LSAT Logic Games: Triggers for Making Worlds

LSAT(Law School Admission Test)
13 followers
1 Video View·Nov 4, 2024
Worlds is just a simple way of doing logic games where you, you kind of, all you're doing is
identifying the constraints of the game and then baking them into a solution. So the easiest
example is if you have a rule that says X must go forth, I would always build my first world
on that. I mean, I'm going to write out my, you know, let's say it's a game where you're
putting things in order. Could just as easily be a thing where you're putting things in groups.
Either way, if you're putting things in order and the rule says X goes forth, well, then the world
we're living in involves seven spaces, if that's what we're doing, seven spaces, and then you just
write X into the fourth spot. And if you do that, you are making worlds. You're making one world
because that's the world we're living in, the world where X goes forth. If that was the rule,
X always goes forth. Then of course, you're going to start with just put X into the fourth spot.
And that is worlds to me, even though it's only one world, it still is worlds because, well, that's
the world we're living in. We had a rule that said X had to go forth. I'm going to bake it into my
solution. X goes forth. That's the world we're living in. Now we will frequently end up splitting
our worlds because there's going to be, you know, not, some of the rules aren't going to just tell
you where players go, right? Some of the rules are going to be like, well, X has to go, uh, fourth
or sixth. If there was a rule that said X has to go fourth or sixth, then I very likely might split
into two worlds, a world where X is fourth and a world where X is sixth. Because now it's not just
one world that we're living in, but it's okay. There's the world where X is fourth and there's
the world where X is sixth. And all I'm trying to do is bake the rule into my solution so that I
don't have to continue to process the rule X must go forth or X must go sixth. So it might be one
world. It might be two worlds. It might be three worlds. You know, maybe there's a rule that says
X has to go second, fourth, or sixth. Well, I might choose that rule to make three templates.
X goes second, X goes fourth, X goes sixth. Although when I contemplate splitting in more than
two ways, or even if I contemplate just splitting two ways, I'm probably not going to do it unless
that rule is connected to some other rule in such a way that it makes me think that I'm going to
make a lot of progress by making that split. So what I wanted to start with today is just some
common triggers for when I'm going to make those splits. I guess I should start. The number one
trigger is, as I said, if they just tell you that someone has to go in a certain spot, or if they
tell you that someone can't go in a certain spot, then I'm probably going to just bake that into my
one world solution first. Because, hey, I can get rid of this rule by just putting X fourth, or I
can get rid of this one rule by writing down X not fifth, if that was the rule that X can't go fifth.
I will prefer a one world solution before I start making my splits. So yeah, if I've got an easy
rule that I can just bake right in with one world, then I'll start there. Some other common triggers,
though, just things for you to look out for when you're thinking about, okay, how do I want to
attack this game? Where should I start? I know that the team has told me that I can start anywhere.
The team has told me that it's improvisational. The team has told me that I really am allowed to
do this however I want to do it. Well, okay, how do you want to do it? Like, what's going to be the
efficient way to bake these rules into your one or more worlds? In no particular order, I want to
give you a few just kind of things to look out for when you're thinking about making worlds. So again,
number one, if they just tell you where somebody goes, please write that person into that spot.
If they say, you know, geography is always in the fall semester, well, then just write G
underneath fall. Don't write down that rule. Don't hold that rule for future contemplation. Instead,
just bake that rule into your setup. All right. If it's not as simple as that, if they don't just
tell you straight up where people go, common triggers include look for a player who is
mentioned in multiple rules. It's kind of obvious once you've seen this, you realize, well, yeah,
no shit. If somebody is mentioned in multiple rules, then that might be a good place to start.
What we're doing here is we're looking for bottlenecks and we're looking for an opportunity
to bake our rules into our solutions. So if there was a rule that was like X has to go
in an even spot, and then there's another rule that says X has to go before Y. Well, in that
case, I might look at my setup and go, and like for, let's just pretend here that we only have
five spots to play with, right? If I know that X has to go in an even spot, sorry, I meant to say
six spots to play with. If I know that X has to go in an even spot, okay, so that's two, four,
or six. Three worlds, do I really want to split? Maybe. If there's another rule though that says
X always goes after, or sorry, before Y, well, let's think about it now. X has to go two, four,
or six, but X also has to go before Y, which means X can't go six if there's only six spots.
