Agatha All Along: One of Marvel TV's Best - Spoiler Review

Latest Movie Reviews
5 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 13, 2024
This video is brought to you by Miracle Made. Go to trymiracle.com
slash dan for a special offer and stay tuned after the video for more info.
Hello everybody and welcome to my review of the first season of Agatha All Along
and I've got a lot to say about this show so I'm going to just put the blanket warning up
here right now. If you haven't seen the show yet I'm going to jump right into spoilers
and there are a lot of twists and turns with this show so if you're on the fence about whether you
want to know or don't want to know what happened in the season I would say watch the show,
come back and watch this review but if you've already seen the show or you don't care about
knowing what happened then go ahead proceed with caution. So let's jump into my thoughts on the
season overall and before the show premiered I felt about Agatha All Along very similarly to
the way that I felt about Rogue One. Before it came out this idea of like okay I mean that's
kind of cool but like did anybody really want this show and who's who exactly is it for but
this was just another reminder for me that it's all about the execution and not necessarily
about the concept and that's why I may have thoughts about a show going in but I try not to
pre-judge it before I watch it because I actually thought that Agatha All Along was one of the best
MCU tv shows that we've gotten so far and when we look at the different tiers of shows I would say
at the top in that top tier we've got WandaVision, Loki especially the first season and then I would
put Agatha All Along in that top tier ahead of a second tier where I would put shows like Hawkeye
and Moon Knight and Miss Marvel and then there's a pretty wide gulf between those tiers and most of
the rest of the MCU as far as Disney Plus streaming shows go and I think you could make an argument
and I'm going to lay out some of my thinking in this video that Agatha All Along is maybe the
most consistent least uneven show that we've seen from Marvel and Disney Plus so far. After the
first two episodes in my review here on the channel I said that I was excited to see what
the show had in store but I honestly didn't expect to like it as much as I did and I really
think a lot of that credit goes to Jack Schafer who came back from doing WandaVision to do Agatha
All Along and a real key if you look at both shows I think to why they work so well is that they're
good at being tv shows which not every MCU show or really every Disney Plus show is. Jack Schafer
understands how to map out and write a tv show that feels like a tv series. It can tell an
overarching story but each episode feels distinct and if I were in charge of Marvel, which I very
much am not, I would try to hire Jack Schafer to be like the tv czar to be a consultant on these
other shows because she shows a real understanding of how to execute a story in this format. Every
episode of Agatha All Along felt like an episode of television, not 20 minutes of a movie chopped
up. They all felt distinct from each other. This wasn't just one of the best MCU tv shows so far
quality wise, it was also one of the best so far form wise and I think that it really only
underscores just how wrong they've gotten it on a lot of their other series. It also had
something missing from a lot of MCU projects overall which is stakes. Every time a member
of the coven died, I kept expecting the classic marvel resurrection but it didn't happen and when
I realized that dead characters would stay dead, I got way more invested in their stories. I guess
you could argue that they did cheat when it comes to Agatha but I also think her return as a ghost
represents a fundamental change in her character and her relationship with Billy so even that death
has consequences. A big reason why the show worked goes to the cast and obviously at the forefront
of that is Catherine Han and what I think was great about the show is that you know Agatha was
fun in WandaVision but this did what a spinoff show should do which is to deepen and develop
that character into her own person not just a supporting character in somebody else's story.
By the end of the show we understand why Agatha is so evil, we sympathize with her but they also
don't completely defang that character. She's somebody that we don't mind rooting for going
forward but they don't undo a lot of what we've already seen. I really do hope that Catherine Han
gets some award consideration for this show because she has to play so many different levels
of Agatha. She has the sort of pretend Agatha who's caught in the spell at the very beginning
of the show, then we get the sort of wickedly funny Agatha towards the end of the season,
we get a much more rounded sad grieving Agatha as we understand more about her past and everything
that happened and also and I think this is an underrated part of her performance,
Catherine Han had to play so much of the season on two different levels because once you understand
what's going on you have to be able to rewind back to the first couple of episodes and have
it make sense. The witch's road doesn't exist. You're lying. Am I? And I went back and watched
some of that she really is playing the scenes in a way that makes sense the first time but
really makes sense the second time and that's a very specific energy that you have to have.
