Today we'll briefly discuss some unusual phenomena and rumors in Chinese politics, then delve into the astonishing debt levels rarely disclosed by a CCP expert, whether a 10 trillion stimulus can save the market, the truth behind Chinese residents' savings, and why the artificial bull market at the end of September might have utterly destroyed the foundations of China's economy.
0:00 Continuous Political Anomalies and Endless Political Rumors
2:49 Insider Expert Rarely Reveals the Astonishing Scale of China's Debt
6:40 Can 10 Trillion Yuan Rescue Plan Save China's Economy?
14:48 The Truth About Chinese Household Savings: 80% of Wealth in the Hands of 2% of the People
19:14 Two-Week Artificial Bull Market Has Completely Destroyed Foundation of China's Economy
Hello everyone, welcome to Inconvenient Truths. I am your host Jennifer Zeng.
Today we will briefly discuss some unusual phenomena and rumors
in Chinese politics, then delve into the astonishing debt levels rarely disclosed
by CCP experts, and whether a 10 trillion stimulus can save the market,
the truth behind Chinese resident savings, and why the artificial bull market at the end of
September might have utterly destroyed the foundations of China's economy.
There is a lot of ground to cover with very real, possibly unseen economic data elsewhere,
so please make sure you stick around till the end.
OK, let's begin with the first topic.
Lately, there have been numerous unusual events in Chinese politics, too many to detail one by one.
In summary, many are scrutinizing every move with magnifying glasses to try to figure out
the true state of Chinese politics, especially regarding Xi Jinping's power,
including whether his control over the military is still solid.
One view holds that his power remains stable, and another believes he has lost control of the
military to Vice Chairman of the Central Military Commission Zhang Youxia. There are also rumors
his closest aide Cai Qi might step down soon. And some say because Xi Jinping has mismanaged
the economy, he is facing pushback from various factions within the party,
compelling him to agree to relinquish power gradually to ensure his safety post-retirement,
among other speculations. Personally, I believe it might be premature to draw conclusions.
Even if Xi Jinping is willing to give up power, the CCP might not find someone acceptable to all
parties to succeed him, or there might not be anyone willing to take over such a mess.
Therefore, I don't want to spend too much time discussing these matters today. Instead,
I want to focus on revealing some real data about China's economy.
How large is China's state? This has always been a mystery to the outside world. Earlier,
the International Monetary Fund estimated that local government debt in China amounted
to 92 trillion yuan. However, recently, an insider, Professor Li Jianjun,
Vice President of China's Central University of Finance and Economics, has made a rare
public disclosure of this figure. Let's listen to what he said.
Professor Li Jianjun, Vice President of China's Central University of Finance and Economics
Well, did you hear that? He stated that the legal portion of local government debt is
42.23 trillion yuan. There is also 57.16 trillion yuan in implicit debt from urban
investment bonds. So excluding implicit guarantees, these two items sum up to 99.39 trillion yuan,
nearly 100 trillion yuan. This amount is more than 7 trillion yuan higher than the IMF's estimate.
Additionally, the central government's debt is 30 trillion yuan, making the total close to
130 trillion yuan. China's GDP in 2023 was 126 trillion yuan,
meaning the debt-to-GDP ratio has already exceeded 100%, reaching 103%. This is far higher
than the international alert level of 6%. It's nearing the physical deterioration level seen
in Greece before its debt crisis. The question now is, why would Li Jianjun
choose such a sensitive moment to reveal these figures? One explanation is that the economic
situation has become so dire that the officials are using this informal way to reveal these
numbers to prepare investors. It's like when a plane is about to make an emergency landing,
they tell everyone to buckle up. This could also be the relevant departments trying to shift
responsibility, knowing that the problem is too severe for them to resolve. So they are leaking
some information in advance. This way, the public can't blame them for not being warned.
On Tuesday this week, Reuters reported that the National People's Congress of China
is prepared to pass a fiscal stimulus plan worth up to 10 trillion yuan to promote economic
recovery. Now, can a fiscal stimulus plan of 10 trillion yuan really boost the economy?
