Architecture of the City by Aldo Rossi

Lost Treasures
16 followers
1 Video View·Nov 6, 2024
It discusses the idea of architecture as an urban artifact and how architecture creates its embedded condition in the city through various interpretation of history and geography.
We are going to discuss Aldo Rossi's Architecture of the City today.
Aldo Rossi is a very important architect and urbanist in the time frame. He wrote this book
Architecture of the City during very important phase of development of architecture and urbanism
not only in Europe but across the world. This book has influenced the architects and urbanists
of the generation of time. If one look at the timeline of architecture of the city,
one can understand the position which is you know right from 60s where Lynch talked about
imagability, Venturi's on complexity and contradiction, you have serial vision in 61
and if you just go further away you will see the planning of Milton Keynes in 72,
Pompidou Center very important urban buildings and then 78 Leon Krier's Rational Architecture.
So there is a certain sense of order of inquiry how each architect and urbanist
raise the questions about cities and how really they shape various manifestations and various
processes around the world in understanding of cities. So there are various processes
that involved in mapping and reading of cities. One can identify clearly you know the spatial
model, morphological model, then there are visual perceptual models, social and functional model.
While today we are looking at contextual model where you are looking at various aspects of urban
setting and architecture as an artifact within that and there are models which are far more
consequential in terms of the climate change and global theories and you know
urbanism in global conversation. We will be discussing this subsequently you know in this
series and one can even look at the chronology of various keywords that have emerged over a
period of time right from basic understanding of cities you know of figure ground theories
to you know idea of behavioral settings and cultural pluralism, simple thing like network
theories, betweenness, closeness, greatness, gravities and stuff like that which are which
are involving different kind of network, very complex network and they are different from
the way we do the morphological study but one you know begins to overlay network understanding
on a morphological pattern you know one is able to in a better position to articulate the
relationship. Now this book is very important from the perspective of urbanism because
it is written by Alderossi from a particular context. This is Italy and there were
history of writing of various kind of theoretical propositions on architecture and urbanism.
What you see the image is by Giuseppe Tarani who began to question
the functionalist movement in architecture. This is way back in you know late 30s,
you know early 40s and when world around you know was trying to revolutionize their
understanding of architectural form coming through a certain kind of a functional logic.
Now Italian classicism had certain tradition of looking at certain sense of logic,
I mean renaissance looked at certain logic of you know anthropocentric architecture.
Similarly there are various traditions across the time which engaged with various kind of logic.
Giuseppe Tarani looked at idea of you know structural logic of the functional logic
of modernist, the machine aesthetics of modernist and how it can really shape
architecture that is that is supposedly a public in nature and this is similarly
another geography where you know another group was exploring the various housing typologies
or Russian constructivist. So Italy has the tradition of looking at larger theoretical
discourse emanating out of architecture but reaching to a large urban question.
There are two aspects of you know this theoretical ideas that Aldorossi talked about
which is exactly opposite to what Pietro Eisenman talked about synthetical model
where architecture is subservient to itself and the very idea of urban question is embedded into
the investigating of self that is architecture as an object. While Aldorossi is exactly opposite
to that he looks at the question of architecture as a regional model. It means architecture is not
just urban but it's a regional question. So to begin with Ross's understanding of
architecture and city starting from his inspiration from the Cerrico's painting on
public piazzas. Cerrico actually painted piazzas with very peculiar characteristics.
One can see a building in perspective, one can see a fine horizon line,
one can also see a deep shadows and most prominently it has objects which are part
of the piazzas but not necessarily related to piazzas. Now one looks at this idea of
this unrelated objects in piazzas, it allows ones to ask larger questions,
it allows ones to kind of move into a kind of a metaphysical excursion of looking at
the other city. A city which is which is not the same but city which is analogous to
the existing one and it is it says that we live in city which is which is always
you know elsewhere-ness. The embeddedness of our city exists in elsewhere-ness.
So there are a few components that he is talking about in his book. One is the memory.
Memory is something that you know we all carry with ourselves when we look at
you know architecture, city, events, any phenomena. I know we always have that kind
of a thing depends on our exposure, depends on where we come from, our cultural background and
thing like that. Analogy is something where we always kind of you know relate something what
comes next to that thing you know or next to that object or event. So you know when you
talk about you know Pink Floyd, you talk about music you know that's analogy. So
cities always has this kind of analogical structure you know and we tend to kind of
live in that kind of analogical structure simultaneously. Typology is all you understand
that you know building types that emerge in any geographical historical context.
Very important part propelling monuments and pathological monument. He began to look at these
two ideas where some buildings are in a propelling state. They are constantly in use. They are
functional. They are engaging you know urbanity at large. So they are propelling monuments and
there are pathological monuments means these monuments are they just exist. They do not
participate in urbanity in any way in terms of activity, in terms of people. They are just there
by sheer historic you know importance. So these two aspects are very important when you do the
urban analysis. Then you have a geography and history of the place, the region. It could be
defined purely in terms of the features, characteristics. You can define in terms of
the mythology and you can define in terms of the various you know evolutionary pattern of the
particular region. Then you have urban artifacts. He calls architecture is an urban artifact. It
means within urban conditions there are various things that exist. Buildings, people, you have
nature, you have history, geography. They all become urban artifacts and they make an event.
