Kaiser Permanente vs Everyone Else! In-Depth Look At Covered Ca, Medicare and Small Business
3 Video Views·Oct 31, 2024
We're getting a lot of questions these days about Kaiser
versus other plans, either Kaiser versus PPO, Kaiser versus
Medicare supplements versus other group plans.
So let's really dive into how do we compare Kaiser with other
options available to us on the market?
We're going to first talk about Kaiser generally, what it is,
how it works, how it's different.
And then we're going to dive into the individual markets,
which is primarily Covered California, Medicare, and small business.
So let's first understand Kaiser as a model, because that'll help us
really get into the differences as we look at the individual markets.
So Kaiser, it's an HMO.
And by definition, let's go back a little bit back in time and history
where managed care really came into play back in the eighties, health
insurance and healthcare costs were kind of exploding.
They came out with HMOs and then PPOs to put constraint on
that cost inflation, basically.
So with an HMO, you could almost think of it as a little fixed
bucket of money per member.
So, and this is partially why it works really well in populous areas, big
cities where you have lots of people and lots of doctors and big hospitals.
HMOs work better there.
They're going to be more competitive price-wise because you have lots of
bodies because you can look at it this way.
Kaiser is essentially saying as an HMO, we're going to have $500 per
member per month to spend in healthcare.
All right, that won't work if you have 10 members, but if you have 10,000
members, then if one person has a $500,000 bill, it's not a big deal.
You spread it out among other people.
But by definition, you have a fixed amount of money.
It's almost like a little mini single payer plan and you divvy that up and
there's a constraint based on costs to kind of deliver healthcare effectively,
but also cost effectively.
And so it was the first model that really slowed the curve of healthcare
costs way back in the eighties.
Kaiser is unique in that it is both the provider of healthcare
and the payer of healthcare.
And most without most other HMOs, which you do have from other carriers, they
have the same kind of cost constraint model and HMO, but they contract out
with private doctors and hospitals.
And what they do is they take an amount that $500 we were talking about.
They say $450, we're going to give to the doctors and hospitals.
You provide care.
You're responsible for that care within that 450.
If you can't contain costs, you're going to lose money.
If you can keep costs at 450 or under, then you'll continue to be profitable.
Or if you're a nonprofit to maintain your cost structure.
So that's kind of how it works.
Kaiser's kind of unique take on it is it's all in house.
So when you go to Kaiser's HMO model, you use Kaiser facilities.
You see Kaiser doctors on almost all cases, you have to stay within Kaiser.
Now, if you have a big Kaiser facility where you live and they have lots of
doctors and they're in all the big cities, because we talked about how HMOs work
best and Kaiser is an HMO, then that's going to work out.
All right.
We're kind of talking high level stuff.
Let's bring this down to you as an individual or as a company or a senior.
Well, how's this really play?
How does this work for you?
What we find is people usually love Kaiser.
They've been in it all their life.
They may have been born in Kaiser or they really don't like it.
Why?
Why is there such a difference in how people see the exact same model?
It kind of comes down to control and to access, because again, with
Kaiser, you have to stay within Kaiser.
If there's a specialist for knee replacement, who's not in Kaiser,
you probably can't go see him.
If there's someone at UCLA or UCSF, who's really good at heart related issues,
you probably won't be able to go see him unless they don't have that, a similar
type of person within Kaiser, and they probably do.
So where we usually see friction is where I want to be able to access certain
specialties in a extreme situation, health wise, something big that's come
up, surgery, cancer, heart related issues, autoimmune, you name it.
And they want to be able to go see somebody outside Kaiser.
You're probably not going to be able to, because Kaiser's all intact.
And again, what we find is for 95% of healthcare issues, this works great.
Kaiser is really good at maternity.
They're really good at your day-to-day health.
In fact, because it's all inclusive, they might be a little bit
better at coordinating all the information that's tied to you.
And then you go to one doctor, you have to give them your medications.
You go to another doctor, they don't have any of your information really.
Well with Kaiser, it's all intact, but then the trade-off is
there's going to be this constraint.
The other way we see that play out where some people get upset about
is your control over what care.
So for example, let's say I have back pain and it's bad.
I have a ruptured disc and I want to go in for surgery to get it fixed.
Well, Kaiser may say, before we do surgery, we're going to do some
pain medication for a period of time.
And then we're going to do some physical therapy, some PT, and then
we're going to do something else.
And then we might look at surgery.
So there's a step kind of process to how care is delivered.
You may not have direct control over what things get done.
And so that's a difference where sometimes people get frustrated and we hear that
on the Medicare Advantage side, and we hear that with Covered California, but
really on the Medicare side where they're like, look, with Kaiser, I feel like I'm
getting turned down to get certain things done that I want to get done.
