(Ep. 252) Your Top Questions as Payments Resume

Trust Channel
6 followers
1 Video View·Nov 8, 2024
I’m covering your most pressing questions as we prepare for student loan payments to resume. The forbearance period is ending, and there’s a lot of uncertainty and confusion about how to navigate the repayment landscape. I’ll discuss the recent developments with the PSLF waiver and IDR waiver, shedding some light on how these changes might affect your chances of loan forgiveness. Learn your next steps, whether you’re considering refinancing, changing repayment plans, or just want to understand the new regulations.
Hey everybody. Today we have a really interesting show.
It's a huge backlog of a lot of questions that I have been not getting to like I
should. So I apologize about that.
So we're just going to run through a ton of questions today about a whole bunch
of different stuff. I think it's going to be kind of interesting.
I think a lot of you will get a ton out of this just to see just the variety of
things that our listeners have to face with their student loans.
So we'll try to get through as many questions as we can. And you know,
if any of them sound like they don't apply to you,
just use that like fast forward button on your podcast player.
So let's start with the first one about an American living abroad.
Hey there.
I'm an American abroad and I recently applied to consolidate my FFEL loans and
Perkins loans through ADVANTAGE. I already have loans through ADVANTAGE.
So I was calling them about something else yesterday. And during that call,
I found out that they sent the letter that has the 10 day window to respond or
make any changes to the consolidation.
They told me that that letter has been sent five days ago. So six days now,
they asked me if I had that letter in front of me. And since I'm abroad,
it's unlikely that I'm going to receive that letter in time within that 10 day
window to respond.
So I'm concerned about what that letter contains and what would happen if I'm
not able to respond within the time if I wanted to make any changes, for example,
or if I wanted to cancel the application or just in general,
I'm concerned about not receiving the information in time.
So I'm wondering what other Americans abroad do. Do they face this situation?
What's the legality of that? What are my options?
Is there anyone that I could call to have the letter read to me, for example,
if they could sit at the platform,
the person at the representative at ADVANTAGE wasn't able to give me that
information at all.
So I'm just a little concerned about the situation and curious about your advice.
Thank you so much.
So it's a pretty common issue, really. I mean,
just in general for people living abroad,
it's pretty challenging to do anything with your servicer. I mean,
the big thing that we like to tell people living abroad is most people don't
know about the foreign earned income exclusion. That is where you can earn,
I think it's up to like 120 or 130 K that you can earn abroad and file your tax
return in the U S and basically have a $0 AGI in the U S.
So that's really intended so that middle-class people that go abroad and work a
go with the nuisance of like hiring a tax professional with expat skills that
can, you know, handle filing in both places.
What that means functionally is we got a lot of people that will move to like
Australia or Europe and they'll have the student loans and they can file a tax
return.
And basically every year they file in the U S and get a $0 income because this
foreign earned income exclusion and pay a $0 on their IDR plan.
And instead of being a default, they're getting, you know,
a hundred percent of their interest subsidized. And it's wonderful.
I know that doesn't answer this particular borrower's question. Unfortunately,
I think that this person's just out of luck. You know,
it's kind of difficult to handle servicer type communication when you're abroad.
I mean,
obviously they're operating with the assumption that everybody's in the U S so
nothing really can do in this situation. Let's now go to the next one.
Hi there. Thank you for taking my question.
I love the podcast and find it incredibly helpful.
I am curious about something you mentioned in a previous episode.
You referred to doctors and other providers who work for Kaiser
Permanente getting PSLF credit,
even though they work for a private institution.
While I didn't work for Kaiser Permanente,
I did work for a private medical company as an outreach athletic
trainer to a public school where I was both teaching and
doing clinical hours with the athletics department.
I worked there for several years and it would actually give me a huge bump in my
PSLF count if I could get credit for these.
But when I go to the student aid website,
it doesn't allow me to certify because I have to have a government official
letter or something from the,
what sounds like it has to be a government contract.
Do you have any advice on how I could submit for this?
Or does that sound like something that would be covered under these new
guidelines? I would love to get more credit if possible.
Thank you for your help.
Sometimes things don't apply to folks.
And this is an example of this not applying to this borrower. Unfortunately,
you know,
you can only get PSLF credit if you are not working directly for a 501c3
or government employer.
If your position is not allowed for you to be working for directly for that
employer by state law. So that's really a very narrow definition.
I think this is why they were able to get around the regulations on this.
Frankly,
I think that this was a very smart campaign by the narrow group of people that
were affected by this problem that successfully got the regulations rewritten
for them.
I think that they deliberately wrote the regulations pretty narrowly to avoid a
lawsuit or a challenge from like, you know,
Republicans or something like that on this. So unfortunately,
this listener could not get extra credit on PSLF. This is something, you know,
that only applies to people that by state law could not work directly for their
nonprofit or government employer,
which is really mostly, you know, physicians and mostly in California,
frankly,
it seems like a lot of these other states that have these prohibitions have
like soften them up a whole lot for direct physician employment.
