A Barbarian Center of Roman Culture ¦ Vandal Africa (1080p_30fps_H264-128kbit_AAC)

Ancient Origins
13 followers
43 Video Views·Nov 22, 2024
When talking about the end of the Western Roman Empire, the idea that often comes to people's
minds is that of destruction, chaos, and the end of all things Roman. Some even go so far as to say
that the fall of Rome pushed civilization back centuries. The so-called Barbarian Kingdoms,
which set themselves up in parts of the Roman Empire, have long been portrayed as bloodthirsty,
hostile, and anti-Roman. And there's probably none who have been portrayed this way more than
the Vandals, whose reputation for destructiveness have forever tied their name to the concept of
vandalism. But do the Vandals really deserve this reputation? Well, I'm inclined to say no.
Although there's no doubt that they were very destructive in their conquests, the kingdom that
they ultimately established in North Africa would become a beacon of Roman culture for the hundred
years of their rule. And more than just being allowed to continue existing, Roman culture was
actively supported by those very barbarians whose lust for destruction was supposedly so strong.
In the Roman context, the word Africa was, for the most part, used in reference to the land
north of the Sahara from modern Libya east of Cyrenaica to modern Morocco. The region was
extremely important for Rome ever since the Punic Wars, when the Romans defeated their greatest
rival, Carthage, and expanded their influence outward over the whole of the southern Mediterranean.
By the 5th century CE, Africa, and especially the area around the city of Carthage in modern Tunisia,
was one of the wealthiest parts of the Western Empire. It provided a great deal of grain and
olives to the other provinces, and exported luxuries like tesserae for mosaics and fine
dishes called African red slipwear. It was also very culturally Roman, especially in the cities
and coastal areas. In 439, however, the city of Carthage was taken by a man named Gesseric and his
people, the Vandals. The Vandals were barbarians in the Roman mind. They were an East Germanic
people like the Goths, who'd come into the empire 100 years earlier and, after several battles and
treaties, were given permission to settle in Pannonia, along the Danube river. During those
100 years, they moved around, ultimately arriving in modern Spain, where they were regularly in
conflict with both the Romans and other barbarian tribes. They sustained themselves through raiding
and pillaging, which is one of the main reasons for their reputation. But in 429, the Vandal king
led his people, which by now was a mix of Vandals, Alans, and other tribes, across the
Strait of Gibraltar and into Africa, where they took lands and conquered cities. Gesseric's main
prize, however, was Carthage, which, as I already said, he took in 439. This marked the beginning of
a new era for the Vandals, one where they were lords over their own kingdom, solidified when
western emperor Valentinian III recognised Gesseric as king of Carthage and accepted the
betrothal of his own daughter Eudokia to Gesseric's son Huneric, something which was unprecedented and
highly controversial. The relationship between the two Roman empires and the Vandals remained
complex, to say the least, and I'll talk a little bit more about that later.
But ultimately, the Vandal kingdom would come to an end in 534 after the last king,
Gelimer, was defeated by the armies of the eastern emperor Justinian, and Africa was brought
back into the Roman, or Byzantine, empire. Historically, it's been easy to dismiss the
Vandals as Rome-hating barbarians. They, like other barbarians, were blamed for the fall of
Rome and the recession of civilisation. Now, that view is problematic for several reasons,
including the iffiness of ideas of more and less advanced civilisations, which I can't really get
into right now, but one important problem is that it ignores the reality behind the Vandal attitude
towards Roman culture. When the Vandals took Carthage, Gesseric seized the most productive
lands from the local senatorial class in the province of Africa Proconsularis, that is,
northern Tunisia around Carthage, and redistributed it to his people. Our only source on estimated
numbers says that 80,000 people followed Gesseric into Africa, though this may be an exaggeration,
and it also would have included non-combatants like women, children, and the elderly.
