We Tested All the New Trail Bikes - Pinkbike’s 2025 Field Test

sports and sports
111 followers
Woo-hoo, right into the pole.
And we forgot to jump.
Oh my God. Oh my God.
Hello and welcome to the 2024 field test in Whistler.
We're here to test out the next batch of trail bikes.
Oh my God. Jesus.
Now, what a trail bike is, is perhaps one for the philosophers.
But for us, it's typically a bike with between 130 and 150mm travel
and something that's meant to be adept going both up and down.
Now, truth be told, we've skewed our test more towards the aggressive trail bikes
and all our bikes have between 140 and 150mm of rear wheel travel.
But let's go take a look at the bikes and see what this year's crop yields.
First in the firing line is the Specialized Stumpjumper
as it enters the midst of its teenage years.
This is the Stumpjumper 15, if you can believe it.
It's got headset cups and angle adjustment, tools from stock and that classic swap box.
This metal bike may be the heaviest on test, but it's also the cheapest.
Next, we have the new Sentinel.
The previous generation of bike had a hard-won reputation as a versatile 29er.
This bike looks to double down on that.
It's still got 150mm of rear wheel travel, but it's got a...
Is this a typo?
A steeper headtube angle. Wild.
Santa Cruz were an early adopter of the not-swap box
and the new Bronson comes with some of the more aggressive geometry on test and 150mm of travel.
Can you imagine a field test without a Canyon?
Well, if you can, you can... can... oh, God.
Well, you don't have to, basically.
The sprawling Spectral family has got a new member
with the 140mm travel platform getting a complete rejig.
This is a well-executed bike with some great features,
even if perhaps one of them isn't the spring steering alignment system called...
Rocky Mountain is a brand based in North Vancouver,
which is actually at the tip of the coast mountain range.
But hey, it sounds good.
The Instinct is the most adjustable bike on test,
with four different eyelet positions for the shock,
chainstay adjustment and different headset cups to adjust reach.
For a bike riding on Instinct, you can put a lot of thought into setup.
The DaVinci Troy is the other metal bike on our test.
It uses mixed wheels and shares the same keyframe components as its 29er ST cousin
and even this one could go full 29 with a flip chip located at the bottom of the shock,
should that take your fancy.
The linkage-driven single pivot uses a tidy rocker link to help fine-tune compliance
and, of course, has frame storage,
where you can keep your inspirational Polaroid of Steve Underhook for when things get spicy.
The Spot Mayhem might sound like a riot,
but that belies some of the more conservative geometry on test,
which Matt ended up having a special term for.
The bike uses a unique leaf spring that is not only alone in this group test,
but also rare in terms of the wider industry,
where brands all too often slap a fourbar on a bike and be done with it.
The Ibis Ripmo has seen a massive facelift and has us scratching our chins.
Do Ibis now make the best-looking trail and enduro bikes?
This frame storage-equipped full 29er can hop between wheel sizes
thanks to its flip chip in its DW link layout.
So, how did we test the bikes?
Well, the first thing we did is load up the truck
and come just down the road to Whistler in British Columbia.
Not only because it's got lift-access trails with a huge variety of terrain,
but because of some of the amazing trails you can get to by pedaling,
which makes it perfect for this style of bike.
Now, on the test, we have myself, Kaz, Dario, and Matt to put the bikes through their paces.
And this year's field test is supported by both Rapha and Schwalbe,
who also provide all the control tires to remove an important variable when comparing bikes.
Now, let's hop in the time machine and jump back two weeks to the start of the test
and compare and contrast some initial reactions.
So, it is day one of testing.
I'm so excited, I pretty much just slept in my kit.
Now, behind us, we have all the bikes.
And the first thing we need to do is divvy them out amongst the testers.
Now, we're all going to ride all of the bikes.
However, each tester will be responsible for two bikes
when it comes to putting together the article
and making sure their article reflects all of our feelings.
So, we've got some names, we've got a hat, and we're going to sort them out.
Then, we're going to go on our shakedown laps to get that first impression
as we ride the bike, not only to see, yeah, what we initially think about how the bike rides,
but also how easy it is to set up and get a handle on the performance it can offer.
Bronson.
Sentinel.
Mayhem.
I don't even know what the mayhem is.
Is this a spot?
Experts in our field.
The Instinct.
What have we got here?
Ripmo.
Spectral.
Whistler.
Premium.
Vacation rental.
Oh, no.
Troy.
That means I'm on the stump jumper, I guess.
The Extra Regular.
