Future of the Defense Industry, Combating Cyber Crime, the Business of Broadway | Wall Street Week

Business, Lending & Investing
2 followers
1 Video View·Nov 4, 2024
This is Wall Street Week.
I'm David Westin, bringing you Stories of Capitalism.
This week, the business of defense,
whether the United States is getting its money's worth
for its military spending.
Plus, turning the tables on cybercrime.
We look at how law enforcement and private firms
are using technology to track down criminals
and even get some money back.
And what it takes to put a show on Broadway.
Behind the scenes with a star producer and director
as they launch their new show, Left on 10th.
But we start with a story about choice.
The choice most Americans are making
between two parties, two presidential candidates,
two economic approaches, and what that choice
could mean for global Wall Street.
Beginning with the U.S. economy
and the battle with inflation.
From Bloomberg International Economics
and Policy correspondent, Michael McKee.
Voters face a pretty stark choice.
One candidate wants to tweak but preserve the status quo.
The other wants to completely remake the global economy.
The U.S. came out of the pandemic
in better shape than any other country.
During Joe Biden's term in the White House,
almost 7 million jobs were created.
Unemployment fell as low as 3.4%.
Inflation briefly roared, but has now fallen back
to an annual rate of 2.2%.
So Kamala Harris would essentially
follow the Biden playbook.
Invest in creating jobs and raising productivity,
expand and strengthen the social safety net.
Taxes would go up on corporate earnings and the rich.
Inflation was a lot lower when Donald Trump came to office
coming out of the great financial crisis.
Up until COVID, it averaged just 1.7%.
If you leave out the COVID year,
6 million jobs were created during his term
and unemployment fell to 3.5%.
Despite more than 500 basis points of Fed rate hikes,
American businesses seem to have done well
over the last four years,
raising the question of what they look for
in the next administration.
Josh Bolton works for the CEOs
of the largest companies in the country
as president and CEO of the Business Roundtable.
The economy's been pretty good
ever since we pulled out of the pandemic.
We've had too much inflation,
which the Fed is now seems to be succeeding
and bringing under control.
But for the most part,
the economy has been relatively successful,
but not nearly as successful as it ought to be.
And one reason we haven't been as successful
as we ought to be is that there is just too much regulation
holding back the robust vitality that American business
has over the decades historically been able to exercise.
So as our business leaders look to the kinds of policies
they wanna see in 2025 and beyond,
regardless of who wins the election,
they wanna see a sensible regulatory environment
that lets them do what they do best,
which is make money.
Taxes are always on the minds of business leaders,
but they've played an especially large role
in this campaign,
particularly when it comes to that 21% corporate tax rate
that came from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
under President Trump.
And that law is up for renewal next year.
The members of the Business Roundtable
were strongly behind the 2017 tax reform,
which was extraordinarily successful
in lifting the American economy out of the doldrums
we had experienced since the Great Recession.
In the two years immediately after the 2017 tax reform,
the median household income increased more
than it had in the previous 10 years combined.
So the members of the Business Roundtable
are really concerned about keeping that going.
The presidential campaigns have also spent a lot of time
talking about tariffs, how they work,
and what they would mean for US business and the economy.
Overwhelmingly, among the membership of my organization,
the view is that trade is extremely important
to the success of the US economy.
Some tariffs may be necessary,
particularly to counteract unfair trade behavior
from some of our trading partners.
But broad-based taxes along the lines
that President Trump has proposed
would be very damaging to the US economy,
and particularly those at the lower end of the income scale.
The line between economics and geopolitics
has become increasingly blurred,
whether it's tariffs, export controls, or industrial policy.
Richard Haass of Centerview Partners
has spent his career on these issues,
in the government and as president
of the Council of Foreign Relations for 20 years.
If you're talking about large,
across-the-board tariff increases,
not linked to behaviors, not, if you will,
with a sledgehammer rather than a scalpel,
you have to assume there's going to be retaliation.
So you have the initial effects
of the American tariffs raising costs here.
It's obviously inflationary,
as all sorts of economists have pointed out.
But then you have the double-down effects,
or the knock-on effects, when the others retaliate.
Many of our trading partners aren't gonna take it in stride.
So yes, you could have a trade war
under a Trump presidency.
Good old-fashioned geopolitical tensions
have come back in the last four years,
with wars in Ukraine and the Middle East,
and China increasing its presence around Taiwan
and in the South China Sea,
which has injected a new degree of uncertainty
in the global economy that businesses do not like.
Is there a potential risk to national security
from putting too much emphasis on economics
and overlooking the strategy?
The short answer to your question is yes.
It turns out that stability is the basis of all else,
whether it's the rule of law,
whether it's balance of power,
so whether it's inside a society or around the world.
You can't conduct economic relations.
You can't make long-term investments, for example,
without confidence about the rule of law and stability.
So I would say of the two,
the geopolitics are the more basic.
When you talk about stability,
being from Bloomberg, think about investment.
One of the things investors want is stability.
Will they get more stability
out of one of these candidates than the others,
a more certain world in which they can invest?
I would think under a Kamala Harris presidency,
it's always dangerous to make predictions about the future,
as Yogi Berra once pointed out,
but you're likely to get more continuity than change.
The economy's doing well.
We're growing up north of 3%.
Inflation's been coming down.
