Weed Fertilizer Tea - Does It Really Work | NPK of weed tea

Organic Fertilizer Hub
59 followers
In this video we're going to talk about weed tea. Now I'm talking about tea made with dandelions
and quack grass, not marijuana. Sorry. So what is weed tea? Well, you go around your garden,
collect a bunch of weeds, put them in some water, let them ferment for a while,
and that stuff is weed tea. People online tell you it's full of nutrients, but is that really true?
And that's the question I'd like to ask in this video. So what I've done is I've made some weed
tea. I'm going to analyze it and see how many nutrients it really has, and then I'll try to
answer the question, is this something gardeners should do? Before I tell you how to make weed tea,
let's talk about the information that's floating around on the internet. So this weed tea is very
nutritious. In fact, some people say it has so many nutrients in it that you have to dilute it
before you apply it to your garden. How much do you dilute that? Well, everyone's got a different
formula. Some people dilute it 50-50 with water, others one part weed tea and nine parts water.
I've looked at over 10 videos on how to make weed tea. Not one ever analyzed the nutrients in it.
They all think it's great, but they have no idea what's in that weed tea. That's a real problem in
the gardening world. People say stuff and everybody else believes it. I mean, if this was really that
nutritious, why didn't someone actually measure the amount of nitrogen or phosphate in this tea?
Then you'd have a number and then they could say, geez, look at the nitrogen. It's a lot. We have to
dilute that before we fertilize our garden. Now, gardeners don't like to do that because that gives
them the real information, but we're going to try to do that in this video. All right, so how do you
make weed tea? Well, there are numerous formulas out there, but most of them will just use plain
garden weeds, put them in tap water, put it in a pail like this, and then let it sit for a period
of time. Every once in a while, you stir it. Now, you should cover this up so you don't get a lot of
rain going in here, and I had this one covered with a piece of wood, but people don't agree on
how long you have to ferment this. Some people do it for a few days, other people for a week.
Only rarely does someone suggest doing it for longer than a couple weeks. The way you know
it's done, according to the internet, is you stir it, and if it stinks, it's done, and I can tell you
this is done. This stuff reeks like you wouldn't believe. You know that plug toilet you have
that's been plugged for six months? Yeah, well, that's what this smells like. Now, in my case,
I left it longer. This has been brewing for a month. I want a really good strong tea to test.
Now, when it's finished, what do the weeds look like?
Well, see, this is the question I have. If I can still recognize all the stems and the leaves,
in fact, some of it is growing new leaves here, believe it or not, how can it be full of nutrients?
The plant has nutrients in it, and somehow they have to get out of the plant and into the water.
That normally happens during the composting process, but at the end of the composting process,
you don't recognize the material anymore. It's changed because, chemically, that plant material
has broken down, and all those large organic molecules in the plant have been converted to
nutrients, the nitrogen, phosphate, potassium, and other minerals, but that's a slow process,
and the one thing I know
is that if you can still recognize the plant, there hasn't been a lot of composting done.
Now, you might think, well, I didn't do it right. Here's a couple very short clips I've
taken from other videos that show you the same thing when their process is finished.
So, how many nutrients are in this weed tea? I'm going to test it using a soil kit I have,
and it's going to test for nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Those are the macro nutrients,
and those are the ones we care about most. Nitrogen, in fact, is the most important nutrient.
I'm also going to compare this to the fertilizer solution that I use for watering my houseplants,
because I know it has nutrients in it. We're also going to compare those two to my tap water.
That way, I know what nutrients went in here from my tap water. For those who understand the
scientific method, that tap water and the fertilizer water are our controls. They'll tell us
what is in the water to start with, and then we know how much the weeds have added, and by comparing
weeds to the fertilizer, we know that our test kit is working. All that's left is to sample the tea.