Very lilac.
It's got a genie.
What is that genie?
It's Magic Shark.
It gives you three wishes.
No, you just ask it.
It tells you.
You rub it in a circular motion, and then it tells you what to do.
But it only gives you what you want three times.
Perfect.
Right, well, I guess we set the bikes, give a good stab of what we want to do in terms
of setup, and then we just go give them a ride and see what's up.
So, Kaz, we're going out for our first run.
We've got these 140, 150 mil trail bikes.
What's the best type of trail to test these things on?
How do we make sure it represents the riding that the end consumer is going to be doing?
Yeah, ideally, we want something that's a good mix of terrain.
We are here in a bike park, but we're not just going to go send the biggest, craziest,
gnarliest things.
We're on-trail bikes and all-mountain bikes.
We're going to find trails that are kind of representative of that.
And right now, we're in the creek side zone, which is great for that type of bike.
These trails are a little bit closer to something that some people might be lucky enough to
have in their backyard.
So the track that we're going to do for this is do some South Park to Palmy Corners and
probably to BC's Trail.
So that's a good mix.
It's got some kind of Burmese bike park-y stuff and then a little bit more natural type
of thing.
So it should be good range.
In your experience, are there some bikes that are drastically easier to set up than others?
Yeah, I'd say so.
I wouldn't say it's necessarily brand-specific, but sometimes the suspension design or something
about it makes it have a bigger window of happiness.
Some suspension layouts are really sensitive.
So just a few psi change can actually make it feel quite different.
Where other bikes, it almost doesn't feel like it matters that much how much pressure
is in that shock.
So yeah, we'll kind of be going over that and seeing how easy it was for us to find
a good, happy place to ride these trails.
And yeah, some bikes will be probably pretty quick.
And other ones, I bet we'll have to tinker a bit too.
Do you think they're related though?
Do you think the longer the setup?
You mentioned window there.
The smaller the window, it doesn't mean it's necessarily a worse bike for that.
It could be a better bike in a sense.
It's just something to consider.
I don't think, I think once, I mean, for most people, even us, once you get it set up, you're
not really tinkering too much.
It's that initial bit.
So I think it's worth people knowing that they should be prepared to maybe experiment
a little bit with some of them.
Or if a bike is super easy, someone might want that.
Someone might just want that bike.
You just put some air in it, go ride, and it's good.
Or other ones, it just takes a little bit longer.
It's just almost a, yeah, like you said, it's not necessarily bad or good, but something
to address in an interview.
Mike, your bike's rattling.
I know.
It's so rattly.
What the hell is that?
I don't know.
I think it might be the cables or something.
Like it doesn't have thin pads.
Going super deep into the stroke.
Not sure what there is to say about that really.
I'm pretty happy with this.
Big wash on the old front.
Looks pretty good and composed.
Like pretty supportive.
The old Sentinel tune could sometimes be a little tricky.
This one feels kind of in a nice spot.
Yeah, I don't know if I want this bike to hold me up a little bit more maybe.
But it does seem to like, once you get your weight on the rear, it really accelerates
out of stuff.
Something feels uncomfortable in this fork, and I don't know what.
Yeah, definitely a bit of weird steering going on with this bike.
Pretty slack, very short out back.
Or at least it feels like it.
Okay, so that deep feeling is feeling less horrible when you've got some proper shunder
to get through.
Yeah, I said it's not like super nimble, but that might be not really the right word.
I don't know.
I've got to think of better adjectives for this bike.
It's just a little harder to scoop it up and off the ground.
Bike feels really good in those sorts of slower speed type things.
Tell you what though, bang for buck.
Immediately, this is pretty good.
So you can see there, I can't even get to the end stroke.
Unbelievably smooth.
Oh, oh yeah.
So we've just ridden a good mix of trail, first lap.
We're going to do some fun word association.
Just three words about the bike that come to you quickly.
So, without thinking about it too much, do we want to say them or do we want to write
them down?
Same, we'll review them later.
Kaz.
Three words.
Muted, composed, medium.
You said muted there.
Is that a feel, not noise?
Right, yeah.
It's pretty noisy.
There's audible.
I can make four words.
Noise, but ride feel is muted.
And then overall, composed, but it's not super peppy.
That's many words.
Easy, breezy, beautiful.
I'm chilling.
Yeah, easy, breezy, comfort girl.
A little tinny.
A little bit backseat.
But still strong.
Wants to push you forward.
Tinny, backseat, strong.
The periwinkle, I would say.
Soft.
