Units of History - Early Germanic Warriors DOCUMENTARY

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
So-called barbarian forces often get the short end of the stick in discussions
about ancient warfare. We'd like to focus on the self-proclaimed civilized armies while
dismissively skipping over their enemies. This comes across almost all forms of media today,
where barbarian forces get stereotyped as mere hordes of poorly equipped brutes,
capable of victory only through reckless charges or underhanded ambushes.
While there may be a grain of truth to such generalizations,
the truth is far more nuanced and interesting.
In this video, we will seek to do justice to one of Rome's greatest barbarian foes,
the Germanic warriors who hailed from the dark forests beyond the Rhine.
If you'd like to lead your own ancient army, you can do so with our sponsor Conqueror's Blade.
It's a free-to-play PC game with tactical MMO action set in a vast open medieval world.
Here, players customize their own powerful warlords with unique weapon classes and special
abilities to then command armies of over 85 diverse units in order to forge an empire.
Fight epic PvP siege battles between teams of 15 players,
where attackers unleash devastating siege equipment like rams, towers,
and artillery, while defenders respond in kind with their own cunning countermeasures.
The gameplay stays fresh with themed seasons that offer new cosmetics,
units, and rewards.
The latest Season 8 Dynasty, for instance, draws inspiration from the 300-year reign of the Tang,
unlocking the brand new Longting region and Haojing City.
You get a new pike weapon class, as well as new units to recruit like the Kajal Monks,
the Greyhair Garrison, and the Shenji Grenadiers.
In addition, Season 8 brings a brand new siege map and over 100 exclusive rewards to collect.
Support the channel and play the game today by clicking the link in the description below
to unlock a free 7 days of premium access, which grants you a 30% boost to earned hero and unit XP,
bronze coins, and honor, as well as additional vault keys.
Behold the Golden Age and conquer.
morphing into a series of tribal societies that would eventually become the Iron Age
culture of Germania, which will be the subject of our video today.
Geographically speaking, we are looking at the lands of modern-day Germany,
Denmark, Belgium, the Netherlands, and some of its peripheral regions.
Admittedly, though, it's impossible to draw an accurate border around this group,
the term Germanic is poorly defined, and even an ancient census would struggle to
categorize the shifting web of people who inhabited the lands of Northern Europe.
Scholars today attempt to do so through an examination of their material culture
and linguistic roots. Ancient authors, meanwhile, didn't bother with such things,
and often just grouped foreigners into fairly arbitrary classifications.
Caesar, for instance, claims that the Rhine served as a border between
the Germanic and Gallic tribes, despite later mentioning that the Celtic-speaking Boeia
lived far east of the Rhine, and the Germanic-descended Belgae lay to its west.
So, how on earth should we go about making sense of all this?
Well, we just have to embrace the lack of clear-cut, top-down description,
and instead look at things from the bottom up. After all, this was the reality for people in
the past. Ideas of nationalism or a unifying concept of German-ness simply wasn't the lens
through which they saw things. Rather, their world was built upon social relations.
This began on the family level. Such a group of blood relatives would often live on a
self-sufficient farmstead, with a primary dwelling, outbuildings, and a fence. Within a
day's walk would be several other of these farmsteads. Sometimes, they might be more
closely packed together for cooperation when it came to subsistence or defense.
Over the years, we see more and more of this consolidation occur, especially around locations
capable of supporting more intensive agriculture, animal herding, or resource exploitation of
timber, iron, salt, and peat. Celtic-style opida even rose through the southern lands closer to
Gaul. However, by the 2nd century BC, these appeared to have fallen into decline, perhaps
as a result of unrest in the region. Broadly speaking, though, we should note that population
density across these northern lands was quite sparse, and the Germanic people had a low level
of urban development. This, in turn, meant that there was no formation of a centralized state,
or even city-state, as might be seen elsewhere around the Mediterranean.
Instead, such higher-level forms of organizing once again revolved around social networks.