Now, in terms of what's effective medically, it may be fine, but in terms
of what the person wants to move forward on or what they're reading about or
what's kind of cutting edge, there may be a difference there.
Because again, there is a cost constraint with an HMO to every decision that's made.
Is this medically effective and is it also cost effective?
So there's going to be some friction there where you have to have
preauthorizations, things can get declined.
On the medication side, we'll see sometimes a class of medication will get
shifted for a lot of members because it's cheaper based on where we think the
contract that Kaiser signs, because again, they provide all medication,
they provide the pharmacy as well.
So you're not going to go to Walgreens if you're on a Kaiser plan.
This is not a knock on Kaiser.
This is really a function of the HMO model.
And so your issue probably isn't going to be with Kaiser.
It's with the way HMOs are going to put pressure on costs to deliver health care.
There's a trade-off with that.
Some of it's good in that maybe they're not as quick to cut and operate when they
shouldn't, we hear about that all the time.
Some of it's not so good in that, you know, you're going to be fighting the tide a
little bit to get certain things done.
That's just a function of HMO and Kaiser.
It just happens to be in-house versus other HMO models in a contract out with
private doctors or hospitals, but because they shifted the cost constraint component
like that $450 I talked about onto them, they are then going to make that same
decision just from their own self, not self-interest, but from their vantage
point, since the carrier has passed on the buck of responsibility to them in an HMO
model.
So how do we compare this with PPOs with EPOs, which are like PPOs and other options
like that?
Let's start to dive into the different markets because that makes it easier to
understand.
And they're very different.
We'll look at individual and family.
We'll look at Medicare, including Advantage Medicare supplement, and we'll look at
small business and see how Kaiser versus these other options play out according to
the market.
All right, let's talk about Kaiser versus PPO and other plans and the Cover
California market, which is almost all our individual family enrollment these days
because we can get subsidies, we can get really rich versions of the silver plan,
which are available to everyone in 2025.
It's kind of crazy, meaning regardless of income, we can get almost a gold level
plan at the silver break.
So definitely almost everything's Cover California, and we're happy to walk
through why that's so important versus off exchange, especially now.
Kaiser versus all the options out there, it kind of depends on which model we want
to look at.
There are, Kaiser's all HMO, and then the other big carriers, a lot of them are
also HMO.
So Blue Shield has an HMO, Anthem has an HMO, Health Net, you have Sharp down
south.
I mean, there are a lot of different options depending on where you're at in
the state that are HMO.
They're going to work very comparable.
The pricing wise, they're going to be kind of close to where Kaiser is.
HMOs generally are cheaper because there's that cost constraint we talked about.
Of course, nothing's for free, right?
We're giving up something, but then it may be a function of what we can afford and
HMO is going to be the deal.
In that case, it comes down to network.
Do you want to be in Kaiser, Kaiser facilities, Kaiser doctors, and you're in
this little ecosystem exclusively?
Or do you want access to other doctors and hospitals outside?
For example, if I want to go to UCLA down south, I can look at LA Care and even
Blue Shield HMO is going to be on board there in 2025.
If I want to go to a different like Sutter, it may be Anthem EPO or a different plan.
So it really comes down to where you want to go, where you want access to.
And it's really night and day, meaning I'm either in Kaiser or I'm out of Kaiser.
That's the thing to understand.
Otherwise the benefits are standardized.
The silver 73 is going to be identical regardless of the carrier.
Now the rates then fluctuate, although they're going to be comparable for HMO.
So then the question becomes Kaiser versus PPO in Covered California or versus EPO.
Anthem has an EPO, which is kind of in between.
It's like a PPO.
It functions very comparable to the PPO and there it's kind of night and day
because a it's also network who we can see with Kaiser, we stay in Kaiser, beat
that horse to death, and then with PPOs, it's a broader network of private
doctors and hospitals that we have access to, but also with PPO, there's
going to be more flexibility or control over care, and that's also part
of that constraint of HMO, you don't have as much with PPO, you refer yourself
out to doctors, you're not locked into a local area, you can move around
anywhere in the state and within the PPO network, you can even see providers
outside of the PPO network, although we don't recommend it because it's
expensive when you do that with an EPO, you have no benefits with a PPO, you
have very limited or watered down benefits when you go out of network, but you can
do it.
And so that's a difference.
And also that Anthem EPO, if you're on the border of California in another
state, or you split time in a different state, for right now, it still has
access to the Blue Cross or the Blue Card network, which means you can see
Blue Cross Blue Shield providers, PPO in other states, even in a non-emergency.
Keep in mind in a true emergency, they're not going to hold you to a
network, regardless of HMO or PPO.
You break a leg, they're going to take you wherever and get you patched up.
