In this compilation of video shorts, Dr. M discusses numerous questions that purveyors of fanstasy archaeology have never been able to explain.
►LEAVE A COMMENT We would love to hear your thoughts about the video. Please be civil to the other commenters. If your comment does not appear, try again with different words. YouTube sometimes glitches and comments don't go through. Or they might flag your comment as potentially inappropriate.
► SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL Supporters get access to behind-the-scenes videos, early-release videos, course discounts and more! http://www.patreon.com/worldofantiquity
things that alt ancient history folks
can't explain they claim that the Sphinx
was not created during the time of
dynastic Egypt but more than 12,000
years ago there evidence they say the
condition of the Limestone on the Sphinx
enclosure and a bit on the Sphinx body
show evidence that rainfall weathered it
for many thousands of years but one big
problem with that is that geological
research has shown that during the
African humid period between 11,000 and
5,500 years ago the level of the Nile
River at Giza was a lot higher and the
Sphinx sits at a very low point so much
so that the Sphinx enclosure would have
been full of water that situation lasted
thousands of years so how is it that
rain could have made those weathering
marks does it rain underwater and a weak
Limestone object like this sitting in
the river and being assailed constantly
by its flow would have been worn down
much more than it is the neck is
particularly weak so why is most of the
Sphinx still there things that alt
ancient history folks can't explain
balbec in Lebanon is famous for its
well-preserved remains of the great
Jupiter Sanctuary scientific research
has been conducted there since 1900 and
the consensus is that the sanctuary is a
product of the Roman period but ancient
astronaut theorists and Atlantis
proponents say that there's no way that
the Romans had the capability to put
into place the three large stone blocks
found in the wall of the sanctuary
because they weigh 800 tons a piece they
conclude that the stones were put there
by a lost ancient civilization more than
10,000 years before that but
archaeologists excavated a sounding in
the sanctuary and at the bottom found
the remains of a much older Hill
settlement below remains there
identified it as coming from the
pre-pottery Neolithic b period and
carbonates came out to the 8th
millennium BCE so my question is how did
they build the village underneath the
stone structure it must have been very
cramped under there
things that alternative ancient history
folks are unable to explain people who
believe in a lost Advanced civilization
that existed during the last ice age and
was destroyed in a cataclysm say that
this civilization spanned the continents
but genetic research has shown that
people in the Americas were genetically
isolated from the rest of the world in
the very period that this civilization
was supposed to have existed geneticists
have been able to determine that
indigenous Americans were formed from a
single found population that came from
Siberia in East Asia then when North
Americans and South Americans split the
ones traveling south got a small influx
of genes from people coming from
australasia it was supposedly after this
during a long stretch of time when
America was completely genetically
isolated that the supposed Lost
Civilization reached its Heyday How can
there be genetic isolation of two
continents from the old world at a time
when Global cultural sharing was
supposed to be occurring
things that alternative ancient history
folks can't explain you'll hear people
deny that the Great Pyramid of Giza was
built during the reign of the Egyptian
king kufu they will tell you it was
built long before then but within the
Great Pyramid and the relieving Chambers
above the king's chamber have been found
hieroglyphic markings in red ochre left
by the workers who put the stones into
place written 12 to 15 times as the name
of kufu some argue that these markings
are forgeries put there in 1837 to make
it seem like kufu men built the Pyramid
but how is it that kufu name comes in
forms that are correct but which were
not known by us until quite a while
after 1837 and how is it that many of
the markings are in places that haven't
been accessible since the pyramid was
built I sure would love to hear an
explanation for that things alt ancient
history people can explain one of their
strongest pieces of evidence for the
accuracy of myth is that the Greek
philosopher Plato knew exactly when the
destruction of Atlantis happened 9,000
years before the time of the Greek Sage
Solon and this coincides with a younger
dras period catastrophe discovered by
scientists whoa but there was a long
period of time from the destruction of
Atlantis until the reinvention of
writing thousands of years when this
accurate information would have to be