Okay, so now I can see that X has to go second or fourth. And so there I might go, okay, so
because X is connected to, X is mentioned in multiple rules. One way of thinking about it
is just X is bossy, right? X has these like, X is particular. X is a pain in the ass. X has
multiple restrictions. Okay, well, if I'm making my seeding chart and one of my friends has a
whole bunch of restrictions, well, then I'm going to probably have to start with them, right?
Or let's say you're planning a menu and one of your friends has four dietary restrictions.
Well, you're probably going to start with them. You're not going to start planning your menu with
the people who are like, oh, I'm an omnivore. I eat anything. I don't care. Whatever is good for
me. Well, you're not going to be like, okay, cool. Let's make something fun for you. No,
we're going to start with the one who's, you know, gluten intolerant and also has a peanut allergy
and also is a vegetarian, vegan. And also, you know, like the ones who have lots of restrictions,
obviously that's the person that you should focus on. I want to stress here that this is really just
common sense. It's not, this is not like you had to take an LSAT class in order to learn this.
Naturally, if you're just solving these puzzles intuitively, I hope that that's how you would
want to solve the puzzle. It just doesn't make any sense to do it any other way.
You know, if you start solving a jigsaw puzzle, where do you start? Well, if you're like me,
you're going to start on the corners and the edges. Why? Well, because they have restrictions.
I mean the corner, you know, it can only go in four places. Of course, you're going to start
with the corners. The edges have some more space, but we know that the edges have to all be connected
to one another around the perimeter. Well, of course we're going to start with those edge pieces
if we're looking to solve this puzzle. All I'm encouraging you to do is to just naturally look
for the bottlenecks in the game and start there. All right. So if somebody just has to go in a
particular place, start there. If somebody else has a whole bunch of restrictions, think about
starting with that person, the person who's mentioned in multiple rules. Another good trigger
is a big block. So frequently on a, well, it's either a sequencing game or a grouping game.
On a grouping game, they might say geography and geology have to go in the same semester.
There's probably not going to be two Gs in the same game, huh? Let's say geography and philosophy
have to go in the same semester. Well, if I've only got the fall and spring semesters to choose
from, and if geography and philosophy have to go in the same semester, well, then it might make
sense to just start with a world where geography philosophy are in the fall and a world where
geography philosophy are in the spring. You have to be living in one of those two worlds. There's
only two of those worlds. Why not just make them explicit so that you can then see how that impacts
the other players in the game? So a big block in a grouping game or a grouping scenario,
a big block in a sequencing scenario might be the exact same thing. I mean, if it was just like
philosophy has to be immediately before geography, you go, okay, so there's going to be a PG at
somewhere in my sequence. I switched now. We're doing a sequencing type of an activity now.
If P has to be immediately before G, well, let me think about that because I guess it could be
first and second, second and third, third and fourth, fourth and fifth. If we only have five
things to put in order here, do I want to make four worlds out of the box? Well, maybe it's not
my preference to split it four ways, but if I split it four ways, I'm going to know exactly
where P and exactly where G are in all four of those scenarios. And that can be really helpful
because I can then start to see how it impacts other variables in the game. So a big block is
another trigger. Three triggers so far. If somebody just has to go in a certain place, start with that.
Maybe if you see somebody who's really a bottleneck, somebody who's really bossy,
somebody who's really particular, they're really restricted, they're mentioned in multiple rules.
Hey, maybe I'm going to get to bake multiple rules into my setup by starting with that player
because they're the one who's obviously a problem in the game. So maybe I start with them. If you
have a big block, you can start with a big block. People who have to go together or people who have
to go adjacent to each other, you might want to start with that. The final trigger that I wanted
to talk about for sure is a conditional rule. So if you have a rule that says it's frequently,
by the way, the last rule in the game, I don't know why they do that. Sometimes there's going
to be multiple conditionals in one game. The friends in the photograph game is a good example
of that. The birds in the forest game is another good example. When you see a conditional rule,
the hard way to do it is to write out the conditional rule, then write the contrapositive
of the rule. Some of you do that and you continue confusing sufficient for necessary when you do
that. It's not helping you to write out the rule and write out the contrapositive of the rule.