We've had four years of a Biden-Harris presidency,
and I would say the arrows are heading
in the right direction.
So yes, you'd have some changes,
corporate tax rates and so forth,
but by and large, continuity would outweigh change.
America first.
I think a Trump presidency
would introduce much greater uncertainty.
Global Wall Street has also watched
as the debate over regulation
rages between the Republican and Democratic standard-bearers.
The one who moves into the Oval Office in January
could have a major impact
on the rules governing the finance industry.
That's the particular expertise
of Professor Catherine Judge of Columbia Law School.
So one of the really striking features
of financial regulation over the past eight years
is how little it has changed, right?
So, I mean, when Trump first came into office,
he was the first Republican president in office
after the Dodd-Frank Act.
A lot of people expected dramatic change,
dramatic rollback.
We had a little bit of legislative rollback.
We certainly did have some regulatory rollback.
His vice chair at the Fed,
who was in charge of these matters,
Randy Quarles, was incredibly effective
in terms of the strategy that he put together.
That being said, if you talk to a typical banker,
it wasn't a dramatically different environment
that they were facing,
particularly for the large banks,
at the end of those four years relative to the beginning.
Regional banks face some rollback, but not a lot.
The independence of the Federal Reserve
has been much discussed during the U.S. election,
though some question just how much any president
could or would do to undermine that independence.
Economists say both candidates' plans
would add trillions to the national debt,
although the hole would be a lot bigger under Trump.
Interest rates would rise along with the price level
as the government had to sell much more debt.
The Fed might have to start raising rates again,
though Trump says he'll pressure the central bank
to keep rates low,
a move that might stir volatility in the markets.
Now, all these are campaign promises, of course,
and some or all may not happen.
Many business executives here and elsewhere say
Trump has a history of bluster, but not following through.
With the race as close as it is, however,
the world is holding its breath.
So, I mean, it's interesting.
Donald Trump has said that being the Fed chair
is the best job in government.
It is at least possible
that under a second Trump presidency,
it might be the worst job in government.
I mean, some of his biggest economic initiatives,
higher tariffs, really limiting immigration,
would have an inflationary impact.
We know going back to 2019 and early 2020
that he was very vocal with his frustration
that Chair Powell at that time
had interest rates where they were.
He wanted them to be lower.
And so you can imagine a scenario
where we're facing significant inflationary pressures
and prices are going up,
but a Fed chair has a hesitancy
in really tightening interest rates
and tightening monetary policy
in the way that would be necessary
to combat the inflation
because doing so might lose the faith
and backing of a second President Trump.
And finally, whoever becomes president in January,
it will not be up to them alone
to decide the direction of regulatory policy.
Congress will have a substantial say,
both through legislation enacted or blocked
and through the Senate confirmation process
for those who lead key agencies.
You know, you can both overstate
and understate this very easily.
So if you actually look at significant rulemakings,
President Biden has actually undertaken
more significant rulemakings
than any other recent president.
And interestingly, President Trump is number two.
So each of them did actually work very hard
to kind of bring about meaningful changes.
That being said, you know,
you can look at financial regulation
as an example of an area
where we haven't seen as significant a change
as we would have expected to.
So I think under Trump,
we would have expected significant deregulation.
We did get deregulation,
but it was more modest in scope.
Still ahead, the price of protection.
We discuss the changing landscape of U.S. defense spending
next on Wall Street Week.
This is a story about getting our money's worth
when we really need to,
when our national defense depends on it.
We spend an enormous amount of money
and we have the best military in the world.
Is it sufficient for all of the problems we have?
No.
For over 20 years,
John Henry helped oversee defense spending
for the U.S. government,
rising to become deputy secretary of defense
under President Clinton.
Now he's president and CEO
of the Center for Strategic and International Studies.
We do have a fine military,
but it's a extremely inefficient system
that we have to buy things
and the way we're organized.
The Department of Defense budget for 2024
is edging toward a trillion dollars,
more than the next nine countries combined.
It amounts to some 13% of federal spending
or about 3.5% of total U.S. GDP
and goes toward everything from pens and notepads
to missiles and fighter jets.
But for all that it spends,
there are plenty of people who believe it may not be enough.
As a percentage of GDP,
the U.S. government is spending half as much today
on defense as we did in the 1980s.
We're spending 1 20th as much on defense
as we did in the Korean War.
So the needs are growing,
the funding is declining.
Amy Ziegart is a political scientist
and a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution,
specializing in U.S. national security and defense.
I think there are two problems, David.
One is that we're not spending enough
and two is that we're not spending wisely enough.
We need to be spending money on low cost,
high tech, affordable, unmanned systems
and other capabilities.
How much the U.S. spends is one thing,
spending it in the right places is quite another,
particularly in a world where the very nature of war
is changing rapidly,
as we've seen most recently in Eastern Europe.
We're watching the war in Ukraine
and it's opening up entirely new concepts of warfare
that we're going to have to really figure out
and I don't think we quite yet know how to do that.
But we do have a very good system
for looking into the future
and designing weapons for that future.
Many Americans are familiar with the Indiana Jones movie,
Raiders of the Lost Ark,
that famous scene where there's a machete wielding guy
in the market and Indiana Jones takes out the gun,
the superior technology and shoots him.
That's been the strategy of the U.S. military
for the past 30, 40 years.
