Building Empires Through Art

Art Exhibitions
6 followers
On September 13th, 1759, the American continent changed forever. The Battle of Quebec, or the
Battle of the Plains of Abraham, marked the end of the French presence on the continent.
There were still French descendants, and there still are today, I'm one of them,
but the continent was now ruled by the British. The Seven Years' War would still last four years
after the Battle of Quebec and would consolidate British power, both in the West in America,
and in the East, mainly in India. Great Britain had been building a colonial empire,
and it was taking massive expansion. This painting reflects this project.
Benjamin West made this painting in 1770, over a decade after the Battle of Quebec. He chose to
the death of General Wolfe, which is also the title of this work.
We are mid-battle. We see the French losing. The city of Quebec is engulfed in smoke. Only
the top of the cathedral can be seen. You see boats in the St. Lawrence River and troops
landing on the shore. But that's only the environment, the context in which takes place
what's really going on. General Wolfe is dying.
General James Wolfe was a hero in Great Britain, mostly because he successfully
defeated the French in Quebec, but also because he died in battle. He was martyred,
erected as a hero, one who sacrificed his life for the glory and expansion of the British Empire.
This painting was incredibly popular because of the incredibly popular General Wolfe,
but it was also controversial. You see Wolfe dying, surrounded by men, who weren't even there
by the way. This isn't entirely accurate as you could imagine from how dramatic this scene is.
But that wasn't the controversy. What was controversial about this painting is what
everyone is wearing. Benjamin West was told to paint the characters of the scene wearing togas.
That was the classical way of depicting history paintings. There was a perceived dignity in
depicting, in large-scale history paintings at least, men in togas, whether it's to depict
bible stories or ancient mythology. The idea was to elevate the subjects and make them timeless.
King George III didn't want to buy the painting because of the subjects' clothes. Sir Joshua
Reynolds pressured West to put his characters in togas, but as West famously answered,
the same truth that guides the pen of the historian should govern the pencil of the artist.
However, this is not, as we've said before, a historically accurate painting. Most of the men
depicted in this scene, some of Wolfe's officers, were busy in battle as you may imagine. Some
weren't even at the battle. However, perhaps the part of the painting which is the least
truthful or the one that West took the most creative liberties on is the figure of General
Wolfe. Wolfe is dying gracefully and though he died getting shot several times, he's not bleeding.
The light falling on him is almost surnatural, it seems a bit divine. And that's where the
parallels with the lamentation of Christ come in. West is making this painting for an audience who
knows biblical imagery, who's primed for images of martyrdom and sacrificed heroes.
This painting is propaganda for the expanding empire, obviously, and it knows it's public,
it knows that it's meant for British people in the mainland. First, it's depicting some American
New World exoticism. It's showing to its viewers that this is not Europe and it's doing so by
representing an indigenous warrior. Second, it's both capitalizing on the fact that Wolfe
is a national hero and it's building that heroic myth by drawing parallels with him and Christ.
Third, the choice of depicting these characters in their actual clothes instead of togas
may not render them timeless, but it emphasizes on the fact that this event
just happened. It's telling the viewers these are your contemporaries. Perhaps more importantly,
it's telling these viewers that what usually is history with a capital H is happening now.
By looking at this painting, you aren't only looking at soldiers abstractly fighting or dying,
you aren't only looking back at history. You're part of history, part of a historical moment.
By supporting your nation, you're not only witnessing this historical domination,
you're an active participant in it. Your pride, your identification with martyrs,
is essential to your country's prosperity. This is what this painting did. It tied its
viewers to a nation and its myths. It's textbook propaganda.
