importance of self-analysis
by the investigator becomes very valuable for himself
and for others in the absence of standardization of fieldwork techniques.
One way to meet this situation is to try to standardize research techniques
and to prepare formal guides to fieldwork.
The argument is simple.
Anthropology as a bio-social science can hardly afford to be personal adventure.
It has to be a collective endeavor united by shared understandings
in respect of both purpose and methodology.
Methods of bio-social research should be communicated to students in the classroom
and replicable in the field.
Now let us discuss about the fieldwork in physical or biological anthropology.
Whatever has been described in the preceding pages
is mainly concerned with fieldwork in bio-social anthropology
and of course most of the anthropological field research is concerned
with this branch of anthropology.
However, research in physical or biological anthropology
also requires fulfillment of some of the conditions
laid down for social or cultural anthropology.
Earlier, physical anthropology research was mainly confined
to the study of morphological criteria for racial classification.
Biological anthropologists study biological and physical features
of cultures and societies by spending time observing,
interacting and taking anthropometric measurements
with the members of those cultures, taking notes.
Here, I would like to tell you certain points
that it is up to the concerned anthropologist
how he perceives the concept of fieldwork,
how he thinks how to carry out the fieldwork,
it depends on the basis of his experience.
What I want to say is, in case you go for 15 days first phase of fieldwork,
you will have a different experience.
When you go for a one-month or two-month fieldwork experience,
in second phase, you will have a different experience.
When you will go for more than three months or four months,
you will have a different experience.
Means here, face-to-face interaction.
That is very important for the student of anthropology.
What I see is that you have to spend maximum time among the people,
in one particular habitat, in a village,
so that you can have all the information from the family,
from the village or whatever group you are going to study.
Historically, biological anthropologists relied on observation and second-hand accounts.
Then, extra-political conclusions, often incorrect,
based on lack of first-hand experience.
Over time, biological anthropologists began to abandon armchair anthropology
in favor of physical study in the field,
collecting their own information.
Biological anthropologists conducted fieldwork using their own senses and tools
to document experiences and research with other societies.
The present physical anthropology involves extensive research in dental anthropology,
population genetics, cytogenetics, molecular and biochemical genetics,
and a host of other specializations like demography.
Some of these fields require detailed knowledge of the environment
and kinship systems of the human groups under study.
All this requires at least some of the methodological fineness and vigor
demonstrated by bio-social anthropology.
The physical anthropologists, too, are required to establish rapport
with their subjects and respondents,
and sometimes have to resort to participant observation techniques
to elicit required data.
Fieldwork has been accepted as an indispensable rite-de-passage
in the making of what modern anthropologists sometimes refer to as
a nectar, or a feat of living with strength.
The anthropological approach to Siu-Klung-Ong's term
is that of attached detachment.
At present, fieldwork is considered, in Kroeber's words,
an opportunity, a privilege, and a professional catch-up.
Levi-Strauss has the last word when he says that
indeed the field research with which every anthropological career
begins is the mother and wet nurse of doubt,
the philosophical attitude par excellence.
This anthropological doubt doesn't only consist of
knowing that one knows nothing, but of resolutely exposing
what one thought, one knew, and indeed one's very own ignorance
to the bufferings, and indeed one's very own ignorance
to most cherished ideas and habits by them to the highest degree.
Let us discuss about history of science of anthropometry.
When White, in 1974, bases his assertion upon the observation of both skeletons,
a living man, made the statement that the forearm of negroes
in proportion to the upper arm was longer than in white men,
he integrated the science of comparative racial anthropometry
and showed that there were constant differences in the bodily proportions
of the various human races.
Differences of this sort seem to have been unrecognized before this,
even by artists and sculptors,
who, although from the time of Egyptians and Assyrian carvings,
had elaborated and even emphasized the racial characters of face and hand,
had given no heed to differences in the other parts of the body.
It is, then, quite possible that the classic sculptors of Greece and Rome
may have used indifferently as models their own people and their foreign slaves,
which may serve to verify and explain the asserted negroid proportions
of the hollow belly-building.
The assertion of White was an advance upon new ground,
and although it was accompanied by neither detailed measurements,
calculations of averages or indices,
it was yet of great value in the development of the subject.
After this, however, the work roasted for 44 years,
when Humphrey in 1838 made careful measurements not only of humerus and radius,
but of femur and tibia also, in 25 skeletons of Negroes
and the same number of those of White men.
White regarding the long forearm, that is, radius of Negroes,
and found a similar greater length in the lower leg,
that is, the tibia, of the same race, as compared with the Whites.