We're gonna out engineer the adversaries
and it doesn't matter if we're outnumbered by them,
but our capabilities are gonna be exquisite
and that's how we're gonna win.
That's not the battlefield anymore.
Now, if we're Indiana Jones in that marketplace,
it's 10,000 machete wielding guys
and some of them have guns too.
And so Indiana Jones is gonna run out of bullets
before he runs out of bad guys to shoot.
That is essentially the United States
and what we face with the rising threat of China in Taiwan,
the South China Sea and war games show it.
The CSIS war games show we run out of ammunition
within a week or two in a fight with China.
For the U.S. to keep up with changes on the battlefield,
it will need more than just new equipment
and new technology.
It will need to reform the way it procures
that equipment and technology,
making it more streamlined and flexible
than what the Pentagon does today.
I think there's widespread agreement
that the procurement process is desperately in need
of modernization and revamping.
So the procurement process is very good at some things.
It's not very good at rapidly developing
and fielding capability.
Those trying to do the innovating agree
that the process badly needs reform.
Andy Lowery is CEO of Epirus,
a defense tech company based South of Los Angeles.
He's working on a system to protect against drones
like those used so effectively in Ukraine.
Bases, aircraft, tanks, cars, vehicles,
stadiums, refineries, borders,
all of these things right now are falling prey
to a infiltration of drones, not just flying drones.
You have drones on the water, drones on land,
drones in the air, drones in space.
Lowery's company is one of the many so-called neo-primes
laboring to help the Defense Department make the big shift
from slow development of huge weapon systems
to the new world of innovation and fast scaling.
We've kind of grown a little comfortable, I would say,
in the way that we've been fighting
this sort of war of deterrence.
But now, enter this new age of consumer electronics,
highly distributed, highly networked.
No one single thing can do that much damage,
but when you add hundreds
and put them in a swarm configuration,
it's the new way that wars are being fought
and it's confounding our Defense Department.
Lowery says part of the problem
is the size of the Defense Department itself,
arguing that its scale and its procurement system
may get in the way of spending its money wisely.
It's expensive to produce and maintain defense technology
because one, it's very low volume.
You know, military systems, for the most part,
traditionally have been low volume.
They haven't had to produce a lot of them.
So there's a lot of change and a lot of customization
to each and every program.
So that adds a lot of expense.
Two is we're trying to get best in breed performance.
I mean, we don't want to skimp
on how high a performance that we get.
So performance becomes paramount to building great systems
and so it becomes expensive
to get the highest level of performance.
The most frustrating part of this story
is that there are lots of really talented, dedicated people
that are trying to change this whole process
and they are swimming upstream.
So the late Ash Carter, Secretary of Defense,
really started this push for a defense innovation unit
here in Silicon Valley.
Lots of people really worried about the direction
of spending and the need to actually produce
more capabilities on a faster cycle to adapt to the times.
Members of Congress, some of them really care
about defense innovation, but members of Congress,
we know, care about getting reelected.
And so there are natural electoral incentives
for members of Congress to protect the jobs
that they currently have in their district.
One path toward reforming defense spending
is through doubling down on the private sector.
Hamre says it has both the capital to deploy
and the tolerance for risk-taking that innovation demands.
Probably the most important thing is,
you know, 50 years ago,
the Defense Department invested in technology
that was going to be a definitive winner on the battlefield.
We're still locked in that system,
but now it's the private sector
where there's far more dynamic and innovative developments.
But this revolution that's taking place
in digital technology is in the private sector.
And we don't know how to bring that into the government
because we want them to slow down and fit our model.
Well, they're not going to do that.
You know, I mean, we, you know,
defense acquisition runs at X
and the private sector is moving at 5X.
I mean, their development cycles are measured in months.
Our development cycles are measured in years,
almost decades.
Part of the answer to encouraging faster innovation
may lie in adding more companies to the mix.
Since 1990, the number of defense prime contractors
has plummeted, going from 13 in some weapons categories
to no more than three,
and in some categories to only one or two.
If we were talking in the 1990s,
we would have had dozens of big defense companies.
That helps competition.
It helps innovation.
Now there are five defense primes.
We've had massive consolidation of the defense industry.
And that means prices are likely to go up
and knowledge gets lost
and innovation is slower than it otherwise would be.
Do we need more companies in defense?
And the answer is a resounding yes, we do.
One reason there's less competition today
than in the 1990s is the U.S. budget process itself,
which makes it difficult to invest in new systems
and discourages smaller companies from sticking around
to find out whether the political winds in Washington
will blow their way.
So the first thing, if I were queen of the world for a day,
that Congress could do would be to pass an annual budget.
So most Americans, I think,
hear that there's a continuing resolution in Congress
and the government's averted a shutdown
and isn't that good news.
From an innovation perspective, it's terrible news.
So whenever Congress can't reach a budget
and we're operating on a continuing resolution,
it means the Pentagon can spend no new money.
That means no new weapons,
no new research and development.
And so if you're a small company
like a startup here in Silicon Valley,
the Pentagon is a terrible customer
because Congress doesn't pass a budget.
Thousands of very small companies
that are key suppliers in the defense industry
have left the defense business in the past decade
because of this cockamamie budget process
that Congress cannot pass an annual budget
and can't fund new innovation in the interim.