Basically, what this looked like is that within a village, the leaders were those people best
able to forge personal bonds between their neighbors. Among several villages, a similar
phenomenon occurred whereby one or more of the local leaders proved better capable of leveraging
their social network for political and military means, thus empowering them to become a sort of
regional shot-caller. This same thing would repeat itself over and over again, creating a rather
intricate and dynamic hierarchy. At a certain point, a collection of these groups would form
a clan, and a collection of clans would become a tribe. Their size varied by location,
but usually numbered in the low thousands. Leading them might be a king or council of noblemen.
Again, who ran the show was highly dependent on that individual's personality and the current
circumstances which might see their fortunes rise or fall. Those in charge were certainly powerful,
but there were limits to their authority. The social basis of their rule kept them in check
and limited the degree to which they could explicitly force their will on others.
Rather, in this more egalitarian system, you would have reciprocal relationships that necessitated
a give-and-take between the upper and lower rungs of society. War leaders, for instance,
didn't hire soldiers. Instead, they enticed people within their sphere of influence
to take up arms for them in exchange for gifts, glory, and favor.
Let us now take a closer look at the individuals who answered the call to battle.
These men came equipped according to their means. In terms of clothing, a typical garb often
involved a long-sleeved tunic made from wool or linen, as well as trousers tied at the ankle
and belted at the waist. Over this, the warrior would wear a thick woolen cloak that could have
doubled as a blanket on campaign. For many, that was it in terms of body armor. This was largely
due to the relative poverty of your typical farmer-warrior. If Tacitus is to be believed,
it also may have been due to an iron scarcity in the region. However, more recent archaeology
has done much to dispute this. In fact, one workshop discovered in modern Poland contained
over 150 smelting furnaces and could have easily been capable of mass-producing quality equipment.
Whatever the case, much of this higher-end gear found its way first and foremost into the hands
of the wealthier aristocratic warriors and their retinues. For defense, these most commonly wore
iron ring mail shirts. Scale armor was also present, though it appears more popular among
the eastern tribes. When it came to protecting the head, we see a similar pattern, where many
of the rank-and-file troops simply went without any armor. This may have been a point of pride,
as it allowed individuals to show off their status-affirming hairstyles, like the famed
Swabian knot. Those who could afford and chose to wear a helmet might have donned a simple cap
of hide or metal, as noted by Tacitus. However, we also have evidence of some quite elaborate
pieces being worn by the upper classes. Plutarch, for instance, records that Germanic noble cavalry
in the Cimbrian War displayed helmets with great feather plumes that were crafted to resemble the
gaping jaws of wild beasts and monsters. The last piece of defense was the shield.
Its adoption was quite common, given just how cheaply basic variants could be produced.
These came in several shapes, from round to oval, rectangular and hexagonal. All were made of wood
with iron or bronze rims and prominent metal bosses. From our records, it seems many of these
shield bosses were also spiked, reinforcing the likely theory that it could double as an offensive
tool. As for the shield designs, these also varied greatly. Cheaper ones were blank or painted with
a simple dye, but many took on more elaborate character, owing to the importance of this highly
visible piece of kit. Shield patterns were often used to show one's tribal affiliations and social
status. Plutarch, for instance, mentions how Germanic cavalry of the Cimbrian War rode to
battle with bright white shields. Other times we hear of entire warbands adopting a particular
style, as with the Hari, who were known to paint their shields and bodies pitch black.
For offense, most Germanic warriors used the cheap but effective spear. Its importance was so
ingrained in the culture of many communities that when a boy came of age, he was presented
with a spear and shield as a rite of passage before a tribal assembly. The main battle spear
was often the conventional type you imagine. However, the tribesmen were also famous for the
use of a lighter spear variant that could be wielded both as a close-quarters weapon and a
ranged javelin. By comparison, swords were significantly less common. Some estimate their
prevalence at 1 in every 10 warriors around the 1st century AD, which later increased to 1 in
every 4 warriors by the 3rd century AD. This increased adoption of the sword is in part due
to the higher levels of development that occurred in Germania, combined with their increased
interconnection with the wider world of antiquity. For instance, we know that the tribes became fond
of purchasing swords from private Roman contractors and other sources, as these appear in large
quantities throughout the archaeological record. The longer Spartha was a particularly popular
trade good until Roman prohibitions on these arms sales in late antiquity began to crack down
on its export. Besides the sword and spear, Germanic warriors also used all kinds of weapons.
