This Crazy Wind Turbine May Be The Future of Wind Energy

Industrial electrical equipment
1 follower
3 Video Views·Nov 7, 2024
Don't be confused. This is not a video on solar panels. You clicked on the right thumbnail.
But solar panels are a marvel, right? One of the neatest things about them is that they
can be used almost anywhere, from big farms to residential spaces and anything in between.
If only we could make other renewables, like wind power, just as versatile.
Well that's exactly what a company called Heirloom Energy is trying to do. They claim
they've developed a radically different kind of wind energy device. One that's much cheaper,
more flexible, and has the backing of Bill Gates. Given his cleantech investing success rate,
I'll let you decide if that's a badge of honor or a sign that this device is all hot air.
How does Heirloom work and is their radically different wind turbine design
going to change the game? I'm Matt Ferrell. Welcome to Undecided.
This video is brought to you by Incogne, but more on that later.
Have you ever loved a really bad B-movie? Like it's one of your favorite movies ever,
but you recognize that it's got serious flaws? Or that all your friends hate it?
I've got quite a few of those on my list. Now, I'm not saying what Heirloom is doing
is on that level at all. But as drawn as I am to what Heirloom is doing,
there are a lot of open questions to their approach. Before getting into those questions,
what are they doing in the first place? Inspired by his time windsurfing, Heirloom Energy founder
Robert Lumley began sketching out this novel wind energy generator almost a decade ago.
The result is a wind power device that looks more like a clothesline or a kinetic sculpture
than the turbines you're used to seeing across the country. But how does it work?
Well, a cable runs in a track on top of a series of 25 meter or 82 foot tall poles,
arranged in an oval. Put a pin in that oval idea for later.
Anyway, the vertically oriented 10 meter or 33 foot tall blades
are attached to the cable. They intercept the wind as it travels down both the home
and the back stretch of the cable's track. The blades move around the track, generating torque,
which is then translated into energy and sent to the grid. You know the drill.
Now, an 82 by 33 foot track sounds massive, but it's small compared to a standard horizontal
axis wind turbine. Most horizontal axis wind turbines operating at the moment are taller
than the Eiffel Tower, and China just launched an offshore turbine 50 stories tall. Why so big?
Well, simply put, bigger blades capture more energy and taller towers allow for bigger blades.
Plus, they elevate the blades up to where the air currents are strong and consistent,
which is very important for energy production. However, the Airloom device sidesteps those big
parts. It's long, low to the ground, and transportable. They also claim that the
device is modular, with the length and height of the track being customizable.
These features should allow their device to be deployed to places where bigger turbines
just can't fit. That said, the most exciting part of the Airloom device is the alleged cost
savings. Large turbines are expensive to manufacture, ship, install, and maintain,
making for a large levelized cost of energy, or LCOE. That's a calculation of an energy
producer's lifetime costs measured against how much juice it makes. I'm not talking about orange
juice here. If the Airloom device works as promised, it could radically lower wind energy's
LCOE costs, maybe by as much as 66%. For reference, the current LCOE on a wind farm is about $0.04
per kWh. Airloom claims they can do it for just over a penny. Of course, that's a pretty big
if, accompanied by some too-good-to-be-true sounding numbers. So how does this relatively
small device make as much energy as a horizontal axis wind turbine? With a little bit of airbending
trickery. By running their airfoils in an oval rather than a circle, Airloom claims they alter
the math behind swept area. That's the area that the blades of a turbine sweep through as they
extract energy from the air. As we mentioned earlier, the bigger the area, the more efficient
the turbine. However, that necessitates bigger turbines and bigger blades, which limits where
the turbines can be deployed. Airloom's swept area is a function of track length, as opposed
to the radius of a horizontal axis wind turbine's blades. Where your average horizontal wind axis
turbine gets maximum torque from the fast-moving tips of its blades, but not much from the bits
closest to the hub, the full length of each of Airloom's system's blades contribute to hauling
the whole loop around. Essentially, instead of a few large blades on a vertical structure,
that energy capture potential is distributed across many smaller blades moving horizontally,
or at least Airloom claims. It's neat, but has it been tested? Does it actually work?