Perhaps the most important force
driving the inertia at the Defense Department today
is the premium it puts on avoiding risk at all costs.
The question becomes, is it all necessary?
Are we over-flexing on how much risk we're willing to accept?
We're like willing to accept no risk.
And when I was a chief engineer
of a series of space programs back at Raytheon,
it was really bad.
They wanted not a single shred of risk on the space program.
And I would say, I would actually contend
that that's what really crippled our space program
until SpaceX came on,
is that the zero risk appetite,
not control risk, not manage risk,
eliminate all risk.
That's one of the biggest factors
that's slowing down the DOD on these large programs.
But now we live in this world
where it's got to be perfect every step of the way.
And that means we have excessive costs
and very slow acquisition.
Rapidly changing technologies could run up
against a military industrial complex
largely focused on what is instead of what will be.
And if that weren't enough,
we're on the verge of an even more fundamental shift
in the dynamics of warfare,
the shift to artificial intelligence.
The Pentagon's AI-related spending tripled
from 2022 to 2023.
I think generative AI, like all technologies,
has upside and downside risk.
One of the benefits of gen AI
is that it can come up with things
that humans would never have imagined.
From a tactical perspective in battle,
that's a good thing.
From a strategic perspective,
how are we managing conflict between two countries?
It can be very dangerous.
I worry a lot that we haven't fully thought through
the crisis escalation risks
when other countries are adopting generative AI
and not thinking through how it could lead us
into situations neither side would want.
Whether it's artificial intelligence or swarming drones
or any of the many other changes the Pentagon faces,
it's more important than ever
that we get what we pay for.
And looking to the private sector may help show the way.
Up next, fighting fire with fire,
how tech firms and law enforcement team up
to combat cybercrime.
That's ahead on Wall Street Week.
This is a story about turning the tables,
taking the technology criminals exploit to do wrong
and using it to bring them to justice.
Unfortunately, human trafficking is as prevalent now
as at any other given time we had it in our history.
Timia Nagy runs Timia's Cause,
a group that raises awareness about human trafficking,
one of the range of crimes using technologies
such as electronic money transfers and smartphones
to spread around the world.
Today, an estimated 28 million people
are victims of trafficking.
Back in 1998, Nagy was one of those victims
herself.
When I was 20 years old, I came to Canada
thinking that I'll be a nanny or a babysitter,
but unfortunately the employees turned out
to be on international human trafficking ring.
So I became a victim of human trafficking for three months.
Human trafficking, which includes forced labor
of all sorts, has grown globally more than 20%
in the last 10 years,
now amounting to some $236 billion annually.
Its spread is built in part on the criminal's use
of technology to take and move money
and to communicate with those involved,
both the victims and the customers.
But as large and disturbing as human trafficking is,
it's far from the only crime business
that's been transformed by tech,
prompting law enforcement to ramp up efforts
specifically targeting the use of technology
to commit crimes.
Because we're located in Silicon Valley for many years,
we've devoted tremendous resources
to combating high-tech crime, cyber crime.
As the District Attorney of Santa Clara,
home to Silicon Valley,
Jeff Rosen has seen how criminals have innovated
alongside technology.
Over the last 10 to 15 years,
the kinds of crimes that we investigated have changed
as the criminals have changed
the way that they're designing these crimes.
So just to give you a sense,
when I started as DA about 15 years ago,
this high-tech crime task force that we have
was basically investigating and prosecuting
traditional crimes that involved,
say, computers or laptops.
But they, so they were only high-tech in the sense
that people were stealing massive amounts
of computers and laptops
and then trying to ship them out of the country,
usually to Asia.
But very quickly, we saw the kinds of crimes
that criminals were committing used the internet.
Criminals have gone way beyond cyber crime
and are in all different types of crime
that exist against society.
Jonathan Levin has seen the evolution of high-tech crime
through his work at his blockchain analysis firm Chainalysis.
Everything from narcotics trafficking,
human trafficking to terrorist financing,
counter-proliferation, really, if you think about it,
it's just another means of moving money.
And criminals have been early adopters
in every type of technology,
whether that's the internet or phones.
And so, you know, they are also early adopters
for the uses of currencies like cryptocurrencies.
You might think that highly sophisticated,
tech-literate citizens of Silicon Valley
might be less vulnerable to being scammed
or exploited online.
But Rosen says it may be just the opposite.
A lot of individuals in our county
are comfortable in a high-tech setting
and they use social media accounts
and they're comfortable with technology
and they think of themselves as sophisticated individuals,
both financially and in their personal
and professional lives.
And what they don't realize is
they're really no match for the psychological techniques
that scammers are using
where they're sending out millions
of these messages each day.
According to a 2024 NASDAQ report,
the full range of transnational illicit activities,
including romance scams, business email compromise
and human trafficking,
generated over $3 trillion in 2023,
with $50 billion alone coming from a scam
known as pig butchering,
where victims are lured into pouring more and more money
into fake investments.
Most of that 50 billion is from the United States.
And in terms of what we can specifically trace back
to Silicon Valley,
we're talking about over the last several years,
we're talking from the tens to the hundreds
of millions of dollars worth of money
that's been stolen from individuals that live in our county
and gone to organized crime in Southeast Asia.
