Why modern foods are so easy to overeat | Peter Attia & Stephan Guyenet

Health Longevity
19 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 2, 2024
So let's start to talk about the hedonic aspect of food.
So we have five tastes, right?
We can taste sweet, sour, bitter,
salty, and umami. Those are the things, the five things we taste.
What's the best way to describe umami to somebody?
It's a meaty flavor that is present in cooked meat,
bone broth, soy sauce.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So I think people kind of get it. It's distinct from salt,
I think is an important point here.
Yes.
Although they often go together.
And I know different parts of our tongues have different, you know, we,
we sense, for example, sweet on the very front of our tongue, I recall,
but that's, that's about the extent of my knowledge and recollection of where,
where our tongue resides in that. But what do those,
what does the taste that we experienced today,
you and I, if we go out to a restaurant,
how does that compare to the range of tastes that our ancestors experienced?
Yeah. I think, I think this is, this brings up a topic that, um,
I like to, I like to talk about because I think most people,
if you look at what hunter gatherers actually eat,
let's say we're looking at contemporary and historical hunter gatherers where
data have been collected and using that as a proxy for types of food that our
ancestors would have eaten.
It is radically different than what we eat today in many ways.
But one of them is the hedonic properties of it.
Like if you look at what the Hadza eat, you know,
if they go out and kill, uh, an antelope,
they just like cut off pieces of meat and throw it in the fire or put it next to
the fire and coals. They don't have sauces. They're not putting salt on it.
And then they just like cut off the charred parts and eat.
And sometimes it's like half raw on the inside. They eat rotten meat,
meat that we would consider literally rotten. They will eat.
I was just thinking about that the other day, by the way,
because I eat so much wild game that I killed,
but I realized like I'm still a baby because like, Hey, I cook it.
I don't eat it raw. Um, but more importantly, to your point,
I season it, right? Like I use salt, I use pepper,
I put lemon on it and I'm sure it would taste fine without those things.
It would certainly be edible. I just don't do it. Right.
Yeah. And that's right. And you know, I'm sure like, yeah,
I think if a person,
a typical person were to try to eat at a Hadza camp for like a week,
I think it would be really challenging for them. Um, you know, like even,
that meat, even, even meat, as you said, cooked unseasoned, unseasoned,
it's not, it doesn't taste bad. It wouldn't taste as good.
But now imagine like the outside is charred inside is half raw.
You're brushing sand off of it. Like that's, that's kind of the context.
And then, you know, that's the meat.
That's like one of the most palatable things they eat. And then, you know,
we have like probably the most palatable thing or yeah,
probably the most palatable thing.
And certainly the thing that they really like is honey,
but they're not putting it on toast with butter on it. You know,
they're literally drinking straight.
They're just taking the honeycomb, eating it and like drinking the honey.
So it's, it's a bit of a different scenario even there.
And then we have like, they eat a lot of Baobab.
That is a very fibrous fruit that has sweetness to it,
but it also has some off flavors. It's not a very sweet fruit.
It's not like an apple. It's got a lot of fiber.
And then there's the the tubers, which is another major article of diet.
And to be fair, this is their least preferred type of food. Okay.
Yeah. It's, it's, they would rather eat things other than tubers.
But they roast these things in the fire. They dig them up.
They're these like long stringy things that look like long sweet potatoes.
There are multiple species, but that's one of the common ones.
And they're so fibrous that they actually have to spit out
a wad of fiber after they're done chewing it.
So it's like a sugar cane or something where you suck out the nutrient,
but you're spitting out the pure unsoluble fiber.
Yeah. And so they're not sitting there sauteing onions on the stove.
They're not putting sauces. They're not spicing.
Like they're just taking food out of nature and cooking it and eating it.
And so I think it's,
it's just a radically different type of diet than we're accustomed to.
And I think in this regard, um,
it's interesting to consider how rewards circuits adapt
to that.
Basically our brains are set up to not
be satisfied with ordinary stuff.
Once we have gotten good stuff is a simple way to put it.
And, uh,
Michael crashes did a really interesting neuroscience study on this in mice.
Mice, normally they eat these unrefined food pellets.
That would be like the default diet,
but they much prefer these calorie dense, refined, high fat pellets.
And if you give that to them,
they will very much preferentially eat that over the healthier,
unrefined pellets.
And what happens is they actually
neurobiologically devalue. If you look at the circuits,
activity of their rewards circuits, they devalue.
Once they've been exposed to the preferred food,
they devalue the less preferred food. So it no longer satisfies them,
no longer motivates them in the same way that it did before they were
exposed to the highly preferred food. And so, you know,
to bring this back to our context, if you have somebody like you or I,
who's been raised in a context where we have, you know,
tasty calorie dense, easy to eat food.
And that's how we were raised.
