Platonic Dialogues on Love: Symposium, Phaedrus, Lysis, & Alcibiades 1, Comments by Anders Nygren

Human Migrations
4 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 4, 2024
"Anders Nygren penned a book, Agape and Eros, that was highly influential among theologians. We will also review comments by famous Jesuit professor, Frederick Copleston.
How can we benefit by reflecting on Four Platonic Dialogues on Love: Lysis, Alcibiades, Symposium, and Phaedrus? How similar are they?
Was it possible for men and women, and husbands and wives, to be friends in ancient Greece and Rome?
Did the Platonic dialogues on love condone or encourage homosexuality and pederasty, or men-boy love?"
Comments are disabled for this video.
How can we benefit by reflecting on the four Platonic dialogues on love,
Lysis, Alcibiades I, Symposium, and Phaedrus, and how similar are they? Was it possible for
men and women and husbands and wives to be friends in ancient Greece and Rome?
Did the Platonic dialogues on love condone or encourage homosexuality and or pederasty,
men-boy love? We will also ponder the comments on these dialogues by the theologian Anders
Nygren in his influential book, Agape and Eros, and also by Frederick Copleston,
the famous Jesuit professor. Please, we welcome interesting questions in the comments. Let us
learn and reflect together. At the end of our talk, we'll discuss the sources for our video.
Our sister blog includes footnotes, and our PowerPoint scripts that we uploaded to
SlideShare includes the illustrations we share. There are four Platonic dialogues on love,
the Symposium, the Phaedrus, which we've already reflected on in our videos,
and an earlier dialogue, Lysis, a shorter dialogue on love and friendship.
In addition, Xenophon penned his own Socratic dialogue on the Symposium.
We also include Alcibiades I and our Platonic dialogues on love, since Alcibiades I and Plato's
Symposium ponder the nature of the friendship between Socrates and his famous and problematic
student, the outrageous Alcibiades. Now, since I'm a Christian, whether Plato and Socrates condone
or merely tolerate homosexuality, and in particular, pederasty, is an important question.
Now, there is no doubt that homosexuality and pederasty was more prevalent and accepted in
the ancient world than in the modern world. But it is also true that both in the ancient
and modern worlds that some people favored homosexuality and pederasty, and some who
were either opposed or who were very uncomfortable with these practices.
We first reflected on the Symposium dialogues by Plato and Xenophon.
Xenophon tolerates pederasty and homosexuality, but he does not promote it.
But Plato's dialogue has passages that condone and condemn these practices.
In each Symposium or dinner party, first the guests deliver a series of speeches,
and in Plato's Symposium, these speeches are on carnal romantic love.
Then Socrates, in both the Symposiums, delivers the capstone speech on divine love.
In Plato's Symposium, the drunken Alcibiades crashes the dinner party
after Socrates finishes his uplifting discourse,
and Hadaiotima taught him the virtues of divine love.
Alcibiades remembers how he tried to seduce his friend Socrates,
but he respected his preference for a friendship based on divine love.
The friendship between Alcibiades and Socrates is explored further in Alcibiades 1.
We agree with the ancient and medieval scholars who accept that this is an authentic Platonic
dialogue, although admittedly, it may be penned by a student under his direction.
Now the next dialogue is between the young Phaedrus and Socrates.
They discuss whether Phaedrus should allow Lysias to seduce him into a homosexual relationship,
and there is mild flirting between Socrates and the young student,
again pursuing more of a divine love than an erotic love.
The first part of the dialogue discusses how many people misuse rhetoric,
delivering speeches that manipulate and mislead rather than inform.
Socrates critiques the seducing written speech of Lysias, showing its faults,
and unsuccessfully tries to improve the speech,
but finds that it is impossible to purify a deceitful speech.
Socrates scraps the speech, replacing it with a memorable speech on divine love,
with a delightful allegory of the heavenly chariot.
This chariot, driven only by mortals, has both an immortal steed that seeks to ascend to the heavens,
which represents divine love,
and an immortal steed that seeks to descend to the earth, representing carnal pleasures.
In Phaedrus, the charioteer mediates between divine love and carnal love,
as represented by these two horses.
But then we are reflected on the dialogue where the young Lysias
discusses the nature of friendship with Socrates.
Hippothales, an older companion of Socrates, asks him to introduce him to Lysias,
the handsome young man on which he has a crush on.
Several old men are watching these teenagers work out nude in the gymnasium in Athens.
There is no hint of condemnation of pederasty in this dialogue.