So I think the shift from architecture as an individual buildings to an architecture as an
urban artifact is a very important shift. And then you have locus. It means the sense of place
kind of a thing. Locus all of us understand in mathematical term but in spatial term it is a
sense of place. And there are four other aspects which I think are very important. History as we
learn are about facts and effects you know in terms of the dates, in terms of the events,
in terms of the heroicness, in terms of winner, loser and stuff like that. But there are other
important part of history. He calls it historicism which is cause and imperatives.
What were the causes? And what were the imperatives? What has forced, pushed or what
has kind of you know superimposed on particular event? And what has caused that event? So
historicism is slightly you know theoretical because you tend to investigate into various
imperatives. For example, the construction of let us say or the Haussmannization of Paris
is caused by certain things you know certain power structure, certain regime,
the reinforcement process and things like that. And once you begin to dissect you know various
secondary events you realize that architecture deals with many, many layers of power structure
and you know and it is very important to engage with historicism. Historicize is something very
important in I think contemporary times to make historically real. We often you know
engage in a situation where we are compelled to make something historically real you know.
These are again situational power attached to it and things like that. So historicize is something
one has to be really very careful you know understand it in detail. And historiography
is about writing and developing narrative of history and the historicism heavily depends
on historiography you know and begin to kind of see you know what is historicize in between,
what is real, what is not real, what is necessary, what is unnecessary. So I think as an urban
designer, as an urbanist it is very important to engage in this kind of conversation when you
talk about city. So his entire investigation, his practice, his research all came from certain
region in Italy. So that is very important that once you are based in certain region you
understand that kind of region better and then I think it is important that to write about that
region and engage with you know various manifestations, architectural manifestation
and various urban formations. I think makes sense in some way. So there are two aspects that he
talked about you know the city. City is a product of generating functional system of architecture.
It means there are various architecture, architectural situation exist and they
generate certain functionally networked system. All of you understand network now. So generating
functional systems of group of architecture, architectural buildings makes kind of a very
important system and they are you know there are spatial linkages. We also discussed spatial
linkages earlier and this linkages kind of put the entire architectural system
is a one functional system with many layers. Then he talked about the analysis of form
through socio-political economic system. So functional system is depending on socio-political
and economic system while spatial linkages depend on architecture, geography and history.
So how this linkages evolved I mean we will discuss this linkages in other presentation
different kind of linkages. We have discussed some basics but this would
the subsequent lecture will kind of elaborate more in detail.
So idea of kind of you know urban form is a product of generative functional system
and of spatial linkages. So what he talks about you know idea of
the modernist city you know the modernist city as a criticism as a starting point
where you know city constitutes kind of a you know of variable data and autonomous
kind of a point of view. It means there is a sense of kind of a sense of neutrality in
dealing with cities. So he calls it reductive scienticism the way the modernist cities are you
know and unlike he began to put an argument that urban history and geography cannot be detached.
Cannot be detached when we look at city only as a reductive process of you know of
scientific understanding and also he started you know discussing this idea of object and subject
of city through history and typology. So you know where history becomes analogy of skeleton.
Now this is where he talks about analogical architecture. It means typologies that you
develop has some sense of semblance with the history somewhere it is connected and that's
what he calls it there is an imprint of action taken place. It means some actions taken at some
point of time in history certain typologies have emerged and architecture that fits into
that kind of system there is a kind of a skeletal understanding of the history.
So when he talks about typology he talks about skeletal form skeletal understanding of typology
where certain forms you reduced and you know to a point that it cannot be further you know
extracted beyond some point. So this is where skeletal understanding comes and the idea of you
know skeletal and historicity he calls it analogous to theoretical set. It means that this
kind of architecture and urban setting should be understood as a theoretical set where you know
people are engaged with on a temporary basis and spatio-temporal basis. Now this is exactly
in you know opposition to the way autonomous cities of modernism where you try to kind of
divide cities with various functional zoning various activity based kind of a zoning.
While Rossi is talking about activity kind of a morphed into each other and it brings certain
different kind of flavors and different kind of phenomena to the city. So he calls urban
artifacts as a kind of a you know permanence there is a degree of permanence in that artifacts
because they are going to be there for many many years and also he called city is an event
and this event needs to be understood with this permanence that is architecture.
So event and permanence they come together they make city they make urban form
and then when they come together there are certain compositional and combinational rules.
This is what he is calling architecture of the city and this is what he called the typology and
skeletal understanding of history. How they can come and how can they can fit together
that's something we need to learn from history and geography. So he is talking about you know
how cities are you know understood as a phenomena by people who live there people who visit cities.
So he's calling a kind of a you know autonomous researcher you know each of us no matter how
long we lived in city we are still independent autonomous because we live with our memory.
