HOW TO PLAY PIANO DUO 4 HANDS // Practice and Performance Tips + BIG ANNOUNCEMENT IN THE END!

Learning Piano
22 followers
Hi everyone, this is Danae, and today I'm joined by my sister, Kiveli.
Hi!
And we are making a joint video because we will be talking about four-hand repertoire.
We chose one piece that we are playing very soon in concert, actually in a couple of days,
and it is by Ludwig van Beethoven, Variations, that he wrote on a theme that is called Ich denke
Dein, and he wrote a couple of variations for piano four-hand, and we will be playing that,
so we decided to make a little tutorial on things to look out for when playing piano four-hand,
important points, when you practice, when you're on stage, and we will be getting into all of that.
Also, stay until the end of the video because we have a very big announcement at the end of
the video that concerns us both, so if you're interested in hearing that, then make sure to
watch the whole thing. So the first point is how we distribute the sound, and in our case,
I usually play the upper part of the piano and Kiveli plays the lower part of the piano,
so for me, it is always very important that I try to project very strongly into the hall,
that I really make sure that these upper tones, which don't carry as much as the lower ones do,
they really get through that whole sound cloud that we are producing and really make it to the
end of the hall, and as the person playing in the lower part of the piano, it's actually quite
paradox thing because the lower keys carry much easier, but you are usually the less important
voice in terms of volume, and I would say another thing that's very important is even within your
lower voice to prioritize, of course, which voices are more important, and more often than not,
I would say the most important voice is obviously the nice melody carrying voice,
and then next in line would be my bass, so my left hand, and then the right hand,
which usually plays a more intricate figure of accompaniment, is the least important,
so usually the more notes you have, the less important they are, and the more staying notes,
the more permanent notes are the ones that kind of bring the depth that are important to stress.
In piano forehands, the person who plays in the lower register is usually always also responsible
for the pedal, which is absolutely its own art form, and something that also took me
a very long time to master, and I have to always be very, very mindful of, because obviously you're
not just pedaling for your own voice, but you're also pedaling for a voice that you're not playing,
which means that many times you have to go contrary to what would feel natural if you
would play by yourself. For example, if Danai has a staccato figure and I have scale figures,
if I would be playing by myself, I would usually try to keep a constant pedaling around the scale
figures to make it seem more together and harmonious, but I have to be very careful
to never pedal in one of Danai's staccato figures, otherwise suddenly you would hear
something very unnatural from Danai's voice, from the perspective of Danai's voice.
So you really have to know the parts of the other player very, very well to the point that you could
almost play yourself so that you can pedal it correctly for the duo. And very important,
especially I would say more romantic repertoire, where you get to places where really what is
expected is that one voice sounds pedaled and one voice doesn't sound pedaled, and many times
the lower voice that would sound pedaled, would need to sound pedaled, is really work with the
entire range of the pedal, not just like pressing it or not pressing it, but half pressing it,
quarter pressing it, especially if you quarter press it, there are like some sweet spots where
the lower part of the piano already is caught pedaled and the upper part of the piano not yet,
or it's just more of an echo that sounds. So this kind of experimentation with the full range of the
pedal is the most important tip I can give in terms of pedaling, especially in later more romantic repertoire.
When we are playing together there are a couple of situations, especially when the piece gets into
a more piano, lower volume register, where there is the danger there that the una corda pedal,
which is the left pedal, might be used in situations where it doesn't really make sense to
use it, especially concerning the upper voice. And it is a very strange feeling when playing together
because for me, for example, who is mostly only responsible for the melody and not really for the
accompaniment, which usually in piano registers is more uncomfortable because you have more notes
and have to get them all super silent, for me it feels kind of natural to really refrain from using
it quite a lot, because otherwise my melody is going to sound a bit muffled. I've made a couple
of previous videos on pedaling and also una corda where I've mentioned this, and if you've watched
them you know that I'm not a fan of using una corda a lot. I always say use it really only when
you want an actual color change and not when you want a dynamic change or a change in volume, so
it really should be reserved for very special occasions. And when you play duo it is important to
always keep in mind what the melody is doing and not only focus on what might feel very right
I would say that as the person actually in charge of not pressing it when when the moment comes,
obviously there are a few things to keep in mind. First of all is where you are. There are certain
instruments or halls where it would make more or less sense to press it, even if you during the
rehearsal session decided for example to not press it, then you are in a hall, it's very echoey, the
instrument is maybe particularly loud, and then you end up pressing it, obviously, or the other
way around. But it is definitely a fact that many times you have to keep in mind that the melody,
kind of the shining quality of the melody, has the priority and you just have to really work on
playing that piano volume just by yourself. However one thing that I do find myself doing
very often also that we we talk about is using the una corda also not just as like a on or off
kind of situation, but pressing it for example just for the resolution of a phrase, like keeping
it not pressed and then for the resolution of a phrase where the melody itself also goes down
and then you have to go down even further as the accompaniment, using it for these very few
special moments and almost like using it for singular notes rather than an entire phrase.
