Heretic (2024) - Movie Review | Fantastic Fest

Latest Movie Reviews
5 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 12, 2024
What is up, guys?
Well, I am still here in Austin, Texas, attending Fantastic Fest.
Last night, we got our third of five secret screenings.
And surprise, surprise, it was Heretic.
So this is one of our most popular guesses, and I'm going to reveal it now.
Don't look at the screen. Just look at me.
We have Heretic.
And this was a film that was certainly on my radar.
I was interested in it.
I thought that the trailer was great.
It was a neat concept.
But certainly wasn't at the top of my list for surprise screenings.
I was thinking like maybe The Wolfman or Nosferatu, something in that monster
universe. And so oddly enough, I was just ever so slightly
a little bummed whenever it was revealed to be Heretic.
But the second the credits rolled in this movie, I was like,
I am so glad that that is what we saw, because not only is this easily
the best film that I've seen at this festival so far,
it is instantly in my top five, maybe even my top three films
of 2024 thus far.
Basic premise of this film is that you have these two Mormon missionaries
that go to this man's house who has requested more information on their religion.
He lets them inside, starts to disarm them with conversation,
and then very slowly they realize that they are locked in this house
and he is going to play this game of wills with them, where essentially
he's just challenging them on their religion.
He's challenging them on the origins of religion, of theology,
and puts all of these questions in their head to try to get them to second
guess their faith.
And basically every move that they make to progress through this mind game
that he has is based off of whether they continue to believe
or they are starting to disbelieve.
And I will say, if you haven't seen the trailer yet,
this is one of those trailers that does a fantastic job at not showing
the entire film.
Most of what it shows is in the first act of the film,
and you just get little shots of things for the rest of the movie.
So if this is the first time you're hearing about Heretic
and you want to go watch the trailer,
this is one of those times where it is safe to do so.
Starting off with the positives, the thing that I adore most about this movie
is that it is quite literally one of the best religious horror scripts
that I have ever seen.
This is a movie that is written so tight and also so smartly
with the way that it attacks its subject matter, that it's constantly
putting the audience as well as the characters in this situation
where it's getting you to question things.
It's getting you to question faith,
whether you're religious or not.
It's bringing these really interesting conversations to light,
but it never slips into sacrilege.
Now, I'm not somebody who's overly religious myself,
but I have a lot of family, a lot of friends,
a lot of peers in this space that are very devout, very religious people.
And so I'm always very sensitive to trying to discern movies like this,
whether they're going to be offensive or they're going to be uncomfortable
for people that do have a faith in a religion.
And I honestly think that this was brilliantly
made to not step on any of those toes.
You have the one character here, the antagonist,
who is certainly attacking religion from a point of conversation,
from a point of questions.
But the movie is also very much based on the power of faith,
the power in your belief, and how you personally see things.
And all the way to the credits, it leaves that open where you as the viewer
can decide for yourself, much like the characters in this movie,
whether the case made here has compelled you to maybe question your faith or
whether it has just strengthened your faith by the end of it.
And the way that it utilizes dialogue is one of the most unique aspects of this
film, because this certainly does have some scares.
It does have some things in the second act and
the third act that make it definitively a horror film.
But the vast majority of the horror in Heretic is derived through conversation.
It's derived through the dialogue.
It's derived through this back and forth between Hugh Grant and these two girls,
and him raising questions, him using these pop culture references as
kind of these analogies for religion, which is also very funny that I'll get into.
But the way that they get you uncomfortable on edge and
at the edge of your seat just through hearing the dialogue and
hearing the charming way that Hugh Grant brings about these very,
very large ideas and these very terrifying concepts.
That's the brilliance of this movie.
And that's something that's so refreshing.
For most of us that watch horror all year long,
that's one of our most common complaints is like,
can we get a movie that's not just jump scares?
Can we get a movie that's not just startling us with these needle drops of
the score?
Can we get a movie that actually starts to scare us by its concepts,
by its ideas?
And this is one of those movies.
Gotta give it up to Hugh Grant.
He was the thing that popped the most about this trailer.
And I have not seen any previous work that he has done in the horror genre.
I know he's done at least one or two of them before, but
this is definitively my favorite horror performance of 2024 thus far.
The way that Hugh Grant is so effortlessly charming and disarming and
charismatic while being so evil and sinister and with a smile on his face.
There's very few scenes in this movie where he has
an antagonistic look about him or a sinister look.
Damn near everything that he is doing, he's doing with this jovial sense,
where he's very light hearted and he's smiling and he's having fun.
And it's all through his charm.
And that was just such a wild thing to see for how creepy and
how effectively just disturbing his character is as the movie progresses.
And he never devolves into any kind of like a traditional antagonist,
was so unique.
And Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East play your two Mormon protagonists here.
And I thought they played off each other great.
You have Sophie Thatcher, who's more of the hard edged character.
She's the one who's a little bit more bold,
the one who's actually challenging Hugh Grant throughout the movie.
And then you have Chloe East, who is much more of the innocent of the two,
the one who's more scared, the one who's a little bit more afraid to step on toes.
And the way that those two bounce off of each other, challenge each other,
their two approaches having certain successes and
failures as they're trying to navigate Hugh Grant and the situation.
They were just really well rounded characters that you invested yourself in,
that you cheered for, and
brought a lot of really interesting dynamic changes throughout the movie.
Scott Beck and Brian Woods were the writers and directors here.
Now, they have previously written A Quiet Place, which I'm a big fan of, but
they also directed 65 from last year, which I was not a fan of at all.
