What are Diving Z-Factors? Do I need them?

Diving Technique
83 followers
#sports #scubadiving #teach to dive
Good morning, Benjamin.
Teach Me To Dive, Technical Dive Instructor in Idaho,
coming up with your latest message.
And I go through these and I think about
what I wanna talk about and what kind of has been brought up
during classes that I've been teaching
or conversations I've had.
And last night while teaching a class,
I had a few students ask about the density
of in-gas difference and calculate the difference
between in relationship to sacrate calculation.
Now, what we briefly touched on a question
that was quite fair.
I may have glossed over it a little too quickly
with a response that was more of a statement
that the difference between gases and capacities
in a cylinder was negligible.
Now, the longer answer to this question
is to take into account the Z factor
when calculating the gas capacity of a cylinder.
Now, before we touch on what the Z factor is,
it's important to consider the actual capacity of tanks.
Now, an example, tanks hold as much as 10% less air
than the commonly used size to describe them.
Now, and that can be up to 20% less
for the gases other than air.
Now, an example, an S80 or a Catalina 80 aluminum
is listed as 80 cubic feet.
Don't believe it when it's actually only 77.4 cubic feet.
Now, this is one of the nice things that we have
with modern HP steel tanks.
These tanks tend to be more accurate
in describing the actual capacity.
For example, if you were to take a Faber HP 100
that says it's 100 cubic feet,
it actually is 100 cubic feet,
but the issue becomes more than the sheer variety
of tanks out there
because there's a lot of manufacturers out there.
There's a lot of sizes out there
and there's been scuba tanks.
We have scuba tanks in the dive shop that I worked out of.
They're from the 60s.
So there's a lot of variety out there to be aware of,
but the issue becomes more than just a sheer variety
of tanks for diving.
It becomes larger issues as well.
So using the manufacturer's listed liter volume
creates a much more concise and accurate standard
for measuring the tanks
and giving us a more accurate value that we can rely upon.
Now, once we are fully able to appreciate the accuracy
of using the published liter size of a particular tank,
we can begin to take into consideration
the Z factor for the gas that we plan to dive.
Now, the Z factor is used to determine
how the gases will compress in a cylinder
and is used to calculate the compressibility factor.
It's Z factor.
This factor has differing values based on gas,
temperature, and total pressure.
Now, so for example, let's look at a few.
So for example, if we took air,
21% oxygen, 79% nitrogen, basically,
we're gonna be very generalist.
We're not gonna talk about that mysterious 1%.
So if we took that air at 70 degrees Fahrenheit
and we had it at 2,015 PSI in an aluminum 80,
that gives it a compressibility Z factor of 0.9984,
giving it, if it was actually 80 cubic feet,
giving that a true capacity of 80.1282.
Now, interestingly enough,
we just talked about that 70 degree Fahrenheit at 2,015 PSI.
The Z factor was 0.9984.
Now, in that same tank,
once we compress it up to 3,000 PSI,
the Z factor increases to 1.0320,
giving that capacity down to 77.5193 based upon the idea
if it was actually an 80 cubic foot tank.
So, and now it changes again if we get to 3,600 PSI,
which is 1.0615 Z factor,
giving that 80 cubic foot 75.3650.
So we looked at it.
2,000 PSI at 70 degrees Fahrenheit for air
compresses to 0.99.
At 3,000, it compresses to 1.03.
At 3,600, it compresses to 1.06.
So you see there's a variety of them.
Now, if we looked at nitrox,
we can get the same basic idea.
Nitrox, 32% at 72 degrees.
2,000 is 0.9912.
At 3,000, it's 1.021.
And then at 3,600, it's 1.04.
So you can see it's a slight variety difference.
For example, the difference between air and nitrox 32
is about 0.02%, roughly, right?
Trimix is a whole different story as well.
Trimix, as we know,
helium doesn't compress as densely as air or nitrogen.
But at 2015, nitrox 1070 in an 80 cubic foot tank
is 1.083.
So it's 8% difference.
So the true capacity of an 80 cubic foot cylinder
at 70 degrees at 2,000 PSI is 73 cubic feet.
If we take that same at 3,000 PSI,
that 80 cubic feet is now 69 cubic feet.
