¿Por qué no funciona TransMilenio?

Magic Markers
1 seguidor
1 Visualizaciones de video·1 nov 2024
Why is the Transmilenio service so terrible?
Well, easy, because it's not enough for a city as big and as populated as Bogotá.
No, the biggest problem with Transmilenio is that it has a too complicated route design.
Is it hard to believe?
Well, let's talk about why Transmilenio doesn't work,
A video based on the proposal and research of Guillermo Ramírez.
It's true that Bogotá needs a better infrastructure, we won't deny that.
However, this observation is basically useless or at least very discouraging.
You mean we should paralyze the city for about 50 years,
O sea 70 porque acá las obras nunca se entregan a tiempo, or sea 70 because here the works never deliver in time,
So our grandchildren don't have the same problem we do.
The complexity of the routes, on the other hand, is something we can solve ourselves.
It's a much bigger problem than it looks.
Involves congestion in stations, the price of tickets
and, in general, the inefficiency of this system.
But to understand this, first we have to answer the basic question.
Why were more than 100 different routes designed?
And the answer, obviously, is velocity.
A bus that doesn't stop at every station is a bus that gets to its destination faster.
Two buses that don't stop at every station also reach their destination faster.
The problem is that this formula cannot be repeated as such.
Because there's a saturation point where the buses start to stall.
By persistently insisting on the same idea, the system now suffers various consequences.
The first is that vehicles behave in a chaotic and unpredictable way.
Besides almost everyone entering and leaving the railway supposedly quickly,
Everyone brakes and accelerates according to a different pattern.
That means the probability of two or more buses
They arrive at the same time at a station and form trancones to become a mayor,
Not because there are more buses but because they are more uncoordinated.
The second is that, among more routes there,
Except for buses that serve each traveller specifically.
Because the rest of the fleet is busy covering other routes.
We've all seen how long buses go by, many with a seat and traveling in the right direction,
Before you think he's going to pick us up.
For example, although the same user may be served by different routes,
These are parked in different wagons,
Or we have to choose blindly and count on luck being on our side.
Finally, the third consequence is that there tends to be very few buses
With the 160 people that should be transported.
There are 200 people inside, and everyone wants to die.
o take much less time and the system becomes more expensive to maintain.
This problem arises from the difficulty of reducing the number of routes to a limited number.
The travel plans of 2 million people.
On this subject we will return further,
But the point is that the operators have a huge mathematical problem in their hands
You, understandably, make mistakes.
Those mistakes translate into useless routes that pass much later,
It's a useful route that never passes.
o proceedings which involve illogical transfers.
Which, in turn, means higher prices and longer wait times at the stations.
Seeing that the buses live in traffic jams,
It's natural that we need more space to park more buses,
But the truth is that it's the routes that don't let us work.
So, how should the system work to prevent these things from happening?
Let's make a list of the targets.
We want to travel as passengers, not as sardines.
We want a civilized transport experience.
Without fear of a storm every time the doors open,
We want to satisfy the demand of passengers,
We want prices to be low, but the system to be economically viable.
And we want everyone's journey to be quick.
Is there something we're missing?
Ah yes, it would be good if the maps were easy to understand.
All these things point towards the need for a much more efficient design,
If you can, let's see how it would be.
This is a map with the most important stations of Transmilenio.
The first thing we need to be clear about is that about 70% of the fleet
It should be routed to avoid the problems we mentioned.
The second is that the key is to connect the edges of the city with the heart.
This is because Bogotá, like many other cities,
It behaves like a cardiovascular system.
By the mornings, the diastole occurs.
By the sea, people move from the outskirts to the heart of the city,
And by the late afternoon, the systole occurs,
By the sea, people are moving from the heart to the periphery.
Then, let's talk about routes.
It turns out that there are only two routes
That connect every portal with the heart of the city
for any destination to be accessible from any origin with a maximum of one transhipment,
and the trans-board would be for the case of less frequent journeys.
For whatever it's worth,
To go from Ciudad Jardín to Mundo Aventura, I would have to do a transshipment.
But this happens because it is impossible to design a route that specifically serves each traveler.
And why only two routes per portal?
Why not three or four?
In part because between fewer routes there,
The closer we get to the ideal that every bus serves every person,
but also partly because the stations have less capacity
They only have two cars in which people can wait.
And when the lines mix, there's a congestion.
The grace of this change is that we can synchronize the fleet
Like a bicycle chain.
and increase the frequency of buses without interfering with each other,
But that's not the only reason.
In a linear system like Transmilenio,
It should not happen that some buses travel much more full than others,
Just like in a train, one carriage is not always more crowded than the others.