Now, the practice of pederasty, or men-boy love, is so embedded in Greek culture
that there is even a myth where Zeus, in the form of an eagle, abducts the mortal youth Ganymede.
Ganymede is granted immortality as the cupbearer of Zeus,
and his father is placated by a gift of immortal horses delivered by the god Hermes.
Men were more likely to form close friendships since Greek marriages were so unequal.
In ancient Greece, marriages were usually arranged.
Men usually married in their thirties to girls in their mid-teens,
and the husband was more like a teacher to his wife than a companion.
But in rural areas of all ancient societies,
women were more part of the society because the woman helped on the farm.
There were other exceptions, and the most notable was Aspasia,
wife of the statesman Pericles.
In ancient Athens, aristocratic women were literally locked up in the back rooms of the house,
on the second floor if possible.
They were only seen in public at funerals.
Women were rarely educated and were rarely literate.
The purpose of marriage in the ancient world was to raise children who would
keep alive the family name, as well as take care of you when you're older.
The epistles of St. Paul in the New Testament, in particular Romans,
exhorted that homosexuality was not to be tolerated by the new Christian religion.
This attitude was not an innovation.
Homosexuality was becoming less acceptable to Roman society,
and was not tolerated by Judaism and the Mishnah.
However, we must keep in mind that while St. Paul's epistle to the Romans
also condemned lesbianism, as did the Mishnah,
the Old Testament itself only specifically condemns male homosexuality.
And we're planning a video on these topics in the future.
So let us summarize the Platonic dialogues on love.
While Socrates delivers a speech on the divine love in both symposiums,
the other guests differ.
The guests in Plato's symposium reflected on carnal or romantic love,
whereas Xenophon guests composed speeches on what beneficial thing they are most expert in.
One of Xenophon's guests is Antisthenes, the Cynic philosopher who lives as an ascetic.
One of Plato's guests is Aristophanes, whose play, The Clouds, ridicules Socrates as a sophist,
and may have contributed to his execution.
All of these dialogues were written after Athens was defeated in the Peloponnesian Wars.
The victor, the Spartan general Lysander, temporarily ended their democracy,
installing Athenian aristocrats in the rule of the Thirty Tyrants.
This government, led by Critias, who was a former student of Socrates,
descended into a rule of terror.
The tyrants first executed their political enemies,
and then started executing their fellow aristocrats so they could seize their property.
After a brief civil war, the tyranny was overthrown and the radical democracy was restored.
In both symposiums, the guests' lists include both tyrants
and those who either opposed the tyranny or were victims of the tyranny.
Among the dinner guests for Xenophon's symposium was Callius, the host,
who had a crush on the young boy, Autolychus,
who attended the symposium with his proud father, Lycaon.
Autolychus's modesty was regal. His good looks drew everyone's attention.
There was not a man there whose feelings were not moved at the sight of him.
Some became more silent.
Lycaon proclaimed in the dialogue that he was quite proud of his son,
and there is no mention that Lycaon approves of Callius's interest in his boy.
In his speech, Socrates proclaimed that love is a mighty god, and likewise fair.
But his friend Diotima proved that love was neither fair nor good.
Do not infer that because love is not fair and good, he is therefore foul and evil,
for love is an amine between them.
Furthermore, love is a great spirit, and like all spirits,
he is intermediate between the divine and the mortal.
Love mediates between gods and men, conveying to the gods the prayers and sacrifices of men,
and to men the commands and replies of the gods.
God mingles not with man, but through love all intercourse and conversing with God,
whether awake or asleep, is carried on.
The knowledge which understands this is spiritual.
All other knowledge, such as arts and handicraft, is mean and vulgar.
Diotima does acknowledge that common love does have its divine aspects,
especially how men and beasts both seek partners and protect their young.
Do you not see how all animals are in agony when they are infected by love,
how eager they are to mate, and how often they are
tormented with hunger or suffer anything to maintain their young?
This is also true for men.
Marvel then not at the love which all men have of their offspring,
for that universal love and interest is for the sake of immortality.
In Plato's Symposium, after Socrates delivers a wonderful Socratic dialogue
by his former lady friend Diotima on divine love,
the controversial, drunken Alcibiades crashes the Symposium
and delivers his own speech on the divine love of Socrates.
Socrates loved his divine because he loves philosophy,
and he has declined to be the homosexual lover of Alcibiades.
Although as a friend, he always seeks to direct Alcibiades
to live a selfless life of philosophy.
Indeed, many paintings depict Socrates tearing his promising but wayward student
loose from the arms of the ladies of the night.
Socrates has a simpler, more stoic style speech in Xenophon's Symposium.
Love for the mind is much better than physical love.
