BMW R12 nineT vs Triumph Speed Twin 1200: Which Is Better?

Rev & Roar X
259 followers
This year, BMW made a significant update to their sporty retro, the R9T,
with a new version called the R129T.
And we recently reviewed it, and there are certainly some key improvements.
But how does it compare to one of the other best naked sporty retros on the market,
the Triumph Speed Twin 1200?
Well, in this video, I'll give you a full rundown, blow by blow,
score them in each category, and then at the end, give you my pick.
So first up, let's start with the engines.
And both bikes are powered by 1200cc twins.
But I think on performance, the BMW certainly has the edge,
with an extra 10 horsepower at the top, made at pretty much the same point in the rev range.
It is a surprisingly punchy engine for an air-cooled twin.
And especially in the dynamic riding mode, it really does have a lot of snap to the throttle.
Now on top of that, you've got the shaft drive, which gives it that very direct feeling.
And also, you've got that typical boxer side-to-side kick.
Now the Speed Twin is still pretty quick at just under 100 horsepower.
But I think it's fair to say the focus is a little more on low-end torque,
with a comparable peak figure, made a couple of thousand rpm, lowering the revs.
Perhaps more than the performance figures though,
the deciding factor here for most riders will be the feel and sound,
which couldn't be more different,
considering they're the same capacity and the same number of cylinders.
The R1290 has that flat, droning boxer sound,
and a super smooth feel to it, which will either float your boat or not.
Whereas the Triumph's 270-degree crank gives it that V-twin sort of growl,
which in my opinion, is a lot nicer on the ears.
Although, it has become such a common engine configuration over the past few years,
that it has perhaps started to feel a bit less special.
So look, both quick bikes, similar-ish figures,
the same on fuel, but vastly different on vibes,
and so I'll call this one even.
Onto the chassis and handling,
and the key difference here is that the R1290 is longer and lower,
with that boxer twin also feeling like it holds the centre of gravity low as well.
This gives the BMW its own handling characteristic,
which isn't necessarily bad.
It's a fun bike to ride, and it'll definitely keep you grinning,
but it just takes a few rides to get used to.
The Speed Twin, on the other hand, feels a little more nimble to me,
with a few less kilograms weight and a shorter wheelbase,
and I'd also say it's the bike of the two that feels the more intuitive.
As for the componentry, well, both are on Marzocchi forks,
but the R1290 has a better ride quality, in my opinion,
with a chunkier upside-down fork at the front,
and a monoshock at the rear,
to the relatively budget twin shocks of the Speed Twin.
On top of that, you've got preload, compression,
and rebound adjustability on the fork,
and preload and rebound on the shock,
but with the Triumph's fork, it's non-adjustable,
and you've also just got preload on the shocks.
So while you can get it set up for carrying a passenger,
the BMW is the one to go for,
if you're keen to get the ride absolutely dialed in to your tastes and dimensions.
From a braking perspective,
I'd possibly expect the Speed Twin to have the better stopping performance,
with the slightly higher spec Brembo M50 calipers,
and also larger 320mm discs,
but out on the road, the feel at the lever,
and the sense of power, in my experience,
is superior on the R1290.
So like I say, the BMW does take a little learning,
but with all those factors combined,
I think it's the one I'd go for on a good twisty road.
With both of these bikes being retro nakeds,
there's not a great deal to separate them from a comfort perspective.
They're both pretty simple,
with neutral bar positions and ever so slightly sporty pegs,
and also the seat heights don't have too much to separate them either.
The BMW is a little lower at 795mm,
the Speed Twin a little more tail up at 809mm,
but it's not exactly the difference between a monkey bike and a Tenere.
Pillions are reasonably well accommodated,
as far as you can realistically expect on bikes like these,
and both have heated grips available in the accessories catalogue.
Now the BMW will go a little further on a tank,
with 16 litres to the 14.5 of the Triumph,
with official fuel economy figures being exactly the same,
but I would say both are reasonable for this style of bike.
So really, there isn't enough to separate them to award a clear point,
and so again, this one is evens.
Where these two bikes really do diverge though,
is on the technology front,
which is better, I think will depend on exactly what you want from a retro bike.
Is it purely for the looks,
and you want something actually pretty modern underneath,
or do you want something with more of an authentic old-school riding experience?
I'd say the Speed Twin delivers more so on the latter.
There are three riding modes, traction control and ABS,
but everything is administered through a small LCD display
set into the twin analogue clocks,
and you've got a pretty simple switchgear layout too.