Let's look at some real data. Compared to GDP figures, which are very easy to manipulate,
the revenue and expenditure numbers released by China's Ministry of Finance are relatively
more reliable. It's China's historical fiscal revenue and expenditure data.
Look at the second column. In the first three quarters of this year, the total fiscal revenue
of the Chinese government was 19.39 trillion yuan, while it was 20.54 trillion yuan in the same
period last year. So this year, it decreased by 5.6%. This 5.6% drop in total revenue is the true
decline rate of China's economy in the first three quarters of this year. In contrast,
the National Bureau of Statistics claimed a GDP growth rate of 4.8% for the first three quarters,
which looks extremely false in the face of this revenue drop. The GDP number was clearly
fabricated. Another set of data supporting this revenue data is the profit data of industrial
enterprises above a designated size. Here, above designated size refers to companies
with annual principal business revenue reaching or exceeding 20 million yuan, or about 3 million
U.S. dollars. In the first three quarters of this year, profits of industrial enterprises
above the designated size contracted by 3.4% year-on-year, with August and September seeing
an astonishing contraction of 22.24% and 23.90%, respectively. Without profit, companies of course
can't pay taxes. Now, let's look back at the fiscal revenue and expenditure table.
Please look. While there is a significant drop in fiscal revenue, the fiscal expenditure data
has not decreased. In the first three quarters of this year, total fiscal expenditure was 26.22
trillion yuan, roughly the same as last year. Much of the government's expenditure is rigid,
such as public servant salaries, the medical and educational expenses for the public.
In such a situation, the fiscal deficit naturally grows rapidly. The total fiscal deficit in the
first three quarters of this year was 6.83 trillion yuan, a sharp increase of 16.1%
compared to the same period last year. Look at another indicator, the sixth column in this table,
the deficit rate, which is obtained by dividing the fiscal deficit by total revenue. In the first
three quarters of this year, China's fiscal revenue expenditure gap rate reached 35.2%,
which is also the highest on record. At the current trend, this year's total fiscal deficit
might exceed 10 trillion yuan, with the deficit rate exceeding 37%. So issuing 10 trillion yuan
in bonds would just cover this fiscal gap. What would be left for economic stimulation?
Look at this table again. In 2013, China's total fiscal deficit was 924 billion yuan. By this year,
just over a decade, it has increased to 210 trillion yuan, with a compound growth rate of 53%.
Isn't that terrifying? With such a scale of fiscal deficit, the only solution is to issue
debt to fill it. Therefore, in the first three quarters of this year, 9.7 trillion yuan in
national debt and 6.69 trillion yuan in local government bonds were issued, totaling 16.39
trillion yuan. This is a year-on-year increase of 12.7% compared to last year.
Looking at the trend, the total bond issuance for this year will reach 23 trillion yuan.
This number is 13 trillion yuan more than expected fiscal deficit of 10 trillion yuan
for the whole year. So this additional 13 trillion yuan are used to repay maturing old
debts, which is what they call issuing new debt to repay old. From another perspective,
even if they've already invested 10 trillion yuan to stimulate the economy this year,
how is the economy doing now? There's been no improvement at all. To really stimulate,
would they need to double this figure? A 20 trillion yuan economic stimulus plus 13 trillion
yuan to repay old debts, wouldn't they need to issue 33 trillion yuan in a year?
What does 33 trillion yuan mean? It's an average of 2.75 trillion yuan per month.
And if we calculate based on 21 working days per month, that's 130 billion yuan per day.
Is that possible? As we've discussed, China's total debt now stands at around 130 trillion yuan,
already exceeding GDP. On top of 130 trillion yuan, an increase of 33 trillion yuan in just
one year, that's a 25% increase. Is that achievable? Everyone knows,
no matter how much the government invests, if the public doesn't have purchasing power,
the economy can't get better. Some economists have marveled at the scale of savings among Chinese
citizens, saying how rich the Chinese public is. Many Chinese economists have repeatedly
emphasized the need to find ways to encourage people to take their money out of the bank
and consume it. So how rich are Chinese citizens, really? Let's take a good look at this table,
which has all the secrets of Chinese people's wealth in it. This is the assets table for
customers and, or above, the golden sunflower label released by China Merchants Bank.