We're probably talking around 20,000 households at the upper limit, and even this is likely
generous. In any case, these newly settled Vandals would have composed a new military aristocracy,
bearing arms on behalf of the king, and sustaining themselves through these plots of land,
perhaps their crafts. But the Vandals weren't completely separate
from the Romano-Africans. North Africa was quite urbanised, especially in Africa Proconsularis
and Bizacena to the south, and many Vandals lived in the cities, especially Carthage,
away from their estates. They also remained a minority within the overwhelmingly Romano-African
cities, and really, most of the kingdom. Now, one could point to Vandal raids in the
Mediterranean and their sack of Rome in 455 as evidence of their hostility to all things Roman,
and for many people, these events are still seen this way. But we have to be careful to take them
in context. 455 was the year when the western emperor Valentinian III was assassinated,
and a usurper, Petronius Maximus, rose up in his place. Petronius forced Valentinian's widow to
marry him, and may have tried to break the betrothal between Valentinian's daughter Eudokia
and Gesseric's son Huneric. In response to this, Gesseric and his Vandals sacked Rome,
plundered a bunch of treasure, and took Eudokia, her mother, and her sister back to Carthage,
where Huneric and Eudokia were finally married. This event was clearly not just random wanton
violence. It was highly political, and closely bound to dynastic struggles in the western empire.
There was even a rumour in the eastern empire that Eudokia's mother had requested that Gesseric
come to Rome and save them from the usurpers who'd killed her husband, though this can't be
confirmed. The Mediterranean raids should also be seen in this light. Gesseric regularly said that
unless he received Eudokia's inheritance, which included a whole lot of land in Sicily and other
parts, he wouldn't hold to the peace that was agreed upon with Valentinian. He also had hopes
that in the dynastic turmoil of the time, Eudokia's brother-in-law, Aenecius Olybrius,
might eventually become emperor. Now, Gesseric never got the inheritance, but a lasting peace
was established with the eastern emperor Zeno in 474, by which point Olybrius had ruled for a year
in the west and died, and Eudokia had born a son and later passed away in Jerusalem after retiring
there. The Vandals and Romans would then remain at peace, though with some occasions of tension,
until Justinian's invasion in 533. As you can see, looking at these events with more nuance
makes the whole situation a little bit more complicated than just barbarians attacking
the empire. Another reason why the Vandals are seen as especially anti-Roman is because of their
religious policies. Like many East Germanic peoples, the Vandals were Aryan Christians,
more specifically they were Homoians. This means that, contrary to the official doctrine of the
established at the Council of Nicaea in 325, they didn't believe in an equal trinity. They believed
that the son and the Holy Spirit were subordinate to the father, and that the son was like the
father, but that specifying what that meant was unknowable. This is in contrast to the Nicaean
view, still held by Catholics, Orthodox, and most Protestants, that the trinity are all equal,
and that the father, son, and Holy Spirit share the same essence, a Homoousian view. If you don't
get all the theological intricacies, don't worry, it's not all that important for this video.
Anyway, the Vandals are often seen as being especially anti-Nicaean, and ruthless in their
persecution. But the reality is, this mostly comes from highly polemical writings by Nicaean clergy,
who were fiercely anti-Aryan. Most of the Nicaean Christians who were targeted were the clergy and
powerful elites, who were, for the most part, exiled to the Mediterranean Islands, which were
under Vandal control. Likewise, just as often as these exiles occurred, subsequent kings would
allow these people to return. The bishops exiled by kings Huneric and Thrasimund, for example,
were allowed to return after those kings' deaths by their successors, Gunthamund and Hilderic,
Other than exile, the main Vandal strategy against Nicaean elites was confiscation of property,
and, very rarely, execution. And although this was largely done against Romans,
these were the exact same strategies that the Roman Empire itself employed against heretics.
The only difference here is that the heretics for the Vandals were the ones considered orthodox in
the empire, but the main aim of both was to dismantle the heretical ecclesiastical structure.
For many Vandal kings, religion was a matter of loyalty. If you weren't loyal to the same
church as the king, you couldn't necessarily be trusted to be loyal to the king himself,
and that's why it was important for them to ensure that members of the court,
and eventually also the army, were followers of Aryan Christianity. For the most part,
they didn't really care about anyone else's religion, although the one exception to this
would be late in the reign of King Huneric when there were some wider persecutions,
though there does seem to have been political motive behind this, likely a show of power
towards Constantinople. Though, even in the case of the royal court, the rules were applied
sporadically, since we hear of plenty of instances where Nicaean Christians retained high positions.
