Live: US Senate Delegates Speak at COP29 at the UN Climate Change Convention

NTD
11.9K followers
143 Video Views·Nov 16, 2024
U.S. Senate Delegates hold a press conference at the 29th Session of the Conference of the Parties (COP29) at the United Nations Climate Change Convention at 8:30 a.m. ET on Nov. 16.
Hello. Hello and welcome to this press conference of the United States Senate
delegation to COP 29. In just a moment I will invite Senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Ed Markey
to deliver opening remarks before we engage in a Q&A. A few reminders, please raise your hand
to indicate you'd like to ask a question. We will have a mic on each side of the room.
When you have the mic, please introduce yourself with your name and your outlet and please stick
to one question so we can get to the multiple reporters in this room. With that, Senator
Whitehouse. Thank you, Steve. Thank you all for coming here today. I'm particularly honored to
have traveled to the COP 29 here in Baku with Ed Markey, who has been, I would say, Congress's
climate champion going back to the Waxman-Markey climate legislation, which had the Senate passed
it back then, would have kept us from being in such a dangerous position right now. So I'm
very gratified to be here with Ed. We sit on the Environment Public Works Committee together,
and I think we share a sense of optimism despite the lateness of the hour to meet climate targets.
What everybody sees is obvious, and that is that the United States has suffered a climate setback
with the recent election. It is unfortunate to lose the executive branch of the federal
government as an ally in the fight against climate change, and it's particularly unfortunate
if the executive branch turns into the bureaucratic glove for the hand of the fossil fuel
industry. We'll have to see about that. We have major battles and challenges ahead on that subject.
But the underlying facts are that an enormous amount of the climate work that's being done
in the United States is being done at the state and municipal level.
If you look just at California, the fifth largest economy in the world,
and New York, the tenth largest economy in the world,
they can get a lot done just by working together, irrespective of who the president is.
If you look at our region, New England, we have multiple states involved in the
Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, a small carbon pricing plan.
If you look at the fuel economy standards, they're essentially driven by California
and the 17 states that all participate in that state-level standard.
So there will rise up very significant state-level activity to fill the gap
that the Trump administration will leave. The second thing that is going to
keep climate progress moving is economics. And there's a push and there's a pull.
The pull is that clean energy is cheaper, as well as cleaner. Even if you don't give it credit for
being cleaner, it's still cheaper. And that market pressure is going to continue. The second,
the push, is that it has long been predicted that the uncertainties created by climate change
will make property insurance extremely challenging. We are already seeing that in Florida,
where home insurance prices have quadrupled, where insurance companies have gone bankrupt,
where insurance companies have fled the state, where the state has had to prop up an alternative
insurer to fill the hole in the market. And what the chief economist for the mortgage giant,
Freddie Mac, has told us is that what happens is that the insurance crisis rolls into a mortgage
crisis, because you need insurance to get a mortgage, and that rolls into a property values
crash. Because unless you're a billionaire living at Mar-a-Lago, then it's easy. You find another
billionaire, they pay cash, you sell the house. But if you're a plumber living in a development
outside of Orlando, you need mortgages to sell your house. And so we're seeing it already in
the insurance market, it's beginning to infiltrate the mortgage market, and we're seeing the early
hints of it affecting property values. When that goes, it could go very subtly, very broadly,
and very deeply. The warning from the chief economist was that this will be
just from a coastal property values crash, an economic hit to the United States,
as bad as the 2008 mortgage meltdown, which, as you know, went global. So that's going to keep a
lot of attention on this problem as that becomes increasingly apparent. The last point that I'll
is that all across the globe, people and institutions who have fiduciary duties
are going to have to make statements and decisions that are consistent with the facts of climate.
The climate problem is no longer just on the scientific horizon, it's now on the fiduciary
horizon. And we're seeing investment managers, bankers, CEOs, corporate boards of directors,
having to adapt to the reality of climate or face liability for failing in their fiduciary duty.
That is what caused the fossil fuel industry to stand up its fake anti-ESG campaign to try to
knock it back. But that's not going to last because the fiduciary responsibility is a
responsibility at law. My two goals here, the things that I think will make this COP a success,
one is that the EU and UK companies, countries who are in the CBAM, the Carbon Border Adjustment
Mechanism, get increased resolution to stand fast and hold, particularly the United States,
to accountability under their tariff regime. It's the right thing to do. It sends a global
price signal and it will change the political dynamic in the United States
favorably. The second is methane. We can now track the damned stuff by satellites.