Deep.
You know what, sometimes it's always kind of easy.
This is an easy bike.
Soft, deep, easy.
Hey, what meaning people want to project onto them is their own fucking business.
After the first laps on the Santa Cruz Da Vinci Transition and Specialized, the bikes
had a good base setting for their tester.
In every field test, we tried to get a mixed bag, and as it would happen, the quirkier
bikes were getting up in the second round.
Up next, we have the Canyon, Rocky, Ibis, and that spot.
Different bike on the Canyon Spectral.
Oh, you can hear the KISS rattling away.
Yeah, you can probably hear it.
If not, it goes like...
I think it's fixable.
We'll probably take that system out.
I've used KISS before and don't really need it.
Don't find it very helpful.
Oh my god, this is...
Oh my god.
I thought the Specialized was soft.
Jesus Christ.
Turns out adding a lot of compression to this fork makes it way better.
This bike feels very solid for being a 140 bike.
Sweet.
I just had a pretty scary deflect in that higher speed section.
I don't really know what is going on.
That is supple in the extreme.
The old man geometry almost caught me out.
It's just everywhere and nowhere at once.
But the bike does feel super nice and calm.
This bike feels very busy.
I will say it's more consistent than the Bronson,
at least right now in these bumps.
Henry, I can hear you grumbling.
You go so far into the ditch, into the stroke, so quickly,
the front comes off the ground.
What is that?
Yeah, it's on that rougher stuff we do feel the shorter travel.
But it's fine.
This would probably be the limit of what most people would want to take a bike like this on.
But the fact that it feels comfy is definitely a good testament to what it can do.
Wow, these brakes are not enough for this bike.
I think I'm going to increase air pressure in the fork.
Maybe add a spacer in the shock.
I'm pretty happy with this though.
Yeah, and then this kind of bermy, bumpy stuff.
That's really where the Spectral feels sweet.
That's a lap on it.
Yeah, very enjoyable first lap.
Excited to spend more time with it.
Kaz, tell me how lovely that canyon is in three words.
Bright.
Happy.
Fun.
Bright, bright?
Bright.
Bright, happy, fun.
Yeah.
I want to hear the instinct.
You only get three words.
Only get three words.
No, that's fine.
I think I would say unstable.
I would say light.
Okay.
And I would say, what would be the word?
Undermining.
Wow.
Undermining, yeah.
Gary, three words?
Comfortable.
Compromised.
Ready.
I'm curious.
We'll talk more about compromise.
Yeah, we'll talk more.
Compromise can be almost a good thing.
But compromised means it was something not as good.
So I'm interested.
You're not interested in pragmatic resolutions like me, Kaz.
I would say my three words.
Controlled.
But reactive.
And agile.
Cool.
Man, I can't wait.
You're happy that he likes it.
I am happy because, I mean, curtain reveal or whatever.
I spent a good amount of time on that bike before the field test.
Yeah.
And I really enjoyed it, but I wanted to not.
You did a first ride on that, right?
Yeah.
But it's good to see other people back there, is what I thought.
As you might have heard, the Canyon had one noisy cockpit culprit at the front of the bike.
Named after a Holley Valance pop classic, it sounded a bit too much like a crash symbol for our tastes.
And was incredibly distracting to ride with.
So much so, our very own Diva took matters into his own hands.
Got some ride time in on this.
And we're going to take the KISS system off of it.
KISS system's a little spring in here.
You can kind of see how it works.
Just helps, provides a little bit of resistance.
The idea is that it stabilizes your steering.
Unfortunately, it's rattling a little bit.
There's an actual spring.
We'll see when I take it out.
But it's kind of hitting the top.
So it's making like...
It's pretty annoying.
So I'm going to take that off.
I did some time with it in the loosest setting and in the middle setting.
And it'll get firmer.
And I'm just not a fan.
We've tested it before on other bikes from Canyon.
So I think the general consensus is we don't need it on this bike.
So we're going to take it off and make the bike quieter.
You can kind of see it's like spring loaded like that.
But once I pull it out, it'll make more sense of what's going on in there.
So I'll take that off.
And then we can fully remove the spring.
There we go.
So there's the KISS system.
It's really simple.
This just is clamped around the steer tube.
And this is underneath the top tube.
And so then when you turn, it's loading those springs and providing a little bit of resistance.
But like I said, unfortunately, what's happening is this was vibrating up and down
and I found the rougher stuff in the bike park that it was getting annoying.
But overall, it's not super heavy.
It's not really complicated.
