Johnny Appleseed: Man Behind the Legend

Ancient Legends Around the World
22 followers
Imagine that you're living on the American frontier in the early part of the 19th century,
and you see a man walking down the trail. He's average height, he's got blonde hair,
he's got blue eyes, but he appears to be dressed in rags. Looks like he's wearing a
rough-spun bag with holes cut in it for his head and his arms. He's not wearing any shoes,
and he looks like he's carrying like a coffee sack with him. What might you think of such an
eccentric creature? You've probably heard of Johnny Appleseed. He's part of American folklore like
Paul Bunyan or John Henry, but unlike Paul Bunyan and John Henry, Johnny Appleseed was based on a
real man named John Chapman. He's usually presented as a lanky fellow who wore a long-hindled cooking
pot on his head and threw apple seeds wherever he went. But like any legend, the reality is
more complex, more interesting, and well, more human than the legend. The life of the man who
came to be known as Johnny Appleseed deserves to be remembered. John Chapman was born in
Lemonster, Massachusetts on September 26, 1774, the second child of Elizabeth Simons and former
Nathaniel Chapman. His father fought as a minuteman at the Battle of Bunker Hill, later served as an
officer under General George Washington, helping construct the defenses of New York against the
British. He served with the Continental Army from 1777 until 1780, which time he was honorably
discharged at Springfield, having attained the rank of captain earlier in the colonial struggle.
Chapman's mother Elizabeth passed away from tuberculosis while his father was at war, and
when he returned Nathaniel remarried a woman named Lucy Cooley in 1780. He had 10 more children with
her. Little is known about Chapman's early life, but we do know that his father encouraged his son
to become an orchardist. He also must have instilled a king's sense of business in his son,
which was to play a large role in what came next. It was the time of the American frontier,
people were pushing out into unbroken land, they were establishing farms, making land claims, and
pushing the Native Americans farther west. Both governments and private land companies encouraged
the growing of orchards because they were seen to have a settling influence. If you came and claimed
that you were going to stay there and establish a community, well creating and tending an orchard
was seen as something that would tie you to the land and prove your intent to stay. This type of
thinking was seen in 1792 when the Ohio Company of Associates, a real estate company formed a
businessman from Massachusetts, stated that anyone willing to form a permanent homestead on the
wilderness beyond Ohio's first settlement would receive 100 acres of land, but would be required
to plant 50 apple trees and 20 peach trees on that land. This requirement is where Chapman found the
business opportunity that he would pursue for the rest of his life. At age 18, Chapman headed west
to Pennsylvania with his 11-year-old half-brother Nathaniel, where he began his life as a nurseryman
on the frontier. His first apple tree nurseries were planted in the Allegheny Valley in Pennsylvania
around 1798, where he then collected seeds, picking them from cider mills around the Potomac River
before traveling west along through Ohio, leaving his brother behind with friends. He kept well ahead
of the pioneers and almost eerily predicted where they would settle next, planting nurseries in those
spots. After clearing the land and planting the orchards, Chapman fenced them in with natural
materials like fallen trees or logs, bushes, or vines. This helped protect the orchard as leaving
trees without a surrounding fence in the open resulted in attracting nearby populations of
black bears, woodchucks, and other wild animals looking for food. Once the orchard was on its way,
he left it in the hands of a caretaker and moved on to establish a new nursery on the ever-expanding
frontier border. Chapman returned to his established nurseries once pioneers began to
settle the land in the area and sold the trees for a fippiny bit, or about six and a quarter cents.
If the settlers didn't have the money, he was known to barter with them or extend them credit,
lending some credence to the folklore figure Johnny Appleseed's legendary generosity. And he could
afford to be generous. The nurseries Chapman planted became his property simply through his
creation of them. When he died he had over a thousand acres in his possession. He didn't
flaunt his wealth though and preferred to live a simple and itinerant life, free from the
responsibilities of family or permanent home. Some of these life choices were driven by Chapman's
religious beliefs. Chapman was a follower of the Church of New Jerusalem, which was a Christian
faith that was based upon the teachings of scientist and philosopher Immanuel Swedenborg.
Among their beliefs was the idea that man could most experience God through nature and that a
good life was one that was lived through simplicity. Very uncommon for people of his time,
Chapman was a practicing vegetarian and a vocal advocate of nature and animals. These beliefs
were considered to be unorthodox and eccentric and are often left out of the children's stories
about Johnny Appleseed. He purchased mistreated horses and animals that were so sick that they
were going to be put down. It is best to help them heal. He took this concern for animals to
legendary status when one night he observed mosquitoes flying into his fire and watching
them burn. The story goes that Johnny took his tin hat, gathered water and quenched the fire,
remarking, God forbid that I should build a fire for my comfort that should be the means of
destroying any of his creatures. This willingness to give up his own comfort for those of another
species made it into other tall tales. Another story goes that one night Chapman made a campfire
in a snowstorm at the end of a hollow log. He intended to pass the night there in comfort but
discovered a bear and cubs in the same space. So he moved his fire to the other end and slept
on the snow in the open air rather than disturb the animals. And another story goes that Chapman
found a trapped wolf that he freed and healed its injured leg and the wolf followed him in his
travels ever after. But before we travel too far down the path of folklore, there were some stories
about Chapman's quest for nature and purity that were more eccentric, maybe even darker.
He was asked once by a pioneer why he didn't marry and settle down on an orchard of his own and he
responded that no woman was pure enough for his love, nor could she compare with his life of
nature and simplicity. He would find a wife later, he said, in heaven after he died. The story
continues and almost creepily that in an effort to find a woman who met his exacting standards,
Chapman arranged for a settler family to raise their young daughter as his intended bride.