transmitted orally did each person
retelling the story have to update the
number of years
let's see Grandpa told the story about
35 years ago so let me add 35 to the
total and everybody did that and if so
when crius told the story at least 150
years after Solon visited Egypt why did
he still say it was 9,000 years ago
without updating the figure are one
example of transmission of the story and
no regard for precision on the
date things alt ancient history people
can't explain many of them say that the
Great Pyramid of Giza is more than 12
12,000 years old the original mortar
that was used between many of the stones
of the Great Pyramid contains organic
material which can be carbon dated and
many samples have been taken from all
over the pyramid we know the mortar is
original because it lay beneath the
outer casing stones of the pyramid which
remained on the pyramid until more
recent times so at no point in ancient
times did people remove the outer layer
to put the mortar in all over the place
that means the mortar was there at the
time of construction carbon dating of
the mortar came out to 4,800 to 4,600
years old can any believer in an older
Great Pyramid provide an explanation for
this things alt ancient history people
can't explain those who think Atlantis
was real point out the astounding
accuracy of Plato about what happened
sure he may not have gotten the part
right about Athens being in a war with
Atlantis and and yeah the story is
probably not right about the Greek
soldiers being swallowed by the Earth
that day and yeah Atlantis may not have
sunk into the sea but the sea actually
Rose over it but one thing it did get
right is the date 9,000 years before the
time of the Athenian Statesman Solon
that's 11,600 years ago and look science
is showing that a common impact happened
right around that time uh 12,850 years
ago hm can these people explain how the
impact caused Atlantis to be destroyed
in a deluge on a single day more than a
thousand years after the
impact things alt ancient history people
can't explain the Pumapunku at tiwanaku
in Bolivia is believed by alternative
history proponents to be more than
12,000 years old but carbon dates taken
from organic remains laid down during
construction of the building have
indicated a date no more than 1,500
years old for the beginning of
construction but the alt history folks
say hey that organic material could have
been thrown in there at any time you
can't trust that on the other hand
gunang Padang in Indonesia is also the
site of a building that alternative
history proponents believe is just as
old carbon dates of some soil that was
in the vicinity of what looked like
could be a human construction based on
radar images were shown to be 20,000
years old these dates were embraced by
the alt history Community as solid proof
why are carbon dates taken from soil
Fill near what may be an artificial
construction better than carbon dates
taken within the actual construction
layers of a methodically excavated
visible building things alternative
ancient history promoters can explain
they say that certain ancient objects
are out of place and that the times
they're dated to are wrong
archaeologists and historians have many
methods for dating artifacts and
buildings absolute dating methods such
as carbon dating Dental chronology
thermoluminescence and optically stimul
at ated luminescence obsidian hydration
dating archeomagnetic dating amino acid
racemization and then there's relative
dating methods such as stratigraphy
typological sequence dating linguistic
dating uh genetic dating astronomical
dating and historical chronology and all
of these work together to corroborate
each other so I asked those who want to
date objects to a far earlier time
period how have you determined that this
is the time these objects come from what
are your methods for dating artifacts I
ask because I haven't been able to find
them discussed
anywhere things alternative ancient
history purveyors can explain many of
them point to Egyptian sarcophagi or
statues that have badly written
hieroglyphs on them asserting that this
is scientific evidence that the makers
of the stone objects come from a
different and far earlier civilization
than the one that wrote the terrible
hieroglyphs which would be dynastic
Egypt civilizations they say can be
identified by the quality of their work
but if dynastic Egypt was capable of
only poor hieroglyphs how do they
explain the countless examples of
beautiful and amazing hieroglyphs from
ancient Egypt it makes more sense to
think that Egyptians had good work and
shoddy work just as we have today rather
than only one or the other but maybe I'm
missing something and they can explain
why they think that both poor
hieroglyphs and well-made hieroglyphs
couldn't possibly coexist in the same
civilization or that great stonework and
terrible stonework couldn't possibly Co
exist things alternative ancient history