And at 3,600, we don't have a huge change.
It's still 69 cubic feet.
Now, you might be asking yourself,
how do you calculate this?
So to calculate the true cylinder capacity of a gas,
you'd simply divide the ideal capacity by the Z factor.
Now, with this, it's worth noting
that this is not a straight line.
As you kind of notice, it's a very line,
but rather curve and has a variance
that is dependent on the amount of pressure.
Now, in the end, there is a general average
that can be counted on.
Now, it is worth noting that different gases
create different sack rates for multiple reasons.
And it is to your advantage to make sure
that you're tracking your sack rate
throughout a history of diving
and dividing all dives into categories.
For example, in all your nitrox dives,
if you're doing all nitrox dives in warm water,
70 degrees, drift dives, and you're using 32%,
put all those in one bucket and start calculating those out.
Put another bucket for cold water dives,
for air dives, for warm dives,
for sea level dives, for altitude dives.
Yes, at altitude, you're gonna have a different sack rate.
In cold water, you're gonna have a different sack rate.
Now, also keep in mind factors like travel,
hydration, how tired you are,
whether your wife beat the hell out of you last night.
My wife is amazing.
She's never raised her voice to me once.
I'm amazed.
But if you have that issues,
there's a lot of things that take into account.
Now, as well, of course, as diving efforts should be noted,
to be able to help determine
an accurate dive sack rate profile.
Now, while many new divers refer to their computers
and simply look at their PSI per minute for their sack rate,
this is far from being anything
that can be considered very accurate
or very useful for more complex dive planning.
This is one of the reasons it's so important
to ensure that you are using
the manufactured listed liter capacity
instead of the described cylinder size
on relying on a PSI per minute
based on a formula that is missing
most of the most important data.
Now, by using the metric liter size of a tank
and multiplying this by the bar pressure,
you are able to determine a more accurate picture
of the actual amount of usable gas within
instead of guessing based on the potential inaccuracy
or inaccurate classification number in cubic feet.
To increase the accuracy of this raw data,
adding the Z factor calculation
will give the diver more accurate picture
of the amount of gas available
and prepare them to be able to plan their dives accordingly.
Now, overall, gas management is an important part
of any diver plan and becomes critical
the more complex the dive
and technicalities of that dive are.
Being able to remove as many variables
from the gas calculation helps ensure
a much higher potential for success
and preparing for potential emergencies
that may arise.
Capacity calculations also ignore the fact
that it is difficult for a diver
to breathe the residual gas in a tank
below 150 PSI or 10 bar
due to regulator flow restrictions
and the fact that the pressure gauges
can be significantly inaccurate,
especially when it comes to lower gas levels.
Now, with this, it becomes even more important
to plan your dives with a generous amount of reserve gas,
adopting a policy of diving the rule of thirds
helps ensure that the diver is not only more prepared
for an emergency that they might have,
but also for one that their buddy may experience as well.
No, wait, I didn't see that.
The last I saw you tell me was just to get it done.
So the biggest thing on this is making sure
that as we're working with our dive buddies
that we're planning out all that key pieces of information
to make sure that we're safe, they're safe,
and able to plan out a dive accordingly.
Now, Z-factors are a fantastic way,
but again, if you don't quite understand this,
take a class.
As you start moving up in the chain,
a nice Nitrox class, if you haven't taken Nitrox,
is a great way to go.
Take those times and really dig into this information.
Make sure you're using the most information.
If you email us directly, I have a list of all,
well, maybe not all, but only 128 of the most common tanks
used in existence today with their Z-factors,
with their actual leader capacities,
with their buoyancy factors.
If you email me directly, I will happily send you that list.
It's an Excel spreadsheet,
so you'll have to probably have Excel.
But other than that, I'm happy to help in any way I can.
Again, my name is Benjamin Hadfield.
I am with Teach Me To Dive.
I'm a technical dive instructor.
I live in Idaho.
I teach diving.
I teach technical diving, teach side mount.
If you have any questions, put them in the comments.
Also, in the description of this,
I will put all the description of Z-factors
in there for you as well.
If you have any questions, reach out.
Again, Benjamin Hadfield, Teach Me To Dive.
Go get them.