But when he saw her flirting with some boys in town, he put off the engagement because of her
behavior. Perhaps these are just troubling rumors about a pious man, but Chapman never did marry or
settle down. Some who knew him described Chapman as eccentric. While Chapman is often depicted as
wearing a long-handled cook pot on his head with tattered clothes and no shoes, he didn't in fact
wear a pot on his head, but rather it was said a tin hat that he also utilized as a bowl for his
food. Although thin in appearance, Chapman was a rugged outdoorsman because of his lifestyle,
walking miles each day barefoot and sleeping outdoors in lands that were known for their
dangerous wildlife. His feet became so rough from his punishing existence that Chapman reportedly
pushed needles through the soles of his feet without pain or walk on hot coals. In another
story from the era, Chapman gave away his shoes to a family traveling west who couldn't afford to
buy shoes for themselves. In acts that would go on to fuel more stories of his legendary generosity,
Chapman spent time teaching the settlers how to care for the trees he sold them before returning
to his travels. There was nothing that required him to educate the green settlers and in doing so,
Chapman helped the homesteaders establish their land claims early in their arrival,
along with leaving them a much-needed source of additional food in the fruit from the trees.
The apples Chapman planted were not the dessert types one would use in cooking, but rather trees
that produced cider apples. Called spitters, these apples were small and unpleasant to eat and had a
bitterness and dryness, qualities that make the fruit unsuited for cooking, but instead were used
to make hard cider along with certain brandies. Cider was a common staple in the American diet as
pioneers didn't always have access to sanitary drinking water. In fact, by the mid-1700s,
the average pioneer was drinking an estimated 35 gallons of hard cider a year. It was also a key
component of the colonial economy. Since currency was often hard to come by in the colonies, cider
was often used as good as cash, with barrels of it being worked out in barter arrangements.
Chapman's association with cider led one American author to refer to him as
America's Dionysus. Beyond drinking it, the cider could be fermented into cider vinegar,
which colonists used to preserve vegetables through pickling, helping with the storage of
food, which was another constant concern on the frontier. Although there was some decline in its
use by 1900, apple cider remained a part of the American diet until the rise of the temperance
movement. When prohibition was enacted in 1919, FBI agents began to tear down orchards with the
making of homemade hooch, destroying heirloom apple varieties that had grown since colonial
times. Which brings us back to another facet of the Johnny Appleseed legend, his association
with apples. Part of this legend was created by Chapman's religious beliefs. Reportedly,
he refused to graft trees, a process whereby a twig or branch of an existing tree is attached
to the root system of another, as he saw that as hurting the plants, and instead carried his
signature look of the coffee sack of apple seeds with him to plant trees. Since Chapman didn't use
grafting, which grows an apple identical to the parent tree, Chapman created the conditions for
apple trees to adapt and thrive in a new environment, the American frontier. Because
of this personality quirk, he is credited for the development of some of the most popular apple
varieties, like the delicious and golden delicious apples. Though Chapman contributed to their
dislocation, he was reportedly known and liked by indigenous American tribes encountered on
the frontier's edge, although the relationship was not universally friendly. He spoke some of
their languages, and they in turn admired his friendly nature and knowledge of plants, both for
food and for medicinal use. Some Native Americans seem to have regarded him as someone who was
touched by the Great Spirit, and generally left him alone on his travels, which were extensive.
Chapman meandered from Massachusetts through western Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana, eventually
traveling as far as Ontario, Illinois, and West Virginia, planting and operating a chain of
nurseries as he went. In 1845, after a 15-mile walk leading his black ox to repair an orchard
fence that cattle had trampled down, he contracted pneumonia. That night, Chapman visited a friend
named William Worth, ate bread and milk, read the Bible, and laid on the floor to sleep. The next day,
Chapman didn't wake up. He died at age 70 on March 11, 1845. At his death, the itinerant wanderer
owned more than 1,200 acres of land and four plots in Allen County in Indiana, including a
nursery with an estimated 15,000 trees. Chapman is believed to have owned even more lands that
he lost track of due to his poor bookkeeping. He left all his property to his sister. Today,
there's a 176-year-old tree in Nova, Ohio, which is one of the last known to have been planted by
Chapman himself. Although the lifespan of most fruit trees is only 15 to 45 years, this tree
will live on using the method that Chapman didn't employ, grafting. The seeds and cuttings have been
used to propagate hundreds of new Johnny Appleseed trees in the time since its planting. You can also
visit his birthplace in Lemonster, Massachusetts, where there's a recreation of his childhood home.
It's unclear when Chapman picked up his famous nickname, but the name and the legend didn't
become popular in America until decades after his death. But eventually, the legend of Johnny
Appleseed captured the nation's imagination and cemented itself in American folklore. And
like any legend, it's difficult to separate the myth from the reality, and there are questions
about most of the popularly told stories about his life. But the reality of the man, his strange
appearance, his eccentric beliefs about animals and nature, his distinctive lifestyle, have inspired
millions to plant trees and help others. And maybe that's all that anyone can hope for in life,
is to create a life that inspires, a life that deserves to be remembered. John Chapman's Memorial
Graveside is in Fort Wayne, Indiana, where they hold a yearly festival. There's a marker at the
site that bears the motto, he lived for others. I hope you enjoyed this episode of the History Guy,
short snippets of forgotten history between 10 and 15 minutes long. And if you did enjoy,
please go ahead and click that thumbs up button. If you have any questions or comments or suggestions
for future episodes, please write those in the comment section. I will be happy to personally
respond. Be sure to follow the History Guy on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and check out our
merchandise on teespring.com. And if you'd like more episodes on forgotten history, all you need
to do is subscribe. Transcribed by https://otter.ai
