Xenophon’s Anabasis

Population History
1 follower
1 Video View·Nov 22, 2024
"Xenophon
The Persian Expedition
The Landmark Xenophon’s Anabasis
The Sunday Penguin
….on Thursday
"
I personally, Captains, cannot sleep any more than I expect you can. And I can no longer lie still
when I think of the position we are in. For there is no doubt that the enemy only made open war on us
when they thought that their plans were complete. But on our side, there is now nobody who is
thinking out countermeasures whereby we can put up as good a fight as possible. Yet if we relax
and fall into the King's power, what sort of treatment can we expect from him?
He is the man who cut off and fixed to a stake the head and hand of his own brother,
his own mother's son, even when he was dead. So what sort of treatment can we expect,
we who have no blood relation to take our side, and who marched against him with the intention
of deposing him, and making him a subject, and killing him if we could? Will he not go to all
possible lengths, trying to inflict on us every conceivable misery, and so make all men afraid
of ever marching against him again? No, it is surely clear that we must do everything in our
power to avoid falling into his hands. Now, personally, while the truce was in force,
I could never stop feeling sorry for us, and looking with envy on the King and those on his
side. I considered what a large and splendid country they had, what inexhaustible supplies,
what quantities of service, of cattle, and gold, and clothing material. And then I thought,
on the other hand, of our men's prospects, that we could only get a share of all these
good things by paying for it, and I knew that there were not many left who had the money to do so,
and that the oaths we had sworn prevented us from acquiring supplies in any other way except by
paying for them. When I reckoned all this up, I sometimes used to feel more misgivings about the
truce than I now do about the war. Now, however, they have put an end to the truce, and I think
that the period of their arrogance and of our uneasy feelings is also ended, for now those
good things lie in front of us as prizes for whichever side shows itself to be the better men.
The gods are the judges of the contest, and they will naturally be on our side,
since it was our enemies who took their names in vain while we, with many good things before our
eyes, resolutely kept our hands off them because of the oaths we had sworn to the gods. So it seems
to me that we can enter the contest with much more confidence than they can. Then we are physically
better able than they are to endure cold and heat and hardship. Our morale is, with the gods on our
side, better than theirs, and if the gods grant us victory, as they did before, our enemies are easier
to wound and kill than we are. Quite likely there are others who feel the same as I do. Well then,
in heaven's name, let us not wait for other people to come to us and call upon us to do great deeds.
Let us instead be the first to summon the rest to the path of honor. Show yourselves
to be the bravest of all the captains, with more of a right to leadership than those who are our
leaders at present. As for me, if you are willing to take the initiative like this, I am prepared
to follow you. And if you appoint me to be your leader, I do not ask to be excused because of my
age. Indeed, I think I am already sufficiently grown up to act in my own defense. That was
Xenophon taking control in this book. This is the Penguin edition of Xenophon's
Anabasis, but in this Penguin edition they call it the Persian Expedition. Not really sure why
Penguin decided not to call it the Anabasis, but they did. They called it the Persian Expedition,
which it is indeed about. This tells the story of a bunch of Greek mercenaries who were hired by
Prince Cyrus of Persia to bring their 10,000 mercenaries into the Persian Empire and battle
and defeat his brother so that he, Prince Cyrus, could be the great king of Persia.
That was the plan. It didn't exactly go the way the Greeks hoped it would. Things kind of went
kind of terrible. So the Greeks marched into the Persian Empire in 401 BC. They fought a great
battle there, deep in the Persian Empire, and they won. They defeated the army they faced.
The Greeks, they were pretty darn tough, they were, when they were all in proper formation
and their armor with their shields and their spears. But Prince Cyrus was killed, and Prince
Cyrus was the only reason they were there. They were there to get Prince Cyrus to be on the throne.
So now here they are, deep in the Persian Empire, all alone with the reason for their being there
now gone. So any Persian ally of Cyrus, they're not going to, they're not going to stick around
with the Greeks. They got to get on the good side with Cyrus's brother. So yeah, due to treachery,
the main generals of the Persian army are killed, and the Persian army, the mercenary army that
Xenophon, the author of this book, is a part of, elects Xenophon as one of their leaders.