Well, the answer is a very, very tentative yes. Airloom has a 50 kW testing device set up in
Wyoming, and though testing has just begun, everything seems to be going according to plan.
Airloom just secured $4 million in seed funding, spearheaded by Breakthrough Energy Ventures.
With the early tests going well, they're preparing to move forward with a 1 MW prototype,
with plans to eventually scale up to a 2.5 MW real deal. But, at least at the time of writing
this video, I can't find any evidence or even claims that third-party tests have been conducted,
which certainly is a reason to raise an eyebrow. We'll return to this lack of outside assessment
in a moment, but first, theoretically, let's assume Airloom really has cracked the code
and made a wind energy device as powerful as a horizontal access wind turbine,
for a fraction of the initial cost and LCOE. How are they doing this, and why use it over
a regular turbine? Well, speaking of harnessing powerful forces and putting it to good use,
there's another powerful force you can put to protect your online privacy,
and that's today's sponsor Incogbay. I've mentioned this before, but I signed up for
a newsletter from a small online retailer, and after I did, I saw a major increase
in the number of promotional emails I was receiving from companies I'd never heard of.
That happened because that company sold my information to a data broker. Sometimes they
sell your info to some pretty shady people, or they can fall victim to data breaches that
leak your data to scammers. I'm sure you've experienced it too. Incogni can help you with
this. We have the right to request that data brokers delete our information, but it takes a
lot of time and effort. I signed up for Incogni, gave them the legal right to work on my behalf,
and then just sat back and relaxed. You'll see updates in your account for which data
brokers they've sent legal requests to and which ones have complied. Couldn't be easier.
I've been letting Incogni stay on top of this for me for quite a while now and I'm really happy
with the results. If you want to take back some of the control around who has access to your
personal information, give Incogni a try. The first 100 people to use the code UNDECIDED at
link below will get 60% off Incogni. Thanks to Incogni and to all of you for supporting the
channel. So back to why you may want to use heirloom over a regular turbine. Heirloom
proposes using readily sourced materials and parts to make sure there's minimal supply chain,
shipping, or manufacturing headaches. These parts are small and are made from widely available
materials, so they can be manufactured in non-specialist factories. You're talking
about small airfoils, metal structures and tracks versus aircraft carrier sized wind turbine blades.
Combine that with their device's relatively small size and they claim manufacturing their device
will cost just 10% of an equivalent horizontal axis wind turbine's price tag.
Then there's the shipping costs, and this one is a big one. The sheer size of wind turbine blades
mean it can be a logistical nightmare to physically ship them, usually from China,
to their final destinations. Plus, it's very expensive to ship heavy things like, you know,
giant carbon fiber blades and steel pylons. And goofy as it might seem, tight turns,
tunnels, and bridges can all become huge turbine transit problems. It can take over a year of
planning and 10 separate loads to move just one turbine into place. Meanwhile, heirloom can fit
an entire 2.5 megawatt track inside a standard tractor trailer. The smaller, modular size has
other alleged benefits too. We mentioned previously how the device can be adjusted in both length and
height to fit a larger variety of sites, including places where traditional turbines just can't go.
While we usually mean places where other turbines physically can't be deployed,
it might also allow us to build wind energy generators in places they aesthetically can't
be deployed either. A lot of wind projects get canceled because people really don't want big
turbines in their line of sight. For example, New Jersey just lost two offshore wind farms
because residents didn't want the turbines to ruin their beachy views. And they're far from
the only example, despite wind energy's broad support and approval ratings. People hate having
them in their backyard. But the smaller, shorter profile should make heirloom's device ... how do
I say this politely? ... NIMBY resistant. And while we're talking about offshore wind,
heirloom claims that their device works great for both on and offshore purposes.