Power doesn't interest me. Keep telling yourself that. The rest of the coven was also really well
cast. Debra Jo Rupp is an actress that is just delightful on screen. So who's going high? Oh no
thank you. I don't take drugs. And my only issue is that she wasn't in the show more. I mean on a
story level it makes sense that the only person who isn't really a witch would die first but I
expected the show to do what probably most other shows would have done which is to reveal that she
was really the super witch all along and then she untaps this hidden power etc. No she's just
kind of this poor soul that got taken along for the ride by Agatha which again underscores the
fact that Agatha doesn't really care about anybody else but also sets things up like the dark running
joke that Agatha cared so little about her that she couldn't even remember her name. Sharon's dead.
Who's Sharon? One of the advantages of doing an episodic tv show right is that if you can focus
on a character for one episode that even if we don't get a whole lot of time with that character
we feel like we understand who they are and I think the best example of that in this season
is Alice who is played by Ali Ann because she got the spotlight in the episode where they're all
forming the band. I felt like I got to know her and why she was along for the ride what she wanted
and I think it's somewhat tragic that I don't think she ever could have gotten what she was
looking for but when you're killing characters like this show does it can feel sometimes like
some of them were meaningless or some of them were placeholders but the structure of the show
and the fact that each little trial gives you a focus on an individual witch made me feel like
okay well you know she's gone a little bit early but I understand her and and I feel like she had
a reason and a purpose for being in the show and that comes down to smart writing. Also tying her
story into the Ballad of the Witches Road I think kept part of Alice alive for the rest of the
series and one side note I know in that episode that the song was sort of a 70s style ballad
but watching a coven of witches fight off a demon inside of a studio consumed by fire
is one of the most metal things I've ever seen. One of my favorite characters was Lilia who was
played by Patti LuPone and again this is somebody who you think you sort of know in the first part
of the season she's just this kooky witch she's losing it a little bit and then when she gets her
spotlight episode you understand what's really going on with her you recontextualize the whole
series and I liked this idea that she's jumping through time she's living her life out of order
so she's able to sort of give meaning from later in her life to moments that come earlier in her
life and we can go back and rewind and watch it and that's actually kind of one of the brilliant
things about the series not just from a creative level but from a marvel financial minutes viewed
level is when you have a show that rewards a second viewing that's just more watch time for
people to go back and watch the series again which in a industry that's ruled by watch time is a nice
little thing for your show to have. Patti LuPone was perfect for the role of Lilia and the casting
in general I think really seemed focused on finding the right actors for these roles instead of casting
the flashiest names and before the broadway people come after me let me just say Patti
LuPone is an acting legend but not necessarily in the circles that the MCU is typically marketing
toward. Honestly I think removing the burden of the 200 million dollar budget on this show
gave the casting directors a little more leeway to go out there and find who they thought would
play the role best and not necessarily the person who is focus grouped and market tested because
they've got to get the ROI back because the Q1 that's the problem with those 200 million dollar
budgets you maybe can't be as risky or even do the things you want to do as much whereas Agatha
all along had more of that freedom. So she's a modest somebody that I was familiar with from
her years on SNL but she really surprised me with the depth of her dramatic acting as Jen
who's kind of the only one who walks away from this whole thing unscathed she's restored to power
she's off to live her best life I'm sort of split on her character because I kind of hope we don't
see her again that she gets that happy ending and just flies off into the sunset but I wouldn't
mind more of Sasheer Zamata in the MCU if they decide to bring her character into whatever the
future iteration of the show is going to be if any but overall I think the character on the page
combined with Zamata's performance was a perfect mix of comedy and drama. You said this might
happen but you're being extra wispy. Wispy? Kooky. Of course I've got to mention Aubrey Plaza who
is one of my favorite actors to watch and I wish that we had more of her in the show but she's very
in demand and I'm sure they only had a small window that they could shoot with her and I
think that's why Rio slash Death is so in and out with the adventures but that kind of suits the
character. She made the most of her screen time though and I love that she got to go full cackling
witch at the end of the series. Now I'm sure a lot of hardcore fans probably want to focus on
some sort of Thanos connection since the comic book version of Death was such a key player
in the Infinity Gauntlet story but I liked how they built her story in connection with this show
with Agatha because that's really what's important to the execution of this show and I'd be surprised
honestly if they decide to use her in the broader MCU and their relationship is smartly written
because again you think for most of the season that Agatha made some sort of malicious deal with
Death that she traded her son for the dark hole and that's what all the other witches think.
