Sarah Kaplan: Challenges can be turned into innovation

Academy: stories and events
54 followers
Any company that is not moving towards better representation on their boards is going to
find themselves behind the eight ball.
Regulators need to think about not just what they're regulating, but the nitty-gritty of
how they implement it so that it can be effective in driving change.
The soft-touch approaches that have worked in the past have not been powerful enough
to move the needle.
What I try to advocate around gender diversity specifically, but also other forms of social
responsibility and environmental issues, is that these are really innovation opportunities.
There's plenty that organizations can do, and that CEOs can do, but the most important
starting point is to really understand the challenge inside and out.
These are really challenging problems that are going to, you know, lead to many kinds
of trade-offs.
And thinking about what those trade-offs are is always the first step before you can get
to innovation.
I have so much to say, and so little time.
I'm Sarah Kaplan.
I am Distinguished Professor of Gender in the Economy and a Professor of Strategic Management
at the Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto.
And I am Founding Director of the Institute for Gender in the Economy.
And I have been an academic for over two decades, and before that I was a management consultant
for many years.
There's been a lot of conversation in the United States, in Canada, and globally around
increasing the diversity in organizations, and in particular on corporate boards of directors.
And so one of the things I've been interested in is understanding, well, how could we help
move the needle on that?
What are the systems, procedures, policies, regulations, and laws that might actually
help increase diversity?
And so one study that I'm doing right now is looking at a regulation in Canada that
required firms to disclose whether they had women on their board, how many, and what practices
they had in place.
And my question was, is, do these disclosure regulations actually help?
And what we find in this study is that for companies that are large and very visible
and covered by analysts and covered by the media, those firms are already well on their
way to moving towards greater representation of women on boards.
And because they have so many different pressures from so many different stakeholders.
But slightly smaller firms, firms that are slightly outside of the media spotlight, are
the ones that are able to kind of use their disclosures to hide their sometimes poor performance.
And in doing so, they actually are somehow prohibiting themselves from moving forward
because in hiding the information from external stakeholders, they're actually sort of hiding
the information from themselves and therefore prohibiting themselves from doing a better
job and increasing diversity over time.
Part of my research has been looking not just what companies do, but what regulators and
governments do to structure the ways that companies behave.
And the conclusion that I draw, for example, looking at regulations in Canada around disclosure
for women on boards, is not just the idea of the regulation, it has to be how it's implemented
that really matters.
And so in the Canadian context, they created a regulation that said the companies have
to disclose about women on their boards and their policies and practices.
They said, just put it anywhere in your disclosure document that includes all sorts of other
things, financial disclosure and other things.
So it didn't really create the transparency it could have created.
And so if they had implemented it in a different way, it would have created more transparency
and potentially created that social pressure on companies to actually make change.
So regulators need to think about not just what they're regulating, but the nitty gritty
of how they implement it so that it can be effective in driving change.
I think what business leaders need to take away from understanding diversity on boards
is that there are so many pressures out there, there are so many stakeholders who are interested
in this.
There's so much research to suggest that you have better governance, better decision-making,
better ability to represent the communities that you serve if you have diverse boards.
And there's a lot of pressure there.
And so any company that is not moving towards better representation on their boards is going
to find themselves behind the eight ball, not just in terms of pressure from stakeholders,
but also behind the eight ball in terms of the products and services they offer that
won't be inclusive enough.
behind the eight ball when it comes to potential investor reactions, behind the eight ball
when it comes to performance.
And so really every firm should be thinking about how they can improve the diversity of
the people who are making the critical decisions in a firm.
It's timely now in particular because there's been a lot of different efforts along the
way to try to increase diversity on boards, including just sort of publicly shaming firms
and other things like that.
And I think people, many stakeholders, whether it's regulators, whether it's consumers, whether
it's investors are becoming frustrated that firms haven't moved faster.
So it's really relevant now because I think that firms are going to really get increased
pressure from all of those or social movement activists or their own employees who want
to see better representation.
And so it's very timely now because I think people have realized that the soft touch approaches
that have worked in the past have not been powerful enough to move the needle.
And so they're going to, they're going to have to be stronger measures.
And so if firms want to avoid being subject to those stronger measures, they better just
move forward themselves.
One of the reasons we don't make progress on any of these environmental, social kind
of issues is that you end up facing trade-offs, but people aren't explicit about it.
They don't understand it.
They don't map that out.
So they might say, oh, well, we want more diversity on the team, but actually to do
that, we're going to have to search harder.
We're going to have to look into other communities that we don't normally look into.
We're going to have to invest more in recruiting.
We're going to have to invest more in team building.
We're going to have to invest more in creating organizations that really allow everyone to
feel like they belong.
So that feels like really expensive to do.
Therefore, I'm not going to do it.