Unfortunately, this also means that like,
let's say you have a physician that worked at a place like Kaiser,
like they can qualify for PSLF now,
but let's say you have a support staff person that works for Kaiser.
They're not prohibited by state law from getting PSLF.
So unfortunately that person would not qualify to get PSLF credit unless they're
sorry, employed directly by the nonprofit entity, right? So what I,
what I meant to say there is just to be precise in my language is that that
person was employed by the, you know,
for-profit group that was contracted with the 501c3.
If they're not prohibited by state law from being directly employed by that
nonprofit, then they can't qualify for PSLF.
So a lot of nuance with all these new regulations.
Now let's check out the next one.
Hey, so I'm going for double consolidation.
I just had a question about some of the services.
So I noticed the advantage, uh,
they have the same address as Mogila and Ed Financial.
I was wondering if there's any problem with
sending to one of those servicers,
other than now Matt as they're all working under the same
roof. Um,
I know advantage is handling and consulting the consolidations.
So I was just wondering if there's any complications that you've seen or
anything like that. So thank you.
So I really love involving Nelnet and then anybody else in double consolidations
and then sending it to either Nelnet or anybody else in that list.
So the reason being is Nelnet is the only company that processes
consolidations besides Advantage.
It used to be that every service to process their own consolidations.
I think all the servicers were very eager to cut costs with all the complexity
with student loans.
And so Advantage handles the consolidations for everybody.
The way we've seen this pop up as a problem most frequently is, uh,
Advantage will often process the consolidation before the IDR application that
was submitted with it. And so sometimes we see people get there or vice versa.
So we'll see, for example,
somebody completed double consolidation that applied for, you know,
the pay or the save plan,
and they'll get denied because they'll say they have parent plus loans. Um,
and that's just because of the order in which Advantage process the
consolidation.
So what we tend to do for double consolidation folks these days is just tell
them to submit for like the extended or the standard plan,
even though it's a huge payment and not to set up auto pay during that process.
And so there's no consequences to having, you know,
a couple months of non-payment, right? You know,
the process is just trying to get through that double consolidation intact.
And then you just, frankly, right now,
it seems like people have no choice but to call the servicer,
mention the double consolidation.
And because the online website seems to be blocking people from getting onto the
save and pay plans,
probably because they wrote the logic like it's 2025 and it's not yet, uh,
the people who program the site dead. So, you know, it's really weird.
These nuanced double consolidation things. That's why, you know,
a lot of our double consolidation clients,
like they'll book a consult and then they might book a followup consult just to
kind of go over that with one of our paperwork parent plus specialists.
And there's just really an expert in the process of reviewing things with folks.
So definitely encourage anybody that could benefit from the parent plus double
consolidation, if you can afford it to book with our team. So, uh,
now for the next one.
Hi, my name is Patrick. I'm an athletic trainer at a big high school in Illinois.
I'm currently employed though, through outreach physical therapy company.
So the physical therapy company is contracted by the school and the physical
therapy company that pays me to go work at the school.
So unfortunately I am not categorized as a school employee.
I have about 44,000 in student debt,
mostly from grad school.
What avenues am I looking at in order to look at any kind of forgiveness?
I've started my loans back in 2007.
I've been paying since, but obviously at the student loan pause,
looking at either the PSLF, if that's a possibility,
unfortunately I have applied and was denied eligible employment
through the company I work for. I am currently on the save plan,
just looking to see if there's any other avenues I should look into.
So without guessing too much about this listeners income, I mean,
I guess I should just guess. So let's just say hypothetically,
this person makes $80,000. Let's say they're a family of four,
pretty common arrangement in America, right? Um,
let's say that this person's married to somebody that makes about the same
income as, as him. Um,
so say you've got a dual income household,
each make an ADK, uh, with two kids. What does that mean?
What does that look like with save payments?
So if you have one person making 80 file separate with two kids and spouse,
you're going to use family size of three because you exclude the spouse when you
file separate with save. So deduction for a family of three is about 55,000.
So if you take 80,000 minus 55, you're going to pay 10% of that remainder.
So that's 10% on about $25,000, about 2,500 a year,
about $200 a month. The cool part is you can get that number lower.
And there's a lot of nuances to say that people are not yet aware of.
So one is if you consolidate, they're going to use 10% no matter what,
even if you have undergrad loans mixed in on a moderate balance, like 44,000,
it really depends on the setup of the loans. But you know,
if everything's already direct, then you might not consolidate.
If you already have, if you have the same credit for everything,
if you don't have the same credit, you might consolidate. And you know,
the $44,000 balance, you, you, you can't get PS left credit.
Unfortunately,
if you're not directly employed by the 501c3 government employer,
because you're probably not prohibited from being an athletic trainer directly
for the system you work at by state law, it's probably not a direct prohibition.
So unfortunately you probably can't get that. What are the options elsewhere?
You know, I would say for retirement. So a lot of people, you know,
so most people,
typical middle-class family is going to be in a 22% or 24% marginal tax
bracket, which means every extra thousand bucks you earn next,
you're going to be paying about 22 or 24% federal in tax.
State most people pay five or 6% for state.
