Adoption Readiness Levels - An Introduction

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Nov 20, 2024
Bringing novel technologies from the lab to the market requires moving through the Research, Development, Demonstration, and Deployment (RDD&D) continuum. To commercial-scale deployment, one must overcome both technical and ecosystem adoption hurdles. While this journey is complex, support exists. The Department of Energy’s Office of Technology Transitions is mission-driven to steward commercialization efforts across the Department and beyond.
welcome to commercialization moving
ideas from Lab to Market when thinking
of commercialization researchers and
scientists often focus on addressing
technology hurdles since that is what we
are trained to do but there are so many
other non-technical challenges to
address in order to commercialize an
idea this series of bite-sized videos
will explain what those risks are and
introduce a new framework to ensure all
commercialization risks are considered
not just technology ones this framework
is adoption Readiness level and was
developed here at the US Department of
energy by the office of Technology
transitions or OT we at OT will be your
guide in this video given the abundance
of acronyms in the world particularly
within the federal government just
remember us as the otter of the helps
Sam the otter who is small and Mighty Is
Our official mascot at Ott our mission
is to drive private sector uptake of
Innovative Technologies this is a fancy
way of saying that we're moving techn
IES out of the research lab and into the
broader Market where they can have real
impact in this introductory video we
cover one what is
commercialization two how do we think
about non-technical barriers preventing
market adoption and three what will be
covered in the rest of the video
series new technologies start at the lab
bench but to have an impact on the real
world they must develop into products
that can be accepted and sold on the
market that's what commercialization is
here at the department of energy we run
17 of our nation's most important
National Labs these are worldclass
facilities where dedicated researchers
scientists and entrepreneurs work on
critical Technologies for our planet the
impact of our national lives can be seen
every day with Technologies born from
our Labs that have successfully
navigated the commercialization
Continuum to improve our daily
lives one example is a 3D holographic
scanner developed by pnnl which has been
commercialized to enable improved
Airport
security another example is lbnl
technology to address arsenic
contamination in water a technology that
was then licensed and sold to a
company and another is lead free solder
that was developed by ases and is used
in every single electronic device in the
world it is important to Define what is
commercialization we don't do R&D and
then
commercialize commercialization starts
with research and development but then
must move through demonstration
deployment to commercialize a technology
means to Shepherd it across the research
development demonstration and deployment
or Rd DND
Continuum we start with the research
phase where we explore a concept or idea
this typically is tested through lab
scale experiments to show the potential
of the technology to address an issue in
the real world this is also known as a
Technology's value proposition in other
words the benefit or service that this
technology can provide
once we see that the concept has
technological potential we then move to
the development phase where we design
and build a proof of concept or working
prototype to see if this technology can
function in the way that we imagined at
this stage lab and bench scale
experiments are done to help validate
the value proposition and to see if it
could behave in the real world from
there we move to demonstration where we
create a pre-commercial pilot scale
system with most functionality in place
this real world installation is tested
to validate the value proposition der
risk the technology especially its
economic viability for something to make
it out of the demonstration phase to
deployment the pilot must show that it
can work in real world conditions and
most importantly there's a pathway to
operate the system at a reasonable cost
so that ultimately we can sell it at a
price that consumers are willing to pay
for it and a profit can still be made
and finally deployment where we have a
fully functional and scale able system
that is cost competitive all the costs
and risks have been resolved resulting
in a sustainable business model ready
for scaling by the private
sector now it would be great if rdd and
was a linear process but is more like a
game of Shoots and Ladders you might
learn something or identify a risk in a
demonstration phase which sends you back
to the research phase this doubling back
between stages As you move through the
rdd and Continuum is part of
commercialization
the key is being flexible and
identifying issues as soon as possible
so you can move through rdd and as
quickly and as efficiently as possible
there are many pitfalls along the
Continuum and it's important to know
what to look out for and assess however
most Technology based organizations use
a stag gate process that only focuses on
technology risk and in many cases the
process use is trls or technology
Readiness levels NASA developed trls in
the 19 s to navigate technical risks but
there are many Market risks that
technology must navigate to fully reach
commercial deployment and these are not
captured in the TRL framework so in
addition to understanding your
technology Readiness you also need to
think about external market and adoption
risks that is why we at Ott developed
adoption Readiness levels or arls to
complement trls commercializing your
technology whether it's a consumer
product a power generation technology a
medical device industrial equipment or
any anything else requires working with
companies customers and at times policy
makers to transform your technology into
a sellable product and these players are
concerned with Market risks just as much
as technical risks aols assess the
external factors that can impact your
technology rather than features
intrinsic to the technology itself the
ARL framework was built using Doe's
extensive commercialization experience
and vetted with input from external
industry Partners adoption Readiness
levels can assist you in assessing the
economic and other market-based risks
you need to navigate both technical
risks using trls and adoption risks
using arls if you do that then you are
well prepared to handle all the
potential roadblocks your technology
will encounter to achieve wides skill
market
adoption the ARL framework goes beyond
the traditional technology Readiness
levels to capture adoption risk that can
impact the successful deployment of the
technology it consists of 17 inventions
that fall into four risk buckets value
proposition Market acceptance resource
maturity and licens to operate knowing
what these risks are can help you take
actions to mitigate as many of them as
possible the lower the adoption risks
the higher the adoption Readiness level
and the closer your technology is to
getting to the market you may be
thinking how do you measure a
Technology's ARL well we created a
qualitative assessment tool called
carrot no not that kind of carrot
something more like this the commercial
adoption assessment tool or carrot lays
out what it means to be lowrisk medium
risk or high risk for each ARL Dimension
once you've assessed the adoption risk
for all 17 Dimensions you use this table
to Total the number of medium and high
risks that you've identified in your
carot assessment to receive an actual
ARL score the ARL score is used to show
how ready your technology is for the
market it only takes scoring medium or
high in a few wrist dimensions for the
arrow score to drop from a 9 to a six
the reason why is that investors and
other members of the private sector can
handle a few speed bumps for a
technology solution but more than two or
three risks makes it hard for them to
get their heads around meaning the
likelihood of their supporting
commercial liftoff plummets in fact it's
often not technology barriers that
impede commercialization rather
challenges like high prices to the end
user or unestablished manufacturing
Supply chains that are the stumbling
blocks but you shouldn't be discouraged
if your technology falls in the
high-risk low AOL category this just
means you have identified key barriers
that must be addressed knowing how your
idea fits into the market landscape can
help you prepare and address these risks
to get further along the path to
commercialization the power of arls is
not in the exact answer but in raising
your awareness of how your product
currently fits into the market so you
can begin to address risk areas beyond
trls the goal for this series is that
you understand what it takes to
commercialize your Technologies how to
identify Market risks and to give you
the language to talk to external
stakeholders about your solution in the
next videos we'll explore the ARL
framework in more depth and by the end
of the series you'll be an a
