This Is What "Always" Happens To Investments After An Election

Coin Crunch
8 followers
Nov 7, 2024
This Is What "Always" Happens To Investments After An Election
Every four years, America picks a president, and investors start to lose sleep,
wondering if the selection that voters make is going to ruin their portfolio for the next four
years. But what if I told you the biggest secret about the elections and your money
isn't what happens on election night. In fact, there's a fascinating pattern about election
years and market performance that most financial advisors rarely discuss with their clients,
one that challenges everything you think you know about politics and your portfolio.
In this video, I'm going to show you exactly how markets really behave before and after election
years, and what you need to do to survive. Plus, I'll explain why Wall Street analysts
secretly watch the Super Bowl for market predictions, and what that has to do with
the relationship between the stock market and elections. And no, this isn't about whether
Democrats or Republicans are better for your portfolio. The truth is far more interesting
and profitable. But before we get into it, my name is Nolan Mathias, and if you want the truth
about finances, and if you believe that there's always opportunity in crisis, then this is the
place for you. So do me a favor, hit the subscribe button and hit the like button so more people like
you can see this video. In order to begin our conversation about presidential election cycles
and how it affects the stock market and your investments going forward, it makes sense to
start by discussing the presidential election cycle theory. This is the theory that US markets
follow a cyclical pattern aligned with presidential terms. Notably, the first two years of any new
president is pretty lackluster. And then typically in the third year, there tends to be a pretty
strong performance, while the fourth year almost always leads to complete uncertainty depending on
who's running and what the outlook looks like for the next president. And this theory stems from
historical observations. Markets typically show weaker performance in the first two years of a
presidential term. Now, typically, typically, the market tends to go in whatever direction it was
going before the actual election. And it becomes pretty clear that who is voted on as president
actually doesn't have an immediate effect on the stock market. Even though CNN and CNBC will tell
you that the first 100 days is the most important and that after the election, any changes in the
stock market are very much based on who was elected. The reality is that's just not true.
But as the next election draws closer, there tends to be economic efforts to boost the economy. And
as a result, we often see in the third year of a presidential term, the economy get a little bit
better. And subsequently, the stock market get a little bit better as well. Because for an incumbent,
what happens in the third year and leading into the fourth year very much determines whether or
not they will be reelected. As many presidents who have had recessions in the third and fourth years
of their terms find themselves out of office very, very quickly. But in times where the economy is
good, the likelihood of an incumbent being reelected is much higher. And this whole theory
is based on observable patterns from the past. So in other words, while it is just a theory,
and by no means is it a hard and fast rule, over the last 50 to 75 years, this has typically been
what has happened leading up to those presidential elections. But there are exceptions and limitations
to this rule. The cycle is by no means foolproof. For example, there was very strong performance in
Donald Trump's first year in office. This is likely attributable to the fact that Donald Trump
was very much business friendly. And when you have a president who makes it clear that his focus
is on making the economy better and making the environment better for businesses, it makes sense
that the stock market would go up in value. Because rules and laws that affect businesses
in a positive manner are obviously going to increase the bottom line of those businesses.
But that being said, as much as presidents would like to take full credit for when the economy is
good, and challengers would like to put full blame on a president when the stock market hasn't
performed as well as it should, the reality is that presidential influence has limited influence
over what happens in the stock market. In fact, more often than not, it is external and global
economic factors that play a bigger role. And you'll start to understand a little bit more about
this when we talk about the Superbowl and how it affects the stock market. But the reality here is
that the president's role in the stock market and the economy has some significant reliability
issues primarily because of varying economic contexts. And what I mean by that is the fact
that there's so much more to the economy and the stock market than who's carrying the nuclear
football, so to speak. So next we need to talk about historical market patterns during elections.
And the market performance in election years historically shows lower returns than non-election
years. Now this past year would obviously be an exception to that. But again, a lot of the rise
in the stock market is probably not due to who was in control of the country and who the president
was. And there's 75 years of data to support this trend. Yes, there's always going to be one-off
situations where the data doesn't follow. But for the most part, during an election year, there
tends to be lower returns. And this is primarily due to the fact that there's higher volatility
in those election years because of the uncertainty of what could potentially happen in the future,
which leads many people to take their money and put it on the sidelines until they have
complete certainty over who is going to run the country, even though who's running the country
may not actually matter. And this highlights the election's influence on market sentiment.
And keep in mind that the stock market over the long term is very much a value of the growth of
investments. But over the short term, it is very much a measure of the market bets. And when less
people are making those bets, you can expect that there are in fact going to be lower returns.
And there's very much fear from both sides, whether you're Democrat or Republican. There's
always fear about who will be the next president and what that will do to the economy and your
investments. But here's the truth. Stabilization occurs post-election as uncertainties reduce.
So in other words, as soon as it is ironclad who the next president will be, the market sentiment
tends to stabilize. And as a result, stock market performance tends to flatten out. And as a result,
things very much go back to normal. And what is interesting here is it doesn't matter who is
elected, whether it's Democrat or Republican. What matters is that the market starts to understand
what it is up against for the next four years and can make their investment decisions accordingly.