Mmm. Now, it stinks too much. I can't drink that. I'm going to take this, let the solid material
settle out, take off the clear water on top, and then we'll do some tests. For the test, I use the
Rapi-Test soil test kit. Now, you might be asking yourself, well, why would I use a soil test kit
when I'm actually testing water or fertilizer? If you think about it, the soil test kit is really
not a soil test kit. What you do is you take the soil, you dissolve it in some water, then you take
the water away and measure the water. So, you're measuring the amount of nutrients that have
dissolved in the water. You don't actually measure the soil directly. So, these kits are really water
test kits, and they should work just fine for testing a fertilizer solution. Now, I'm not going
to show you the whole detail of the testing. I've done that in my previous video when I did a product
review of the Rapi-Test soil test kit, and if you're interested in the details, have a look at
that video. When I reviewed the methods online, I found a variety of different dilutions, anything
from 50-50 up to 1 in 100, but the most common dilutions I found was one part weed tea to four
parts water, and so that's the dilution I used here. Here are the test results for nitrogen. Now,
there are three test containers there. The one on the left is for tap water, one in the middle is
the fertilizer I use for my indoor plants, and the one on the right is the weed tea. Now, just ignore
the caps. Okay, they are color-coded for different tests, but I'm not using them that way in this
test. What I did here is I put each liquid in a different container, and then I added the chemical
all at the same time, put the caps on, and shook them all at the same time, and let them sit for
an equal amount of time. That way, my comparisons are the same for each nutrient. The nitrogen test
produces a nice pink coloration. One of the nice things about this test kit is that there are two
chambers. The one on the left has the liquid in it, and no chemicals are added to it, so it's not
changed. If we look at the left chamber for tap water, it's nice and clear. That's what we'd expect.
The fertilizer has a slight tinge of green to it, and the weed tea has a kind of a brown coloration.
The chemicals are only put in the small chamber on the right side. Now, the nice thing about this
test kit is that you're able to look at the coloration in comparison to the natural liquid
without chemical additives. Now, if we look at the results, tap water has no nitrogen, the fertilizer
has a fair amount of nitrogen, and the weed tea, well, it's showing no nitrogen at all. And remember,
nitrogen is the nutrient that your plants need most. It's probably the nutrient that is deficient
in your soil. This is the phosphate test, and the phosphate gives you a nice blue coloration. You
can see here that the tap water shows a bit of phosphate, the fertilizer shows a lot of phosphate,
and the weed tea is somewhere in between these two. This slide shows the benefit of doing controls
whenever you do this kind of testing in the garden. You can see that my tap water has phosphate
in it. That's probably because the water comes from underground here. I'm on a well, and our soil here
has a high level of limestone in it. So that limestone is giving us phosphate, and all of the water
around here has some phosphate in it. So we now have to subtract that away from what you see on
the weed tea. Now if we look at the weed tea, it does show a fair amount of blue, but remember, that's a
combination of that dark coloration of the natural tea and the phosphate it's getting from tap water.
So the amount of actual phosphate in that tea is pretty low. Fertilizer, on the other hand, is quite
high, which is what we'd expect from a commercial fertilizer. And by the way, the fertilizer here is
Miracle-Gro, and it has an MPK ratio of 3-1-2. What about potassium? Well, the three tests show
no potassium in any of the samples. Potassium would show up as a nice orange color. Now in the tap
water, you do see some coloration there, but that amount of color ends up being zero on the
comparison chart. So even though there's a bit of color there, that's still zero potassium. Same with
the fertilizer and the weed tea. Now this test was kind of unexpected. I mean, I was certain that my
fertilizer had potassium in it. So I went back and looked at my old test results when I first
evaluated this soil test kit, and actually I had the same results there. For some reason,
the potassium test in this soil test just doesn't work. Even when the sample has potassium in it,
you still don't get proper coloration. In that previous test, I compared the RAPI test results
to a lab test, and I know the lab test was correct. My soil has a fairly high level of potassium,
and yet the RAPI test kit showed none. Again, this illustrates the value of controls. That middle one,
the fertilizer, we know it has potassium, and if it doesn't color up correctly, we know there's
something wrong with the test kit. If you want to know more about the value of controls and the
scientific method, have a look at my blog, and I have an article there called The Scientific Method
and Why Controls Are So Important. And the name of that blog is GardenMeths.com. So let's summarize
these results. Tap water and weed tea has almost no nitrogen in it. Fertilizer has a high value.