So if you wanted to add any modern capabilities to a bike like this,
you'd realistically have to go with a foam mount on the bars,
and so this is a great chance to give a huge shout out to today's video sponsor,
and that's Quadlock.
In my opinion, they make the best foam mounts in the business,
with a whole different range of fittings to suit pretty much any bike.
So check out the link in the description if you want to see our full guide to their product lineup,
and also down there, you'll find a 10% discount code specifically for our viewers.
Now the BMW, while the standard kit is a step up,
with not only the same three riding modes,
but also their dynamic traction control and ABS probe,
both of which are lean sensitive.
Then you've got many, many more options in the accessories catalogue,
with cruise control and a quick shifter,
both available as part of their £980 comfort pack.
Then you can swap out the twin clocks for a mini TFT display for £120,
and also spec their £280 connected ride control feature,
which allows you to use your smartphone as an extra display,
and control it with the jog wheel on the left hand switch gear.
Now clearly, if you start adding all this stuff,
it's going to push the price up significantly,
but in terms of technological capabilities,
if that's your sort of thing,
the BMW has much more to offer.
Now one of the big updates to the R1290 this year,
is in the styling department,
with a much neater frame design,
that makes things look a little more cohesive towards the rear end of the bike.
They also removed the air intake scoop from the side of the tank,
and moved the airbox to the traditional spot under the rider's saddle,
for a more conventional silhouette.
Then you've got the new tank shape,
the new cylinder head covers,
and also some new finishing options,
and in my opinion, it combines for a great looking bike.
The only thing I will say,
is that from the comments under our videos,
I know the boxer engine,
much like its feel and character,
is a bit divisive in terms of look,
so that might be a put off for some buyers.
But within the constraints of what's possible with this particular engine layout,
I think they've done a banging job.
As standard, it comes in black with aluminium knee areas on the tank,
but the bike we borrowed,
had their option 719 upgrade pack,
with the red frame,
brushed aluminium tank,
seat cover,
fly screen,
and the extra bits of billet hardware.
Now sadly, it is another £2,100,
along with the £550 for the spoke wheels,
but it definitely had a special feel to it.
Now the Speed Twin,
like the R1290,
comes in black for the base price,
although I really do like the ironstone and grey finish,
for another £350.
£800 on the other hand,
will get you the stealth edition tank,
which is only available for this year,
and I actually tried my hand at painting one,
at the Triumph factory,
with moderate success.
Elsewhere, I'd say this bike is a little bit neater looking still.
Triumph really do have the whole modern classic thing nailed,
with not a single part looking out of place.
Everything just looks well finished,
and considered in its design,
right down to the smallest parts,
that other manufacturers might overlook.
But ultimately,
both of them are beautiful bikes,
and so again,
this one's evens.
From a price perspective though,
there can only be one winner,
and that has to be the Triumph.
£11,995 puts it much more in line,
with other sporty retros,
like the Kawasaki Z900RS,
and the Yamaha XSR900,
whereas the BMW really is,
a significant step up above.
Then you've got the extras.
It feels like there's a lot less flexibility,
with the BMW catalogue,
because some of the parts are bundled into those packs,
whereas with the Triumph,
you can pretty much pick and choose,
the individual upgrades.
And then also,
you know we've talked about,
how well finished and good looking the BMW can be,
and how many techie options you've got,
but of course,
you're going to have to pay,
for a lot of those things.
The specific press bike I was riding,
was specced up with the absolute works,
and so from my estimations on the configurator,
you'd be looking at over £18,000 for all of that,
which just puts it in a totally different price point.
That makes it with my rudimentary scoring system,
2-1 to the BMW overall,
with a lot of the categories being drawn,
because they're so comparable.
And I think that scoring is pretty fair,
it is a little more snappy,
it has more quality to the ride,
the brakes felt better to me,
there's more technology on offer,
and the finish can look really special,
but there is a huge caveat,
and that's the price.
Realistically,
if it were my own cash,
I'd probably be going for the Triumph,
because it's so much better,
in terms of value for money,
but the flip side of the argument,
is that if you've got the funds,
and you love a boxer,
then I'm sure the R12 will live up to expectations.
Which one would you choose though?
Do let me know down in the comments below,
and also if you want to see some of my other picks,
for the best retros this year,
then I'll put our full list on the screen now,
so you can give it a click,
and give it a watch,
in case you haven't already.
Also hit subscribe if you've not already,
to see more of the latest motorcycle,
head-to-heads like this,
right here on YouTube.
Many thanks for watching today,
and we'll catch you in the next video.