But in a non-emergency, that EPO with Anthem allows you to see
providers in other states.
That comes into play, let's say if you're up in the Tahoe area and all
your providers in Carson City, in Nevada, well, you want that Anthem EPO in that
case, even Blue Shield's PPO won't allow you to do that anymore.
Now check in with us to make sure it's still available because year to year
that can fluctuate and change.
But Kaiser, that's kind of the trade-off is we say within Kaiser, it's an HMO
model, and we talked about how that really plays out in terms of cost
constraint, and the PPO, we have a broader network, we have more flexibility
within the network, and we have more control over decision-making
between us and our doctors.
You still may need to get things pre-authorized, you still may get
pushed back from the carrier on certain things, and never take
no as your final answer.
They say no, push, push, push.
We've seen many times where eventually something gets through.
Medication's got to be a little bit more flexible in terms of your choices on
medications, although you're probably going to pay for it if you're on brand
name and more expensive brand names.
But that's the real difference for individuals and families through
Covered California or even off-exchange, but there's really no reason to go
off-exchange anymore when we're looking at Kaiser versus HMO plans or PPO
plans or even EPO plans for, again, individuals and families in California.
Let's talk about Kaiser versus other plans, including PPO and Medicare
supplements for the Medicare market, which is generally 65 and over.
Let's discuss how we compare these.
This is a little more complicated.
On one hand, Kaiser is going to be all Advantage plan, meaning the HMO side of
things, and we looked at what that really means.
Medicare is a little bit different because traditional Medicare is basically an 80-20
plan, where they're picking up 80% of the bills, you're picking up 20% after you
meet deductibles, one for hospital, part A, and one for doctors, part B.
Then you're picking up 20%.
We have to cap that 20% because it goes on indefinitely, meaning if we have a
$100,000 bill, that's 20 grand out of your pocket.
It makes no sense to do that, at least have an Advantage plan, which caps that
exposure with what they call a max out-of-pocket, so Kaiser versus other
plans, and we're getting a lot of calls lately, we're in open enrollment now, so
we expect this, of people who are on Kaiser and they want to look at other options.
Let's talk about why, what that is, and usually what is causing that surge in
general on the Medicare side, so Kaiser's all HMO, Advantage, you stay within
Kaiser, there's going to be a cost constraint because it's an HMO model, and
then on the other side, we have two different options that are quite different.
We also have Advantage plans that are offered by carriers that contract
with private doctors and hospitals, so if there's a hospital or doctor you
want who's outside of Kaiser, and this comes up all the time, we had someone
who wanted a surgeon at Keck Hospital, they were the best, they taught the
other surgeons, they taught the surgeon at Kaiser how to do the surgery.
This person wanted that doctor, so we went through a lot to get them off
of Kaiser, onto an Advantage plan that would work with Keck, work with this
doctor, and it was a process, and we got it through, reach out to us if you're
in a similar situation, but that's a difference in that private doctors and
hospitals will contract with other plans and carriers, and there can be Advantage
plans that work with really top-notch level institutions, including UCLA, UCSF,
you name it, there are a couple who don't, for example, Stanford right now is an
issue, they don't work with Advantage plans, Sharp Rees-Stealy just announced
they're no longer going to work with Advantage plans, so this is an issue,
reach out to us, and we can research who in your area with your providers
will work with you, so that's one thing.