That's a trade-off.
But no one says that explicitly, maps that out, and therefore it makes it harder to think
about how could we innovate around that?
How could we think about something that would break that trade-off in terms of how we organize
in a way that would allow people to feel more included?
Or think about environmental things.
If you just say, well, I can't put air cleaner on that smokestack because it's too expensive,
therefore I'm going to continue to pollute, as opposed to thinking about, well, could
we actually change our manufacturing technology?
Could we use different suppliers?
There's all kinds of things that you could do, but if you don't actually lay out, here's
the trade-off and here's the potential nugget that could allow us to innovate.
If we look at that trade-off closely, we can actually come up with different ideas.
Research shows that you can get the most innovative ideas often when you have the most constraints.
Mapping those constraints out and thinking about what those trade-offs are is always
the first step before you can get to innovation.
Investors, employees, consumers, the media, social movements, they care about all of the
different ways that corporations can affect society, can affect the environment.
We know that firms can have many great positive impacts, creating new drugs and products that
people want to use, but at the same time can create many damages, exacerbating inequality,
creating environmental degradation, contributing to climate change and global warming.
People care more and more about this.
Organizations are going to have to find a way to respond.
If they respond by talking a good talk but not walking the walk, they're going to ultimately
be in trouble.
What I'm trying to do with my work on diversity and also more broadly on corporate purpose
is to get organizations to figure out how to walk the walk, how to really do the work.
It's hard.
These are really challenging problems that are going to lead to many kinds of trade-offs.
What I try to advocate around gender diversity specifically, but also other forms of social
responsibility and environmental issues is that these are really innovation opportunities
and that if organizations could think about these challenges not as heavy weights on their
shoulders of something that they have to do, but instead exciting opportunities to think
about how they can innovate, innovate in how they organize, innovate in their products
and services, innovate in how they go to market.
If they thought about it that way, I think they could come up with something really interesting
and something that would break some of these trade-offs that have been getting in the way
of making forward movement.
I think there's a real opportunity there, but I also think that it's easy to get stuck
for many organizations.
It's easy to get stuck saying, oh, it's too hard or we can't break the trade-offs.
What I'm trying to say is, no, you can break them, but you have to do it by being innovative.
One thing I just want to highlight is this idea that a lot of the challenges that organizations
face can be turned into innovation challenges.
One way we're trying to do this at the Institute for Gender and the Economy is introducing
training and courses that are around what we call gender analytics, which is about how
to think about your products and services using an intersectional gender lens, thinking
about race, disability, other forms of inequality, and how that could lead you to design better
products and services that would serve the communities that you serve better.
That's an example of flipping the script on a challenge.
We always thought of diversity as just this thing that we have to do on the talent side.
Let's flip the script and think about what it means for going to market, but we could
do the same thing with environmental issues.
We could do the same thing with global warming, with inequality, is to really think about
how we can reframe this challenge as one that leads us to think about how we go to market
differently.
I think too many companies leave all of that to the side.
I think there are so many exciting opportunities that organizations could have if they just
would flip the script more often on that.
Rather than treating all of these different pressures as just one more thing hammering
me, think about them as one more opportunity to go to market in a different way.
One example that I give is an organization called McCarthy Uniforms, a small company
in Canada that sells uniforms to schools and also for construction and other things like
that.
The new CEO comes in for a turnaround.
The company has been run into the ground by the prior folks.
She decides that to do the turnaround, she's actually going to apply a gender lens to that.
She analyzed everything about how they went to market and their products, thinking through
what does this mean from a gender lens.
She discovered a number of things that are really important.
For school uniforms, they were always sold with the hems undone because they figured
the mother somehow at home was going to hem the pants or the skirt for their child, depending
upon how tall that child was.
One of the things she discovered was no one has time for that anymore.
They innovated by creating a hem tape that would allow families to quickly fix the clothes
for the kids.
That led her to win many more contracts with schools because the product was just going
to be easier to use for the customer.
She looked at some of the uniforms she was selling for bus drivers and discovered that
they weren't and none of the competitors were selling uniforms that were sized for women.
Women who have, for example, larger hips were being forced to wear men's pants that were
very poor fitting for them because they would then be too big in the waist and everything
like that.
They said, we're going to launch this line of women-sized uniforms.
She said the first time there was a woman bus driver actually tried on the uniform that
fit her, she cried because it was so powerful and, again, leads to winning many more contracts.
What does this gender-based analysis do?
The company is supposed to take four years to do the turnaround.
She does it in two years because she has applied this lens in ways that allow her to innovate
in the product and service offerings, how she goes to market.
That's one example where you use the challenge and you don't say diversity is one thing and
my product and go-to-market strategy is another.
You bring them together and suddenly you have a more powerful company that does much better
financially than could have been anticipated.