There's moving parts, but not anything you'd really need to replace.
So I think the simplicity and the fact that it might help some people prevents me from riding it off completely.
But I just don't really think it's necessary, at least for the group of testers we have here
and what we're planning on riding and how we like to ride.
So no more KISS.
Good morning from day two of the Pinkbike field test.
Yesterday's beautiful warm weather has given way to something a little more dreary.
But we persist.
This morning, Matt and Henry are going to go out
and give a little preview of our in-bike park testing loop or testing track.
And then Mike and I are going to do some riding.
This afternoon, Mike and I are going to show you our pedal loop
and we'll do some swapping of bikes.
So we're going to get out and get wet.
That's a pretty interesting bit of trail.
As you really prove your worth as the renowned bike handler that you are.
When we're dealing with trails like this, I mean, there's so many corners
and I think it's easy to paint it as a really simplistic thing.
But actually, there's so much weight going front and back on the bike, right?
Oh, yeah. Yeah.
I mean, you're going up and down through the turn, you're changing,
coming in steep and then rising out of the end.
You want to stay centered.
You want the bike not to sort of like trip and fall forward,
but not to slip from out underneath you, you know?
And also when you get bikes that feel really high on the front,
maybe they don't have enough weight on the front.
They feel as you're transitioning and your weight's sort of trying to settle again
through that y-axis as you go from left to right or right to left.
When you're unsure and it almost feels like the front's unweighted
and not kind of elastic and reassuringly grippy either side.
It's good to have that high front end because you start,
you're nice and confident as you go down steep into the turn.
But then when you hit the bowl and everything compresses,
you sort of feel like you're going real back seat
and then it's almost like you're wheelie and the weight comes off the front wheel
and that's where you're most likely to wash out.
Yeah. So it's a really interesting thing like…
We're here.
Yeah. Yeah.
With terms like how bike geometry and stuff like, yeah, you know,
front end height, wheelbase length, chainstay length, reach,
can get that balance.
But also I suppose you want suspension that is supportive
and is handling that mass and, you know, the clues are in the name,
suspending our mass as it wants to go forward and back.
When we look at a turn like, you know, especially coming through this exit,
we talk about what the front wants to feel like, you know,
positive, grippy, consistent.
What do you want the back to feel like? Do you want the same attributes?
Yeah. I think you want it to be balanced,
just like the length of the bike front to rear.
You don't want anything to change drastically.
And as we ride all these different bikes,
you can definitely tell really quickly riding the consecutive lap
what each bike does differently.
And there are definitely some that, you know,
it's way more pronounced through those turns.
Now we're going to cruise on.
We're going to the next part of the trail,
which actually is still quite bike parky, but it's a lot faster.
And what we want to find out here is how the bike feels
when we're really pushing it hard.
Is it poppy and playful?
Is it squatting down in our travel and kind of driving our weight,
like you were saying,
kind of into the back of the bike as we hit,
take repeated hits over braking bumps.
And yeah, we're going to cruise to that and smash the bike some more.
Henry, why are you so obsessed with turns like this?
You're dropping everything on it.
Right. Okay.
So my theory is when testing bikes,
sometimes when you ride something natural and gnarly,
you'll come down a chute and you will hit a turn harder
than you ever had in your life.
Just so much side load going to the bike.
And it's really hard to replicate that situation without,
like, you know,
going to ride some trails that are maybe hard to kind of get to
ride time and time again.
So for me, when I think about this whole situation,
I want something that's going to put a huge amount of lateral load
through the bike because then you can feel how the bottom bracket
swings around, whether it feels like a, you know,
a noodle underneath you, whether it feels quite firm.
Do you see what I mean with that?
Or do you think it's kind of nonsense?
Yeah.
So this is kind of like when you see somebody skiing down a flat
piece and they're just carving for no reason.
Yeah.
You're just getting a feel for what the bike's doing.
You want to know the limit.
I want to know the limit.
And you would be surprised like something as simple as this,
especially when there's a lot of grip frame to frame,
they feel massively different wheels to wheel.
They feel different.
However,
the thing we've got planned next is something that's probably the kind of
definitely the kind of trail you do ride on it,
but it's very different to this old school techie flavor,
old school techie flavor,
and just go buckle some wheels and hold on for dear life.
Okay.
So I've got an observation about the bike set up currently,
but before we get to that,
what we're riding earlier on is in some ways representative of a lot
of the trails we have back in the UK.
A lot of places like the bike park places that are built,
there's a lot of that style of trail machine made.