Criminals couldn't scale their global efforts
without the assistance of technology,
but that same technology can also be used
to turn the tables and catch the culprits,
or if they can't be reached abroad,
to get at their ill-gotten gains.
In the case of pig butchering,
that most often involves Southeast Asia.
One question was, here's a crime that's happening.
We're not able to prosecute the perpetrators.
Is there anything that our task force should do?
And so after discussions with the individuals
on our task force, both the prosecutors,
as well as our local and federal law enforcement,
we decided we're gonna try to get the victims' money back
as much of it as we can,
even if we can't prosecute the perpetrators
because they're beyond our reach in Cambodia, in Myanmar.
And then we set about figuring out how to do that.
So we use tools like chain analysis
and a tool from TRM Labs to follow money
as it moves across the blockchain.
And we've gotten very good at tracking money.
It's one thing to detect the criminal,
actually search them out,
turn them over to law enforcement.
It's another thing to get the money back.
How often can you get the money back?
Increasingly, it's actually something
that we are proactively working on
with our private sector clients.
If you look at the pig butchering example,
it's a problem that is now costing
the United States billions of dollars a year.
We are identifying that activity
and helping map that all the way to the points
where money is being laundered.
And together with Tether and OKEx last year,
$225 million of proceeds were seized
from the people who were perpetrating these crimes.
And eventually, that money can hopefully
be returned back to victims.
Cryptocurrencies, every single transaction is public.
The thing that criminals think
is that there is no linkage between their transaction
that they've made on that public network.
They know that everyone can see it,
but they don't think that anyone will be able
to link that transaction back
to the services that they're using.
And actually, at Chainalysis,
we've spent the last decade mapping out
those addresses to those services
and have a very good understanding
of all of the ways that people
are actually using cryptocurrencies today.
When it comes to human trafficking,
it's not so much about getting the money back
as it is about locating the victims,
using their digital footprints to free them from servitude,
and bringing the criminals to justice.
The basic thing is that you need to understand
the behavior of human trafficking.
So mainly, let's talk about domestic sex trafficking
because that's one of the most prevalent type
of trafficking in North, not most,
but this is the easiest to detect right now.
So you just need to understand how these victims live.
What's the lifestyle?
They travel all the time, city to city.
They don't eat.
So once you understand the behavior behind trafficking,
then you can basically look at the transactions
and the transactions will show you, black and white,
that this individual is potentially trafficked.
Nagy now works with banks and other financial institutions
to find these patterns,
using technology they developed to fight fraud
and helping law enforcement shut down trafficking operations.
Through transactions, now we can actually prove
how human traffickers are trafficking these individuals
and how they are the one who's benefiting from this.
So we have to prove proceeds of crime,
and that's how we would do it.
It's not just individual law enforcement agencies
like the Santa Clara DEA using technology
to fight cybercrime.
Increasingly, they're teaming up with other agencies
and private sector companies like Chainalysis
to attack the problem.
Part of the conferences that we have had
about combating cryptocurrency,
crypto thefts of money via these online scams
is we've invited companies that create products
that allow law enforcement to trace
the movement of crypto funds
as it moves from an individual's bank account
to other kinds of exchanges.
So Chainalysis and TRM Labs are two of the companies
that we have worked with,
and partly we're speaking with them
about the kinds of tools that we need,
the kinds of things that we're seeing
that would be most beneficial in the products they make.
And part of it is those companies letting us know
about techniques that they're seeing
for criminals to move money quickly.
We actually managed to bring together
the private sector and public sector
to work in one room together to look at
what are the instances where the private sector
has identified some type of fraud
and how does that match to the information
that the government has been receiving from victims.
And together they use Chainalysis
to create the common map of the full life cycle
of the fraudulent activity.
And that is what the blockchain provides
is that you can see victim funds,
you can see where those victim funds end up
and where they are being laundered.
And the goal is ultimately to hold those people accountable
and return money back to victims.
There's an old adage that we're always planning
for the last war.
Cyber criminals are not only fighting the current war
against law enforcement,
they're busy planning for the next one.
And Levin of Chainalysis at least says, bring it on.
Rosen and private actors like Chainalysis
are getting better than ever at identifying patterns
to catch bad actors who use technology to commit fraud.
We actually really like competition
and we think about it as a way for us
to leverage all of our technology from the last decade
to be able to bring to bear on new problems.
And so even if there are new laundering techniques
or there's new privacy protocols
or things that happen in cryptocurrency,
we have mechanisms and strategies
about how we can continue to keep up
with those adoption curves.
Now there's a new tool on the horizon
that may push law enforcement and the private sector
even further in combating cyber crime,
artificial intelligence.
Some of the things that we think
are gonna begin to happen in the future
are gonna use AI to supercharge this process.
So instead of needing hundreds of people
to send millions of these messages,
maybe you're only gonna need a dozen people
to send tens of millions of messages
because they're using artificial intelligence.
So that's one way that we think the criminals
can scale their efforts.
Another concern is with advances in technology
that allow for things like deep fakes
and impersonating people's voices
or impersonating what they look like
as well as what they sound like.
That's gonna make the criminals even more effective.
Every powerful tool can be used to do harm
or used to do good.
And Tamia Nagy sees ways that AI could give her
even more power to combat human traffickers.
This is an incredible way to see AI
and artificial intelligence and technology coming together
to fight such a terrible financial crime
such as human trafficking.
