Comparing Kamala Harris' and Hillary Clinton's performances against Trump

Hillary Clinton
2 followers
4 Video Views·Nov 11, 2024
Hillary Clinton attempted to shatter the highest glass ceiling in U.S. politics and went up against now-President-elect Donald Trump in 2016. CBS News deputy director of elections and data analytics Kabir Khanna compares her performance with Vice President Kamala Harris' run in 2024.
Many of the conversations around Vice President Kamala Harris's 2024 loss
have compared her results with President Biden's in 2020. Using CBS News' election data we wanted
to compare her performance to a woman who also attempted to shatter the highest glass ceiling
in U.S. politics and went against now President-elect Donald Trump in 2016, Secretary of
State Hillary Clinton. Joining us now to help answer that question is CBS News Deputy Director
of Elections and Data Analytics Kabir Khanna. Kabir, good to see you. How did these two women
compare when it comes to certain key voting groups? So the first thing I just want to start
with is that there's still a sizable gender gap when it comes to American elections. Let's take
a look at that using the latest CBS News exit polling data. So what you can see is that in 2016
the last time the Democrats nominated a woman, Hillary Clinton, women went for her at much
higher rates than men did. That's a double-digit gender gap. What you can see this year is that
we still have a sizable double-digit gender gap. So that part is true, but what's interesting is
the gender gap hasn't really grown in these past eight years. In fact, if anything, it's even
gotten a little bit narrower. What that suggests to me is maybe obvious to a lot of people. Women
are not a monolithic voting bloc. Women have lots of different interests. Sometimes they're in
tension with one another. And what I can tell you based on exit polling is that the women who
supported Donald Trump this year, they said two things loud and clear. Their number one issue
was the economy, and the thing that they were most looking for in a candidate was change this year.
There's one other demographic shift that I think is interesting and I want to point it out.
Let's look at Latino voters. So again, as we saw when Hillary Clinton ran in 2016, Latinos did
break for the Democrats in terms of their overall vote choice, but that gap was much, much narrower
this year. In fact, Latino men actually voted Republican in the exit poll. So what that really
amounts to is that there were shifts across the country, but those shifts rightward were more
pronounced among voters of color, Lindsay. What are some comparisons you can draw between the 2016
electoral map and the 2024 electoral map? So let's look at those maps. So this map should look
familiar if you paid attention to what happened in 2016. It's almost the exact same winning map
Donald Trump had that year. He's on track to win all the states he won in 2016, as well as pick up
Nevada, which we currently have as leaning Republican. The shifts in support I just described,
when you combine that with turnout shifts around the country, produced an interesting pattern.
There was certainly a slight shift to the right across the country, but that was even bigger in
less competitive states. It means places like New Jersey, New York, California actually shifted to
the right while Democrats still held them. Of course, the battleground states all shifted just
enough for Donald Trump to be on track to sweep all seven. Kabir Khanna, thank you so much. We appreciate your expertise.