purveyors can't explain if new things
are being found on the ground every year
in archaeology why do ancient astronaut
theorists and Atlantis proponents prefer
to site sources from the 19th and early
20th centuries over those written in the
last 100 years I mean there's some good
information still to be found in such
sources but surely none of those writers
know anything about any of the
discoveries that have been made since
then nor any of the scientific analyses
that have been done since then so why
are the newer studies almost completely
ignored while the more primitive
research is held up on a pedestal isn't
this akin to basing Medical Practice on
medical sources from the 1800s over
modern medical sources it' be nice to
have an explanation for that things
alternative ancient history promoters
can explain they say that academics
don't want to update history because
they derive power from the current
version of History
how so is there something about that
history that embies them with power I
mean I teach history in college and
whenever the textbook gets updated which
is often I don't lose any power I just
teach the new information or are the alt
history people referring to the power to
make the textbooks in the first place
textbook writers are chosen by
publishing companies and there are many
textbooks that compete with each other
it's a free market at least here in
America and teachers in college anyway
are usually allowed to choose whatever
textbook they want for their classes so
I'm really trying to figure out how
academics derive power from the current
version of history and wouldn't from any
other
versions things alternative ancient
history promoters can't explain many of
them say it is highly improbable that
the heavy Granite stone blocks that are
now found in the Great Pyramid of Giza
could have been brought to the site from
their original location at azwan quarry
some 500 Miles Away by the Egyptians of
the Old Kingdom with the Primitive
technology that they had well what about
the direct testimony that we have from
them wenny the Elder an Old Kingdom
Court official writes in his
autobiography that he brought Granite
portal Stones Granite lentils a granite
fall St and the basalt sarcophagus for
the Pyramid of Morra and Sakara just a
stone throw from Giza from azwan I
traveled North with them to the pyramid
in six barges and three towboats of
eight ribs in a single Expedition he
bragged he also speaks of later building
three barges and four towboats and
loading them with granite blocks for the
pyramid how do the Skeptics explain this
testimony answers are welcome things
alternative ancient history purveyors
can explain I've heard so many of them
used the argument that the ancient
Egyptians of the Old Kingdom couldn't
have carved granite or Basalt or diorite
or similar stones to build things at
least not effectively because these
Stones register between six and8 on the
MOs scale of hardness and their tools
made of copper only come in at around
four setting aside the fact that the
most scale is only supposed to be used
for natural minerals even iron is lower
on the scale than these Stones so what
I'm hoping they can explain for me is if
the mo scale determines what substance
can carve another why is it that glass
which is a six on the most scale can be
broken so easily how's it possible to
break a diamond which is a 10 on the mo
scale with a single hit from an iron
Hammer I know the answer but my answer
contradicts the use of a hardness scale
to determine what can Chip Away Stone so
I'm interested in their alternative
answer please help me out things
alternative ancient history purveyors
can explain some of them say that
certain significant numbers are encoded
in ancient structures such as the Great
Pyramid of Giza they might be in a
roundabout way related to the
measurement of the Earth for example out
of the thousands of measurements that
might exist in a large structure these
are just a select few and there needs to
be some additional math done to them to
make them fit this is at the discretion
of the interpreter but what I've never
heard explained and they can let me know
if I'm wrong is what the purpose was for
these supposedly important numbers why
did they put them in the measurements
was it to relay information what would
this information be used for and why was
this important information unlabeled was
it meant to be hidden and if so why
if any of you have the answers please
tell us because on the surface it seems
counterintuitive another thing
alternative ancient history purveyors
can't explain many of them scoff and say
that the pyramids of Egypt were most
certainly not tombs but how then do they
explain the fact that documents from
Egypt that have survived until today
refer to the pyramids as the tombs of
Kings the Egyptians told Herodotus they
were but even earlier the Abbot Papyrus
of the 20th Dynasty around 1100 BCE
documents robberies of many of the kings
and queens tombs some of which are