And also the fact that as a survival of such a crime,
I am so excited to see that there are other technologies
and technology in general are coming on board
and we finally starting to see some real results
and starting to deploy real technology
to fight such a terrible crime.
Coming up, the business of Broadway.
We talk with the people bringing ideas
from script to stage.
That's next on Wall Street Week.
This is a story about stories,
the kind we read in books,
the kind we tell one another every day,
the kind we spend a good deal of money
to put on the stage and screen.
We're giving you a standing ovation.
Max.
This is it, I'm going into show business.
The theater is an art form like no other
in the sense of that real strong collaboration
of all these different artists.
Susan Stroman is a star on Broadway,
not as an actor, but as a leading director
of hits like The Producers and Contact.
And storytelling is her life's work.
It's being sure of the storytelling.
And every department needs to be sure of the storytelling
that we're all on the same page telling the same story.
And that's all you can do.
Stroman's latest project
is directing the new Delia Ephron play, Left on 10th.
Originally brought to her
by another behind the scenes Broadway star,
this one, the star producer, Daryl Roth.
Basically, when someone says to me,
what does a producer do?
I have two answers.
One is put things together,
be the mother of the family,
and facilitate other people's dreams.
Daryl Roth has been telling stories on and off Broadway
as a producer since the late 1980s.
Over the course of her career,
she has led over 90 productions.
But she didn't always know
how she fit into the theater world.
I was lucky enough to grow up in a family
that loved theater, especially musical theater and music.
And growing up in New Jersey,
we had the benefit of being close to New York
and we would go to theater early.
I was very young when I started going.
I didn't see a place for me in that world
in those early days.
I mean, I have no talent, but I knew I loved it.
And I used to read plays
before I even wanted to read a novel.
And when I went into college,
I actually was an art history major.
And I kept wondering,
is there a way for me to get into theater?
And I didn't see the path in those days.
So I started my career actually in my 40s,
which I like to tell other women, it's never too late.
The theater world Daryl Roth entered
is big business in New York.
Almost 12.3 million people attended Broadway shows
in the 2023-24 season,
and paid over $1.5 billion for the privilege.
Down slightly from the year before,
dramatically higher than the pandemic years,
but not fully recovered from the $1.8 billion
in gross revenues in the 2018-19 season.
In comparison, London's West End
attracted 16.4 million theater goers in 2022,
and took in just under 900 million pounds,
or about $1.2 billion.
Each one of these productions began with a story.
Starts with a script.
In the case of some,
the source material could be a movie or a book,
or just even an article that someone saw somewhere.
So it's the idea of the story that you want to tell.
The new play that we're talking about now is Left on Tenth,
which is also a very challenging story,
but it's a true story.
I began to believe that I had fallen
into my own romantic comedy.
So long as I'm living, I'll be king.
It's based on a memoir by Delia Efron,
who I met some years ago when she and her sister Nora,
may she rest in peace,
wrote Love, Loss, and What I Wore, which I produced.
And so we stayed in touch over the years.
And when Delia wrote her memoir,
she came to me and said,
do you think this could be a play?
And I happily read the manuscript.
The next step is finding that writer,
and then thinking about a director.
In the case of Delia's book,
because she wrote the book and she is a writer,
and she has written plays,
I thought my most important job would be
to put her together with a director
who the material would resonate with.
And I introduced her to Susan Stroman,
who's one of theater's greatest women directors,
known mostly for musicals.
But I had seen a play that she produced
and it moved me greatly.
And I always sort of had her in my mind,
you know, if I ever had the opportunity
to work with her on a play.
And she and Delia met and they're like girlfriends.
Working with Roth, Stroman put together a creative team,
including two big names in the business.
Peter Gallagher and Julianna Margulies
have incredible chemistry.
And they are the loveliest people,
just the loveliest people.
So they are very right to play these parts.
And the parts are, of course,
the life of Delia Ephron
and her now husband, Peter Rutter,
and how they met.
I think it will be very inspirational.
The plays I look for, I think,
in my mind and in my heart,
I want to be inspirational for people.
Not in a spinachy way,
but in a way that might make them think about things
or maybe even allow them to activate in ways,
you know, build bridges,
maybe with communities or people
they're not so familiar with
and situations they're not so familiar with.
But as important as the story is,
it takes a lot of work
and a fair amount of money to bring it to the stage.
A lot more money than it did just a few short years ago.
Broadway has changed.
For one thing, finances.
Before the pandemic and now,
I would say that everything involved in Broadway
is three times the cost.
And that is, it's upsetting,
but it's difficult now to get investors
that you might have gotten before the pandemic
to take a chance.
So it is a miracle a show gets up
because of its cost.
I would say a play now, a small play,
ours is a four character play,
can cost between four and five and a half million dollars
to produce.
A musical can be between 10 and 14,
a larger musical between 15 and 25 million dollars.
So the costs of getting something on stage,
you know, it's a lot.
The point is, it's all still very risky
and so you try to put up safeguards
and guardrails around everything you do.
You try to think through,
what's the best way to bring my audiences in?
And what's the best way to be,
I hate to use the word frugal, but I will,
you know, use every penny really wisely.
To cover these substantial costs,
producers like Roth turned to outside investors.