We're beginning to enforce in the United States through EPA's Supermeters Program,
through the Department of Justice, Methane Enforcement Task Force. That should be a
global initiative. If we can't get that concluded here, it should be a priority for Brazil.
Where satellites detect a leak, enforcement should follow wherever you are on the globe.
If we can do those two things, I think we will have made important steps towards
climate safety. Just one last word on the CBAM. Senator Markey and I are both very attuned to
the concern in developing nations that they have not been responsible for this mess,
and yet their populations feel it more painfully and more acutely and more immediately than anybody
else. The CBAM actually accomplishes the most important thing we can for developing nations,
which is to avoid a climate crisis. The full bore of the climate crisis is going to fall
so hard on developing nations compared to developed nations. Our number one job has
to be to head that off. That's where carbon pricing comes in. There are no remaining scenarios
by which we avoid climate catastrophe without carbon pricing. We have to get that done.
Then we have to sort through which countries get actual economic advantage from carbon border
tariffs, because there are many, and which ones will suffer economically and focus our attention
on those so that we can meet the demands of economic justice and the moral requirement for,
particularly our country, that we make sure that the climate solution is a fair and just
climate solution. That's why we came. We've made those points pretty relentlessly.
Let me turn it over now to Senator Markey, the legend from Massachusetts.
Thank you, Senator Whitehouse. Just for clarification, Senator Whitehouse has been
the chairman of the Budget Committee in the United States Senate for the last two years.
What did he take the Budget Committee and turn its agenda to focus upon? It was more than 20
hearings on climate change and the impact upon the American economy and on the global economy.
That's what he did. That spotlight, of course, is one that really did come into play
with two storms that hit the United States in a two-week period,
Hurricane Milton and Hurricane Helene, which caused $300 billion worth of damage.
That's 35% of the entire defense budget, every aircraft carrier, every fighter jet,
everything that the United States has. One third of that was just two storms.
When it went over Florida, I think all Donald Trump was saying to himself,
I hope Mar-a-Lago doesn't turn into Mar-a-Lago because it missed Mar-a-Lago.
The next time it may not, but it hit millions of other people. The impact was catastrophic.
It's just a preview of coming atrocities that climate change is creating for potentially
any community in the United States or across the planet. It's just been great being here with
everyone. We just want to let you know that we're not going to allow COP to stand for courting
oil profits. We're here to tell you that COP really stands for Climate Outlast Presidents.
The Trump presidency will just be a footnote in history, just very quickly dismissed because of
the inexorable upward trajectory of the investment in clean energy technologies
in the United States and across the planet. The climate tie gets established through
updated nationally determined contributions are going to outlive Donald Trump. The new
climate finance goals can outlast a climate denier. By coming here to show our support
for ambitious action, we can hammer in the nails for the signposts that we will
hopefully use in the not too distant future to find our way back to the negotiating table.
Trump may pull the United States out of the Paris Agreement, but he cannot pull
the United States out of a revolution which is taking place in the United States,
in wind, in solar, in all electric vehicles, in battery storage technologies. It's happening,
and it's happening very rapidly. Even if Trump makes public climate finance an uphill battle,
we can't follow his lead in declaring climate bankruptcy or running out on the bill.
By supporting a climate finance goal of more than $1 trillion by year, by pushing for more
for multilateral banks, and by showcasing climate leadership, we can prevent developing nations from
being forced to pay the United States climate damage tab and instead fund a livable future
for everyone. By fighting back against limitless, needless, and reckless fossil fuel exports,
we can start turning off the tap and backing up the global push to phase out fossil fuels.
That's why I joined advocates and global legislators today in calling for a rejection
of fossil fuel exports and a full fossil fuel phase-out. The United States is set to double
fossil gas exports in the next five years, but supercharged LNG exports will be a new energy
tax, courtesy of Donald Trump, on all American households. Fossil fuel exports just increase
costs for American households in order to increase profits for fossil fuel executives.
The estimates now are that LNG exports already cost Americans $111 billion
in just the last year, from September of 2021, when LNG exports began to skyrocket to December
of 2022. Pretty simple rule of economics 101. The more natural gas you take out of the United States
means that that which is left is going to have a higher price, supply and demand,
and American consumers and businesses are paying it. What we have to do
is then to make sure that the rest of the world doesn't pay the price for what the United States
natural gas industry wants to do. Here's why there's a big problem looming for the industry.