Did you know she traded her own child for the book of the damned? Then you find out
that there was no deal that Agatha's just pissed off with Death because Death took her son away
from her even though Death had given her extra time and that's sort of a recurring theme on
the show is you think that there's all these complex things going on and rules and mythology
but it's actually a lot more simple than that and a lot more human instead of the convoluted
contrived stuff that a lot of the other shows get into it's really kind of the simplest explanation.
Generally every time I thought the show was going to do something that fell more into comic book
movie tv show convention it actually took a turn and did something that was surprising and more
meaningful and the Rio Agatha relationship was one of those things. I'm not really focused on
her role in the overall MCU and I think that that's a credit to this show there's so many
shows that Marvel's made that seem solely focused on setting up whatever's next and this show was
focused on establishing the relationship between these characters and telling this story that
seems like tv 101 but it's actually more and more rare these days. I loved someone and I had to do
something that I did not want to do even though it was my job. Finally we have Joe Locke as Teen
who was later revealed to be Billy Maximoff. I said in my first review that he was the co-lead
in Heartbreaker it is Heartstopper trust me I heard about that one. I liked the solve on his
character as far as how Billy got into the real world and I think it was another example of the
show anticipating fan questions and coming up with a satisfying resolution because it makes sense.
The idea that Billy was a consciousness that was in Wanda's hex and was able to escape that and
inhabit the body of somebody of a dying teenager who then becomes Billy it again doesn't stretch
credulity and listen you don't have to give me a necessarily realistic scenario if you just give
me something that's thought out then I'm okay with it and it felt like writers actually spent
some time thinking about this instead of doing again what you see on some of the other shows
which is going like I don't know whatever something happened. I actually like that we see Wanda's
strengths and weaknesses in Billy and he feels like somebody who's gone through all of these
things in his life and is really trying to find his own way forward without falling into the same
pitfalls that took both of his parents away and isn't that really kind of what most people are
trying to do to learn from what's happened before and then to chart your own path and maybe do it
just a little bit better. I was actually glad in retrospect that I don't frequent the forums and
social media and subreddits that are always speculating about what's going to happen in the
show or leaking what's going to happen in the show because when I went back and looked a lot of them
were saying from early on oh yeah that's going to be Billy he's Wiccan and this is you know what he's
going to come in and this is the role he's going to play and I think that takes a lot of fun out
of the show it's why I don't intentionally seek out that sort of information and I thought that
the reveal of that was done really well with the appearance of the crown on Billy's head and then
the smash cut to the credits of Billy Eilish's You Should See Me in a Crown and generally I thought
that the music department on the show apart from the original music that was composed for the show
did a really good job of finding great songs for that cut to credits that fit with the show that
kind of left you excited for the next episode and I think it's another example of how different
departments inside of the production of a show can all come together to try to make the best whole.