For phosphate, tap water and weed tea are very low. The potassium test failed, so we really don't know
how much potassium is in any of these samples. But there's no reason to think that either tap water
or weed tea would have a high amount of potassium when all of the other nutrients are low. Those
results are a little surprising. I mean, the internet tells you this stuff has a lot of nutrients,
and we didn't find very many. In fact, almost zero. Why is that? Well, there's a fundamental mistake
being made by gardeners. They know that plants contain nutrients, and that is true. They think
that when you put it in water and get some green liquid out of this, that all the nutrients are in
there. But that's the mistake they're making. Most of the nutrients in plants are tied up in large
molecules. Let's look at nitrogen, for instance. It's in protein, which are huge molecules. And until that
plant material is completely degraded, that nitrogen stays in there. In fact, even in finished compost,
that nitrogen comes out slowly for another five years. So although plants have nutrients in it,
it doesn't come out very fast, and it's certainly not going to come out after a two-week brewing
process. Now, what does the science say? I looked for studies on weed tea, and I only found one.
They looked at three different plants, including comfrey, which is supposed to be really nutritious.
And they found that all three plants gave about the same amount of nutrients. They did find a
reasonable amount of nutrients in their brew, but they did the brew a little different than
gardeners. So first of all, they brewed for a full month. The longer you brew, the more nutrients you'll
get into the water. The second thing they did was they took that plant material and they chopped it
up very fine. In effect, they made a mash of the stuff. You know from composting that the smaller
the pieces of plant material, the faster they compost. Well, the same is true for making weed tea.
You have to get that stuff very fine. A good suggestion for a home gardener would be to put
it in the blender. Taking whole weeds or even cutting them up with the scissors is not really
going to do very much. The third thing they did was they used a lot of weeds for a small amount of
water. You really want to create a kind of a pasty material. By increasing the amount of weeds and
decreasing the amount of water, you end up with more nutrients in that water. The nutrients they
found were fairly reasonable. I wouldn't call it a high nutrient material, but it did have nutrients
in it and therefore it would be useful for fertilizing plants. Would I make weed tea and
should you make weed tea? Let's have a look at the facts. First of all, it takes a month and a fair
amount of work to grind this stuff up. So, there's a fair amount of work involved. It also stinks terribly.
Now, that might not stop you, but quite honestly, I hate that smell. And why does it smell? Well, what
happens is a few of the nutrients go in the water and bacteria go into the water and they start
growing and they're anaerobic. They grow without oxygen because they're in the water. Anaerobic
bacteria tend to create smell. It's as simple as that. The smell really doesn't indicate a high level of
nutrients. It just means that there are bacteria living in there. And in fact, the bacteria are using
up the free nutrients as they grow and they're incorporating those nutrients into big molecules.
So, those bacteria are actually your enemy in releasing the nutrients. They're tying it up so
it's not available for plants. Now, the material would be good for small gardens, potted plants.
Maybe if you have one or two small raised beds, it might be worth doing. But if you're trying to
fertilize a normal garden like this, you'd have to make an awful lot of weed tea to get enough
nutrients in there to make a difference. I have a much better solution. When you're weeding the
garden, take these weeds and just throw them back into the garden. Within a day or two they dry up
and you won't see them. Then they'll slowly decompose and add the nutrients into the soil.
No work and just as many nutrients as in weed tea. This process is a little slower in releasing
those nutrients, but we're talking a month or two slower. Eventually they go into the soil and
quite honestly, no work at all. I won't be making weed tea anytime soon and most of the information
online is wrong. It is not a high nutrient fertilizer. If the person recommending weed tea
doesn't test it and show you the values, don't believe them. Now, if you want to learn more about
Garden Myths, have a look at my two books, Garden Myth Book 1 and Garden Myth Book 2 and I'll put a
link to those right here. I've also made other videos about Garden Myths and that link will be
in the top right hand corner. Happy Gardening!