Those who have a celestial love for the character of their beloved have a pleasant love,
but many with sensual desires criticize and dislike the characters of those whom they love.
For those with a sensual love, the bloom of youth quickly fades, as does affection.
But when a mind is progressing to greater wisdom, the more lovable it becomes.
Now, the dialogue between Socrates and his most notorious student in Alcibiades I
continues their dialogue in the Symposium.
Alcibiades has unlimited potential, but his hubris has made many enemies
dedicated to his ruin at all costs, including the ruination of Athens.
Socrates returns to his main concern.
What is justice?
With regards to Alcibiades, what makes a good leader?
Should the good leader be a philosopher?
Alcibiades has more patience than most with Socrates' constant questioning.
But they both agree that courage is a primary virtue for a leader,
since ancient Athens was, indeed, a warrior culture.
Socrates shares with Alcibiades that he is his true lover because he loves his soul,
unlike his many other friends whose carnal love never lasts and will be gone tomorrow.
Socrates ends this dialogue saying he is not hopeful for the future of Athens under Alcibiades.
I am filled with dread, not because I do not trust it in your nature,
but because I see the force of the city and fear it will overcome both me and you.
The Phaedrus.
Socrates, again, is interested mainly in the love of philosophy,
the love of knowledge and wisdom, and is more interested in virtue than passionate pleasure.
Socrates encounters his young student, Phaedrus, and they reflect on the letter from Lysias,
a male suitor seeking to seduce young Phaedrus.
The beginning portion of the dialogue is about love and rhetoric,
and Socrates demonstrates how Phaedrus' suitor employs a logically faulty speech to deceive
Phaedrus, grooming him for an exploitive relationship.
Phaedrus also delivered a speech on love in Plato's Symposium.
It may have been involved in the destruction of the Herms that was blamed on Alcibiades,
leading to his exile and to the disastrous Athenian defeat in the Sicilian expedition
that contributed to Athens' evangelical defeat in the Peloponnesian Wars.
The final speech by Socrates and the Phaedrus is a wonderful metaphor for divine love
and carnal love.
The metaphor is that of a divine charioteer whose chariot is pulled by two steeds,
immortal and divine, and mortal and passionate.
The immortal steed, noble and virtuous, seeks to pull the chariot to the heavens to contemplate
the good and divine truth.
The mortal steed, the carnal and passionate, seeks to drag the chariot down to earth in
vulgar impulses.
All intimate relationships are a battle between opposing drives,
symbolized by these two opposing immortal and carnal steeds.
The Socratic dialogue of Lysias is disturbing for those who are less tolerant of homosexuality.
In this dialogue, Socrates is accompanying the older man Hippothales and Thesipas to
the gymnasium, where 12-year-old Lysias will be exercising with his young best friend,
Menexenus.
Hippothales has a crush on the young Lysias, and Thesipas complains that his older friend
even composes love songs about the young Lysias.
Yucko!
Socrates agrees to try to provide an entree for Hippothales to converse with Lysias to
get to know him better.
Socrates notices that Hippothales is quite shy, so he decides not to encourage Lysias
to converse with his suitor.
This reluctance can be due to the fact that although old men like to observe gymnastic
exercises in competition to ogle the nude young boys, the pederasty at the gymnasium
was likely illegal in Athens.
One footnote mentions an ancient court case referencing those laws guarding against pederasty
at the gymnasium, which apply to both spectators and especially coaches.
Like many dialogues, Lysias concludes without an answer to the question,
What is love?
What is friendship?
Many of the arguments and responses are purposely faulty.
It is up to us to study the dialogue and formulate our own answers.
That is our duty in life, to determine truly what it means to love your neighbor.
What are some of the questions Socrates raises?
If someone is useless to you, does that mean he cannot be your friend?
When is a person fond of another person who is his friend?
Is the one who loves the friend of the one who is loved, or is it the other way around?
Can you only be friends to those who befriend you?
Can only good men be friends with one another?
Can an enemy love a friend, and can a friend love an enemy?
Socrates concludes that friendship is indeed a puzzle.
Perhaps friendship is not so much an academic endeavor we need to understand,
but is rather companionship which we should enjoy and experience.
As true friends, we should seek to bring out the best in everyone we meet,
making everyone we meet slightly better people because they met us.
The Jesuit theologian, Frederick Copleston,
quotes from dire time his speech on divine love in the Symposium,
showing how this divine love enables the soul's ascent to true beauty under the impulse of arrows,
the arrows that passionately draws us upward towards the divine,
up to divine wisdom, justice, and temperance.