For close quarters, this meant battle axes, clubs, and even long knives, while for long distance,
this meant bows and slings. Now that we've fleshed out the kit of the individual tribesmen,
we can look at their role within their respective army units.
When a Germanic tribe went to war, it did so on a rather ad hoc basis. After all, there was no
standing professional army. Rather, what they had was a call to arms that would mobilize warriors
by way of the social web we previously described. What this meant is that at the top would be your
tribal chiefs and highly influential figures. These might choose to lead jointly, but more often
than not elected a single war leader. Thus united, they would then call upon their own followers to
join them. Tribal chiefs turned to clan chiefs, who turned to local chiefs, and so on down the line,
until the muster was deemed sufficient for the mission at hand. First to answer the call would
be the personal retinue of each leader. Such warriors had the best equipment, often provided
as a reward by their noble, and would be the closest thing to professional troops. Overall,
though, their numbers were quite small. The bulk of those who answered the call to arms would be
your everyday commoners at the base of the social pyramid. As these armies slowly coalesced, they do
not seem to have done so according to any tidy unit structure. Instead, they organized themselves
roughly according to their familial, regional, and tribal associations. The end result was a force
composed of an eclectic group of war bands that mustered in all sorts of shapes and sizes. It
would be up to the leaders to choose how best to organize these into a proper fighting force.
For example, in his battle against Caesar in 58 BC, the warlord Ariovistus divided his army
into seven contingents, separated into roughly even intervals based on their parent tribes.
Who would lead these subunits remains an unfortunate mystery. It is speculated,
however, that they likely would have also chosen their own leaders by way of popular vote.
Yet, while most tribal armies may appear rather amorphous in nature, we do have some evidence of
standardization taking place. A prime example was the practice of the 100, employed by many
Germanic armies. This was the title given to a carefully selected body of infantrymen,
who drew members from each district in a tribe. In battle, they would be tasked with acting as
a close support force for the army's cavalry, attacking or defending as needed. Such horse
runners added much-needed tactical flexibility to the army and greatly impressed Caesar when
he encountered them during his Gallic campaigns. It seems that this 100-man unit system was later
expanded to serve as an organizing structure for tribal armies as they slowly became more
sophisticated. This evolution was accelerated through their interactions with the Roman
military either in battle or while serving as their auxiliary forces. We see this really start
to take effect during the Germanic Wars of the 1st century AD, when Arminius led a wide-scale
revolt against their invaders. For example, it's during this period that we hear Tacitus praise the
For Germans, they have much intelligence and sagacity. They promote their picked men to power
and obey those whom they promote. They keep their ranks, note their opportunities,
check their impulses, portion out the day, entrench themselves by night, regard fortune
as doubtful valor as an unfailing resource. And, what is most unusual and only given to
systematic discipline, they rely more on the general than on the army. Their whole strength
is in their infantry which, in addition to its arms, is laden with iron tools and provisions.
Other tribes you see going to battle, the Chatti to a campaign. As the years went on,
the Germanic tribes would continue to become even more organized as they became
more enmeshed with the Romans. Many of their sons went to war for the empire and formed
core units of its army. Thus, by the time the Western Empire fell, they were in a prime position
to take up the mantle of its former military power. The organization of such later Germanic
forces, however, will have to be covered in another video. For now, let us move on to a
When it comes to training, there is not much that can be said. For one, we have few sources
on this matter. Furthermore, it appears that there was no institutional training system in
place by which we might assess how the ideal soldier was prepared for battle. It turns out
that this was just not necessary, as the general population was quite accustomed to fighting.
Hunting was common practice, and intertribal clashes from raids to all-out wars were fairly
common. Thus, a warrior mentality was deeply ingrained in the Germanic culture. Within every
family, most fathers, uncles, and cousins would have seen battle. There would therefore be many
experienced family members capable of training up the young men of the tribe. As with most cultures,
it's likely this would have involved physical exercise in the form of running, wrestling,
and weight-carrying, as well as instruction on the proper use of a spear and shield. In addition,
this was probably accompanied by an introduction to the basic principles of Germanic warfare
involving a shield wall. However, we should note that such collective unit-level training
was not very common outside of battle. In times of peace, the focus remained very much
on the individual, but that isn't to say that higher-level training never happened.