So you're about 30% all in for federal and state.
And then you're at probably 10% for your student loan payment.
So you're at basically at a 40% marginal bracket,
which is really huge for a family making 160 K total 80 K each.
So what you could do is max out your 43 B or your 401k.
You could do 22,500 into that this year. Maybe let's say you have a spouse.
It doesn't have loans.
Maybe you have the spouse do 4% of of their income.
And then you do the 22,500.
What that does is remember I say you're paying 10% on 25 K in this case.
So you'd basically be paying 10% on only $2,500 in this case.
So that's $250 a year, about $20 a month.
So imagine paying $20 a month with save. There's no interest accrual.
So your total interest is just the amount of your monthly payments.
That's about $250 of interest a year.
That's like a 0.5% interest rate. If I'm doing that math,
right at the top of my head, um, who would not run,
not walk to get a 0.5% interest rate. That's pretty amazing, right?
Especially cause you're growing wealth while you're doing it.
So this is really why a lot of this sort of debt ranting,
anti-debt live on rice and beans type of eyes.
It's just so wrong these days because there's all this planning opportunity that
you can do to avoid having to make those $450 a month payments that you'd need
to pay if you're trying to get rid of it with the standard plan.
And if you have a family, two people make an 80 K each, a couple of kids,
$450 a month, you know, it's not daycare in New York,
but it might be daycare in the Midwest. It's a big car payment basically, right?
It's a huge deal.
It's a major impact in this person's family if they can get a lower payment.
So now onto the next one.
Hi, I have a question regarding the new save plan that was introduced recently.
I've done a lot of research and learned as much as I can.
And I feel like I have a pretty good handle on most of it,
but there's one piece that I don't have clarity on and I'm hoping that you can
help that. And it's the forgiveness piece. So as I understand it,
loans that had an original principal balance of less than $12,000 are eligible
for forgiveness after 10 years of qualifying payments and an additional year
for every thousand dollars beyond that $12,000 threshold.
That much I understand the piece that I cannot seem to find clarity on
anywhere is whether that $12,000 threshold is referring to individual loan
balances or cumulative.
My wife has some student debt that we're working on knocking down and her debt is
made up of eight smaller loans,
each of which fall under that $12,000 threshold for their original principal
balances. But if you cumulatively combine all of those principal balances,
it exceeds the $12,000.
So what I'm not clear on is whether the $12,000 is referring to cumulative,
the original principal balance of all of the loans combined or individually per
loan.
Part of the reason that I have confusion on this is because I qualified for loan
forgiveness through PSLF about a year ago. And when I received forgiveness,
it was not a cumulative forgiveness all at one time.
It was individualized per loan.
So one day I saw one of my loans dropped to zero.
A couple of weeks later, another two of them dropped to zero,
but the rest were still there. And then a week later, two more dropped to zero.
So it appeared that my forgiveness was distributed on an individual basis,
loan by loan.
And that's why I'm not entirely sure if this $12,000 threshold under the safe
plane is referring to individual loans or the cumulative.
So hopefully that question makes sense. Hopefully you can provide some insight.
I'd be so appreciative of that. Thanks so much for your time.
Clearly this person's done a lot of research is a total amount of loans, right?
It's 12 K total. It's not per loan. So I mean,
otherwise that'd be pretty doggone amazing, right? And if it was 12 K per loan,
a whole lot of people will take out kind of small loans across a much larger
balance. So why did they say 12 K by the way,
12 K is basically the amount for community college that most people borrow.
And so the idea, you know,
if you think about what are priorities of president Biden, obviously the first
lady, Dr. Jill Biden is a, is a community college professor,
huge proponent of community college. And so, you know,
this is essentially their way of trying to make community college free by doing a
10 year timeline, super aggressive, 225% of the poverty line with, you know,
5% of your income for undergrad, which would be community college.
I mean your typical probably 90,
95% of community college borrowers under save would be able to pay zero.
And so you pay zero for just 10 years and you get rid of it.
That's what kind of the aim here is the reason why this borrower got forgiveness
on an individual basis for each loan is because they weren't consolidated.
And you know, PSLF is 10 years on a particular loan amount. You know,
usually the way it works is you've got to get 10 years on a loan.
So if you,
you might've gotten PSLF or close to getting PSLF on one set of loans and you
take out some new loans for a new graduate program, well,
now you gotta go get 10 more years in those loans to get forgiveness. Right?
So one of the big opportunities during that PSLF and IDR waivers has been being
able to consolidate those types of loans and get the oldest loan credited on the
whole thing. If you consolidate,
what's going to happen after the IDR waiver is over is it's going to be weighted
average.
So that's going to be a lot less generous because what happens a lot of times is
people's oldest loans or undergrad loans with really small balances.
And then they go back for school after working a little bit and take out huge
loans for grad school.
So some of the most shocking massive savings we get for clients during this IDR
waiver period are when, you know,
you have one of these scenarios where you've got like a $3,000 loan that was
from, you know, 2005 and worked for 10 years.