Then going back to eat food more like how our ancestors would eat is,
is really difficult.
Like twice you've mentioned the calorie density.
So let's now talk about that because that's kind of different from taste, right?
So the, the, the taste thing is interesting to me.
And this is something you and I actually remember speaking about probably one of
the first times we met this, like I said, 10 years ago, which was,
I actually think table sugar is disgusting. Like I truly do.
Like if you put a bowl of that white crap in front of me and said,
dip your finger in and eat it, like could maybe do it once, but that's about it.
Right? If you said, just mix it into water and drink it,
it's gross. It tastes fine in coffee and tea, but just by itself,
it's really disgusting. And similarly, if you just have me eat lard,
it's really disgusting. Like I,
despite the fact that I was on a ketogenic diet for three years,
I never developed a taste for putting coffee and butter and things like that.
But I freaking love ice cream, right?
Like I think ice cream is about one of the
most beautiful tastes in the world, everything about it.
So, and it really isn't that much more than sugar and fat, right? I mean, yes,
there's some flavors to it. And if you make it a coffee ice cream,
I like it even more. But so, so I guess my question is,
can you walk me through what my brain is doing when it's tasting
sugar, when it's tasting butter, neither of which by itself I find remotely
enjoyable. But then when I'm tasting ice cream and cause the ice cream is not
that much more caloric than the butter and the taste of those two things,
you know what I mean? Like there's something I'm trying to understand here,
which is taste and energy density.
And how are those figuring out because I believe they are instantly rewarding.
So I'll give you one other analogy here.
I remember when my daughter who's now 13 turned six months old and my
wife and I were really fastidious about not feeding her any junk, right? Like,
you know, fortunately my wife was able to breastfeed,
so she didn't have all that formula. And you know, we just,
we were like, you know, your typical idiot first parents, right?
Like we spent way too much time thinking about what she was eating, I'm sure.
But on her six month birthday, we got her ice cream. So you gotta,
so this is kind of an interesting experiment, right?
Like she's never experienced anything like this.
So I take a little ice cream cone and I put it up to her face and I still
remember where we were sitting in Del Mar when I did this. Stefan,
it we're talking in milliseconds response from her
milliseconds,
her eyes opened wider than they've ever opened and she
couldn't get into that thing fast enough.
So to suggest that that isn't her brain responding is crazy, right? Like
there's, there's nothing in her periphery in the moment that governed that
response. So whatever ice cream loving genes I have, she got them.
Yeah, absolutely. So I'm in a hard degree on ice cream. It's,
it's really for me like almost drug-like the effect it has on my brain.
Um, so yeah, this brings up a couple of interesting questions.
So you're alluding to the fact that sugar
and pure fat are very calorie dense.
So if our brains are wired for calories,
why are those not very motivating? Which is a great question.
So I'll start with that.
And the reason is that this, this starts to get into the,
the complexity of it is that there is an optimal concentration
of these nutrients that is not a hundred percent. So, you know,
a great way to illustrate this would be with salt, right?
Like eating straight up salt is not something that most people would
enjoy like eating spoonfuls of salt. It's horrible. Um,
but at the right concentration, it's excellent, right?
It really enhances food.
And so that's actually generally true about all of these nutrients.
It's true also about carbohydrate and fat.
So, um, a term that's been used for that as the bliss point.
So there is an optimal concentration for enjoyment and presumably
also for reinforcement,
which is that dopamine release that sets your motivational
drive and helps you learn and form habits.
And so ice cream, you know,
if you take out the sugar probably wouldn't taste bad without the sugar,
but not nearly as good, right? You take out the fat and fat free
ice cream is not flying off the shelves, even though it does exist. Um,
so it's really that combination of the two that really puts it over the top.
And that's generally true.
When you look at the types of foods that are most commonly associated with strong
cravings and loss of control over eating. So like addictive,
like behavior,
you see that generally the foods that are cited are combinations of carbohydrate
and fat. Usually there's other stuff involved. There's flavorings,
there's salt in the savory items like pizza or,
or French fries. Um, so sweet or savory,
generally they're combinations of carbohydrate and fat.
And I think that again,
it just relates to the fact that there is an optimal
concentration of these nutrients in terms of stimulating our,
our, our reward centers.
And so what you see in modern foods that have been
crafted to maximally stimulate our,
you know, enjoyment and motivation, either,
either they've been crafted by, um, food industry or by grandma, you know,
passed down through the generations of recipes.
What you see is that generally these items are hitting multiple
bliss points at the same time.
And that's just not really a combination you see in nature. So, I mean,
you don't see foods that are as
reinforcing. I mean,
I think the closest we would come is like maybe certain types of nuts would have
some carbohydrate and some fat together. Um,
but we really don't see anything that really hits the high points as much as,
um, the foods that surround us today.