For example, Velius Perturculus has the following to say of the army raised by the
Marco Mani tribe. By continuous training, Merobedus brought the body of troops safeguarding
his empire almost to the standard of Roman discipline in a short time, raising them to
such a level that they were feared even by our empire. As was the case with the army's
organization, methods of training were also greatly evolved through increased interaction
with the Roman military. Now, let us move on to the topic of battle tactics.
The stereotype of tribal armies like those of the Germanic people is that their tactics amount to
nothing more than a frenzied frontal charge. This idea dates back to antiquity, where such
enemies of the civilized folk were categorized as wild barbarians, whose fervor and bravery
was great at first contact but quickly diminished should they not find immediate success.
While a gross overgeneralization, it does speak to some underlying truths about the method of
One major aspect of this has to do with the composition of their armies.
As we discussed, they were built upon a mobilized population, largely consisting of the working
class, that could not afford to be away from their fields and herds for long periods of time.
As a result, any massed call to arms had a limited lifespan, thus pressuring army leaders
to achieve their aims as quickly as possible through a decisive pitched battle.
Admittedly, this dynamic was also true for other armies of antiquity.
However, the phenomenon was made worse for most tribal armies as a result of their loose,
fluid means of organization. On a strategic level, this hampered their rudimentary logistical systems,
which could only marginally improve the lifespan of armies in the field.
On a tactical level, this also made complex maneuvers difficult,
with only the most simple of operations being practical.
For instance, we hear of several cases where a Germanic commander attempted to wield his force
more dexterously, only to be undercut by army elements that broke ranks on their own accord.
Again though, we shouldn't think that this is a uniquely Germanic or even tribal problem.
We are dealing with spectrums here, and many other of their contemporaries
also grappled with these sorts of issues.
So, with all that said, what would be the tactics employed by your typical unit
of Germanic warriors in a pitched battle? Well, this would have broken out into phases.
The first phase would involve the armies deploying on the field.
Your average warband would do so by forming up around their standards.
These were often wooden poles that held up colored cloth and other tribal insignia.
The loss of such a prized item would bring great disgrace, and it would be closely guarded.
During deployment, these would be moved into a battle line with the numerous warbands forming
a single massive front. Kings, chiefs, and their retinues would often feature prominently
near the front lines. The army's flanks would be guarded by cavalry and support troops,
or anchored by difficult terrain. The second phase would involve opposing
armies sizing each other up. This might include duels between champions and some light skirmishing.
However, the most important element would be the use of noise to display strength,
much like we see between rivals in nature. The fiercest roar would be a factor of any
army's overall size and its confidence. This would be communicated using a combination of yells,
instruments, and war gear. In this regard, the Germanic tribes
were famous for the unique practice of the Berittus. Tacitus describes it as beginning
as a low murmur with warriors holding their shields in front of their mouths to create
a reverberating sound. This slowly swelled like waves crashing into a rocky shore,
until it finally escalated into a deafening crescendo. Those who did not retreat in the
face of this intimidation would meet the next phase of battle, the charge. Often, this occurred
at the very peak of the Berittus, when the leaders at the front of each warband charged
into the fray in a massed attack along the whole front. While modern media often depicts this as a
mob-like attack with no cohesion, we should be reminded that our sources often point out the
good battle order of the Germanic armies. While not traditionally organized, they still
understood the value of maintaining a coherent battle line. After all, the greatest crime for
a warrior was throwing away his shield, emphasizing the importance of fighting as a part of a mutually
protective unit. As further evidence of organized Germanic tactics during the charge,
we know for instance that their units often transformed into wedges. Such formations lent
themselves naturally to the army's social structure, where chiefs and their heavily
armed retinues could form the spear's head with the rest of the rank and file falling in behind
them. Wedges seem to have been made up of anywhere from a few dozen to several hundred men,
whereas a traditional linear charge would see their force distributed across a wide area,
a wedge attack helped concentrate their efforts, dramatically increasing their chances of breaking
through. This was made even more true by the fact that many warriors were oath-bound to protect
their leaders. Thus, once the tip of a wedge became engaged, this only further motivated the rest of
the unit to plunge in. Such tactics went hand in hand with the offensive approach of the Germanic
tribes. However, should the attack falter, a wedge with its leadership core exposed at the front
was particularly ill-equipped for conducting a careful retreat. This would eventually be remedied
in later years when they began to adopt Roman tactical doctrine involving the use of reserves.