And he tells the story of their march back to the sea. All along the way they suffer hardship
and privation. The Persians are trying to kill them the whole way. There are other angry tribesmen
who are there, they're trying to kill them. Everybody's trying to kill these guys. And so
they have a tough time of it. It is a struggle to survive on their way out of the Persian Empire.
They had a tough time of it, these guys. And this is a fascinating story. It is one of the
fascinating things that you will read from the ancient world. Xenophon was a really interesting
guy. He was Athenian, a mercenary for a while with the Spartans. He continued the history
that Thucydides started of the Peloponnesian War. Thucydides died before he could finish
the Peloponnesian War history. Thucydides just picked it right up from where he left off.
And he continued the history, but he wasn't the historian, unfortunately, that Thucydides was.
Not even close, really. But he is a really interesting writer and he wrote a few books that
are still available for us to read. This one, the Anabasis, being one of the most fascinating
just because of the position that these Greeks are put in. And there are just a bunch of little
things that you learn in this book about the Persian Empire at the time and about the Greeks
at the time. And so it's kind of, in a way, a kind of rousing adventure story, sort of.
And an interesting history of this experience that Xenophon and these 10,000
soldiers had. And I, of course, highly recommend it. But I no longer recommend this edition.
For a long time, this was probably the best edition of this book that you could get.
But now, recently, this has finally been published. I've been waiting for this one for
literally ever. This is the landmark Xenophon's Anabasis, edited by Shane Brennan and David
Thomas. The series editor is Robert B. Strassler and the translation is by David Thomas.
So Robert B. Strassler started the landmark ancient history editions. He did Thucydides
and Herodotus all by himself. And then a bunch of others came. Well, not a bunch of others,
but quite a few came after that. And most recently, it was actually a Roman history.
It was Caesar, Caesar's histories. And now we have the continuation of the Greek histories.
And the landmark editions, I've showed them before. I've showed my beat up landmark Herodotus,
which I've carried around with me everywhere for about 10 years or more.
However long I've had that book. But this one just came out. And this one, of course,
is so much superior to the Persian, excuse me, to the Penguin edition. For one thing,
because there are a ton of maps. Of course, there are going to be countries in here
who have and they have different names than the places that they have now.
So there are a bunch of places that you just you wouldn't know where they were
without these maps. And they do travel quite a bit. So it's really handy to have
these maps. And also at the bottom, you've got a ton of notes, of course.
Xenophon was writing this well over 2000 years ago. He had no idea how much the world would
have changed. So yeah, we're going to need some notes to figure out what he's talking about
sometimes. There are a ton of appendices, though. Starts even earlier than this. Yeah,
this much of the book is just supplementary material. That's the history there. This is
just the extra stuff. And the extra stuff is really, really valuable. It always is in these
landmark editions. Aside from just the maps, you get a lot of illustrations and pictures
in these landmark editions. And they really give you a sense of the world at the time.
They're all chosen deliberately for a reason, every single picture that they put in
these landmark editions. And they're just fantastic. And this is a fantastic edition
of this. I have not read it yet. So I can't speak to the translation. Actually, the translation that
I just read you was from this one. But I've kind of poked around at it. And it seems pretty good.
But I haven't read the whole thing yet. I will. I don't know if I'm going to get to it this year,
because I've got a lot of other ancient histories. I'm going to be reading before it.
And I'm going to be talking about that in a future video.
So you'll be seeing this guy again, along with a bunch of other books.
So yeah, the Anabasis, this is a fantastic story. And it's if you're interested in history at all,
you really want to read this book, no matter what edition you get it in. This is very readable.
This is just way, way better. And if you can get this one, I of course would recommend
to get this one. All the ancient histories, they're better in these editions. They're large,
but they're fantastic. So yeah, Xenophon's Anabasis, I highly recommend it. Okay, guys.
I will see you here next time.
