The Yankees Might Be Screwed

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
One of the most impressive things about Garrett Cole really throughout his whole career up
until this point, but especially since 2017, is how reliable he is.
It's part of what makes him such a valuable pitcher.
He's nasty, throws hard, throws accurately, is durable, and reliable to always make his
starts, take the ball every 5th day, and stack up innings.
2018 was when Cole's career truly took off, and he cemented himself as arguably the best
pitcher in baseball, a status that still remains arguably true.
If Jacob deGrom stayed healthy, it'd probably be him, but either way, Cole has been an
absolute horse out there, in the Cy Young conversation every year until last year when
he finally won his first, which seemed long overdue.
So as we now head into the 2024 season, which is just around the corner, it's just been
assumed Cole will be penciled into this Yankee rotation good and ready to go per usual as
the most vital piece of this team other than Aaron Judge.
Except, out of seemingly nowhere, there is some new Garrett Cole news that may change
everything, at least for 2024 and maybe even beyond.
And speaking of Aaron Judge, there's also some concerning news on him.
It's alarming, but before I get any further, make sure to hit that subscribe button if
you haven't already.
Over 65% of my watch time is from people who aren't subscribed.
A lot of viewers just don't realize they aren't, so if you enjoy the video, hit that
button along with the bell for post notifications.
Thank you!
So the scary news is that Cole is undergoing an MRI on his elbow.
His right pitching elbow, obviously.
That is horrifying.
As for Judge, he also underwent an MRI, with him getting one on his abs.
Everything, at least according to him and the team, came back clean.
But this is just yet another thing the Yankees most definitely don't need to have happening
right now.
You also have Judge's toe, the injury he got last year, which Judge himself admitted
he thinks will require constant maintenance for the rest of his career.
And when you consider Judge is also someone who just in general has a history of being
a little banged up and injury prone, none of this is what you want to hear, obviously.
The goal is for him to be ready by opening day, which he says he's pretty sure will
But that doesn't seem reassuring.
And even if he's ready to go for opening day, who's to say he won't have to hit
their injured list a week later for his abs, his toe, or something else?
It's all worrisome, but I wouldn't panic as much about Judge as Cole.
That's a lot more concerning, at least right now.
It's actually funny, well not funny, but interesting because Garrett Cole and his health,
as far as his elbow and arm and everything, has been on my mind I'd say for a while
now.
I can't tell you exactly for how long, but Cole has stuck out to me as someone who's
continued to make starts and rack up innings while simultaneously not having any health
issues to go with it.
Most pitchers at least have some points in time where they have soreness somewhere or
need to sit for a bit, but not Cole, and without looking or doing any research about his injury
history, I just felt Cole was pretty abnormal with this.
Turns out he really is and has been, he's never once gotten Tommy John surgery, he's
also just never had a serious injury in general at all, and speaking of being durable his
whole career, Cole has actually made the third most starts in MLB since his career
began in 2013.
He had a couple slight injury stuff with the Pirates, like a little shoulder soreness one
time and a tricep strain another time, in 2019 he had a little hamstring strain, something
that of course has nothing to do with the arm, and the hamstring is really the only
thing he's dealt with since becoming a Yankee, and it's not even a thing.
It was just one time a couple years ago, and he's pitched 200 plus innings in the last
But now Cole's not feeling at his best, and has gotta get it checked out.
This is of course bad and scary for the obvious reason, but it also goes beyond that.
What's so scary about this to me, and what I feel like should scare everyone, is how
little prior warning there was to any elbow problem with Garrett Cole.
At least that we know of, but if there really ever was a concern about Cole's right elbow,
it would've been likely made known.
Cole's 33 years old, I just went through his history, a history that really has no
concerns.
He has a very clean record with being healthy, which of course is amazing for a pitcher to
have and what you want more than anything.
But again, that's what makes this even more horrifying than it already is, and it speaks
to a broader issue going on in baseball, an issue most of you already know about obviously,
the elbow injury epidemic, the Tommy John epidemic, whatever you want to call it.
Everyone is hurting their elbow and getting surgery, and that of course includes the best
of the best, the guys who are so much fun to watch, the guys who baseball isn't the
same without.
No matter who you are, how old you are, how good you are, you're a walking Tommy John
surgery and if anything, the better you are, the more likely you'll get it.
If you suck or aren't as good, you won't be pitching enough to eventually suffer what
guys like Jacob deGrom, Sandy Alcantara, Shane McClanahan, Walker Bueller, guys like that
have suffered.