Obviously when you play piano forehand it has to be very clear in any given phrase what is the sound
responsibility of mine and what is the sound responsibility of Danai's. More often than not
the allocation of responsibility is pretty clear. Danai's responsibility is to project and give that
shining quality of the upper registers of the piano that can really reach into the last kind of
audience member in the back of the hall and my responsibility is of course to be
present but carry in a different way. So I always find myself thinking I'm like kind of more
the warm, the support from underneath and my role is to kind of provide that perfect little
natural framework on which then the painting can be drawn musically. I think what is important is
for the person playing on the upper part to also kind of try to go into the sound that is being
created from the bass and we have one musical example that we're going to play now in a minute
where this is demonstrated, where Kiveli is playing kind of a carpet of harmony underneath
and it is important that I don't only project but that I also sound-wise find myself getting
into this bass that she has created.
When playing piano duo and especially piano four hands on one piano so that excludes the
repertoire for two pianos, it is I think the only form of chamber music that exists where you are
sharing one instrument. There is no repertoire for two people playing one violin or anything like
that. It only exists on the piano and that is a very special situation because you are creating
the sound from one tool, one piano and it means that you really have to sound like one person and
what you would do when you would play solo and somehow create a sound common with two hands,
you now have to do with two people and four hands and this is why it is really important to know
exactly what your piano partner sounds like, to know what kind of sound they produce, how they
produce it and really find your place within that sound and this is why we also believe that it is
very common for piano duos to be either siblings or married couples because it really takes a lot
of playing together to achieve this common sound. It is not the type of thing where you can meet at
a festival and then just play together. Of course that exists and of course sometimes there are
amazing results but to really have an actual amount of repertoire as a piano duo and sound
good, it is I think comparable to for example a string quartet that also has to find a common
sound and this is why we also like to play piano duos because we've been playing together
basically for our entire lives and it really takes that dedication also to have that common sound
as a piano. Another thing that of course is a very interesting element of when you play chamber
music in general but maybe it's an extra intent when you play piano for hands is the fact that
you have to be in a constant dialogue with each other and that many times when one person starts
a phrase the other person actually ends the phrase ends that musical thought so you have to
kind of be able to finish a phrase in a way where in your mind you're actually continuing to play
and phrase beyond your own notes and that is I think one of the probably funnest parts also
of playing piano duos because those are the moments that usually end up getting the most
spontaneity when you end up playing them on stage like the way maybe one of us would time the
beginning of the phrase would of course then influence the way the other person would then
time the ending of the phrase and of course those are the moments that when you know each other very
well and you can trust that the other person is able to pick up on that spontaneous idea you can
then of course have so much fun with it and really try to also kind of coax out of each other a
completely new way of looking at that phrase in that moment which then creates of course a very
nice dimension to the performance and when you're practicing at first it might feel a little bit
unnatural to when your phrase ends to not have it actually end like it would if you were just
practicing a solo piece so even if it feels unnatural don't be worried about that the piece
will only be complete when playing it with your partner and it is more important to create one
common phrase than for you to feel comfortable when practicing it alone so sometimes when we
practice separately it feels very strange because we kind of stop in the middle of the phrase full
of tension there's no resolving feeling but this is because the other one then has that resolving
feeling and actually i don't know if you remember we used to do this uh many years ago when we used
to practice two and even two pianos where we would have this thing where we would say okay i'm going
to play this phrase in five different ways and depending on how i play you're going to react to
it and it always was was like a game for example when it was about dynamics three phrases are we
going to play it in a crescendo in a diminuendo in a like two one three so what we will do is
almost like a game i deny let's say we'll decide okay tonight today i'm going to play it with
diminuendo you're gonna have to react to it so you can really also get into a playful mindset with
these things
another interesting aspect about playing piano for hands is the space there is not a lot of space
you're sitting next to each other body's touching at the piano and also your hands are touching and
your fingers very often get in the way of each other and i think there is no piece where there
is not at least one of these situations where either my hand or kiveli's hand is in the way
of the other one playing and very often i have to put in my score take away that finger or maybe
actually i have to let go of one legato in order to lift that note so that kiveli can play because
she has the melody with it so there are tons of situations like this one and in the in this
piece that we chose for you today right in the beginning if kiveli would play her voice as she
would normally play it fingering wise and hand position wise i wouldn't even be able to play
my first note so we recorded what this would be like and as you can see the solution is for her
to lift her hand up in a kind of a natural way actually and for me to go underneath and play
that first note and then for her to slowly go back into the normal playing position
and this kind of situation is very normal in a piano duo so you always just have to be open to
finding solutions of how you're going to position your hands in order to accommodate the other
person i think that usually there are like one or three scenarios if it's not like one of the
times which also happens sometimes but there is one of three scenarios that you need to go for
and always when we play through a piece for the first time we have to write them down in our
score okay the first one is what you just mentioned with the hand position like one person plays from
the top or the one person plays from the bottom and you have to decide what makes more sense
usually depending on whether someone plays black keys or white keys is what it comes down to
the second thing is actually having to go against what's in the score what you mentioned with the
legatos and things like that or maybe a note that is written in the score as a quarter note
you have to then suddenly play it as a quaver note because you know in the second quaver suddenly the
other person hasn't managed to actually have to go against what's in the notes to make it possible