Many CEOs, many leaders really do want to take action, but they don't exactly know where
to start.
In part, that's because these problems are super complex.
There's many different trade-offs.
There's many different demands.
These are things that are making the job of the CEO, the job of the whole organization,
the job of the board much harder to do.
I think about three things that organizations can do, any CEO or leader who wants to get
started.
The first is actually be thoughtful and explicit about what those trade-offs are that they're
experiencing because I think many organizations skip over that.
They're just like, let's go do something.
The drive to make change is so compelling that you just try things.
If you haven't actually been thoughtful about why are there trade-offs, what are the underlying
mechanisms, what's really going on and being very thoughtful about that, including engaging
with communities, not just thinking in your own brain or looking at your belly button,
but engaging with communities, engaging with critics, engaging with the data.
That's a really important first step and many organizations skip that.
The second thing is to think about, well, are there some low-hanging fruit, easy things
that we can do.
Instead of using plastic bags, we'll use paper bags in the grocery store.
Instead of putting a deodorant in a box, we'll just put it on the shelf on its own without
wasting the extra paper to give some kind of retail grocery type of examples.
Those are some low-hanging fruit and every organization should just pluck those fruit
and do them.
That will make a huge difference.
But then there's a situation where there aren't low-hanging fruit, it is going to be a little
bit harder.
The third thing that organizations can do is really think about, is there a way I can
innovate around this?
We have all these great product and service innovation teams all over our organizations.
Then when it comes to environment or diversity, we suddenly don't use all those talents and
skills of the people who know how to innovate.
I'm like, use the talents and skills of the people who know how to innovate and apply
it to these kinds of questions to see if you can come up with innovative insights.
Those are three main things.
I actually wrote a book called The 360 Corporation, and I have four points because the fourth
one is when you can't figure out a solution, it's very tempting to say, it's too hard,
I can't do it, and you lay it to the side.
The fourth thing is not giving up, not giving up when it's hard.
If you can't do anything, at least marinate in it, at least try some experiments, at least
try to do something that could eventually lead you to that innovation or that change.
There's plenty that organizations can do and that CEOs can do, but the most important starting
point is to really understand the challenge inside and out.
We've heard a lot about corporate purpose.
Business roundtable, companies are saying they're going to take care of all stakeholders.
I think there's a huge risk if companies do purpose washing or just say that they have
corporate purpose without taking it seriously.
I think there's a lot of ways to take it seriously, but to do that, you're going to have to actually
change.
You're going to have to really decenter the organization in a network of stakeholders
and use that as an opportunity to rethink how you do business.
I think that is hard.
Most companies, if they think they can just put purpose on top of what they're doing without
really thinking about how they operate, I think they're not going to go far enough and
they're going to end up getting called out on it.
I hope that organizations use purpose as a way to transform as opposed to a way to do
window dressing.
When we think about making change in the corporate world, we need to also make change in business
schools for sure.
I think we're at a cusp of a moment where business schools are actually in many ways
quite far behind corporate practice and we need to catch up.
We're behind the expectations of our students too.
Our students come to business school not just wanting to produce total returns to shareholders.
They want to have meaning.
They want to use companies to create innovations that are going to change the world.
We need to catch up in business schools.
One, we need to get finance, strategy, and social responsibility much more aligned.
Even if we teach courses on social responsibility or integrate it into our strategy courses,
if the students then go to the finance class and they learn that everything is about the
net present value that's created and they have that one financial metric, then we're
not really solving the problem.
We need more integration across the functions around this.
I think second, we need to really rethink every element of how we teach.
I teach strategic management.
We often talk about the strategy and how it relates to financial performance.
We could have other, what we call in the technical research world, dependent variables, other
outcomes that we can measure.
How does this strategy lead to less deforestation in the Amazon in Brazil?
How does this strategy lead to reduction in carbon emissions?
Really count those as legitimate outcomes that matter.
People say, well, then you're not really worried about investors and investors are the ones
who own the shares of the companies.
Most investors these days don't want to retire on the backs of the destruction of the Amazonian
rainforest or retire on the backs of workers who have been very poorly treated.
Even if we care about investors, we need to care about these things.
That mindset needs to be integrated into everything that we teach when we teach in the business
school.
I think business schools need to transform.
We have the ideas, but it's so easy to get locked in, like any organization, to the traditional
ways of doing things.
We need to unlock ourselves.
The cool thing about bigs is that it's business in global society.
What's so important about that is you might be tempted to think of it as business and
global society over here, and they're somehow separate.
The point is they have to be seen as integrated.
They have to be seen as all part of a whole, and that if we're really going to make progress,
if we're going to survive as a planet and as humanity, we are going to need to really
see that integration at a very deep level, and I hope that that's what this initiative
can do.