You went back to school,
got 200 K of debt to get some sort of doctorate or professional degree and you
just consolidate the whole thing's done. That's, that's just an example.
I'll say though that a lot of times people get in the weeds and steal loans and
maybe people enjoy it.
And so they try to learn it all because they enjoy it or they need to save money
and they're trying to not spend money on unnecessary things.
And people might feel like, you know,
loan help is something that's not necessary. Yeah, that's true.
It's not necessary. You're not going to, you know, nothing's,
nothing terrible is going to happen to you if you don't get a loan consult.
But I'll just say almost always there's something people are missing.
So just be aware of that.
You've got to feel really confident that you're not missing anything.
One of the jokes,
one of our new consultants said is they basically locked themselves in their
apartment for the past month and did nothing but study loan rules.
It's very complicated right now in particular. So let's listen to the next one.
Hi, I'm a graduate student, a graduate pharmacy student,
who's graduating in May of 2024.
And I'm sort of starting to navigate the world of repayment.
And so I came across the new safe plan as everyone's been raving about.
And I just wanted to know whether we active students who are graduating in less
than a year are eligible to apply for the safe plan whilst in school,
or is that something that's just automatically done? Cause I was on the website.
I don't see any issues with applying. I mean,
I see that it's letting me apply even though it knows the status of my loans,
which are in forbearance until obviously graduation.
And so that's what I wanted to know. Thank you.
So there's a really cool loophole that people are not aware of where grad plus
loans are able to be entered into repayment 60 days after disbursement,
I believe,
and Stafford unsubsidized loans are required to stay in deferment the entire
time you're in school.
So the opportunity is essentially to get your grad school loans out of this in
school deferment by, you can call your servicer,
you can submit an in-school deferment waiver form,
and you can also just try to go online and apply for it and see what happens.
And what's going to happen is 60 days after disbursement,
any of your grad loans would get onto the safe plan. And if,
since you're a student, if you've been filing taxes, showing a $0 income,
you could get a $0 payment.
All of your interests and your grad plus loans could be subsidized.
This is a really big opportunity.
This does not apply to Stafford loans or parent plus loans.
The thought process here is why don't more people do this?
It's going to be a big pain in the butt to keep them in repayment.
So what happens is every time your school reports your enrollment status,
it kicks your loans back into deferment, uh, just automatically.
And so somebody that does this would have to be constantly checking their loans,
calling their servicer,
making sure that their loans are continually being placed in a safe plan,
like every semester at least. And again,
only grad plus loans can go into this plan. And then when you graduate,
you would probably consolidate everything together. And at that point in 2024,
it'll be the weighted average that would be applied to the new loan.
So you'd probably get an extra year towards forgiveness.
If you're doing a 20 year plan or 25 year plan by doing this.
And then if you are going for PSLF,
it actually doesn't really help you the strategy because PSLF is, you know,
unlimited forgiveness. And then, you know,
PSLF you have to be working at a nonprofit employer to get your credit.
So this is really something that I think, you know, pharmacy,
a lot of people work in private sector and pharmacy law, that med dental,
that's the primary application of this. Maybe physical therapy as well.
Physicians it's a little bit less important because most people would be going
for PSLF these days. Uh,
if you were a private practice physician or expecting to be,
then this would be a pretty valuable thing to at least attempt. If you'd,
you know, if you don't, if you read about financial stuff,
if you don't mind listening, you listen to podcasts like this,
you're probably a financial oriented person. So, you know,
it wouldn't be a bad idea to at least give it a shot.
There's no reason why you wouldn't try this now for the next one.
Hi, I have a very specific question.
And my question is regarding parent plus loans that my ex and I,
while my soon to be ex and I took out in probably the amount of about $90,000
our kids are graduated by now and have their own student loans to pay back.
So though those parent loans are all in my soon to be ex's name,
he contends that that is marital asset and it is marital debt and that we both
need to pay that back.
So what he is proposing is that he writes a check to me in the amount of $45,000
and then I can handle it in any way, shape or form that I like.
The parent plus loans have just been sitting there throughout COVID and we
have not or he has not done any form of consolidation.
So my question I guess is two pronged.
A is the double consolidation loophole the best way to get the parent plus
loans in shape for the future repayment and B would I be smart or not smart to
accept his proposal of a cash offer to me for $45,000 after which he would
like to put the parent plus loans in my name and he will have nothing to do with.
So a do we use the double consolidation loophole to get those in shape and then
B would it be smart for me to allow him to put the whole debt in my name,
take the $45,000 and repay it in some fashion on my own.
Thank you.
I think I disagree with what's being proposed here in a lot of levels.
Parent plus debt is in the name of a person and it is their debt.
The only way to get their name off of it is to refinance it into the private
system. That is the only way to do it.
The person that has the debt would be have to be the one to do a double
consolidation. There's no way to transfer it.
And so effectively if this 90 K of debt would have to become yours,
you'd have to refinance it into a private loan.
You'd get 45 K to pay it off and suddenly you've got to pay back 45 K with
interest. Uh, so this is a very inequitable proposal here.
The other thing to think about is, so let me put this disclaimer in here.