As I said earlier, the Vandals were a minority in their kingdom, and although the most powerful
pre-Vandal elites had had their lands taken away, many Roman elites remained, and new ones emerged
who couldn't just be ignored. But regardless, the idea that the persecution of Nicaean Christians
is inherently anti-Roman is itself problematic. Contrary to the view of polemicists like the
bishop Victor of Vita, Roman identity wasn't intrinsically tied to Nicaean Christianity,
nor Vandal identity to Aryanism. There's plenty of evidence that lots of Romano-Africans converted
to Aryanism, and that many didn't have particularly strong feelings about sectarian divisions one way
or another, attending services at both churches. The Aryan church wasn't exclusively the Vandal
church, and there also seemed to have been Vandals who converted to Nicaean Christianity.
What was very Roman, however, was the connection of religious affiliation to loyalty. There's
plenty of examples of that throughout Roman history. That, of course, isn't exclusive to
the Romans, but there are plenty of examples of ways in which the Vandals did clearly participate
in Roman culture. The Vandals were all quite familiar with Roman culture. Pretty much every
one of them had lived their whole lives within the empire by this point, after all. And both
in archaeology and literature, it very quickly becomes extremely difficult to distinguish between
Romans and Vandals. On the part of the king, there was a lot of effort placed into comparing him to
a Roman emperor. Since Hunnic's reign, the kings often included Dominus in their title, something
highly evocative of the Roman emperors, and they seemed to have started wearing imperial purple
and sitting on a throne. They ruled from the proconsular palace, which was eventually adorned
that they took from Rome in 455, including the Menorah from the Jerusalem Temple,
and they held traditional Roman-style triumph parades through Carthage to commemorate victories.
It's likely that at least part of the importance which Gesserich placed on the marriage between
his son and Valentinian's daughter was to strengthen his dynasty's imperial connections.
And indeed, his grandson by Eudokia, Hilderich, grew up in the imperial court in Constantinople
and became close with the soon-to-be emperor Justinian. In fact, it was Hilderich's deposition
by his cousin Gelimer that prompted Justinian to invade in 533, who originally wanted to restore
his friend to the throne before Gelimer had him executed. But when I say Roman culture,
you probably think about things like arenas, horse races, and baths. Well, the Vandals were
into all of that too. It's tempting to imagine that the end of imperial rule over an area would
change it completely, but literary and some archaeological evidence make reference to all
of these things continuing to exist. Some baths and amphitheatres had fallen into disuse at this
time and were adapted for other purposes, but this was a trend that predated the Vandals.
At the same time, however, other facilities were being maintained, and there were even new ones
being built. We hear, for example, from the poet Felix of a bathhouse built in Eleani under the
King Thrasymand, and the scholar Edward Courtney has suggested that Felix's several short poems
praising it were intended to be inscribed onto its walls, a common practice in late antiquity.
The poet Luxorius wrote several poems which give us a similar glimpse at life in late Vandal Africa.
He writes about beautifully crafted fountains and baths, about chariot racers, both those who
are loved and those who are hated. In a couple of epigrams, he writes about a particular arena
fighter from Egypt named Olympias, who was beloved in Carthage. In one of them, he writes,
Of course, poetic traditions are often
full of long-standing thematic tropes, so if we were to take some of these poems on their own,
we'd have to be careful. But there's enough external evidence to suggest that Luxorius
and others weren't just being old-fashioned in their writings. The Byzantine, or Eastern Roman,
historian Procopius, wrote about the Vandals in his book on wars, after the Byzantine reconquest
of Africa, and in it he notes that the Vandals had specific tastes.