We live with lots of lots of memories about cities or about elsewhereness and we are still
exploring our cities. So one side you carry your memory other side you have an inventory kind of
understanding you want to kind of find out new things about cities and the analogical city the
analogous city is exactly suspended between the inventory and memory. So you are constantly
negotiating between these two you know when you when you when you wants to understand cities or
you experience cities or experience events or visit places within your own city and as I think
your memory and inventory kind of a matures over a period of time your understanding of city also
grows in deeper sense. So this is one of the project that he did long back I think in 80s
where I'll discuss this project a little bit in detail very interesting project
and Aldo Rossi has a very peculiar way of making drawings please understand this
and in this drawing also you can see buildings you can see some object flying from somewhere
you know so very strangely you know that Giorgio Chirico's you know
the art form is emerging in kind of all kind of drawings. So he is not talking about you know
any particular language but the language that has emerged you know in certain time
and language it has evolved it's like a dialect you know which has evolved it may not have a
specific historical point of departure but it has over a period of time overlapped with so many other
dialect and imbibe certain ways of you know developing communications architecture is seen.
So there is no clear point of departure but subsequently it has evolved over a period of
time he's talking about that aspects which is you know skeletal in nature so you need to engage in
kind of a sense of historicism you know and develop the understanding of that skeletal form
and that skeletal form is exactly where your nature of architecture and urban setting
kind of is embedded and which is product of memory and inventory simultaneously.
So this is the project that he did which is a theater on a raft and it floats around you know
it changes its context very interesting building and you know it has a several events organized
in several piazzas in Venice and building kind of a constantly you know in a state of
dynamics kind of a thing moves around and you know recontextualize. So it's very interesting
yet it looks as if it's a part of that geography. So the urban form is determined by simultaneous
action of dynamics that is propelling and you know and constraining forces which is
pathological presence and this kind of two ideas of pathology and permanence are constantly you
know are exchanging they often complement they often contradict they often cancel each other
out but I think the idea of the event that exists within these two aspects of architecture is
something where there is a sense of history and embeddedness you know could be discussed.
So there are several projects this is a town hall that he designed one can
not really say this is building which is designed new or building which existed historically.
It's quite confusing also when you look at the architectonics you know of the building
it has a lot of resemblance to perhaps many historical buildings in that area.
There is a presence of industrial kind of a you know look to this entire manifestation.
So this is this is exactly what you know Cherico's about that you are actually constantly
you know your experience of their architecture is constantly you know suspended between
inventory and memory. You want to find out what is it about at the same time you carry
some image like this one obviously is referring to Giorgio Cherico's MTP adsas deep shadows
the color tones are same and it evokes certain sense of kind of a you know introvertness at
some point. It allows you to have that very strange excursion in that other city and I think
this is very very important look and look at the color palette you can look at the material
textures the quality of light they all talk about kind of things that exist in kind of you know
the strange dream sequence of space and the city. As I said that he is he has a very particular you
know way of making drawings. So it's like you know you remove some part of the city and fit
the another with another part and that part is almost looking what was earlier or what exists
around and it has that so there is no kind of a you know strange characteristics suddenly coming
from nowhere or you know gestures which is which is alien to that context. The interesting
building it's a supermarket that he designed again very strange a plan is not clear but it has a you
enter through you know this space and that's a that's a shopping shopping center but the thing
is that if you look at the gesture you know somehow you know it because Turin is a region
where the Fiat the car the Fiat and Lamborghini comes from you know and it's a it's an industrial
town and some of these gestures are definitely you know coming from there and there is a you know
no kind of a straightforward signages but he uses those industrial feature as a kind of way to
advertise and it looks as if building has been remodeled and not really newly constructed.
This is the school of architecture again using existing buildings putting
new buildings on a high plinth creating axiality with library buildings with the
courtyard in the front this is the this is the library building that's access
this is the exhibition these are the five years five studios and lecture all together
and these are the existing buildings this is a water edge that's a section of the library building
so I'm slightly moving into architecture but just to give you an idea that how this argument of you
know city memory inventory anything like that how it really brings about the sense of that
metaphysical city that he keeps talking about. So I think all of you should pay attention to
these drawings the way they are drawn and understood you know with this context this
is a lighthouse that he designed he combined two functions of lighthouse and amphitheater
again very you know thoughtful very introvert kind of a thing it withdraws yet you know
looks at you know the water edge with the you know sense of openness kind of a thing
so I think architecture has that inbuilt you know complexity at the same time contradiction you know
and this sense of this two kind of things brings you know makes buildings to be far more responsive
than you know building which are just you know like an object that's exactly what he's talking
autonomous architecture and analogous architecture and this is the last slide
just to give you a little glimpse of what author has written on what ideas and what is the method
or a unit of analysis that is method so you know if you look at you know Camillo city composition
and principle we discussed this you know Corbusier comes here functionalism and composition and
technology Alderozzi somewhere here so some of these ideas we will look at it you know
in a later lectures but it is important that how each author is trying to understand read
and represent cities through different positions different methodology and how the unit of analysis
that emerge you know in understanding of the city. Thank you.