As a final note on tactics, I wanted to touch on ambushes. There seems to be this common
perception that the Germanic tribes were masters at it. However, this does not really seem to be
the case. Yes, they pulled off a few spectacular ones against the Romans, but this really only
occurred when they felt they couldn't take them in a head-on fight. As history shows again and again,
guerrilla tactics and asymmetrical warfare are a matter of necessity when facing lopsided odds
in war. In these matters, the Germanic tribes were pretty good at it, but by no means exceptional.
We have many examples of their ambushes failing or of their own forces being caught
in enemy traps. At the end of the day, the hit-and-run lifestyle ran contrary to their
warrior ethos, and as soon as the tribes regained their confidence,
they almost universally reverted to their preferred approach of the pitched battle.
It will be hard to speak comprehensively about the full service history of the Germanic warrior,
as this is such a widely defined unit compared to something like the very specific sacred band
of Thebes. We will therefore have to speak generally about the broad strokes of Germanic
warfare with a few examples along the way. Much of this history is unfortunately lost to us,
as the story of the Germanic people largely comes from outside sources. As a result,
we can say little about the bulk of their fighting which occurred among the people
of Northern Europe unrecorded. Tacitus offers us a glimpse into this veiled conflict when he
hearing reports of one especially large battle in Germania, where an alleged 60,000 warriors
perished on both sides. As for warfare in the light of the so-called civilized world,
we first hear of Germanic armies in the late 2nd century BC, when several tribes migrated
into the Roman sphere of influence. In these initial clashes, they seemed unstoppable,
inflicting a series of crushing defeats against the legions sent to oppose them.
The Battle of Arausio in particular saw the Cimbri and Teutonis wipe out an army of 80,000 Romans
in the worst defeat since Cannae. They and their allies would only be defeated several years later
when Gaius Marius brought reform and new leadership to the Roman army.
We next hear of the Germanic tribes in the 1st century BC, when Julius Caesar intervened to
oppose their moves in Gaul. Caesar would clash with King Ariovistus of the Suebi and his tribal
allies in 58 BC at the Battle of Vosges. The battle was fiercely contested with the warbands
finding initial success until legionary reserves moved in to turn the tide. Later, Caesar would
actually cross the Rhine in a lightning campaign to raid Germanic lands before retreating in what
amounted to a mere publicity stunt. However, it would be a prelude of things to come.
The next encounter with the Germans occurred in 16 BC during the reign of Augustus,
when several tribes crossed the Rhine into Gaul and defeated the legions sent against them.
In response, Augustus would dispatch more forces that kicked off a decades-long struggle to tame
the region. The effort featured numerous campaigns of intense fighting, which include the famous
Battle of Teutoburg Forest and its aftermath which we have covered in another series.
Ultimately, outright conquest of Germania would be abandoned in favor of fortifying the frontier
and periodically launching campaigns of intervention or retaliation to keep the region
in check. The degree to which this was possible varied over time, and we see many revolts and
invasions spilling out of the area in times when Rome's power waned. Yet, still throughout most of
this period, imperial armies tended to come out ahead in pitched battle against Germanic warriors,
thanks to their superior training, equipment, and support from heavy cavalry. However, we should
also note that this success was also owed to the integration of Germanic forces into Rome's own
armies over the years. The scales would eventually tip as the period of great migrations, starting
around the 4th century AD, saw many Germanic tribes push into the lands of the empire. It's a fascinating
period of history, well worth exploring, but which will unfortunately fall outside the scope of this
particular episode. For now, I hope this overview of the history of Germanic warriors has helped
dispel some of the simplistic stereotypes that often come up when discussing barbarian armies.
Let us know what units of history you would like to see covered next.
A big thanks to the patrons for funding the channel and to the researchers, writers, and
artists for making this episode possible. Be sure to like and subscribe for more content
and check out these other related videos.