Indeed, from the time when they captured Africa, all of them made use of the baths every day,
and they enjoyed a table abounding in all things, the sweetest and the best that the
earth and sea yield up. And they wore gold as much as possible, and, wrapped in Persian clothes,
which they now called serike, they spent their time in theatres and in hippodromes,
and in the enjoyment of other good things, and most of all in hunting. And they had dancers and
actors and many things to hear and watch which happened to be musical and especially worth seeing
amongst people. And most of them lived in gardens, which abounded in water and trees. And they held
as many drinking parties as possible, and all kinds of sexual activities were widely practiced
by them. Procopius here is clearly playing into some tropes himself. His mention of their sexual
habits and specifying Persian clothes plays onto tropes of Eastern barbarians like the Persians
themselves – aspects of what we would today call Orientalism. But it's interesting to compare
the language he uses here to that which he does for other Germanic barbarians like the Franks,
who he describes as being ultra-violent and who kill at random. The Vandals were clearly too
tied to urban, civilised culture to be seen in the same light. And in light of this outside
of perspective, as well as archaeological evidence, it's clear that poetic references
to things like theatres and hippodromes aren't just complete fabrications.
This quote from Procopius also makes something else clear. This wasn't just a continuation of
Roman culture by Romano-Africans. The Vandals were quick to engage in it as well. Although,
in the 60s, Morris Rosenblum, who translated Luxorius's poems, claimed that Roman poets were
clinging to a dying tradition and went unappreciated by those outside their little circle of cultured
artists, least of all by the illiterate barbarians who ruled the kingdom. More recent scholarship
has been highly critical of this idea. Besides baths and theatre, Vandal elites also adopted
Roman elite clothing and lifestyles. Many spent much time in country villas, where they spent a
lot of time hunting, as noted by Procopius, but also the Romano-African poets and even mosaics
preserved from the Vandal period. Of course, hunting wasn't exclusively Roman, but it was part
of the elite culture that the Vandals adopted. In fact, much of the Roman culture taken on by
the Vandals was taken on for the very fact that it was the culture of the Mediterranean elite.
They didn't forsake a Vandal identity for a Roman one. They remained Vandals, and that ethnic
identity continued to exist until the end of Vandal rule. But Vandal elite identity became
very similar to Roman elite identity. And so, in addition to hunting in the countryside,
they also maintained elaborate villa gardens and pools, as was popular amongst the Romans.
Luxorius even writes about the garden of a Vandal aristocrat named Oagus,
which contained every medicinal herb one could ever need. A garden like that means Oagus,
or at least someone in his household, was likely familiar with the works of Dioscorides,
or perhaps Pliny the Elder, which would be unlikely if the Vandals were really as
illiterate as scholars of old have claimed. The truth is, however, that many, maybe most of them,
especially those higher up in society, learned Latin fairly early on. In fact, the poet Dracontius
tells us that his grammarian Felicianus taught a classical education to Vandal boys alongside
Romano-African ones. This isn't all too surprising in light of what I said just before, considering
how important such an education had been to elite Roman culture. Young Vandal men would have been
just as familiar with Virgil and Cicero as any young Roman. And yes, traditional Roman education
continued even into the Vandal era. In fact, another poet, Fulgentius, claimed that in his
own day, Africa was the centre of culture and learning. Likewise, although we don't know of
any Vandals writing anything themselves, the numerous dedications of literary works to Vandal
kings and aristocrats means that they were in all likelihood quite engaged in these literary
circles. Rosenblum might claim that the poets whose works have survived to us were only writing
for each other, but it makes a lot more sense to imagine them being patronized by wealthy elites,
as was done in the Roman Empire. And Vandal patronage of classical poetry speaks to a
familiarity with and appreciation for Roman culture. In fact, the number of dedications to
Thrasymand has led many scholars to conclude that he and his court were especially cultured.
Far from a fall of Roman civilization, then, the Vandals were probably some of its greatest
preservers and promoters in the late 5th and early 6th centuries. Sure, they'd been destructive,
and the conquest of Africa was hardly peaceful, with some cities never recovering. But after a
few decades, things had mostly settled, and Vandals and Romano-Africans lived side by side.
There was still conflict on occasion, of course, but Vandal Africa became a place where Roman
culture continued to thrive, even half a century after the fall of the Western Roman Empire,
and it was being consumed and appreciated by Roman and Barbarian alike.