The soul ascends until he reaches the contemplation of a beauty that is eternal,
unproduced, indestructible, neither subject to increase nor decay,
not partly beautiful and partly ugly.
This is the perfect beauty of the forms, the ideas, the ideal.
All other things are beautiful through a participation of it.
Copleston says that in the Phaedrus, Plato speaks of the soul who beholds real existence,
colorless, formless, and intangible, visible only to the intelligence,
in which sees distinctly absolute justice, absolute temperance, and absolute science.
Not such as they appear in creation, nor under the variety of forms to which we
nowadays give the name of realities, but the justice, the temperance, the science,
which exist in that which is real and essential being.
This implies that these forms or ideals are comprised in the principle of being,
in the one, or at least they owe their existence to the one.
These thoughts are more fully developed in Neoplatonism.
And we'll discuss the comments by the theologian Anders Nygren, Agapian Arrows.
This was a very influential book in theological circles on the nature of love.
Many Christian commentators posit that there are three types of love,
Agapian divine love, friendship, and carnal erotic love.
But actually, the Greek word arrow is often seen as a passionate love,
both between lovers and experienced by those who love God with a passionate love of the divine.
In this latter type of love is love which is allegorized in many
interpretations of the Song of Songs in the Old Testament,
where a Persian style love poem is allegorized to mean the love felt
by the devout believer towards our compassionate God.
An notion that is heavily influenced by Neoplatonism
in theologians such as Dionysius the Areopagite and Saint John of the Cross.
Dionysius the Areopagite influenced many medieval and modern theologians,
including Saint John of the Cross, Saint Thomas Aquinas, Saint Maximus the Confessor,
Patriarch Severus, mystical and orthodox theologians, but not Martin Luther.
In his book Agapian Eros, the theologians Anders Nygren
coins the word Eros piety for the divine love described by Socrates in Plato's Symposium.
Did this Eros piety of the ancient Greeks pave the way for a Christian concept of love,
or was it a rival to Christianity? Scholars have argued both positions.
Nygren views the doctrine of Eros as espoused by Diatima,
companion of Socrates in Plato's Symposium, as fundamentally a doctrine of salvation.
He posits that there is a connection between this Platonic concept of divine love and Orphism.
Orphism was the early Greek religious practices surrounding the myth of Dionysus,
according to the mythical poet Orpheus. This early myth tells us how Zeus had
resolved to give his son Zagreus, who is predominantly identified as Dionysius,
dominion over all the world. But while Zagreus was still a child,
the Titans, who were the primordial giants, killed and devoured him.
But Zeus smote the Titans with his thunderbolts and destroyed them.
And out of the Titans' ashes, he then formed the race of men.
This myth explains man's double nature, both being akin to the divine and an enmity with it,
due to man's double origin. As created out of the Titans' ashes,
he is evil and hostile to God. But since in the Titans' ashes,
there was also something of the God that they had consumed,
there is also something divine in the composition of men.
Man thus belongs by origin to two worlds. He is an earthly being with a titanic nature,
but he also has in him a divine spark. Nygren proclaims,
This conception of the double nature of man, of the divine origin and quality of the soul,
its liberation from the things of sense, and its ascent to its original divine home,
is the common basis on which every theory of Eros rests.
This conception of Eros he sees as the basis for other ideas,
such as the belief in a pre-existent fall, the conception of the body as the prison
house of the soul, and the idea of the transmigration of souls,
belief in the soul's natural immortality, and hand in hand with these go the basic
mood of cynicism and the mystical ecstatic nature, way of salvation.
Plato, in his Doctrine of the Ideas or Forms, is a synthesis of Greek rationalism
and Oriental mysticism, or Logos and Mythos. While Western philosophers emphasize the Logos,
Nygren warns that in Plato, we do not find philosophy in the modern sense of a critical
scientific discipline, but rather in the sense of a philosophy of life built up partly on a
religious basis, a philosophy concerned with the salvation and the soul's welfare.
This is a deeper meaning of salvation, which improves the soul.
Salvation with the kingdom of God is among us.
Nygren notes that in the Mysteries, the soul's salvation is attained through initiations,
purifications, and ritual observance, while in Plato it is through philosophy.
But even for a philosopher, it involves a conversion and purification,
and not even the philosopher can achieve the goal by means of dialectic,
but he reaches it only in a state of divine madness.
Nygren proclaims that it is the business of man to cut himself loose from the lower world and
ascend to the higher, and when he does so, when he turns away from the things of the sense to
Plato describes this in the Republic, when the ignorant choose to advance to the light of the sun
in the allegory of the cave, and in C.S. Lewis, whose souls continue their advance
up the mountain to the ultimate Christian salvation.