I'm not an attorney. You have to, you know,
consult a licensed attorney for legal advice. But here's my opinion.
If you do some Google searching in general, debt is not an asset.
It's not community assets. It's not a, it's in the person's name.
That's probably why this person's proposing this is because they've probably
done some research and, um,
everybody going through something that people don't want to,
obviously nobody wants to go through it,
but that are going through it is probably going to be looking for the best
option for them. And, um, and to me, this is not a great proposal.
I will say this, if you're both trying to get towards a thing that is fair,
I will say I've seen some pretty reasonable approaches to parent plus loans and
a divorce. I mean,
one of the cases that really jumped out at me was I remember a case where
somebody had like 300 K of parent plus loans. They were a lower income person.
They had a higher income person that the court ruled them to split that 300 K
down the middle.
And that was a terrible approach for both of them because essentially it was
totally forgivable as a parent plus debt. It was totally forgivable.
The person had a low income,
their payments would have been a couple hundred a month.
The thing that made a lot more sense is just for, uh, frankly,
an additional amount of alimony below the level of the monthly payments as to
what they would have been. It was a better,
it was better for both of the parties involved. Um,
and so this judge clearly didn't understand student loan debt because the judge
was the one that ruled it. So I would just say, be very cognizant. Uh,
and I'll say this as to everyone in general, if you, you know,
think at some point there's a chance you get divorced, uh,
you should know that, um, assets are split 50, 50, but debt is not.
So if you have, you know, if you're, if you're the spouse with the debt,
get as much prepayment on your loans as possible because that debt is not split
50, 50, you would keep all of it in the event of divorce in most cases. Uh,
and then, you know,
if your spouse has debt and you think there's a possibility you might one day be
an ex spouse,
then you'd want to not make payments into that because you're paying down
something that would only be with them anyway in the event of the split.
So little fun fact to know. Now let's listen to the next one.
Hey guys, my name's Emily. You are amazing. And if you are listening,
these guys are amazing.
They have transformed my life and have created an incredible amount of control
in my life, which if you understood how little bit of money I have,
you would be surprised.
I have 290 something thousand dollars in loans and I pay zero dollars a month
every month. And that was before the COVID pause.
Now coming out of the COVID pause, I also happen to be divorced.
Now I had been on IBR in order to keep my payment at zero because my wife had a
high income,
but now I don't know if I should be trying to stay on IBR or not or go to the
save plan. So that's question one is,
do I try to stay on the IBR plan? And question two,
trying to verify my work eligibility,
the school district I work for who fired me had filled out my eligibility
paperwork and said that I was a current employee and that I was like working
currently in everything. And that was back in June of 2023.
And now it's August.
And so I don't know if I can file that right now while I'm filing for
unemployment and not raise some red flags cause I don't want to get in trouble
with the government or anything else.
So hopefully that made sense.
So love you guys and hope that makes sense.
So this listener probably needs to go to the save plan,
but the thing that matters is the timing.
So if your payment is $0 a month, it's likely, you know,
that that could last until 2024 or even 2025 you have to look at your NSLDS
file or your service or you call a service server. That's a long hold time.
So the NSLDS file is the easiest way to figure this out.
If you just download that TXT file and then just control F anniversary,
you'll find your anniversary date for IDR and then basically add a year to
whatever you find in most cases.
So let's say this person's recertification date is August,
2023 and their NSLDS file,
you would know that you could keep $0 a month until August of 2024. Uh,
if this person's divorced, then let's say they're filing single,
then the probably the best option is going to be the same plan.
It gets interest subsidies. It's 10% of income instead of 15% with IBR,
old IBR at least. That's a pretty good deal.
In terms of the question about PSLF, how to do that. I mean, in general,
we always just recommend people be above board, right? And just whatever, you know,
your situation is, you submit for it, get it certified the end, right?
If they called you a current employee on their form that you recently submitted,
and let's say that you realize, Oh no,
I got like given credit that I wasn't supposed to get.
You could always make an argument.
If somebody ever raised the question that you were maybe on a 12 month contract,
you have summers off, you're technically an employee in the summers, you know,
I don't know. I mean like, you know, don't lose sleep over this.
It's not the kind of thing where you made a mistake on your taxes and you have
to correct it. You know,
I don't even know if they have a process to undo a PSLF certification form that
was filed incorrectly. I would just continue just moving forward.
Just go ahead and fill out everything the right way and let them determine it.
Right.
That's probably what I would do is just recommend this person not lose any sleep
over this. So let's listen to another one.
Hi, student loan planner team.
I am getting ready for my repayments under the save plan.
And I am wondering,
is there any benefit in making additional monthly payments while on the save
plan?
Or is it best for me to put this additional money into other areas such as a
mortgage and retirement? Thanks for the advice.
So we expect the save plan is going to work the same way that the repay plan did.
And the way that plan worked is if you're getting interest subsidies,
you get the interest subsidies calculated whenever that new IDR, you know,
monthly payment is calculated.
And then if you want to pay extra on top of that,
you can and it would all go towards any accrued interest balance.