While the U.S. gets ready to double its exports, our allies in Europe, the entire European community,
are expecting a 50% decline in natural gas demand by 2030. Can I say that again? A 50%
decline in natural gas demand in Europe by 2030. Last year, more
investment was made in solar than oil for the first time in global history,
and it's never going back. This is just going to continue. If fossil fuel exports aren't for
our own energy security or cost savings, and they're not for our allies' energy security,
we'll have to look to the $173 billion in profits taken home by the 15 biggest
U.S. fossil fuel companies for an explanation. While fossil fuel companies try to yank money out
of our pockets, the Inflation Reduction Act is still working to put money right back in.
In two years alone, it has created 400,000 new clean energy jobs in the United States.
It's unleashed $372 billion of public and private investment in the United States.
Disproportionately, those jobs are in red states, red congressional districts.
If Trump wants to try to repeal the IRA, he's going to have to convince the congressmen who
represent the 80% of the money that went to their congressional districts, the red congressional
districts, that created 400,000 new jobs with a promise of hundreds of thousands, if not millions
of more, over the next eight years, the duration of that bill. So that's going to be the future.
And I'm optimistic. Congressman, Senator Whitehouse is optimistic that this revolution
is unstoppable. And we were here just to let all of these delegates from around the world
know that. And I think what excites Sheldon and me the most is all the young people who are here.
You can see still the excitement, the demand that we do something. The first generation to suffer
from climate change and the last generation who can do anything about it. And they're going to
be demanding it across the planet. And so the United States at the city level, at the state
level, and Sheldon and I are in the Congress, we're going to fight hard to preserve the vast
majority of the IRA. So those incentives are there to continue to deploy the clean energy technology,
the wind, the solar, the all electric vehicles, the battery storage technology, any technology
that reduces greenhouse gases, and to make sure that we do the right thing. Because it is the
political, economic, environmental, and moral issue of all time. And we must solve this problem.
And we're just here to tell people that the United States is still in. So I thank all of
you and turn it back to Sheldon. Questions? Hi. Sorry. Alec Moon from Scientific American.
Donald Trump talks a lot about energy security, energy independence, cracking down on Chinese
imports. If the U.S. focuses on fossil fuel expansion rather than clean tech, if the U.S.
cuts back on foreign aid money, if the U.S. repeals parts of the IRA, if the U.S. isolates
itself from the world, doesn't that give countries like China room to grow, compete better, fill that
void in climate policy, climate finance, and international foreign aid? Yes. There are two
things wrong with the energy security propaganda that the fossil fuel industry is putting out.
One is you simply cannot have energy security if you are dependent on a product whose price
you can't control domestically. When a foreign cartel drives the price of oil and gas,
it will always be out of America's control. That is not energy security. The other aspect is that
there's a mercantile challenge for dominance in markets. And if we don't keep moving forward,
other countries will eat our lunch, as the saying goes. So it's going to be really important to do
that. And as I've mentioned here, the CBAM creates an emissions-based tariff that because of China's
emissions falls much more heavily on Chinese products. So that actually accomplishes what
Trump's trade representative, Ambassador Lighthizer, has said he wants to do. And it
moves manufacturing and jobs to the United States, which is something that I would expect
the Trump administration would welcome. And there's bipartisan carbon tariff conversations
happening. So there's plenty of opportunity for progress around carbon tariffs. And
the real energy security comes when our own clean energy technologies at home
are providing the bulk, if not all, of our energy.
China has a plan. China wants to be the dominant country in the world,
manufacturing renewables, manufacturing all electric vehicles, manufacturing battery
technologies, and exporting those technologies around the planet. China has a plan. Donald
Trump does not have a plan. If they have a plan and we do not have a plan, we will lose.
We will lose markets around the planet. We'll lose the cutting-edge technological
breakthroughs that otherwise would have been incentivized here in the United States.
And generations will look back and wonder, what were they thinking to allow China to take such an
insurmountable lead over the United States?
If the United States has a plan and China has a plan, we will win. But you have to have a plan.
The IRA is that plan. Increasing fuel economy standards is that plan. Having utilities have
to reduce their greenhouse gases and install new technologies invented in America, that's a plan.
Having tax breaks for new metals that are going to be developed, that's a plan.
So we're going to be having a mighty battle in the United States House and Senate over the next
several months over whether or not we should have a plan or not. Otherwise, we should just get used
to having the whole rest of the world buy products that say made in China, because they will be
better technologically and they'll be cheaper. If we don't get in this race, then we will lose.
There's just no two ways about it. And Donald Trump is going to, I think, learn a lot about
how many Republican congressmen want to have stuff made in America, innovated in America.