The next big reveal is that The Witch's Road isn't real and that it was a construct that Billy
unintentionally made. I liked the usual suspects like way that this was revealed and it makes
perfect sense given who his mother is and really again recontextualizes every interaction Agatha
has with him through the whole show because she knew from the very beginning and the show showed
once again that they have people in the writers room that are actually anticipating what the fans
at home may be thinking because after that big reveal I'm like well wait people died on the road
and then Billy immediately starts feeling guilt. My mind killed them. Don't give yourself too much
credit. And the show takes a minute to let him address those feelings it becomes sort of a part
of his journey but at the same time with the counter reveal regarding Agatha it diffuses that
issue because we also find out that The Witch's Road was something that Agatha herself invented
that it was never real and that it was basically a con so that she could lure covens together to
build The Witch's Road or summon The Witch's Road and when they couldn't do it she would
provoke them into attacking her to steal their power and kill all of them. Those two story elements
worked so well together because Agatha could then sort of diffuse Billy's guilt by saying well
don't feel too bad because if you hadn't built the road I would have killed everybody so technically
you saved lives. I thought that was a good way to write yourself out of that situation and then on
top of it all we learn in the flashback episode that the ballad of The Witch's Road was a song
that Agatha wrote with her son and so now you add into that mix that this song is used to help summon
the road it's really a song that Agatha has now poured all of her grief and anger and rage into it
was something that at one time was a very special thing to her because of her love for her son now
it's a very sad and tragic and angry thing for her and it's just layering and layering and layering
and it makes the story feel complete it makes the show feel thought out and it makes it all
satisfying or at least it did for me. Lilia actually nailed in the moment what Agatha's
true intentions were back in the second episode of the series. This is a power grab she wants us
to attack her. What? You brought us here hoping our proximity coupled with your cruelty would get you
a spark you could steal. And what I like about the twist here is that it does change the game
but it doesn't diffuse the evilness in Agatha it underscores it and I like that the show didn't
feel the need to take her and turn her into an all-around good guy because that's another thing
that I was expecting. Let's take this evil character from the MCU and then over the course
of the show she's going to discover that she's got a heart of gold and that she was really
misunderstood and that she was good all along and so now she's going to be somebody we love
and then let's just forget about all the terrible stuff. The show's not interested in that. It
contextualizes everything and you understand how she got to where she is but it's not interested
in making us forgive Agatha it just gives us an Agatha at the end of the series that's entered
a new phase of her life and I love the idea when Billy was trying to banish her to the afterlife
that she's saying no I'm not ready to go because I can't face my son because she understands all
of the things that she's done since he died and that gives Agatha herself a road to keep walking
as a character. So many times the show or the movie that we're watching says okay well from
the beginning to the end we've got to come all the way around on this character and again that's not
what this show wants to do. It's so much more well thought out and constructed than 90% I think of
what we've seen not just from MCU shows on Disney but from Disney shows across all of their different
properties and I think that sort of meticulous planning of the series even shows in how they
structured these episodes because I think most shows would have given you the Agatha flashback
a lot earlier mainly because they might have been trying to do that 180 degree character switch
but Agatha all along saves it until last because that's when the story requires the audience to
know that information. Instead of doing a rushed one season Agatha redemption arc this was a season
that lets us get to know this character and what's happened in her life and from this point on we can
then perhaps understand or accept as an audience that she's going to try to redeem herself because
we fully understand her. They're not trying to go from A to B all at once they're just jumping
around to different points in the trail and it's just another example of that old Roger Ebert quote
about it's not what it's about it's how it's about it. You can do a redemption arc but you've got to
do it right and I think that this show is attempting to do it right. Really I think this season had
everything you'd want from a good season of MCU TV. It had humor, it had drama, it had an intriguing
plot full of red herrings and reveals that actually make sense. There's character growth, we had a
through Billy and there's even a little bit of broader world building and some teases that we
may see Wanda again sometime in the future. Is Wanda Maximoff really dead? Yes. No. Maybe. And
really it all comes back to what I've said so many times about the key to making a good movie or
making a good TV show which is that it's about story story story because when you look at what
Disney has done across all of their TV franchises they've brought back popular characters like
Boba Fett, they've revised franchises like Willow, they've brought in big-name characters
like She-Hulk, they've tried to adapt big storylines like Secret Invasion and yet I think
that Agatha all along is a demonstrably better show than all of those. This is a TV show that's
about a supporting character that most people hadn't heard of before WandaVision outside of
the comic book circles. It stars the cast who are popular in their own pockets of the entertainment