People like Beth Fasciatelli,
who has invested in Roth productions in the past,
but who also understands the world of finance and business
from her time at Goldman Sachs.
It's no different than when you invest in a company.
You invest in a company
because it's got a strong management team
and Daryl runs this management team
and you have to invest behind someone you believe in.
Her shows always made me think by the time I got home,
really in a different way about what was being discussed
and I was excited to help produce that.
I was excited to help support her.
How many years have you been investing
in Broadway projects?
Our first investment was with Daryl in 2006.
Yeah, so it's a long time.
18 years.
My father used to say,
you can only invest in the stock market
if you're willing to lose the money, okay?
And I kind of feel the same thing about this.
You can't invest in this expecting to make,
you know, technology returns,
but you will hit some good ones
and 20%, I think, of theater shows
are profitable and make money.
And historically, we've invested in funds of Daryl's.
So you had a diversification.
So if Kinky Boots did great,
but four of the other ones didn't do so great,
that was okay.
That's how we have invested in the past.
You know everything, where you stand on every show,
you can get any information you want
and she's really good about the financials
and the stuff you need when you make an investment.
It's not amateur hour.
Even with all the track records
and analysis and talent in the world,
it's sometimes difficult to know before opening night
whether a show will be successful,
critically or in terms of the box office.
You never know.
Even when I did the big musical,
The Producers, we were out of town
and I thought, well, I know there's a group of people
that love Mel Brooks, but how will we do?
And then, of course, we were out of town
and the roof blew off the theater on the first preview.
I had no idea it would be that.
And of course, we were all extremely happy.
But you just never know.
I did a show last season called New York, New Yorker
that was so beautiful and so wonderful
and the audiences loved it.
But it was coming back at a time
when the pandemic wasn't totally,
well, the tourists weren't back.
New York wasn't back.
And we took a chance on a big musical,
hoping it would bring the tourists back.
But it wasn't.
The timing was off.
Come on!
But in the end, it's not just the money
that determines whether a Broadway production
succeeds or fails.
There's also the intangible sense
of accomplishing something, hopefully something good,
and sometimes even important.
I think audiences want to be entertained,
but they also want something important.
I think it's that combination of an important story
and entertainment.
If you don't make it entertaining, they won't listen.
So if you're trying to tell an important story,
something that pertains to what's happening
in society today, it still has to be entertaining.
I judge my success by saying that theater
deals in a different currency.
It's not always about the money,
although some people will say it's always about the money.
Of course I want to be responsible fiscally to my investors.
Of course I want to see a return of capital.
But I think my heart, first and foremost,
is in presenting work that's meaningful and thoughtful
and could change minds and give people,
I don't know, just hope in life
and just give them the opportunity.
And so the currency that I deal in
is whether I can offer a piece of theater
that moves a person and stays with them
and motivates them to just find the joy of it.
Whoever is elected to be the next president,
they will have a full inbox of international issues
to address.
Centerview Partners Senior Counselor Richard Haas
tells us what is at stake.
I think it's the most worrisome inbox
that any president has had in your lifetime or mine,
and it's about the same given our respective ages.
And what adds up, if you take the geopolitical challenges,
North Korea, China, Iran, Russia,
the revival of wars between countries,
the prevalence of still civil wars within countries,
the fact that at the global level
there's an enormous gap between the challenges,
say climate change, and the collective response,
which is, shall we say, negligible,
the fact that you've got these new technologies emerging
that will be essentially unconstrained
but with real consequences,
and all of this happening in the inbox internationally
come here, the foreign policy inbox,
at a time the United States faces
all sorts of internal challenges
from our border to our debt to whatever,
and the fact that we're so politically divided
and we no longer have a consensus
about the basics of America's role in the world,
the kind of leading role we've played
for three quarters of a century.
So if you add up the international challenges,
at least in three geographies,
the Middle East, Europe, and Asia,
weak states, strong states, then the global challenges,
then a divided, distracted United States,
that is a recipe for concern
no matter how you slice or dice it.
Is it also a more difficult set of challenges
because although the United States
is still primus inter pares,
it's closer in power and size and influence
to the other Western countries
than it has been probably since World War II.
You not only have to figure out
what to do about that inbox,
you have to figure out how to bring along
a lot of other people.
It's a good point.
We live in a world of what I would describe
as distributed capacity, military capacity,
economic capacity, diplomatic capacity.
So when people use words like American hegemony,
quite honestly, that is really far from reality.
We may have a plurality of certain forms of power,
but we do not have a majority of power.
We're competing for influence with others,
and we've seen, for example,
the emergence of this new alignment
among China, Russia, North Korea, and Iran.
That's another reminder that this is no longer
American-defined or dominated world.
We're competing with others with power.
We're competing for influence.
It's one of the reasons, I come back to this,
that our alliance relationships are so important.
The good news is we don't have to compete
with these forces alone, unilaterally,
but that puts a focus and highlights the importance
of our relationship with our partners and our allies.
So we have gotta tend to those relationships,
try to bring our partners in Europe and Asia on board.
Japan, first and foremost,
but also South Korea, Australia, and others in Asia,
and then obviously the NATO allies in Europe.
We have gotta work to keep those partnerships intact.
Let's put you back in the Oval Office,
where you've been in various administrations over time,
advising on foreign policy,
and the new president,
whether that name is Trump or that name is Harris,
turns to you and says,
okay, I've got a really complicated,
really dangerous inbox.