If you have any first and then it would go towards the principal.
So I'll give you an example. So let's say you're,
you've got $100,000 loan amount. Let's say you have 6% interest.
So your total interest every year is $6,000, 500 a month, right?
Let's say that your save payment is $200 a month.
So the way that save plan works is anything above $200 a month.
In this case, that'd be 300, but be fully subsidized by the government.
So effectively you're getting a $300 interest subsidy every month for the next
12 months until you have to recertify next.
But then that interest subsidy is recalculated. So what you could do,
let's say you get a $10,000 bonus. So you know,
you're going to pay off your loans.
You can take that $10,000 and dump it into your loans.
If there's any accrued interest balance, it's got to go to that first. Now,
a lot of people get real freaked out about that or, you know, worried about that.
Don't worry, worry about it at all. It's not a big deal. It's still going towards,
you know, your balance. People think it's not going towards principal,
but it really is because you do owe it. So don't, don't freak out about that.
The $10,000 would go into paying down that balance,
whatever your total balance is.
And then let's say you've got $90,000 now and it's time to recertify next year.
And let's say your payment is $500 a month because your income went up a bunch
of the save plan. Well, in this case, because you paid on the balance,
the total interest every year is no longer $6,000 a year.
It's a little bit less than that. So that means $500 a month.
Would not only fully cover your interest,
but it would also pay down some of the principal balance.
So now you have no more interest subsidy on save.
Your interest rate is actually 6%. And now if you're needing to pay off the loan,
you would look at refinancing options versus just keeping it federal. Now,
let's say this person checks refi rates and finds a 5.5% rate for private.
That's not that big of a difference to me. I would keep it federal, right?
Now let's say if you have an 8% rate and you find 5.5 to me,
anything better than 1% lower is like worth it.
If you're just rock solid finances, no chance you're going to go PSLF.
You've looked into it.
There's no way you can get 20 or 25 year forgiveness.
Then go ahead and take it to private sector and just get lowest interest rate
you can and follow that refi ladder strategy,
which is where you start off with a longer term loan,
pay it down with prepayments. Whenever you get extra money,
refi it again to a 10 year, pay down extra money, refi it again to a five year.
What I would expect is like, you know,
we'll see lower interest rates.
The federal reserve will probably lower rates the next recession we have. Um,
and or when inflation calms down and then we'll be able to get better rates for
like shorter term refis right now.
But right now the only really valuable refi out there is like a 15 or 20 year
refi, I think for the most part,
because otherwise you're committing to a high interest rate with a fixed payment
with a short term and that's not a good idea. Now onto the next one.
Hey Travis,
I heard there has been a few modifications to the ECFR
685.219 public service loan forgiveness
program.
I was wondering whether PSLF eligible borrowers must stay employed by the
PSLF eligible employer until the loans are completely forgiven.
I have been informed by a few sources that you are allowed to leave the
PSLF eligible employer once you send in your final ECF.
Just wanted to see if this is true. Thank you.
So to be honest, I had to double check this one myself.
I'm going to get through some of the regulations to see if I can get an answer
on this one. But the issue,
the reason why it's complicated is because the PSLF waiver waived this rule.
So you'd no longer had to be at a qualifying employer to get forgiveness.
And then the IDR waiver,
that was one of the only provisions of the IDR waiver that they did not include
in the IDR waiver.
And so we had somebody that we could not figure out why she was not getting
forgiveness.
And then we realized it's because she had a lot of forbearance and she needed the
IDR waiver to take place to get to 120 and she was at more than 120,
but she was not at a qualifying employer anymore.
And that's why they hadn't discharged it.
And then now there's new regulations that just went into effect July one.
This is one I should really know,
but sometimes stumps me and I have to go double check to make sure I don't get
out incorrect information.
So I'll get back to y'all on this one in a future podcast episode.
I know it's obviously quite important.
So most people luckily are at a qualifying employer when they get forgiveness
just because they like the job. They like staying there.
But some,
I know some people are looking for an opportunity to either reduce their hours
to go part time or to switch to a private employer where you can earn a lot more
money for the time that you're putting in at work.
So I'll I'll double check and get back to you on that one.
Let's listen to another one.
Hi, I have super old loans.
I started college in 1999 and so I have old loans under that FFEL program.
I then changed careers in 2009.
I went back to school for grad school and now I have a big loan balance.
I'm currently in the old IBR and I've made payments in that since 2013.
So I'm wondering if I consolidate and get in a save program,
are all of these 10 years of payments going to count or am I wasting my money?
Thanks. Bye.
This person needs to hurry up and consolidate absolutely everything ASAP because
this loan from 99 could get credited towards the entire balance that she's got
from the more recent graduate loans. And you know, if all things work out well,
if you've been in repayment or forbearance of some kind since 99,
the only thing you wouldn't get credit for would be in school deferment.
Probably when you were borrowing for grad school in that interim period.
So let's say you're in a grad school program for, you know,
three years and you've been in repayment or forbearance or deferment since 99,
basically that's 24 years minus three or four years for grad school.
That's 20 years towards forgiveness. You might need five more years.