clearly stated to be pyramids the Harper
song of inth early to midc millennium
BCE mentions the god Kings who rest in
their pyramids even older than that
ferary texts inscriptions on walls
inside pyramids of the Old Kingdom fifth
and sixth dynasties contain spells and
instructions for the Kings on their
journey into the Afterlife even naming
the kings in later times these texts
were written on Papyrus and placed in
tombs first as the coffin text and
finally The Book of the Dead so those of
you who deny the pyramids wherever tombs
how do you explain this evidence things
alternative ancient history salesmen can
explain many of them point to
similarities of architecture or
symbolism across cultures which are
separated by vast expanses of time for
example they will see some kind of
connection between approximately 4,500
year old pyramids in Egypt and pyramids
in messo America from around 1800 years
ago what they have never explained and I
wish they would is why it took so long
for them to appear in certain places I
mean if contact between the old and new
worlds was made by the survivors of a
great cataclysm right after the
cataclysm occurred and they are the ones
who taught the simpler peoples to make
pyramids wouldn't the technology that
they taught have appeared at around the
same time in the various places they
reached out to where was the knowledge
of pyramids being stored in meso America
for 3,000 years before the people built
them and why did they wait that seems to
defeat the purpose that the survivors
had in mind the sharing of their
knowledge was to reduce the amount of
time for civilization to restart right
it seems to me that in 3,000 years the
mesoamericans could have just figured
out how to make pyramids themselves
things alternative ancient history
purveyors can't explain this cylinder
ceiling made by cylinder seal VA 243 is
claimed by ancient astronaut theorists
to be evidence the Sumerians had
knowledge of the entire solar system
seals were used by officials
administrators and businessmen to make
their unique mark on something this one
belonged to a guy named IL elot in their
writings the Mesopotamians make it clear
that they they knew of only five total
planets and no more their 7-Day week was
based on the seven Udu as they called
them the sun moon and five visible
planets their astronomical text mul apin
which has its origins in the middle
Babylonian period says that there are
seven and only seven Udu ID why are
there 11 of them here when there are
only seven Udu idim you can see that
ilot and the others here are standing on
earth and the heavenly bodies are in the
sky so how could one of the circles be
the Earth and Mesopotamian writings and
Maps say that the Earth is flat so how
then could they know about planets
rotating around the Sun things
alternative ancient history sellers
can't explain old history enthusiasts
spend much of their time looking for
patterns and artifacts across various
cultures they love to find similarities
between them and they use these
similarities to make a case for common
origin but what I don't understand and
this is something I've never heard them
explain is why they practically ignore
the differences what I mean is that
logically if similarity mean something
about where certain technology or
cultural elements come from then
differences should also for example the
crosso was invented in both China and
Greece and a few other places
independently now someone could say oh
look they both had crossbows there must
be a common origin and yet there wasn't
the differences between the crossbow
Styles can be seen now if I see a stone
clamp with a wedge shape and a stone
clamp with a t-shape alt history folks
will tell me there's no appreciable
difference is this a blind spot or are
differences legitimately Irrelevant in
seeking for Origins if irrelevant why so
things that alternative ancient history
sellers can't explain many say that a
lost Advanced civilization produced
Stoneworks that are identifiable by
their Precision in manufacturer but one
thing that they have not explained
clearly is why there are so many
imprecise objects from this presumed
Advanced culture why do sarcophaga that
they claim come from this culture
exhibit so many imperfections why do the
vases that they proudly Proclaim exhibit
Precision also have clear imprecision
why are there numerous imperfections
everywhere now I understand that
nobody's perfect but if you have an
artifact that is a mixture of precision
and imprecision then all you have is an
artifact that is imprecise now they
might say all you need is one precise
cut or one precise angle to prove that
it couldn't be done by ancient people
but as they say even a broken clock is
correct twice a day and wouldn't we need
to have a predominance of Precision
artifacts to consider this a Hallmark of
the Lost Civilization or to conclude
that special precision tools were
commonplace back then things alternative