Now, when it comes to the impact of the election results on the markets, well, believe it or not,
markets perform well under both Democratic and Republican leadership. Just because there's a
change in the president doesn't mean that the U.S. and the U.S. economy is going to stop doing U.S.
and U.S. economy things. And it doesn't mean that the economy is all of a sudden going to shift
and collapse purely because of a change in political control. In fact, the political
party often does not directly affect the long-term market trends. Now, there are some exceptions to
that, which I've discussed in another video, which I'll link to at the end. And that more
has to do with the makeup of the total government than just who is president. But for the most part,
who is president really doesn't have a significant effect on long-term market trends. What matters
is that the market adapts to whoever is in power. If one party is elected and there's going to be
certain rules that affects the market, the market will adjust in order to make sure that those rules
have less of an impact on the investments. It's really that simple. So now let's talk about what's
more important than the actual presidential elections. The first is the broader economic
conditions. Things like inflation, corporate earnings, these are all more influential than
elections themselves. Then there's the economic fundamentals that outweigh the political factors
in the market performance. Things like debt to GDP, things like the actual GDP numbers,
things like inflation, things like interest rates. And as a general rule, aside from two or three
months leading up to an election every four years, the focus for the markets is typically on real
economic indicators rather than election outcomes. The reality is that the election outcomes have
very little effect on the long-term market direction. Now, that's not to say that it isn't
always true that the election has a major effect on the economy and the markets. In some cases,
there's been major economic recoveries under democratic administrations, but more than likely,
those economic recoveries would have happened anyways. The problem was that the economic
crashes happened under Republican watch, which made it less likely for them to get re-elected.
But it doesn't mean that the Republicans wouldn't have been able to have the same sort of recovery
after the fact. In most cases, it was more than likely just bad luck that the economic crashes
happened while a Republican president was in office. And in addition to that, we've often seen
resilience in markets under Republican fiscal policies. Obviously, the more business-friendly
the policies, the better the markets will do, and in all likelihood, the better the economy will get.
But regardless, the economic health of the U.S. is really not tied to a political party. In fact,
the foundation of the success of the U.S. economy is very much to do with the capitalist ideals that
have been in place since day one. And I can't emphasize this enough. Economic performance is
driven by structural factors, not party lines. It is driven by the way that the U.S. was built.
And the evidence for this is the fact that the U.S. stock market continues to climb regardless
of which party is in power. And economic stability, at the end of the day,
is a non-partisan characteristic. As much as presidential candidates would like to have you
believe that it makes a big difference who the next president is with respect to the economy
and the stock market, the truth is who gets elected is probably just a rounding error when
it comes to your investment. So let's round this out by talking about elections and market dynamics.
Electoral cycles introduce short-term volatility in the markets. Yes, that is true.
Leading up to an election, you will see the stock market start to flatten out. You will see people
less likely to make big bets because they have some uncertainty about who the next president will
be. But at the end of the day, the long-term performance remains relatively unaffected by
the specific officeholder. Markets adapt quickly, adjusting to new administrations,
which means, for the most part, that regardless of who is elected, your investments are probably
going to do just fine and will probably do a little bit better after the election cycle is
complete. Now, what gets interesting is that political gridlock actually adds to market
stability. So it's less about who is elected president and more about the total makeup of
the government. Markets tend to favor political gridlock, where there's going to be less policy
changes leading to less uncertainty, which leads to more certainty about the fact that markets will
increase. And real stability arises when opposing parties control different government branches.
For example, when the president is Republican, maybe the House is controlled by the Democrats
and Congress is controlled by Republicans. In fact, there's some really interesting data around
this, which, like I said, I'll link to a video at the end of this one that talks about exactly that.
But political gridlock reduces the likelihood of sudden policy shifts. And the benefit to this
is market predictability, which, by the way, is the one thing which is significantly more
important than who the president is. And it might be argued that the predictability of the next
president is actually more important than who the next president will be. And while I'm not going to
make an argument over who is more predictable, I think an argument can be made for both sides.
And with respect to the next election, it's very clear that regardless of who gets elected,
there is going to be initial market fluctuations due to political outcomes,
or in other words, who gets elected. But the historical evidence tells us that this volatility
will be short lived. And the best strategy that an investor like you or I can have
is just to maintain a steady approach. Don't let who is elected dictate the moves that you
make in the stock market, whether that's going in on some sort of investment because you think
that the political landscape will favor it or pulling out all your money because you're scared
of what the next president is going to do. And here's the reality of what you should do.
And you've probably noticed a theme throughout most of my videos.
First is understand that elections add temporary excitement and uncertainty to the market.
This can go both in your favor or it can work against you. But you should have an emphasis
on solid economic fundamentals as the main market driver in your investment strategy.
Forget the noise, forget all the sensationalism, and just think about your investments as a long
term strategy that if you stick to over a long period of time, and I'm talking 20, 30, 40 years,
will inevitably work out in your favor. It is the market timing that makes people go broke
really, really quickly. It's the market timing that makes people lose money. But if you are
consistent, regardless of what's happening politically or in the economy, and you have
a strategy like an all weather portfolio, for example, where you have different types of assets
and you're diversified for risk, well, then regardless of what happens in the economy or in
elections, you should be better off. And that's where you need to really detach yourself from the
short term economic stories, the news, all of those things. You need to create a long term investment
plan, and you need to stay focused on it. Avoid being swayed by election year volatility, avoid
being swayed by the news. And with patience and economic insight, your portfolio can withstand
political, economic, and well, pretty much any other sorts of shifts that will affect it
temporarily. Oh, and that Super Bowl indicator that I was talking about, this is a fun market
myth. Since 1967, Wall Street traders have been watching the Super Bowl. And with 80% accuracy,
when the NFC teams win, the old NFL teams win, the market tends to rise that year. And when the
AFC wins, well, stocks often decline. But the question is, is this a coincidence or a pattern?
Well, there's no real basis for whether or not who wins the Super Bowl is actually going to affect
the stock market. And just like the winner of the Super Bowl has little to no effect on the stock
market, well, who wins the next election is probably going to also have little to no effect
on the stock market. Oh, and by the way, if you want to see that video where I talk about what's
more important and how the total makeup of the government is actually significantly more
important, make sure you check out this video right here.