What do I do first?
A couple of things.
One is I try to stabilize relations with China,
and that means, yes, keeping the diplomatic lines open,
but also making it clear to China
that any use of force against Taiwan in particular
would be counterproductive.
So that means strengthening our ability to deter
or, if need be, defend against China.
That means what we do ourselves militarily,
but also things we do with our partners and allies,
beginning with Japan, beginning as well as with Taiwan,
also with the Europeans on what we would do economically
if China ever moved,
then we could signal those things to deter it.
That's one.
Secondly, I would be robust in my help for Ukraine,
continue the arms long-term,
give Ukraine greater freedom to use them,
but I would also press Ukraine
to move towards the negotiating table.
I do not believe no matter what we do for Ukraine,
it can win this war on the battlefield.
If you define winning as ousting all Russian forces
out of Ukraine, it's not gonna happen.
We need to move towards a diplomatic outcome.
We need to impress Mr. Putin that time is not on his side.
So we need to be both more supportive of Ukraine,
but also have straight talk.
I would also have more straight talk with Israel
about the future of the Middle East.
So I would be supportive in particular against Iran
and Iran-backed proxies, but, this is a big but,
I would press very hard for the introduction
of a serious political dimension in the region,
particularly when it comes to satisfying
some Palestinian political aspirations.
And then here at home, I think the new president
needs to talk a lot to the American people
and to the other party about why it's important
for the United States to stay involved,
why we can afford to, why we need to spend more on defense.
We're spending roughly half the Cold War average
as a percentage of our GDP,
why we need to spend differently.
We need a much more modern defense,
much less focused on a small number of large legacy systems,
much more on drones and the new stuff.
Obviously, we're gonna need to deal with a broader range
of national security issues,
beginning with the border and with debt.
That's already, you only, when you use the word priority,
you talk about three things,
and I admit I violated that rule,
but that's because the inbox is so crowded.
We're not gonna have the luxury
of just focusing on two or three things.
This is gonna be a demanding presidency.
When you're elected president, David,
you've already chosen your vice president.
You can choose your cabinet.
You can choose your inaugural speech.
The only thing you can't choose is your inbox,
and this is going to be as demanding an inbox
as any president has faced.
You can choose the people
to help you sort through that inbox.
You mentioned the cabinet.
If you were the incoming president, again, whoever it is,
what would you do in looking
for your national security advisor
and your secretary of defense and secretary of state?
The first thing I'd say is these are not jobs
for on-the-job training.
It's gonna be demanding for your senior staffs.
You wanna get people who have experience,
who have proven capacity.
You also wanna get a range of views.
You don't wanna have a group think.
If you have personal relationships with some of them, fine,
but that shouldn't be paramount.
I mean, the most successful administration,
in my experience, was one I was a part of,
full disclosure, was George H.W. Bush, the 41st president,
and you had people like Brent Scowcroft,
Jim Baker, Colin Powell, Dick Cheney.
Not too shabby, not too shabby,
and the president set the tone,
but you appoint the strongest,
most capable people you can find,
and you make it clear how you want it to operate,
and I would think people could do a lot worse
than taking a lead from 41's presidency.
And finally, in your inbox,
you might not think it's a foreign policy issue,
although I suspect you do, Richard,
because you've always said security begins at home.
What about the debt and deficit?
How big an issue is that for the national defense,
the security of the country?
You know, it's one of those issues
that democracies have trouble dealing with, David.
The reason is, it's a slow-motion crisis,
and in some ways, it's not a crisis until the day it is,
but when that day arrives, you've got no good choices,
and it's too late to head it off.
So I would start to, you don't have to solve it
in the sense of get rid of it.
You wouldn't want to do that.
You don't want to go from 60 and slam on the brakes,
but you want to dial down the pace of increase for sure.
You want to change the ratio between GDP and debt,
and that ought to be a long-term goal,
and I would have, maybe you need to set up a commission
with the Congress and others, though I will say, David,
and it's gonna be almost impossible to deal with it
absent dealing with entitlements,
and that means looking at how we build
cost-of-living adjustments into Social Security,
you know, the age limit.
If we're living, if the average American is living longer,
we may need to begin to adjust
when entitlements kick in at what level.
We may want to look at how we tax them,
but we've reached a point now
where we're spending more on debt servicing
than we're spending on defense.
That seems to me a crazy and unsustainable trajectory,
so yeah, I think the new president,
this is the kind of reason you'd have to have
an open dialogue with the American people.
You almost want to bring back fireside chats.
You want to level with the American people,
say here's our strengths, but here's our challenges.
Here's what we gotta do on the border.
Here's what we gotta do on debt.
Here's our foreign policy challenges.
I think the next president needs to be
more of a communicator with the American people,
and that may in turn help with the Congress.
I don't know how divided the Congress will be.
None of us can know that at this point
given the uncertainties, but you've got,
let's just for a moment assume
there's gonna be some division,
then we've gotta get things done.
So I would spend a lot of time working the Hill,
but also working the American people.
That might be the best way to incentivize people
in Congress to maybe embrace the dreaded C word,
which is compromise.
That does it for us here on Wall Street Week.
I'm David Westin.
We'll see you again next week
for more stories of capitalism.