Yeah.
This style of trail is very,
it's a bit rarer perhaps,
but it's still really good.
And it's a lot of stuff that people tend to ride in this sort of bike.
Um,
can you,
is it,
does it contrast in terms of the set of demands?
Is it the opposite?
Can you get,
can you get both?
I think you can get both.
There's definitely going to be a compromise either in the control through
those high speed corners where you're either going to have more firm
suspension to hold you up,
or in this case where it's slower,
a lot rootier,
you want that comfort and sort of light feeling with the suspension.
So you might go a little softer.
Um,
so those are kind of the main components of our test track.
I think we should carry on riding and then we're going to end up lapping
for the rest of the day before the camera crew are going to go join the
Bellingham boys,
Dario and Kaz on their pedal loop.
So we'll roll down and we'll,
we'll see what's going on.
Cool.
There they are.
The filmer's hard at work as always.
Oh yeah.
Really crushing it.
All the footage.
Yeah.
Bangers.
Well,
hello.
We are at the base of our pedaling test loop here on the West side of the
Valley.
This is a pretty quick little,
maybe 10,
20 minute loop.
We can pedal up,
gets through some technical trickier climbing,
doing some natural traversing terrain into some more slow speed,
difficult kind of funky descending with some bigger moves as options to the
side.
It's a good way to mix it up from the bike park stuff,
but slower speed over here.
Bike park is,
you know,
fast and flowy,
more berms and jumps and things.
And this slows everything down a bunch,
a lot more janky stuff really kind of see how the bike slow speed handling
goes.
Yeah.
And the beauty of it being a pretty tight loop is we can check settings and
kind of repeat,
repeat,
repeat as we hone in on how the bikes are performing.
So we're going to get off and jump into our first lap here.
Yeah.
Let's go for it.
All right.
We are here on what I would say is a pretty prototypical climbing trail.
It's not too steep,
but there's some techie stuff involved to kind of keep you awake.
You've got to be able to,
I don't know,
control the bike through some tighter corners,
as well as put down power on some smoother terrain.
Yeah.
Realistically kind of the type of trail that you spend a lot of your time on,
you know,
it's where you want the bike to feel nice and efficient.
You don't want to be bobbing up and down,
wallowing,
doing anything strange.
This is kind of when you,
you sort of zone out.
So if the bike does what's supposed to,
you don't have to think about it.
And so that's where we're checking out right now.
Yeah.
We're going to cruise on up and then show you guys the next section.
We're at the top of our climb section.
It's finished.
Climbing is done.
We just finished the most technical portion of it.
It gets kind of off camber,
very slow speed,
pretty technical.
Yeah.
I think what shakes out in this more technical climbing stuff is like,
what kind of traction the bike has,
how the geometry handles weird undulating terrain.
On this descent,
it's kind of a classic Whistler West side trail,
where it just has a mix of chunky rocks.
And all of a sudden you'll encounter almost a punchy climb and it goes steep again.
So slow speed handling is really what we're going to focus on here.
Just kind of see how that bike,
how much work it is to get around some of these tighter sections and then stability as well.
There are some parts we can open up a little bit and kind of see how that bike,
how it feels in that transitioning from going slow to fast.
It's kind of overall comfort on the bike.
If you're going to look at the definition of like what a trail bike or all mountain bike could handle,
this loop encompasses a whole bunch of that.
Now we get to go ride it.
All right, we're getting near,
well, kind of near the end of our test track.
This section is where we can really focus on how the bikes handle at a variety of speeds.
Kind of how easy it is to pick up and place the bike.
There's some good line choice,
kind of features you might want to,
you know,
get a little air,
double up,
land somewhere different.
So this is where we can kind of really see what different bikes feel like.
Yeah.
The stability of like the chassis and suspension starts to play a role here too.
You know,
we're picking up speed,
but then suddenly having to like slam on the brakes,
hop over something.
It's a good way to intuit like how well a bike can change direction as well.
So I think,
again,
just what's nice about this loop is everything kind of fills in to all these short little sections.
Yeah.
This is kind of like the generalist area of the test track,
which is general bike handling.
So let's keep going.
We're going to generally handle our bikes.
Generally handle them.
All right.
There you have it.
Those are our two test tracks that we're running all the bikes through,
getting acquainted,
and then obviously taking them elsewhere to do further testing.
Yeah.
So now we've got the tracks dialed,
bikes are set up,
ready to roll.
We'll let these filmers get back to their napping.
We're going to go get a bunch of miles in.