So I didn't really know what to expect with their names attached,
cuz I was kind of at like a 50-50 track record for them.
I think this is their best work, certainly as a director, but even as a writer.
I mean, the way that this script was so tight, as I've said,
is something that had to have been a painstaking process to go through to
attack such sensitive topics in a way that's very thought-provoking, but
never leans into anything that's overtly offensive or overtly sacrilegious.
But on the directing side, there's a lot of really cool shots in this movie.
There's a lot of very simple tricks where they have something that's being rotated,
and rather than the camera staying on it and having the reveal of the front of it,
the camera follows the back of it as it's rotated.
So you actually see the character's response and
reaction to what has been revealed before you actually see the reveal.
There's a shot that you see in the trailer that's really neat,
where it almost looks like the top of the house is cut off as they're navigating
this floor like a maze, and you just get to see inside of it.
Really cool stylistic stuff here that it doesn't overtake the movie.
It's still very simplistic in nature, but
you get these little pops of style here and there that was just really cool to see.
And certainly one of the biggest surprises,
which I've already alluded to earlier, is this movie's sense of humor,
which I did not expect.
And even as the movie was starting, it was continuously catching me by surprise
how genuinely funny it is, despite how dark and how sinister everything going on is.
You have Hugh Grant here that, through his jovial performance,
is doing all these pop culture references, and they're having
conversations about their favorite fast food, or Parker Brothers board games.
And even though you're in this ridiculously tense scene,
where tensions are at its highest, you get disarmed through these conversations and
these little jokes and references to things outside of religion that
loosen you up so the movie can continue to wind that tension even tighter.
So it's such a solid sense of humor here.
And the final thing that I'll say without getting too specific is that for
a movie that is so dark and is so heavy with its themes and
with the things it's exploring, there's actually a really surprising hopeful
nature to a lot of the things that they're exploring too,
especially towards the end of the film.
There's a certain visual that you get in the third act that is such,
I hate to use this word because I feel like it's overused, but
it's such a beautiful note to put into that scene,
where you have all of these really dark things happening, and
then there's just this visual that gives you this glimmer of light.
It leaves room for faith and for belief to be in there through just visuals.
And so we actually had a girl that I've been hanging out with this group
at Fantastic Fest that literally was brought to tears by the end of this film.
So it is something that it has a powerful nature to it
that is also as surprising as the humor.
Ultimately, the biggest thing that I love about this is that I love
smart religious horror.
I'm somebody that movies like Frailty have stuck with me for
more than two decades at this point.
And it's a movie that I constantly champion, I constantly talk about,
because it feels so unique within this sub-genre of horror,
where so often when you go into the religious side of horror,
it leans into exorcist rip-offs, it leans into sacrilege,
it leans into fanaticism, and while those can be entertaining,
depending on the execution, I much prefer movies like this
that take a very smart approach to everything,
that are actually a thinking man's horror film,
that are actually thought provoking.
So if that's your type of movie, if that's your type of horror,
this is going to be easily one of your favorite films of the year.
Now as far as the negatives, I gotta be honest with you.
I really struggled to think of anything that I disliked, or
anything that I was kind of on the fence about with this film,
when I first walked out of the theater.
And that's always the times where I'm very adamant about sleeping on it,
not going home and reacting immediately in front of the camera,
with the high of just seeing it at a premiere still in my system.
So now that it's the next morning, thinking it over,
I still don't really have much of an issue with this film.
I have only given one new release that I can remember,
a five out of five, in the eight years that I have been on YouTube.
And this damn near was going to be the second one.
But there is one thing that as I've sat and
thought about it more, could have maybe been done a little bit better for
my experience.
And I even think this element is going to be what most people are going to point to
that don't have a phenomenal experience with it, or dislike the film, or
walk away a little mixed.
And I can't get into any specificity with it,
because it deals with third act stuff.
But I'll just say that there's certain reveals about the true nature of what
Hugh Grant is doing here, kind of like the reveal of what his master plan,
what he's ultimately trying to say by the end of this film.
And it just raises a lot of questions that are certainly interesting.
And I would not want to see a version of the movie that tries to over answer
all of it.
But it doesn't really give you much of an answer for quite a bit of it.
And while I do think that leaves a lot of room for interpretation,
it leaves a lot of room for you to fill in the gaps yourself, which I do enjoy.
There are certain aspects to it where I feel like I did need to know a little bit
more to make complete sense of what his plan was, how long he's been doing this,
what his ultimate goal is, how long he plans to be doing this, things like that.
So there are some unanswered questions in the third act that I think I would have
preferred maybe one or two of them to be answered a little more definitively.
All in all, guys, this is absolutely my type of horror film.
I'm so excited that I get to tell you guys about it, and
I get to pump you up for it even more.
Because I haven't heard a lot of buzz for this, but
it absolutely should be on your radar if you're a fan of this type of film.
It's easily in my top few A24 films, probably my number two right now,
only behind X, I loved it that much.
So as the guy that is always telling you guys to take early reactions and
festival reactions and premiere reactions with a boulder of salt, trust me,
this is one of those times where it merits the hype.
It merits the words that are being said about this film.
It is that fucking good.
Well, that's it for this one, guys.
If you enjoyed that, please click over here for all of my 2024 new release reviews.
I'm also gonna put a playlist up here of all the films I've covered from Fantastic
Fest thus far, and I'll continue to add to that list as the week goes on.
Like, share, hit that subscribe button so you don't miss everything in the future.
And as always, remember, opinions are like assholes, but
that doesn't mean you have to be.