We don't do it that way here at LSAT Demon, not anymore. Instead, and so for an example of a
spring, then geology has to be in the fall. If philosophy is in the spring, then geology has to
be in the fall. If we only have two semesters to deal with here, you can eliminate that rule. You
can make it so that you'll never fuck up sufficient for necessary if you simply build worlds around
that rule. Got it? Understand what you're doing though. You're making worlds based only on the
sufficient condition in the rule. So the rule was if philosophy is in the fall, then geology has to be
in the spring. So you're going to make a world where philosophy is in the fall and you're going
to make a world where philosophy is not in the fall, which if we only have two semesters, then
okay, philosophy can be in the fall or if philosophy is not in the fall, then philosophy has to be in
the spring. Fine. I'm allowed to do that because philosophy has to be in either the fall or the
spring. Okay. Then I apply the rule and the rule is very simple to apply. The rule said when
philosophy is in the fall, geology has to be in the spring. Well, one of my two worlds has philosophy
in the fall. In that world, geology has to be in the spring. In the world where philosophy is not
in the fall, the rule disappears. The rule does not apply. You do not have to think about the
contrapositive. The rule only applies when geology is in the fall. So I apply the rule when
geology is sorry, when philosophy is in the fall, I apply the rule. Geology has to be in the spring.
And then in the other world where philosophy is not in the fall, I don't care about that rule
anymore because the rule does not apply. Frequently you can eliminate the nastiest rule in the game
because there can be conditionals that are even worse than that. You know, there can be a
it can have multiple things, right? It can be like, if philosophy is third, then geology has
to be fourth and statistics can't be seventh. Oh boy. That's impossible. Well, no, it's not
because philosophy is either third or not third. So you make a world where philosophy is third.
You make another world where philosophy isn't third. You just put not P under the third spot
in the world where philosophy is third. You then apply the rule. I can't even remember what I said.
Somebody has to go in a certain spot. Somebody else can't go in a certain spot. Fine. Write that
all in to the world where philosophy is third. That's the world where the rule was triggered
in the other world. Philosophy isn't third. Okay, fine. Then the rule doesn't even exist.
No contrapositive don't have to remember the rule. I get to totally forget it because I've
already applied it in the world where it applies and I know that it can't apply in this other
world. So it's gone. All right. So I came up with four. If somebody goes in a particular space,
just write that in one world solution. That's the world we're living in. If there's a hyper
connected player, somebody who's mentioned in multiple rules, especially if they're mentioned
in three rules or four rules, I mean, like look for the bottlenecks and consider making worlds
based on that really connected, really bossy variable. If you have a big block of two people
who have to go together or they have to go adjacent to one another, consider starting your
worlds based on that big block. And if you have a conditional rule, especially if it's a really
nasty conditional rule that you really just don't want to have to continue to process over and over
and over, consider making a world where the sufficient condition is true and a world where
the sufficient condition is false. When the sufficient condition is true, you apply the
necessary condition. When the sufficient condition is false, the rule just doesn't even apply.
Erica, when the rule has two necessary conditions, that's perfect. Okay. So the sufficient condition
is true. Well, then if it has two necessary conditions, then both of the necessary conditions
have to be true. So an example of that would be if P's third, then G's fourth and S is not seventh.
That's two necessary conditions. Well, fine. So when P's third, G's fourth, S is not seventh.
And then in my other world, I don't know shit about G and I don't know shit about S.
I just know that P is not third because I'm making a world where P is third and a world where P is
not. The way that you guys always fuck that up. And when I look at your diagrams, you guys fuck
it up because you try to make worlds based on both the sufficient condition and the necessary
condition at the same time. And that just doesn't make any sense. Start with one player, the
sufficient condition, the trigger on the rule. Who's the trigger? Okay. Well, they're either there
in the triggering spot or they're not there in the triggering spot. When they're there in the
triggering spot, then the rule applies and you just get to write it right into your diagram.
In the world where they're not in the triggering spot, I don't care.
As long as they're not there, then the rule doesn't do anything in that world.
Although what am I missing? I just really want to echo the part about conditional rules.
I found that to be like the last sort of big click for me for games was making worlds with
conditional rules because for especially more challenging games, it gets very conditional
rules used to scare me on logic games, but they're not scary. They're just giving you that information
in a this happens and then this happens order. That's all it is. And when I used to bake them in
first, I used to take a big deep breath and it would just feel so much easier because now I
don't have to think about the conditional rules. So I highly recommend that. And then the other
thing is, I think this would fall under the bottlenecks category, but rule distribution,
like the distribution of the actual individual elements, let's say you have seven slots,
but then you have three things that can't be consecutive, then that tends to have a limited
set of ways that that can be distributed across seven slots or even six slots.
That game doesn't happen super often, but I feel like I found it happening often enough that just
doing a quick, oh, there's four things that can't be consecutive and there's seven slots. Well,
that's fixed. Even if I don't know what order those might go in, then I can just write that in.