The so-called golden sunflower customer refers to clients with an average daily total assets
of 500,000 yuan or more. Let's just call them big customers here.
Take a look at the evolution of wealth in this table. The first column shows the year from 2007
to 2023. The second to the fifth column show the number of retail customers,
the number of big customers, and their total assets amount. The last two columns show the
percentage of big customers among all retail customers and their assets share.
Look at the yellow column. You can see the number of big clients have varied between 0.9%
and 2.5%, meaning less than 2.5% are considered big customers.
Now look at the blue column. The asset share of big clients has risen from 55% in 2007
to 81.2% in 2023. What does this mean? It shows that wealth in China is increasingly
concentrated in the hands of a few, and by 2023, just 2.4% of the people holds 81.2% of bank
deposits. China Merchants Bank is one of the top six banks in China. So if we estimate from this
ratio, then out of the total 147.6 trillion yuan in Chinese household savings as of August this
year, only about 20%, which is a very modest 29.5 trillion yuan belongs to the general public.
You need to understand that China's total personal debt now stands at 81.6 trillion yuan.
It's conceivable that the 2% of the population with 80% of the bank deposits certainly have no
debt. So all this 81.6 trillion yuan in debt is borne by the general public. In other words,
for 98% of the Chinese population, their total savings are only 29.5 trillion yuan,
while their total debt amounts to a staggering 81.6 trillion yuan. In such a situation,
how much purchasing power do you expect them to have? As everyone knows, the Chinese government
recently engineered a forced bull market through its policies.
Now, here, look at this chart of the Shanghai Composite Index. This is the chart of the China
Securities Index. From the lowest point on September 18, there was a mad continuous rise
for 9 days, with the China Securities Index surging by 44%. However, after the National Day
holiday on October 8, when trading resumed, it started to fall, dropping over 4 consecutive
trading days, and it never regained upward momentum after that. The crazy bull market ended
in just 9 days. During these 9 days, statistics show that up to 3 trillion yuan in retail
investor funds entered the market, while the main force capital was in a net outflow state.
This 3 trillion yuan in the subsequent decline could at best see 1 trillion yuan escape,
meaning the net loss for retail investors was 2 trillion yuan.
Is this 2 trillion yuan loss considered large or small? If we look at the total household savings
of 147.6 trillion yuan, 2 trillion is just less than 1.4% of that, which might seem like a small
loss. But as discussed earlier, for 98% of the Chinese population, their total assets
are only 29.5 trillion yuan, while their total debt is 81.6 trillion yuan, meaning their net
debt has reached 52.1 trillion yuan. In this context, losing 2 trillion yuan in the stock
market in just 9 days, what does that mean for them? What does it mean for their purchasing
power and the economic prospects of China? So, the government's rescue of the market
was merely an opportunity for the market leaders, namely state-owned enterprises and
weak investors, to loot the already very impoverished retail investors once again.
And the damage this had done to the economy is something many people have yet to realize.
The original level of economic downturn will be significantly amplified. Some economists
have even said that the total collapse of China's economy, which might have taken 2 or 3 years to
occur, could, at the pace set by the current government actions, reach a point of no return
in just one quarter, a point where even unlimited, unanchored money printing by the central bank
would be unable to save the economy. In other words, in just 2 weeks,
the CCP government has completely undermined the foundation of China's economy.
Well, are you shocked? Well, that's all for today. Please
like this video and subscribe for more. Please also visit my website at
jenniferzongblog.com to sign up for a membership or make a donation.
Your support helps me continue sharing the inconvenient truths.
Thank you, have a nice weekend, and see you next time!