So this is literally showing the massive impact of the IBR waiver.
A lot of times people get scared because they've heard that if you consolidate,
you wipe away your credit. That's normally true. That's not true right now.
It's the opposite. And then, you know,
what's going to happen in December 31st is it's going to be weighted average,
which is somewhere in between wiping everything away and getting loans credited
with the loan with the oldest max count. So yeah,
hurry up and go to studentaid.gov and consolidate.
We have a little redirect link because the website is kind of weird.
So studentloanplanner.com slash consolidate will take you to the right place.
If you want a shorter URL to remember, let's listen to the next one.
Hello.
I am trying to figure out what to do with my student loans as they
come due here fairly soon.
I am currently on the IBR plan or the
income based repayment plan,
and I'm considering the new save plan.
I was wondering if you switch from,
say the IBR plan to the save plan,
if you are easily able to switch back to say the
income based repayment plan or another income driven plan,
if something were to happen to this new save plan in the future.
Also, as I was looking at the studentaid.gov website,
there's a section here that says end of interest capitalization when a
borrower leaves most IDR plans.
And it says as of July 1st, 2023,
unpaid interest on your loans won't be added to your principal when you
leave any IDR plan,
except the income based repayment plan where capitalization is
required by statute.
I do not understand what that is saying.
If I switch from IBR to the save plan,
am I going to have some sort of capitalization on the interest
to do that switch?
If you could explain that for me and also regarding
my previous question about going back and forth between different plans,
I would appreciate it. Thank you.
What that means is basically Department of Ed wanted to do as much as they
possibly could do for people,
unless the law explicitly prohibited them from doing something.
So in this particular case, the income based repayment plan,
when you leave that plan and enter another plan,
it literally requires in the law clear as day that you have to capitalize the
interest. What that means is let's say you were accruing interest in grad school,
that balance is added to an accrued interest bucket instead of the principal
bucket. And then when you exit repayment,
it used to always be that everything capitalized and you had a new principal
balance based off of that total amount.
Now we think that's going to happen only basically by consolidating or leaving
the IBR plan. So you might say, is that bad? Sounds so terrible.
Capitalizing it's that kind of almost sounds like a capital punishment,
right? I mean, that's like,
that's what kind of maybe some people's minds would jump to.
It's not that at all because of the save plan, if your income's low,
you get interest subsidies, right? So if your interest subsidy, you know,
if you have an income that results in interest subsidies,
what matters is your effective rate. And the only thing, you know,
interest accrual, uh, the interest accrued interest bucket impacts is just,
what is your effective interest rate? That's the only thing that matters for.
So if you can get a really low effective interest rate by the same plan,
capitalizing your interest is no big deal at all.
I will say that one of the big things people will mess up on is getting off the
IBR plan if their payment's really low,
because maybe you recertified and using a 2018 tax return that showed you making
30 K for three months that you, after you graduated your program, uh,
I'm just throwing out a hypothetical here at your payments,
like a hundred a month. And now you're making two 50 as, you know,
corporate counsel somewhere. And you're, you know,
your payments would be 2000 a month or 1500 a month or something like that.
If you switch to save, uh,
you can still go for forgiveness or something like that.
I'm just throwing out some hypothetical numbers here.
So that case you could cost yourself tons of money by applying for the same
plan.
Because what's going to happen is they're going to ask you for that most recent
tax return if you switch. So this is a hazard, big hazard.
It's why kind of,
I think that there's not a lot of downside to people who are on like a pay or an
IBR just to wait until 2024 deep breaths and like sort of wait to
switch to the same plan,
just to make sure one that you're not recertifying early with a much higher
income. And two, just to let the dust settle a little bit,
they just threw out tons of regulations and servicers are going to be swamped.
It's going to be a big mess.
And it might be kind of good for some people just wait.
Now the downside to waiting is the idea of waiver going away.
That'd be a disaster for certain people that could be benefiting from that. Um,
in terms of being able to get back onto the IBR plan.
So the same plan has a rule in it that basically says if you are on this plan for
more than five years, between 2024, July, 2024,
and after that, you can't switch onto anything else. So what that means is,
you know, say you're on it as of July, 2024,
the first state that you're locked into the same plan forever is July, 2029.
Now the pay plan goes away in July of 2024 for people that are trying to get new
access to it. So if you're already on the pay-as-you-earn plan,
you can keep it after that date,
but anybody who wants to sign up for it on a new basis after July, 2024,
cannot.
And so the people that don't have to really worry about that at all are people
that are new borrowers as of July, 2014,
that had no balance of student loans before that date.
Because in that case you qualify for new IBR,
which means that if you're a new borrower as of July, 2014,
then you have access to essentially what's the same thing as the pay plan.
Pretty much new IBR is basically the same thing as the pay plan.
And you have access to that all the way up until July of 2029.
So what are some of the catches or what are the,
some of the things that I'm worried about?
There is a possibility that let's say you have a Republican win in
2028 and they wait until nobody can switch out of the save
plan.