Sometimes that little check can absolutely destroy a game, but I think that falls under
the bottleneck category. Yes and no. I mean, there are games where it's like, well, we're not just
putting the clowns in order. We know something about the color of their shoes. And so what
you're talking about is there might be a rule that's like four of the clowns have red shoes
and four of the clowns have green shoes. Sorry, four of the clowns have red shoes and three of
the clowns have green shoes. There's only seven clowns. And they might say no two clowns with
red shoes can get out of the clown car consecutively. In that scenario, you would go,
wait a second now, seven clowns, four of them have green shoes, but none of them with green,
sorry, with red shoes can get out of the clown car consecutively. Oh, well then they have to get
out one, three, five, and seven. That's a one world solution because all you're going to do there
is you're going to put R for red shoes underneath the first spot, the third spot, the fifth spot,
and the seventh spot. But yeah, you are baking in, you're baking in the rule about red shoes.
In that, in that instance, it's a one world scenario, one world solution. The world you're
red has to be first, third, fifth, and seventh. And then you can get to work figuring out, well,
you know, is it clown P or clown Q or clown R or clown S that's in the first spot? I don't know,
but it's one of those four because those are the red shoe clowns. Yep. Yep. And that does happen
quite frequently. I've found at least like once every couple of game sections, you'll see a game
that is really easy to split up just based on the fact that a bunch of things can't touch each other
or there's repeats that can't go right next to each other. There's like a consecutive,
that consecutive non-consecutive thing used to crush a few games for me. And then I just,
I think that happened on my official test too. I just saw when I was like, yes,
it's one that I can split up based on the fact that they can't touch. And that was really cool.
Cool. Back to the conditional thing. I just want to say it one more time,
that the necessary conditions do not matter if the sufficient condition is not true. Okay. And,
and don't get all caught up on the necessary and sufficient and everything. It's just the
sufficient condition is the trigger on the rule. The necessary is the shit that has to happen when
the first thing happens. Okay. So an example would be if you get a DUI then. Okay. And let's go
through the litany of bad shit that happens to you. If you get a DUI, right, you're gonna lose
your license. You're gonna have to hire a lawyer. You're gonna spend the night in jail. You're
gonna end up spending $10,000. You're going to have to go to a serious offender driver's ed
program and whatever else badge, you're going to be embarrassed with your friends and family,
you know, like lots of stuff's going to happen to you if you get a DUI. So in the world in which
you get a DUI, you know, that all that shit is inevitable in the world in which you don't get a
DUI. Does that mean that you're not going to lose your license? Does that mean that you're not going
to spend the night in jail? Does that mean that you're not going to have to hire a lawyer? Does
it mean that you're not going to waste $10,000? Does it mean that you're not going to be embarrassed?
Well, of course not, because there's all sorts of other stupid shit that you could do that could
get you into those circumstances knowing that you didn't get a DUI. That's great, but it doesn't
mean anything about all of those necessary conditions that are associated with the DUI.
They could still happen. You could still end up, God forbid, having to hire an attorney. You could
still end up, God forbid, in jail for whatever reason. You could end up embarrassing yourself
with your friends and family. You could lose your driver's license in a lot of ways. Maybe you're
just 90 years old and you, you know, instead of going around the roundabout, you drive right over
the middle of the roundabout. That's an old grandpa of a cousin of mine, I guess. They finally took
away his license when he did that. He drove over the middle of the roundabout, scraped all of the
equipment off the bottom of his car. His car then, like, the engine blew up five miles later because
he didn't even realize he had done it. Okay, so they take away the guy's driver's license. Well,
but that's not anything to do with the DUI. He still lost his driver's license for some other
reason. All right, I think you guys get the point, yeah? I apologize on behalf of all other LSAT
teachers, including myself, in my first, you know, five years of teaching LSAT, because I used to be
real heavy-handed about sufficient and necessary, and you've got to write the rule, and you've got
to write the contrapositive, and you have to always be aware of the contrapositive. Well,
the only reason why I ever said that is because that's what I read in an LSAT book when I very
first started my LSAT prep. You guys, if you've never read that shit, you don't, thankfully,
you don't need to bother with any of that stuff, because there's just the world where the sufficient
condition is true, in which case we have to go ahead and apply all these necessary conditions,
or there's the world in which the sufficient condition is false,
in which case the rule just, poof, disappears.