ancient history sellers can't explain
some of them point to this image of
Egyptian art in the temple of haor at
dendera and they say that we're looking
at a light bulb or lighting device
powered by Transformers of some kind but
then how do they explain the fact that
there is no evidence of the actual use
of the lights or the Electric System or
whatever system it was was no sockets
anywhere where are the remnants of the
system why is there only this piece of
art in a back corner of a helenistic
period Temple and more importantly how
do they explain the writing in
hieroglyphs that identify the images the
writing above the image of the bulb on
the left and right identifies it as the
sun god harata the snake in a Lotus
Flower and that these are Jed pillars
below holding him up as he is born so do
the alt history sellers have an
explanation for why they look at the
pictures but don't take into
consideration the
writing something else that alternative
ancient history sellers can't explain it
is common for many of them to place a
great deal of credence on events
described in myths most of them coming
from times thousands of years after the
events they describe professional
historians generally distinguish between
primary sources and secondary sources
and they give more Credence to sources
close to the time and place being
studied then sources far removed from
the time and place being studied and
historians also take into account the
genre of the source is it history myth
Legend Parable whatever the case may be
I would love to hear from alt history
folks what their method is for
Discerning reliable historical facts in
a source how they distinguish between
good and bad
information from the outside it looks
like they ignore the date and genre of a
writing and just choose to believe what
they want and discount what they don't
want but maybe there is a method and it
just has not been made known to me yet
can you help me out things that
alternative ancient history promoters
can't explain several people have told
me that the Inca themselves stated that
the great architectural achievements of
their culture such as Sak Haman kusko
and anante Tomo are from an advanced
culture that preceded them well how do
they explain the testimony of 16th
century Spanish conquistador Pedro Sia
de Leon who wrote In His chronic Peru
that the Inca told him that they had
built Sak Haman and Cusco even providing
details about it according to the
chronicler Santo de Gamboa the Inca
ruler pachakuti built alante Tambo while
garcilazo DEA attributes the
construction to wiocha but either way
the Inca told them that an Inca ruler
built it I've not seen any testimonies
from the Inca that say that these places
were built by others maybe the alt
history folks are getting confused with
tiwanaku if they can show us where the
Inca say this about Sakai man Cusco and
anante Tomo we would love to see it but
even so how do they explain this other
testimony another thing I was thinking
that alternative ancient history
purveyors can explain one of the loudest
battlecries you hear coming from a
certain section of that camp is that
there is no way that ancient people
could have made certain pieces of
amazing stonework whether that be stone
sarcophagy or vases or what have you but
one thing I've never heard explained is
why they've not consulted sculptors and
stonemasons who work in traditional
methods sure the alt history folks have
consulted stonemasons who work in modern
high-tech methods who like to say we
could only make that the way we do today
but surely they know very little about
traditional methods for a long time
traditional methods have been replaced
gradually by modern approaches that
prioritize speed and cost Effectiveness
workers today don't get trained in the
old ways so what would they know about
them before making proclamations why not
consult the ones who would actually know
they exist if you have a good reason for
it please let us know what it is things
alternative ancient history sellers can
explain recently there's been a lot of
Buzz about how a group of researchers
have been measuring specially selected
ancient stone vases to try to prove they
were made with Advanced tools similar to
Modern CNC machines but that the vases
are not modern but rather from the last
ice age and they might not even be vases
at all but rather High Tech components
of some kind their measurements indicate
that the vase shapes are often within
microns of what they would consider an
ideal measurement so they conclude that
they could not have been made with hand
tools but all their vases are only
partially precise what I've never heard
them explain is what kind of tool made
the imprecise parts of the same object
did the same tool that made the outside
of a vase perfectly round also make the
lopsided handles or the rough interior
or was it a different kind of tool did
they make part of the vase with a
high-tech tool and part with a hand tool