ASNJ 02-21-21 George Leader, William Green Plantation: On-Going Archaeological & Historical Research

The Archaeology Mystery
17 followers
Nov 22, 2024
Thank you for having me. My name is George Leder. I'm an archaeologist at the College of New Jersey
and thanks to the Archaeological Society of New Jersey. So I'm going to talk to you today a little
bit about our on-campus research project which is the William Green Plantation and you know I may
have some of you may be familiar with it but others may not be. So I'll just give you a little
bit of a background as to what we've been doing at this this house that you see here on the slide.
First and foremost if you've been to our campus you'll know that the main entrance is kind of
down here on the east side of campus. If you follow the road Metzger Drive that is the circular
road around campus all the way to the end you're going to see a very tucked back nonchalant house
that's kind of got some foliage around it and it would be very unnoticeable if you weren't
specifically looking for it. That is the William Green House. That house in its current state in
the insert picture up here that was built around 1720. Now some accounts have that as early as
about 1717 and some accounts differ so we'll say about 1720. Here you can see it in a 1920-ish
photo with the working farmyard here just south of the house, the barn, the windmill up here,
some animal houses in here, animal barns and you know the back porch coming off this south side of
the house. So we have an idea of kind of its uses through a little bit of time and into the 1920s
and then up into the 1960s. So why are we interested in this house? Well for obvious
reasons it's a very very old house with a very interesting history. Part of that history
is its possible role in the Revolutionary War. This is an example, this is a pension application
that came from Phoebe Green, one of the individuals who lived in the house, and she
mentions in her military pension application that the light horse of Washington's army
billeted at different times during the war at the William Green's plantation. Now
what does she mean billeted there at different times? Well what that possibly means or probably
means is that the cavalry which was stationed out there after the Battle of Trenton might have
billeted there for foraging for food different times over those harsh winters. In particular
this brings us into the possibility that it was Casimir Pulaski. So Pulaski was the head of
Washington's light cavalry after the Battle of Trenton. He and 120 men and horses were
were they were assigned to patrol the area around Trenton so that the British and the
Hessian forces could not return. It was a particularly harsh winter and subsequently
they had to forage, they had to billet at numerous plantations in the area. So it is very likely that
they spent some time at the William Green plantation. So the next reason we're interested the
house itself as a representation of early architecture. Here is a nice example you can
see the Flemish brick bond work on the oldest section of the house here. They discontinued
that patterning with subsequent additions to the house. This section was built in the 1780s
and then on the other side in the 1830s as I'll discuss. But you know we're interested in
the evolution of obviously the house but also the occupants of the house and that would be
all people who lived in the house and who worked the land and we'll talk a little bit about that.
We know that the house was occupied into the 1960s and the last known occupants were I believe
there was a football coach and at one point a professor of TC&J then known as Trenton State
living in the house before it was closed up. So what can we do archaeologically? Well in the
late 80s and the early 90s a few excavations were conducted out there by a now retired
professor Carolyn Metz and she excavated on the south side of the house and made a few test pits
along the yard and into the east section of the house. In the years to follow these artifacts
were completely forgotten about. The field notes were kind of after her retirement were kind of
passed around from department to department and eventually lost. And when I arrived at TC&J in
2013 I stumbled upon them in the anthropology lab along with a few artifacts that were catalogued
in. So some of the field notes are still there but we decided to open up some new excavations
and attempt to answer some new research questions about the house. And you see that it's got a
number of different sections here all except for the 1920s summer kitchen is are still standing.
So in 2015 we began the excavations 2019 also and we hope that we'll be excavating again in 2020.