And I think he's in for a rude awakening, to be honest with you. I don't think there's any
question about it. We went first on these technologies. You all have one in your pocket
right now. You also, and many of you also have a version of a tablet or an iPod. We went first
and the United States branded it made in America. It's the new language that we created, Google,
eBay, Amazon, Hulu, YouTube, made in America. And China's been trying to catch up for 25 years.
So we have the same choice on clean energy technologies. If we have a plan and we keep
it in place and we expand it, then we'll win. And Sheldon and I are looking forward to having
that debate in the Environment Committee and across all of the Senate in the first half of 2025.
And we think that young people are going to respond. We think that red state congressmen
are going to respond because they'll want the jobs to compete in their home districts. They're
not going to want to lose that incredible opportunity to raise up and to train a
whole new generation of young Americans in the deployment of these technologies.
I would like to know if you have been in talks or are you planning to work together with
local legislators of Argentina, considering that the actual government of Malay
is having similar climate policies, not based in science, of course,
like Donald Trump did and probably is going to do in his second term. Thank you.
For me, no. COP is coming to its end. Argentina has made its decision. I think
those conversations will take place as we move towards Brazil.
Hello. Aina Zabaliba for Baku TV. Hello, gentlemen. The question is,
60 pro-Armenian U.S. Congress members have appealed to the U.S. government calling for
sanctions against Azerbaijan, including during the 44-day war. However, Armenia has been
occupying and terrorizing both ecologically as well as ruining historical Azerbaijani
monuments on the territory of Karabakh that belongs to Azerbaijan and is internationally
recognized. No sanctions imposed against Armenia, not even a proposition to do so,
even after Armenia has been involved in circumventing U.S. sanctions imposed over
countries involved in conflicts. Why, in your opinion, still no action to impose sanctions
against Armenia? Thank you. I think Senator Markey and I support Armenia, both of us.
We are very regretful that the dislocation of so many Armenians has taken place.
To put it mildly, I'm far from convinced that Armenians are to blame for that.
I don't want to dwell in the home of my hosts on human rights issues,
but if that were to be the topic, I would not be very complimentary.
Ed? We believe that the political prisoners should be released.
We believe there should be a right of return of Armenians to the corner of Karabakh.
We believe that there should be a peace treaty between Azerbaijan and Armenia.
Our hope is that it's negotiated soon so that these issues can be resolved,
including the issue of a capacity to have a road that can be traversed through Armenia
by Azerbaijan. But it all has to be part of a negotiated treaty. My hope is that that will be
the case. But as Sheldon said, we ultimately need to make sure that those prisoners are released
and that there is a right to return peacefully by Armenian people to the corner of Karabakh.
For time's sake, this will be the last question.
Thank you very much. Mr. Trump is being pressed by his allies this time around to withdraw not
just from the Paris Agreement but from its parent treaty, the UN Framework Convention
on Climate Change. Some legal scholars think it could require as much as a two-thirds Senate
majority for the U.S. to rejoin under a future Democratic president. Others disagree. But I
just wonder, as two serving senators, what your views are, please. Thank you.
I haven't looked at what the rejoining requirement would be parliamentarily on the Senate floor.
Our immediate struggle is to try to convince the Trump administration of the folly of such ideas.
We'll just have to watch as that develops over the next two months of the Biden administration
and the early months of the Trump administration. I think a lot of this is going to come out
in the context of confirmation hearings in the Senate, and we're looking forward to
energetic engagement with his nominees. It's a rude awakening that the Trump
anti-environment nominees are going to receive. He's intending not on appointing a cabinet but
on appointing a cartel who will control American environmental and energy agencies.
It is going to create an uproar across our country. America did not vote to dismantle
the environmental protections in our country. They may have voted on certain other issues,
and that's what drove their vote, but no one was voting, with the exception of the oil, gas,
and coal industry, for the kinds of fundamental changes in environmental law which Donald Trump
is proposing and his cabinet members have committed to implementing. It is going to be
one of the most turbulent political debates that we've seen in a generation,
and it's going to give rise to young people once again at the university and high school level in
the United States coming out of the woodwork to begin to lobby the protection of all those
environmental protections. I think by the end of this debate, people will be wondering why we're
not making them stronger. That would be my own personal history in Congress, which is when
Ronald Reagan tried to do it, the firestorm was intense. When Newt Gingrich tried to do it,
the firestorm was intense. When Judge W. Bush tried to do it, the firestorm was intense.
What Donald Trump is doing is going to make all of those look tame compared to the uprising
from our country if he seeks to dismantle those environmental protections.
I think those are good words to end on. I'm sorry that the time has run out. I know many of you
didn't get to your questions. My apologies. Thank you all. Thank you all for being here.