Now, there's a whole other piece to this, let's say we want Stanford, or have to
have them, or we want Sharp Rees-Stealy, well, in that case, there are Medicare
supplements, or Medigap plans, those are kind of like the PPO side of things,
because there are Advantage plans that are PPO, but they're kind of in between,
they're not what we think of as PPO, which is a Medicare supplement, a Medicare
supplement, you can go to any doctor or hospital who accepts Medicare, which is
basically everybody, even Cedars-Sinai, even your Stanford, your Sharp Rees-Stealy,
they still work with traditional Medicare, you kind of have to, right,
because it's such a big part of the market, so we can get traditional
Medicare, we can get a Medicare supplement, like a G plan, by far the
most popular, we can run the quotes for you, you can run the quotes at our site
across all the major carriers, so you've got United Health, you've got Anthem,
Blue Cross, Blue Shield of California, Health Net, Sigma, Mutual of Omaha,
you name it, you can run it, we can run the quote for you with just zip code,
date of birth, see who's priced best for your age in your area, and it really
fluctuates, as we get older, one carrier who may have been cheap at 65 is no
longer cheap at 70, do not rest on that, use the birthday rule, you can change
plans, so with a Medicare supplement, that's the ultimate extreme of
flexibility and control and access, anywhere in the United States, you want
to go to MD Anderson for cancer in Houston, you can't with a Medicare
supplement, you're probably not going to be able to do that with even a PPO
Advantage plan, or you're going to pay a lot to do it, so that's a huge
difference for the Medicare market, again, we see a lot of people who are
on Kaiser, they may like Kaiser, but they move to an area where they didn't
like the facility, they didn't have a facility, and they need to switch to
another Advantage plan to keep costs down, or they want access to someone
and they want a Medicare supplement, they're willing to pay the extra
monthly premium in order to do that, to have control and flexibility, that's
what we see on the Medicare market, going from Kaiser to traditional
Medicare and a supplement is a little bit tricky, we have to coordinate this
well, usually around the end of the year, unless you have a trigger, like
you've moved, or Kaiser dropped you, something to that effect, reach out to
us in that situation, we can run the quotes, we can also guide you through
that process of how we transition over to traditional Medicare and a
supplement or another Advantage plan, because it's different, and we have to
do one step before the other, to make sure we don't end up with no coverage,
so that is the Medicare lay of land for Kaiser versus other plans, let's look
at small business now, and then we'll wrap it up from there, all right, Kaiser
versus all other options for the small business market, here we have some good
news, first of all, you can have a Kaiser small group, they're super flexible, if
everyone's in Kaiser in your area, in your company, that works out really
easily, it's easy for us to set up, to help you with that process, to make sure
it's structured correctly, you can pick your contribution level, how much you
want to pay towards each employee, maybe for a given plan, let's say you want to
do 75% of the silver plan, you can do that, they pick and choose from bronze,
silver, gold, platinum, super flexible, the problem we usually run into is, we
have some employees that love Kaiser, been in it all their life, they want to
stay there, and then we have other employees, where they have relationships
with private doctors and hospitals, and they want to keep those, they don't want
to go to Kaiser, as I mentioned in the very first part, it's really interesting,
people either love Kaiser or they hate Kaiser, it's kind of a weird dichotomy
for the exact same model, but as an employer, it's very hard to please both,
if you tell the Kaiser people, look we're gonna run this way, they're gonna be
upset, because literally all their records are in Kaiser, and if you tell
other people, look we're only gonna do Kaiser, you're gonna get some pushback,
you're gonna get people who aren't happy, and so what do we do about this, it's
actually really nice, we have something called the Kaiser wrap, where we can
offer Kaiser alongside other major carriers, United, Anthem, Blue Shield,
Health Net, we can have PPOs, we can have HMOs within those carriers, even EPOs or
HSA plans, we can offer those plans alongside Kaiser plans, side-by-side, and
here's the best part, as the employer, Kaiser usually is gonna be cheaper in a
given area, which is why they're so dominant, if we have good Kaiser
facilities, a lot of groups go that way, because they're cheaper, and a lot
of the employees are used to Kaiser, because they've been in it, so we can
base our contribution as an employer on a Kaiser plan, we can say, hey we're gonna
pay 75% of the silver plan for Kaiser, the Kaiser silver, and then we can create
a worksheet, which will go to each employee, we'll give it to you, and it'll
show their plans, they're out-of-pocket by plan choice, so they can pick a Kaiser
plan, they could also pick a Blue Shield PPO plan, because they're, that's very
important to them, they're willing to pay extra, maybe they have doctors or
hospitals in other areas they want to access, they have established, they're in
the middle of some kind of treatment, you don't want to take that from them, they
can pick and choose from a Blue Shield gold plan, now they're gonna pay the
difference of what you would pay for the Kaiser silver to get that gold, but
they're gonna make the calculation on what's important to them, is it worth it
for me to pay an extra $100 a month to be able to get this flexibility and
control and access, that's up to them, that's the beauty of it, you're able to
lock in your budget on a monthly basis, even based on a Kaiser plan, which tends
to be cheaper, they have full flexibility, they can go Kaiser and save some money,
or they can go with a Health Net or Anthem plan, we can offer one carrier
alongside, but they could pick from an HMO, so they can still see their doctors
but keep their costs down, or they could pick a PPO plan if they want complete
flexibility, not only where in California, but probably the US, depending on how we
structure it, that works well if you have employees in other states as well, in
fact you almost have to have that, some kind of PPO option in other states, so
where you can get access to what's called the Blue Card Network, to see
Blue Cross Blue Shield providers, so the Kaiser wrap is fantastic, and if we have
a small company, let's say three, four, five employees, there's a way we can
actually get this done, even with Blue Shield of California, they have
requirements on how big of a company can do a Kaiser wrap, there's actually a way
we can get that done as well, so reach out to us if you're trying to offer
Kaiser by itself, we can run the quotes, or alongside another carrier, and still
lock in your budget to those Kaiser numbers, this is by far the best way to
go, you lock in your budget, the employees are happy, it's almost as good as you can
get for employer benefits.