In the dark cave, the soul has retained a memory of the light above,
and feels an upward attraction to the light.
Nygren says the sight of the beautiful, which comes to man in the sense world,
awakens Eros in his soul, not, however, in order that his love may be fixed on the beautiful object,
but rather that it may pass beyond it in the continual ascent,
which is of the very essence of Eros, pointing it to the absolute beauty,
in which it participates, and from which it derives its own beauty.
This ascent is described in the Phaedrus as the heavenly chariot pulled by the mortal and
immortal steeds.
What are the types of Platonic Eros or love?
Diatima describes them to Socrates in Plato's Symposium.
Eros is the love of desire, or acquisitive love.
Eros is also the man's way to the divine.
And Eros is egocentric love.
In this context, Eros as egocentric is not derogatory,
but simply describes how we seek the good for ourselves, how we seek happiness,
and indeed, how we seek salvation.
Eros as acquisitive love.
Nygren notes that Plato says Eros is intermediate between having and not having.
Eros is obviously a desire, a longing, a striving.
But man only desires and longs for that which he does not have,
and of which he feels a need, and only if it's valuable.
Hence, love, as Plato sees it, is both the consciousness of a present need
and the effort to find satisfaction for it in a higher and happier state.
Plato has no room for spontaneous and unmotivated love,
for acquisitive love is motivated by the value of its object.
There is a baser form of acquisitive love that drags the soul downwards,
and only binds it the more firmly to things temporal, and that is sensual love.
But Eros is a love that is directed upwards.
It is the soul's upward longing and striving towards the heavenly world,
the world of ideas.
And Eros is a man's way to the divine also.
As Nygren notes, Plato's Eros has a religious significance.
Eros is the mediator between the divine and human life.
It is Eros that raises the imperfect to perfection, the mortal to immortality.
In this connection, Plato can speak of lives as something divine,
though only in the sense that it unites man with the gods,
not in the sense that the gods feel love.
The gods live their blessed life wanting for nothing.
They do not need to love.
In contrast to the Greek gods, our Christian God does love us.
In the future, we will reflect on Nygren's discussion of Christian love
in the scriptures and the writings of the Church Fathers.
But for Plato, love is always the desire of the lower for the higher,
the imperfect for the perfect.
Eros is the way by which man mounts up to the divine,
not the way by which the divine stoops down to man.
Eros is itself a form of flight from the world.
Eros can be seen as an egocentric love.
Nygren observes, the entire structure of Platonic Eros is egocentric.
Everything centers on the individual self and its destiny.
All that matters from first to last is the soul that is aflame with Eros.
Its divine nature.
Its presence straights while it is in bondage to the body.
Its gradual ascent to the world above.
Its blessed vision of the ideas and their unveiled glory.
Diatima tells Socrates,
it is by the acquisition of good things that the happy are made happy.
And since all men wish to be happy, then all men love the good.
To love the good is the same as the desire to possess the good
and to possess it permanently.
Love is therefore always a desire for immortality.
But in this desire too, the egocentric will is in evidence.
The positive egocentric love is illustrated in the Phaedrus,
where the souls endeavor to rise to the higher world in a chariot race.
Now we'll discuss the sources we used for this video.
Martin's Noble has an excellent collection of many of the Platonic dialogues,
although you can buy volumes that have all of them.
You can also find the Benjamin Jowett translations free on the Gutenberg site.
And in Mino and other dialogues, Robin Waterfield's includes the Dialogue of Lysas.
And you may need to buy the Alcibiades I in a separate volume
because many scholars doubt its authenticity,
an opinion that's not shared by many ancient and medieval scholars.
We highly recommend Frederick Copleston's many-volume set of the History of Philosophy.
These texts are used in many of the Jesuit universities,
and he is an approachable scholar.
I discovered this work by Anders Nygren, Agapian Arrows,
in the footnotes of many of the works of theology that I've covered.
The YouTube description includes a link to our PowerPoint script
that we uploaded to SlideShare, and also our blog.
Please support this channel by sharing this video with your friends,
and by clicking on the like and subscribe buttons,
and by clicking on the Amazon links to purchase any of the books we discussed,
which will earn us a very small affiliate commission.
And please consider becoming a patron of our channel,
plus we will host special discussion groups for our patrons.
Plus, you can click on the Meetup or small M icon to participate in our online discussions,
where we practice our future YouTube scripts.
And please click on the links for other videos
that will broaden your knowledge and improve your soul.