and the third thing is that you have to choose your fingering not just according to what feels
the most comfortable but also what makes sense in comfort with the other person for example many
times if i have an accompaniment figure of course i would usually use my i would say
quote unquote dominant fingers the first the second and the third and i would kind of play
with these fingers however if then i as a melody very close to my compliment i'm gonna have to
play the accompaniment with my third fourth and fifth finger which is less comfortable i would
say and less natural however i have to do it because otherwise my third fourth and fifth
finger are just constantly in the way and she can't play comfortably so this is like a classic
example that happens many many times i think the number one thing that people practice when playing
channel do worry about and want to go or playing play anything with another musician is being
together not just having the same pulse and being together throughout the piece but especially
starting together being together in the rubati in the ritardando where there is no clear pulse
and those kind of moments where you can't really explain it you can't really count it you just have
to feel it and very often this is labeled breathing together breathe together with your
musical partner and i think there is some truth to that um for sure it is the most common thing
is to kind of show there is this thing that either kiveli or i depending on the situation
show when to start but even that showing can be so different from person to person it can be an
entire bar it can be a beat it can just be a feeling so you really have to know once again
your partner really feel what they mean and this comes over time in the beginning i think we
completely didn't know of course what the other one meant when doing that and now we are at a
point after playing together for years and years and years we're at a point where we can almost
just place the hands on the piano and more or less start together i think um there are two
kind of important elements that i have found and had to kind of move towards the first thing is
that it is very enticing in piano forehand because you can actually see the other person
to try to look at their hands and when they're going to press the keys and then kind of instead
of listening to when they play look at when they play and then try to be together that way and that
is not a good strategy i find that many times because two reasons one is a psychological reason
because then you're kind of getting more into i would say panic mode okay i'm going to see exactly
what they play and panic mode is never conducive to good music making and the second thing is
because simply it's not a good way to get your information from because there is also the speed
with which you press the key and everything so it really it seems easier it isn't so it's always
easier to really focus on listening to each other and then when it comes to these like kind of
intangible magical qualities feeling for example in the end of a slow movement when to play the
resolution together you have to do it again and again and again and it's the most important
element is this element of trust that at some point you know that if you just focus on really
listening to how the sound develops it's going to be together it's really difficult to explain
because at some point it's just this feeling this like kind of gut feeling of i know when the note
is going to come and that's when you play it and the moment you get out of that and you start kind
of second guessing yourself those are the moments where it ends up not being together and i think
the trust thing is very important because it's also very dangerous to wait for each other oh
yeah because you don't go into that thing where you wait for each other and you kind of wait for
that beginning of the sound and then quickly add in your note because that never works you're never
together you really have to take that leap of faith and if you believe the note's coming now
place your note as well yeah and that's going to be better than waiting and then being completely
apart another thing that of course for piano doers like us that we also live together is something
that we have to think about is whether we practice separately or whether we practice together
immediately and definitely like in any other form of chamber music where you meet for rehearsals
it is very important to first practice by yourself for many reasons first of all not just to learn
the notes and be able to kind of technically master your part but also you first have to get
to know your part very well and feel so comfortable in it that then when the other person comes in you
can actually focus primarily on the other person's part rather than your own part that's when you can
actually start to have a quality interpretation together i imagine it's like almost i don't know
like an actor who first has to know their part very well so that when then they get into the
scene with the other person they don't have to constantly think about their next line but they
can react to the way the other person says their line and of course that is the point you want to
get to to then find a common language within that piece having said that of course you can read
through the piece once together with your partner to just get an idea to know what you were saying
before where those phrases go if there are any musical surprises coming from the other side but
then of course get to know the piece by yourself before you get into that dual practice which has
its whole own set of challenges so these were our tips for playing piano four hands as a long-time
piano duo that we are we really hope you found this interesting and now before we end this video
here is our big announcement and surprise we are starting a podcast together it's called the sister
trill and i'm going to link the channel down below you can listen to it anywhere that you are listening
to podcasts you can also watch it on youtube and the first episode is going live on saturday which
is the 3rd of july the podcast is going to be a lot about our lives as sisters and as sisters who
are both in the same business and in the same social circles about our relationship how we
cultivated our relationship now how we used to be like with each other when we were kids and
teenagers going through music studies and masterclasses and playing concerts together
navigating our lives in as i said the same business knowing the same people sometimes trying
to kind of go for the same chances to advance our careers so it's very much about that aspect of our
lives also of course our personal lives yes it's very personal so much more personal than what you
see on this channel sometimes i get very personal comments and questions and i never really get into
here but on the podcast we are going to be getting deeply into those ones so if you're interested in
seeing this more personal approach very much more behind the scenes of our lives as sisters musicians
and everything that goes with that then definitely tune in you can head over and subscribe to the
channel now already as i said the first episode is going live on saturday or just listen to it on all
the other platforms we're very excited about this and we hope that you will tune in and other than
that i'll see you again on the next video on this channel next tuesday bye bye
you're listening to the sister drill with danai and kibbeli