industry but aren't the A-list marquee stars that have been recruited for other shows and this was
a show that was also brought in at a budget of reportedly less than 40 million dollars and I
think has done more goodwill for the MCU than two or three of their other shows probably put
together. There's an old William Goldman quote about Hollywood that's making the rounds for
decades that says nobody knows anything and to an extent that's true because nobody does really know
what's going to be a hit and what's going to be a flop but I would amend that a little bit to say
that while you don't know what the reception is going to be I think generally if you hire good
writers, if you hire good actors, if you hire people to run your TV shows who actually care
about the story and the show itself and aren't just recruited because they're a hot name or a
buzzy name or they wrote something else that's popular and you want to just grab them as soon
as possible, if you hire all of those people, people that understand why you're telling this
story other than just supporting a billion dollar machine behind it, then I think that generally
you're going to make a pretty good show and hopefully the quality of that show will entice
people to watch. It really does seem simple which is why I feel like banging my head against the
wall when I've reviewed so many of these shows over the years because it's been proven time and
time again how you make a great show and so many of the studios just seem to want those rules and
just say like no we're going to try it this way, a way that largely hasn't worked and the optimist
in me is hoping that maybe this is a turn the corner moment for Marvel where they realize okay
you know what we need to refocus, go back to basics. Remember the Marvel Cinematic Universe
was largely built on maybe less known or less popular characters at least in part that were
made popular by creators and directors and writers who loved those characters and through their
passion made the audience love them and that's what I think Agatha all along does here because
I'm now invested in this character and invested in Billy and the other people in the show that I
never even heard of because the show and the story were so well written, way more than I'm invested
in Modok or Kang or even some of the A-list quote-unquote Avengers. I'd like to think this
maybe signals the end of the era where Marvel would just throw 200 million dollars in a marquee
character or an own storyline and assume that people would like it even if nobody really has
an idea about what to do with that character or that storyline. That would be nice but the realist
in me is worried that that could be a witch's road to nowhere as far as my hopes and dreams
for the future. Still you can always hope and I think that Agatha all along is a step in the
right direction, I just hope it's not two steps forward three steps back when it comes to the MCU.
I'm just going to be thankful for the season and the story that we got and I have to give praise
to the cast, the writers and especially Jack Schafer who reportedly kept including Agatha
in so many of her pitches that Kevin Feige just told her to go make an Agatha show. Let's see more
of that, let's see more passion, let's see more creators that are brought in to make stories about
characters that they love and trust in the part of Kevin Feige and the MCU that they can translate
that love to a broader audience. So when we talk about Agatha all along in general I was a doubter
going in but I really liked this show and I'm going to give it a see it now rating because I
really do think that this is one of the best MCU tv shows and honestly I think this is what an MCU tv
show should be. It should be this thought out, it should have this kind of love for its characters
and I am hoping that when people come in in the future to make MCU tv shows that people point to
this one as a template for what you should be doing because we've had a whole lot of other ones
that you can point to as examples of what you shouldn't do. So those are my thoughts on Agatha
all along, what do you think? Did you like it as much as I did? Let me know down in the comments
below and before we go I'm going to thank the sponsor for this video, Miracle Maid. It's the
scariest week of the year so I'm going to tell you something absolutely terrifying. Did you know
that traditional bed sheets can harbor more bacteria than a toilet seat? I sure didn't and
I don't really like the idea of sleeping on a toilet seat. I mean I haven't done that since at
least college and that one time in 2009 that someone brought me an original formula 4 loco
for my birthday. True story. But you don't have to worry about having a toilet bed with Miracle
Maid. Their sheets are infused with silver that prevent up to 99.7% of bacterial growth which
means they're not just cleaner, they stay fresh three times longer than other sheets and you're
going to want to keep these sheets on your bed because they're also incredibly soft and comfortable
and their silver infused fabric is also temperature regulating to keep you at the
perfect temperature all night long no matter what the weather is. So to me the choice is clear, a
sleepless night trying to unlearn what I just told you or night after night of great sleep under your
new Miracle Maid sheets. Go to trymiracle.com slash dan to try Miracle Maid sheets today and
whether you're buying them for yourself or as a gift for a loved one, if you order today you can
save over 40% and if you use the promo code dan at checkout you'll get three free towels and save
an extra 20%. Miracle is so confident in their product it's backed with a 30-day money-back
guarantee so if you aren't 100% satisfied you'll get a free refund. Upgrade your sleep with Miracle
Maid. Go to trymiracle.com slash dan and use the code dan to claim your free three-piece towel set
and save over 40% off. Again that's trymiracle.com slash dan to treat yourself. Thanks to Miracle
Maid for sponsoring this episode. Thanks to Miracle Maid for sponsoring the video and thank you for
watching. Be sure to stay tuned right here for more movie news, reviews, box office and more.
Until next time stay safe and I'll see you then.