I do have a few students doing some small scale testing this spring as well but what we recovered
were a great sample of colonial aged and 18th, 19th century artifacts and everything that you
find at a typical colonial household site. You know shells, metal ornamentations, ceramics,
glass, glasses of different sorts, window glass and bottle glass. But we still have a lot of
questions that remain unanswered. Luckily we have very enthusiastic students here
standing in 2019 with some of the artifacts that were recovered. Now what we have done to this
point is attempted to increase the assemblage and increase the context with which we
understand the assemblage because the field notes from the previous 1990s excavations are
kind of very fragmented. Numbers are wearing off. Artifacts sometimes disappear over many years
if there's not an archaeologist working there. So we've got a lot of lost data that we're trying
to piece together. The next question that we have is a very important question. We are interested
in whether or not there were enslaved persons or indentured servants at the house and this got
some attention last summer when we were sharing some of the research we've been doing. So to this
point we have a few lines of evidence that demonstrate that the Green family in other
households were indeed slaveholders. So here we have a William R. Green who did not live at the
Green Plantation, our Green Plantation, manumitted Michael Gibbs aged 27 in 1806. And I should say
before I get ahead of myself that this great work was done by one of my students for her senior
thesis, Kristen Bridges, and she did just a fantastic job. And then William E. Green in 1803
manumitted a mulatto slave named Philip aged 27 years old. So we know that the Greens in the
extended family were practicing slaveholders. Additional evidence comes from the form of birth
records. Okay this is again Kristen Bridges thesis work and she found that Charles was born to Betty
owned by Nathaniel Green. She's got George born to Dina. She's also got Dick born to Dina, a
different spelling, perhaps the same enslaved person owned by the same William E. Green in the
records. And Ruth born to Jeanette. And all these are different time periods ranging from
from 1804 to 1835. Again all of these individual Greens are not at our particular
plantation. But we are interested in seeing if there were, there is evidence of enslaved persons
there. That is a big part of our research question. So how can we do that from an archaeological
standpoint? Well you know many of you are archaeologists and you know that this is
really really difficult for many reasons. One of the places we can look is potentially in the
basement. So here in the basement where often in the north on smaller plantations which maybe had
a smaller number of enslaved persons. Those persons would live in either the basement,
sometimes the attic, sometimes the kitchen, not always having separate quarters to build for them.
Now that can vary of course. So we you know we looked at some archaeological evidence in the
basement. Lots and lots of artifacts down there. And of course as you very well know it is very
very difficult to distinguish any artifact that might have been part of an enslaved person's
belongings. So at this point no archaeological evidence has yet been found of enslaved persons
at the plantation. But again as I said you all know that rarely in the north do they live in
separate cabins. Now it does happen but more often in you know maybe even in a barn. It is
very difficult to find artifacts that can distinctly be associated with enslavement.
One of the sites that James Dell worked on was at the Thompson site and he's
suggested that you know the enslaved occupants of this small eight-room house lived in close
contact likely sharing objects and spaces with each other. Again very difficult to distinguish
these artifacts. So we have to go back to the archives and look at the historical records.
And when we do that we start to put together a little bit more a few lines of evidence.
In particular we have within the last will and testament of Phoebe Greene, the same Phoebe Greene
that wrote that military pension in 1803. She wills as you can see here the time of a black boy
and excuse me doesn't will it but it is listed as property and valued at 115 150 dollars. So
the black boy is listed as property here and and 150 dollars. This is 1830. I believe that's 37
there. And the other piece of evidence is in the last William testament of William Greene III. Okay
I leave the time of my black girl Eliza Reasoner to my daughter-in-law Rebecca Welling. And that's
not the only evidence of indentured servitude or excuse me in possibly enslaved person or indentured
servant we have being willed to somebody else. The question we have is that muddy differentiation
between enslaved person and indentured servant which is as you as you may know very slightly
different legal terms and slightly different rights for an indentured servant versus an
enslaved person making it no less a horrendous and awful situation for the person. So you know
one of the things we must continue to do with this house is continue to investigate its full
history. And we see it you know it is this is its current state. Okay this this is its current
state. It is you know derelict in the inside it is completely overrun with with you know
feral animals and and it's it's falling apart. It's got the fence around it it's boarded up
and you know many of us see this as a preservation and educational opportunity for for so many
individuals. We are we are right around the corner from from Trenton and you know we see this
potentially as an opportunity to to educate on the lives of early Ewing early Trenton's history
but also share the great contributions that early black enslaved and indentured servants
added to the economy in in colonial and post-colonial time periods in central New Jersey.
So the story is really just being pieced together now and we're very excited about the possibility
of of being able to share this with with as many as many young children school students and and
also continue undergraduate research projects and then and with the public. So so that is that
is in a nutshell and I hope I hit my time the William Green project which we are really excited
about. So thank you very much to the Archaeological Society of New Jersey. Thanks to Mike and Kristen
and thanks to everybody for for listening.