But by this time, other anthropologists had become interested in racial differences
in body proportion, and under the critical scrutiny of Broca.
This subject received still more careful treatment.
He pointed out the fact that a total height obtained from the articulated skeleton
depended too much upon the preparatory who put the bones together,
and hence disregarded these unsubstantiated measurements
in favor of one involving the length of a single long bone or of two combined.
He thus substituted for Humphrey's standard, now the length of the femur,
then the radius, and again the combined length of the humerus and radius,
or femur and tibia, with each of which, in turn, with a value of 100,
the length of the other long arm and leg bones was compared.
This line of work, the anthropometry of the living subjects,
developed naturally in the field as astrometry had developed in the museum
and was a direct result of a series of great scientific voyages,
like those of the novice and the challenger characteristics of the last third of the 19th century.
Naturally, in the development of physical anthropology or ethnology,
the facial features had long received much attention,
and had become the subject of careful measurements with averages and indices,
and the extension of this work to the rest of the body naturally followed.
Thus, by the opening of the new century,
anthropometry had already become an important branch of anthropology,
expressed in extensive and rapidly increasing literature.
Individual instigators, however, differed widely,
not only in the measurements employed and in their relative values,
but in the manner in which these measurements were taken and the instruments used,
so that there could be little or no trustworthy comparison
between the results of different investigations.
The science was thus ready for its next phase of development,
the standardizing of the measurements.
This was first attempted in the case of the skull,
as criminology had received the most attention,
and these measurements were thus the most in need of standardizing
and came as a result of the International Congress on Anthropology's meeting in Monaco during April 1906.
The proposal for this came from the committee of the Congress,
M. M. M. P. Pepillon and Vernieu,
and the work was done by a special committee appointed for the purpose.
M. F. Gluferida-Rugri et al.,
the proposals presented by the committee were ratified by the Congress
and have thus become the set of standard skull measurements
to be followed so far as possible by anthropometrists everywhere.
A second standardization, that of measurements of the living body excluding the head,
resulted in much the same way from proposals at the International Congress of 1912,
which met in Geneva, Switzerland, in September of that year.
There were 49 separate measurements proposed by the committee,
and these were, as in the previous case, enormously devoted by the Congress.
The anthropometry of the bones of the skeleton, aside from the skull,
has not as yet become subject of international agreement,
and is thus still in the stage of anthropometry just previous to 1906.
That is, detailed measurements have been worked out for the separate bones by different investigators,
but the work needs yet to be standardized,
and those measurements selected which are generally considered essential.
We accept the final work of Turner,
who published his work on the skeletons collected by the Challenger expedition in 1886,
that detailed astrometry of the separate bones has been the work of the 20th century.
The modern treatment of the vertical column, a difficult problem for the astrometrist,
was delayed until 1912, when it received competent treatment by Hasseby.
The skeleton of hand and foot may be treated as a whole,
or certain significant bones, especially those of carpus and tarsus, may be considered by themselves.
Thus, for the foot skeleton as a whole, there is the paper of Volkovo in 1905,
and that of M. N. Mimmi, Adachi of the same year,
while for separate foot bones those of Siebel.
On the talus of M. S. Smith on Cupid and Ravicolor's bone.
And a lecture on the calculus in 1913 may serve as an example.
It may thus to be said that at the outbreak of the European war in 1914,
the field of astrometry had just been covered as for the first blocking
out of essential measurements for the separate bones.
But that no attempt has been made to establish a general agreement
or to insure the industry industry is still less.
There have been a sufficient number of studies based upon the bones of the separate human races
to form the basis of much comparison.
It at this point that we may trust the work will be resumed at the expiration of the Great War.
The employment of angular measurements, now an important part of anthropometry,
especially in the case of bones, has had a course of development closely,
similar to that of linear measurements and above reviewed.
The first angle employed was a famous facial angle of Petra's Camper,
described in a posthumous work of this author bearing the date 1780.
On the other hand, the apes, monkeys and lower mammals gave angles less than 70 degrees
in a decreasing series, so that this facial angle was roughly a measure of the height of the forehead
and hence indicating of their general intelligence.
As with the linear measurements, the mid-19th century,
largely under the leadership of Paul Broca, brought into use other angles,
for the most part those of the skull,
while at present times important angular measurements have been established for many other bones.
Concerning the actual value of anthropometric measurements of whatever sort
and the extent to which measurements may be profitably carried,
both opinion and practice differ widely.
As in other forms of biometrics, where mathematics plays an important part in the investigation of a primarily biological problem,
certain investigators are bound to be more interested in the mathematical than in the biological side,
and there is always danger that in their hands the latter cause may suffer
and the work be viewed as a mathematical problem in which the goal is reached
when the new relations involved are expressed in the form of formulae and tables.