Earlier this spring, just recently, Lucas Giolito, who just signed a contract with the
Red Sox, out of nowhere felt discomfort in his last downing, in his elbow.
Lucas Giolito isn't nearly as established and elite as Garakol, but this is a guy who's
also built a resume of being reliable, making every start, stuff like that.
There was no prior warning here, the Red Sox obviously didn't find anything alarming
in Giolito's physical before giving him millions of dollars, it just happened.
He's seemingly fine, then all of a sudden he's hurt, he's getting surgery and is
done for the year.
Garakol's situation is a little different.
There's not a specific moment or start this spring where Cole felt something, it's more
about how difficult it's been for him to bounce back between starts.
Apparently Cole has been comparing how he feels right now to when he throws 100 pitches
in a start during the regular season, meaning he's feeling the same fatigue and recovery
process as that.
The issue is Cole is only throwing about 45-55 pitches because it's spring training.
To be having trouble recovering when it's just that is of course concerning and not
normal.
Something's not right, and here's what sucks most about this.
Even if Cole's MRI came back clean enough, or there weren't any glaring issues or nothing,
this is still now something that's still going to be glaring over Cole and the Yankees
heads now moving forward.
I'm no doctor, but Cole's elbow is not feeling right for a reason, even if nothing
is torn or whatever.
Something is still going on, and what I see with that is maybe he doesn't have to get
any type of surgery now, but that doesn't mean he won't have to get it tomorrow or
next week or in 3 months in the middle of the season.
It just seems like once there's that initial problem with the elbow, everything else afterward
is just delaying the inevitable.
I'm not saying Garakol is getting Tommy John surgery, I don't know that.
Maybe he won't have to.
I and everyone should hope that he ends up being just fine and healthy to pitch another
200 innings this year.
But just seeing how this dance usually goes, the elbow issue doesn't magically go away,
and it sucks.
Not that anyone is immune to hurting their elbow, but it really sucks to just actually
see the most durable and reliable guys possible start having these issues.
Guys like Garakol with no prior problems, nothing that foreshadowed the situation he
and the Yankees are currently in.
And speaking of the Yankees, anything wrong with Cole of course means a whole lot wrong
as a team.
You don't have Garakol, I mean that is one of, maybe the biggest blow anyone can take
to the rotation right now.
He's getting paid 320 plus million dollars for a reason.
He's their guy.
It may not be the smartest thing ever, but the Yankees really are relying a whole lot
of their success on Cole.
And if Cole is even not fully there, that's bad, let alone if he's fully not there.
I don't think it's an overreaction to say the Yankees season is done if the Garakol
news is anything but good.
I've seen Yankees fans say that, and I don't blame them.
I mean this would be as big of a blow as a blow can possibly get.
I don't know if anyone's ever said that before, so if not, I just created a new saying.
You're welcome.
The Yankees rotation is full of question marks.
Carlos Rodon is the furthest thing from a sure impact piece, which is the furthest thing
from ideal considering the contract he's on.
Nestor Cortez had an awful year last year when he pitched, which wasn't often because
his shoulder kept him mostly on the injured list, so he's not certain.
I'd say the only certain guys are Clark Schmitt and Marcus Stroman.
Schmitt wasn't good last year, and even Stroman was banged up last year.
Nothing with his arm, but even if he's fully healthy, if he is looked at as the ace, your
team is not built that well, and when your team is not built that well in the AL East,
you're asking to get smacked around.
The Orioles, the Blue Jays, the Rays, the Red Sox, those teams aren't looking to mess
around.
Okay, yes, I was just making sure you were paying attention.
The Red Sox are not in the same boat, at least seemingly, as those teams, but with the AL
East being as tough as it already is, even with Cole on the Yankees fully healthy, now
imagine him no longer being a factor?
Never say never, but it'd be a miracle for a Yankees team without Cole to win more games
than the Orioles, Blue Jays, and Rays.
Garrett Cole is just one guy, but he still means so much to this pitching staff and has
such an impact, and with this news, it just shows that Cole is yet another reminder that
you have to hold your breath with basically every pitcher now, it seems.
It's like the NFL, where at any moment, on any play, any player can get some season-ending
injury, just with baseball, it's for pitchers.
The Yankees seem to already be preparing for the worst, too, as they've re-engaged with
the White Sox and made a new trade proposal for Dylan Cease, their ace, so let's hope
for the best for Cole.
It's hard to see this having a good outcome, whether short-term or long-term, but hoping
for the best is all we can do.
Either way, from what we know right now, with Cole, and with Judge, and with everything,
the Yankees really might be screwed.
Let me know what you think, thank you for watching, and I'll see you soon.