At this moment, because of the structure of the routes,
The system obliges passengers to force their way into the first bus that serves them.
Because the next one comes after many others that pass by.
That's as absurd as putting a lot of people in the same section of a revolving door.
Let's imagine an extreme example to make the problem easier to understand.
Suppose tomorrow there was only one route that the passengers needed.
All the buses making different routes were empty.
The buses on this route would not be sufficient to transport the users of the system.
Well, this scenario repeats itself every day, never in such a dramatic way.
but the imbalances between supply and demand are increasing
Until it becomes a general congestion.
Instead of playing with the puzzles with the routes that intersect
and assume a responsibility which does not correspond to them,
The operators should only be concerned with putting more or less buses in the chain
Depending on the demand.
And then what about the second lane?
We must certainly take advantage of it.
But we must be careful not to damage the synchronization.
between all the buses that run on the Transmilenio tracks.
What we must do to achieve this
The aim is to reduce the number of express routes and the number of stops each of these routes makes.
Here we see how that new design could be.
There would be two express routes leaving from each port.
None of those would have more than eight stops.
We want the express buses to be fast.
They must not be hindered and must stop only at stations capable of receiving them.
Would you like to do some transbordos?
Yes, but in the worst case, only one.
The point is that the two tracks can flow in synchrony
If the internal rail is used to move most people
The external rail is used for long distances
o to attend critical points on the line,
As in this case.
That bus that comes there just went through the whole empty line
to get quickly to a point that was very congested.
160 people have just been treated and the problem is no longer as serious as before.
Let's think for a moment about what the nomenclature of this design would be.
Instead of having dozens of routes that change depending on the day and time,
We'd always have the same routes and the frequency would adjust.
Lower during the valley hours and higher during peak hours.
It's that simple.
We must not underestimate the importance of having a system
that he can understand without scratching his head,
Especially when we're talking about a system
It's made up of straight lines.
Now let's talk about silver.
For the possibility of increasing the system capacity
and improve the user experience was not sufficient reason for making this change,
The result is that, in strictest terms, prices should fall.
Greater efficiency means lower operating costs,
Users pay less and owners get the same.
But before we continue, it's time to tell you where we got all these ideas.
A couple of years ago, Guillermo Ramirez,
A passenger who was also professor of business administration,
I introduced the Transmillennium system as a case study in my classes.
And with the help of his students he dedicated himself to confirming the suspicion
The system is terribly inefficient.
And then we designed the route module that we described.
That work is embodied in a document that bears the same name as this video
It has been consulted more than 100,000 times on the Internet.
The link is in the description of the video.
To name the most striking things,
The study ensures that the time savings of the express routes
Compared to the usual routes, it is 6 minutes on average.
Six minutes to go to the garbage in the moment we have to wait for the next bus.
But there's no end to the surprises.
Guillermo and his team assure that no significant changes were found
in the frequency of buses between the valley hours and peak hours.
Something absurd!
All this leads us to the key question.
How much money could we save with this simple route model?
According to Guillermo's study, it would be possible to charge an average fare at the small stations
The full rate is only charged at the stations where express services stop.
In that hypothetical scenario, both those who want to save money and those who want to save time
You'd have the option to enter the system wherever you want.
But to explain that we would have to approach matters too specific
We're running out of time.
It is important to understand that it is possible to reduce the tariffs considerably
The Commission has also proposed to increase the number of subsidies for the production of electricity.
Details more or details less, that's the idea.
As you may have noticed, Guillermo's proposal is based on data
They were discovered over two years ago by a group of volunteers.
It does not include the third phase of Transmilenio or the integrated transport system.
But the logic of the model is perfectly valid regardless of whether it comes from any passenger.
In the end, the biggest question of all is
Is there any factor we haven't considered?
Because if in essence Guillermo's proposal is right, and it seems that it is,
That means two things.
The first is that we are witnessing an unusual event.
Someone, a passenger, out of sheer curiosity and for free,
I produced a proposal that would be worth a fortune if it had the backing of a consulting firm.
The second is that Transmilenio has done nothing with this generous gift,
Either because they don't know it exists or because they haven't given it the importance it deserves.
We made this video because we want to help spread this proposal
And above all because we want to solve this mystery.
We will then move on to the open letter procedure.
The Commission has not yet received any information on the situation in the country concerned.
Would you be so kind as to tell us if you know the proposal of Guillermo Ramírez?
If you know her, could you please tell us what's wrong with her?
If there's nothing wrong, could you please implement it?
In advance, thank you very much for your attention.
Cordially, Magic Markers and everyone who helped us share this video.
By the way, if any of you are interested in us helping you explain ideas with videos like this,
We recommend that you visit our web page magicmarkerspro.com