A real danger that besets the anthropometrist along the mathematical side
and one to which a student may be naturally brought by seeking to be accurate
is the temptation to take with too great respect the actual figures obtained from the individual measurements,
to regard the decimal place as of equal importance in all the cases
and to feel that a series of measurements carried out to the third place, for instance,
is much more accurate and reliable than one carried out only on a single place beyond the part.
As a matter of fact, the accuracy of a result depends essentially upon the method of taking the measurement
and here not only must be personal equations as involved in the operator.
We take into consideration but also the condition of the material measured
for where the decimal places used go beyond the error of two consecutive measurements,
there is absolutely no value in carrying them out
if, as an illustration, we find that in the certain skull measurements,
the results obtained by different operators or by the same operator at different times
do not agree with each other to within 0.5 mm,
it is simply time lost to attempt to carry out the needed measurements beyond one decimal place.
Especially in the case of measurements on the living
where the operator has to consider not only his own degree of accuracy
but also the slight involuntary changes of position of the subject,
there are certain other longer measurements where work cannot hope to be accurate within a whole cm
and where attention to differences of 2-3 mm would be of no possible avail.
What are the aims and demonstrations of field methods in Bioregional Anthropology?
That is very important when we deal with the Bioregional Anthropology.
The aim of the demonstration of field methods in Bioregional Anthropology is to provide
in a form suitable for use in the field instruction on the whole range of methods
required for the fulfillment of human biological studies on a comparative basis.
Certain of these methods can be used to carry out the rapid surveys on growth, physique and genetic constitution.
They are also appropriate for the pursuit of intensive multidisciplinary investigation.
Finally, procedures are laid down whereby the requisite background information
about the group, sample, subject under study may be obtained.
These concern in particular the full identification of the group, sample and subject,
medical and nutrient status, socio-demographic characteristics
and analysis of habitual activity pattern and the description of the environment.
When we take the arrangement of sections, demonstrations of field methods in Bioregional Anthropology
can be arranged in the following sections.
First is an introduction which includes a brief general description and rationale of the procedure,
a list of observations to be made and most important a note on desirable sample size and composition.
Second is technique. This part includes detailed instructions for carrying out any test required relative to the observation to be made.
Next is the data collecting sheet.
This is a form to be filled in for each individual study,
giving minimum personal details and all the essential data obtained by means of procedures.
These forms are also to be used as a primary data collecting sheet in the field.
The great majority of the data sheet, however, is presented in a form suitable for recording in the field,
but for computer use transfer and encoding the data would be necessary,
which is very important in present day scenario.
The next is need for trained personnel are required to carry out these all measurements.
The methods, even where these are described in great detail,
demand a thorough acquaintance with their underlying principles as well as the technical details and use of instruments.
Even the simple techniques such as those of anthropometry and anthroposcopy cannot give reliable results
unless the observer has practiced the methods thoroughly
and has an appreciation of the inherent errors and limitations of the techniques.
Facilities for training in all the requisite techniques certainly exist,
although it is appreciated that to take advantage of these may in some cases be difficult on financial grounds.
Next comes fieldwork approach to the local population.
The detailed formulation for research and its execution is naturally the responsibility of the team concerned
and they will undertake the necessary discussion with those countries whose cooperation in a particular region is desirable.
Wherever possible, a preliminary visit should be planned,
so that proper arrangements can be made with the authorities concerned for administrative, customs, etc.,
and a full explanation of the aims and conduct of the local authorities concerned.
The full cooperation must in all cases be ensured.
In this connection, research team in the field will be under special obligation
to maintain a high ethical approach to the local population.
Permission to test subjects on the field should be sought not only from individuals and administrative leaders,
but also from community and tribal leaders.
Next comes the specification for the individual and the group description.
For each technique related to data collection during biological and biological fieldwork,
sufficient information is to be recorded.
To make possible the clear identification of both the subjects of the examination,
the following suggestions may be considered.
For example, marking the subject, taking photographs, taking fingerprints,
distinguishing features, some other characteristics.
The second is age ascertainment, where the chronological age is known.
This method will be recorded as a decimal age.
Many persons living in the developing region or the tropics, however, are ignorant of their exact age.
Occasionally, many employ a system of age classification different from the Western method.
The reason for this is that the precise age may have little significance unless it has been recognized.
Social value, for example, in relation to legal responsibility, permission to school prevention rights, etc.
Among some people, functional or physiological age groups are recognized.