Though again, they haven't presented any information about what that might look like.
How much more feasible is it to build a long wind track instead of a single platform?
I have questions. Back to cost savings though. Taking into account the cheaper materials,
manufacturing, shipping, and installation, heirloom calculates that its wind farms could
be built for less than 25% of the cost to build a conventional wind project. Just $0.21 per watt,
compared to the standard $1.25 per watt. Add in the lower maintenance costs and you can start to
see why heirloom's projected LCOE is so low. LCOE varies from site to site, but with an LCOE at just
over a penny per kilowatt hour, by some accounts wind could surpass solar as the cheapest form of
energy generation. But this is the point where we have to get real. Call me cynical, but the lack
of third party testing is a stark and serious red flag for right now. Heirloom has only recently
come out of stealth mode, so it's possible these tests are on the way. I would assume they are,
but until some national labs have vetted their work and some economists who know their way around
green tech have given this a thumbs up, we just won't know how well it works or how cost effective
it will be in the real world. And that's a bigger deal. I hate to say it, but historically speaking
there's good reason to be critical of heirloom's device. They're not the only group to try to
revolutionize the wind energy sector with smaller or cheaper devices. There's Shearwind Invilox,
Safon Energy, Transpower, and many, many others. All these options looked good on paper,
more or less, but so far none have proved to be viable. Disconcertingly, Transpower's device looks
an awful lot like Heirloom's, and they fell apart in the 1980s. But that may have fallen apart
because the time wasn't right and the technology is here now to make it viable. We'll have to wait
and see on that one. But there's also some conventional wind engineering wisdom reasons
to doubt Heirloom's design. As we touched on earlier, there's a lot of reasons turbines have
been getting taller. Tall masts and big blades give you a certain kind of efficiency and consistency
that anything lower to the ground is going to struggle to match. Turbulence is a major issue
for wind turbines too, especially small turbines, since it can reduce a turbine's annual energy
output by 15-25%. So how do you get away from that turbulence? Unfortunately for small and
low-lying turbines, you go above it. The general rule of thumb is to install a wind turbine on a
tower with the bottom of the rotor blades at least 30 feet or 9 meters above an obstacle
that's within a 300 foot or 90 meter radius of the tower. So even if Heirloom can truly make
radically cheaper turbines, it won't matter if the turbines aren't able to consistently and
effectively generate energy due to weak winds or turbulence. I haven't even touched on some
of the questions that came up with my team around things like dirt buildup and friction
with the track system over time. How will that impact performance? There's so many open questions.
To be fair, Heirloom is in the early stages, so third-party tests are likely to come.
And with the backing of Gates and the promising round of seed funding, Heirloom has a solid
financial base that might help them navigate some of the upcoming challenges. They say they'll be
building a pilot project in 2025 with plans to build a commercial demonstration connected to
the grid by 2026 or 2027. So we shouldn't have to wait very long to find out if their device
actually works or not. Despite some of my skepticism, innovation does happen and maybe
Heirloom really does have the magic formula for cheaper, better wind power. At the same time,
this sector is also littered with devices that sounded good on paper, but just couldn't work
in the field for whatever reason. Often a device passes every test and almost makes the leap to
commercialization only for some small detail to ultimately prove that it's just not economically
viable. As a science and technology communicator, I have a Carl Sagan quote quota that I have to meet.
So here it goes. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And a device that could
transform the energy sector? That's definitely extraordinary. So I'll be watching Heirloom
closely. Fingers crossed they live up to the hype. But what do you think? Is Heirloom onto
something or is it just hype? Jump in the comments and let me know. And be sure to check out my
follow-up podcast, Still To Be Determined, where I'll be discussing some of your feedback. And
thanks to all my Patrons who get ad-free versions of every video. Your support really does help to
keep delivering you these videos every single week. If you'd like to support the channel and
get in on the early videos, check out the link in the description. I'll see you in the next one.