And then they redo the regulations and switch everybody back onto the
repay plan. No longer people have the ability to file taxes separately. You know,
that's a possibility. I'm not saying it's a probability. I mean, certainly,
you know,
Republicans want to win elections too and they are going to do things that
appeal to voters and especially like highly educated voters disproportionately
in the suburbs of swing States, right? Like, so you're going to try to,
you know, modulate your positions to appeal to the audience.
You need to, it's not necessarily saying they would do that,
but it's something to think about. I mean,
there is some benefit to being at a plan like pay and it was sort of forgotten
about left behind because it probably means that people aren't going to mess
with it. The save plan. I mean, it's extremely generous.
It's extremely opposed by Republicans.
It's a big obvious issue now that people will pay attention to on the GOP side
of things. And just to let you guys know this,
like a GOP Congress person on the education committee literally called into the
negotiated rulemaking committee while they were making these new rules and said
essentially like a throw down. He was like,
don't make these rules too aggressive or the next time we're in charge,
we're just going to undo everything you did and go farther.
I'll talk about that in a new and then a podcast episode in the future.
I don't want to just create worry to just create worry, but it's,
it's a possibility. It's not necessarily a probability, right?
But there are some benefits to using a plan like pay that's going to get left
behind or especially new IBR that's in the statute that can't be modified
without 60 votes in the Senate. But that's sad.
Save plan if you're getting benefits from it.
Nobody's taking those benefits away while you're on it.
So if you can get benefits from it, absolutely do the same plan.
Benefit all you can from it. It's no harm in that.
No bad idea in that at all. So let's, let's do another one next.
I had a question.
If we amended our tax return for the year 2022
from married filing joint to married filing
single, would they accept that on an income driven plan?
So we'll just make this the last question.
You cannot amend from joint to separate.
You can only amend from separate to joint.
What that usually means is you file separate and that helps you. Great. Use it.
Sometimes you can get a lot of money back if you amend from separate to joint.
And the most common case we apply this in is PSLF where somebody has a final
three or four years that they're trying to get the minimal payments,
but they have a big tax hit from separate.
So you do separate for a few years and then you go and amend it at the end.
You can do that three years in the past.
So you can amend a bunch of returns all at once with 1040 X,
but you cannot go from joint to separate.
What we would suggest instead is that you take advantage of the on-ramp
forbearance,
which is something that it's probably best achieved by just calling your
servicer and asking for forbearance.
I would really suggest this to anybody whose payment would go down next year
compared to what it is right now.
So that's most commonly people who filed joint that should have filed separate
and people who have only undergrad loans that could pay 5% of income on save
versus 10, because that regulation doesn't go into effect until July, 2024.
So if you need to do that then I would just go into that forbearance status
and then file your, once you get your tax return in correctly,
you can go recertify your income again and get a lower payment.
And that question is a very minorly complex
question compared to a lot of the stuff we get with taxes.
And so that's one of the reasons why we have decided to get into the tax
preparation business because of just how many people would use a CPA or a tax
person and would have no clue what we were talking about when we said to file
separately or to file a form 8958 or split the income or, you know,
whatever, you know, amending the returns. I mean, you know,
the tax folks just look at folks just like, like, uh,
you got five eyes or something like that. Right.
And so we are going to only offer that service to folks who are also clients of
SLP wealth. And we will talk more about that in some future podcast episodes.
So just know that that's coming down the pipeline.
But if you have a rapidly increasing income,
if you live in one of the nine community property States,
if you have concerns about married filing separately and how it affects your
ability to do a Roth IRA or the dependent child tax credit or the capital loss
deduction, you know,
we are going to be able to give really expert level help on that pretty soon.
I'm excited to share. So for now, that is a lot of questions.
It's a little bit longer episode than we usually do.
I apologize that we had so many to get through today.
Obviously there's a whole lot of questions with repayment going on, right?
So if you have a question or a comment about what's going on with student loan
repayment about stuff that you're seeing, we'd love to hear it.
So go to studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail,
and you can just use your phone to just talk into that phone and leave a quick
message as to what you're seeing or questions you have about what your payment
should be.
We'd love to feature some more listener questions on a future pod episode.
So studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
And then of course, if you need a student loan plan book now,
because you need a book now or almost forever, hold your peace.
It's kind of getting to that point because we're running up on the end of the
year.
We do have a limited capacity despite tripling the size of our consultant team.
And so we want as many people as possible to get the IDR waiver benefits that we
can humanly help.
And so we would suggest you go to studentloanplanner.com slash book to get on
our calendar for that.
A lot of these questions show the complexity of student loans. It's hard.
It's dumb, shouldn't be this hard, but it is.
And we'd love to kind of put that loan burden behind you.
Or if you're an existing client, we can refresh your plan.
A lot of people haven't talked to us since the pandemic and there's a whole
bunch of changes that have happened.
So it'd be good to get a refresher if you need one of those.
And of course, if you're a client of SLP Wealth, just reach out to your advisor.
That's included.
You can kind of do a refresher on your plan if you need one.
Thanks everyone for listening to the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
Hope you have a wonderful rest of your week.