For example, big enough to be able to carry goats, or capable of carrying a younger sibling, or marriageable.
For adults, all that have been possible is to consider the two sexes in a broad age group, young adults, adults, and older adults.
However, differentiation may sometimes be difficult in groups where the gap here is safe,
where there is no middle-age obesity, and where facial wrinkles are less prominent against a darker complexion,
or conversely, where women age rapidly with continuous childbearing and too much work.
A long-term local calendar of important events may have to be constructed based on events in the preceding years,
including agriculture, climatic and political occurrences, as well as natural or man-made disasters.
More exact age assessment is desirable in the anthropometry of young children.
When dealing with infants and preschool children, ages should, if possible, be known to the nearest month.
For school children, assessments of ages to the nearest three months should be attended in field surveys.
Circumstances of age assessment in young children may be attempted in various ways.
Documentary evidences may, through, rarely be forthcoming, including birth certificates, horoscopes, and baptism certificates.
Careful must be encouraged to bring these vital papers at the time of examination.
Next is selection of sample size.
For a single population, following points must be kept in mind while selecting the sample size,
that is, sampling should be simple, random, without replacement.
Second is the population sample should be infinitely large,
and the sample size in each instance should be to provide a confidence interval of half-range, the probability being 0.05.
Two cases are mostly considered, mainly the estimation of a proportion and the estimation of the means of normality distributed variable.
For comparison of the two populations, the standard procedure for deciding the appropriate sample size to obtain a given clearance,
or to be given a chance, a discrimination between the means of two normal populations is set to out in Biometrica,
that is a table for statistician Kevin Strieper's paper published in 1954,
where the comparison is between two proportions for the two populations,
the procedure to be followed is described in the most statistical books.
Anthropometric instruments, the instruments employed in anthropometry may be grouped according to form and use,
as follows, instruments for measurement, linear measurements, you have to use calipers,
craniophore, craniometer, palliometer, slide compass, anthropometer, rod compass, osmotic board,
angles, goniometer, goniometer for attachment, special types for goniometer, torsion angle, that is the shaft of lung and bones.
Palliograph, volumetric instruments, scales for recording weight, then comes instruments for holding and orienting skulls and other bones.
Simple types of craniophore, cubic craniophore of marten, osteophores, combined craniophores and osteophores of hedgehog,
instruments for drawing and delineating deptograph, or lucas, perigraph, or region, digraph of marine, stereograph of baroca.
Let us summarize what we have learned in this module.
Fieldwork characterizes the discipline of anthropology.
It advocates face-to-face experience with the subjects.
Anthropology in its early stage was mainly concerned with the study of primitive society,
but now it is concerned with the different fields, like development, health, nutrition, lifestyle, culture, and belief,
and not leaving behind the conventional areas of research.
Seligman remarked that fieldwork was to anthropology what the blood of the martyrs was to church.
Indeed, rude, prophetic.
From this time onward, anthropology became a whole-time professional study,
and field experience is an essential part of anthropological study.
The use of more technical aids today increasingly relies upon statistical tools,
but the essential definition of the nature of fieldwork remains substantially the same as Wernicke's description.
It is necessary for anthropologists to spend sufficient time on the study.
He must throughout be in close contact with the people among whom he is working,
and he must communicate with them solely through their own language,
and he must study their entire culture and social life.
The essential requirements and conditions of a good fieldwork
may be covered within the parameters of two terms, intensive fieldwork and participative observation.
So, distinguished anthropological studies, methods of bio-social research,
should be communicable to students in the classroom and replicable in the field.
Physical anthropology research was mainly confined to the study of morphological criteria for racial classification.
Finally, I would like to say that nowadays there is a change in the perspective of anthropology.
As we have discussed, the fieldwork started from the prehistoric or from the primitive society.
Now in 21st century, fieldwork is carrying out in different parts, different global level, in different institutes.
Nowadays, corporate sectors have come, industries have come,
different things are coming up where the student anthropology is carrying out the fieldwork.
In the case of corporate sectors, in the case of...
Even people have chosen, the students of anthropology have chosen different temples to carry out the work.
So, mainly at that time, it is up to the student.
He or she has to think on which topic he or she wants to do the research.
And then accordingly, he has to make the plans for the fieldwork.
And in my personal view is that whenever you make a plan, it should be minimum,
it should be a one-year program for fieldwork so that you will have the data,
all the information in all the seasons in a particular area,
get the information in case you are a good fieldworker.
Nowadays, it has been observed that people go there for a few days and then come back.
This is not the way. The maximum time you spend in the field, maximum data you will get from the field.
Thank you.
