Historian Answers Wild West Questions | Tech Support | WIRED

Matters That Matter
38 followers
Oct 31, 2024 #Education
I'm historian Mark Lee Gardner. Let's answer your questions from the internet. This is Wild West
Support. This question is from Quora. Who is the most dangerous outlaw in the Old West? Well,
there's several candidates. John Wesley Hardin maybe killed as many as two dozen men. He's the
one you might have heard of that killed a man just for snoring. He heard a loud snoring through the
thin wall in this hotel and fired several shots, and he stopped snoring. But I just think Jesse
and Frank James are a little scarier. I would vote for them as the most dangerous. Jesse and Frank
had come out of a very vicious, horrible civil war. One of their leaders was called Bloody Bill
Anderson, and he actually hung Union soldiers' scalps from his bridle and saddle. And after the
war, because they'd become so numb to that violence, it just didn't bother them to kill
somebody. And there were lots of innocent victims in their robberies. You either opened up the safe
or you got shot, and they were serious. One man who knew them said, if Jesse said he was going
to kill you, you could probably talk him out of it. But if Frank said he was going to kill you,
he was going to kill you. At Made of Dope, WTF is a 49er. Gold is discovered in California in 1848.
The news rushes eastward, and the very next year, 1849, sees hordes, thousands of potential
gold seekers, traveling west to California, and they got named the 49ers. At Butch Clayson asks,
Tombstone or Wyatt Earp? Which film did the OK Corral scene best? I feel like the Wyatt Earp,
Kevin Costner version, is a little more accurate in that it has the gunfighters much closer
together. They were literally within a few feet of each other. The Tombstone movie with Kurt Russell,
it's a very big lot, and actually that lot where the gunfight occurred, estimates are as small as
15 feet across. So it's very tight, very compacted. One thing that I liked about both films was that
they did pull from the historical dialogue that was taken down in witness testimony after the OK
Corral gunfight. That one famous line where Doc Holliday tells one of the McLaurys, he says,
you're a daisy if you do. Well, that actually was what he spoke at the time. But the one thing that
really stood out to me was that they have the Earps and Doc Holliday pulling guns from holsters.
Wyatt Earp pulled his revolver from a coat pocket. Doc Holliday pulled his revolver from
a coat pocket. It was very common at that time to have tailors make pistol pockets in your coats.
It's said that Wyatt Earp's pocket was actually lined with canvas to ease a revolver coming out
of that pocket and not catching the hammer on your coat. User 714943 says, please help me make
a Wild West playlist. Well, I'd be happy to. I play lots of Wild West songs. You know, the Cowboys
love all kinds of music, sentimental ballads. Here we have a couple of cowboy musicians in Texas,
and they also like songs about the range. And we'll do one for you right now. Hit it, Vance.
So in that song, you hear the word doggie. That was an orphaned calf. An orphaned calf
is eating, you know, kind of coarse range grass, and their bellies get extended, and they were
called doe-bellied or doe guts. And from that, we get the word doggie.
Here's another one for your playlist. It's Old Dan Tucker.
Thank you, Vance. Thank you.
At Chris J. Jarrett says, watching a Western the other day, and they had to check their guns to
come into the city. Made me think, did the Old West have stricter gun laws than we have now?
They did have very strict gun laws in the towns or the cities. Places like Tombstone,
Wichita, and Dodge City, these are big cattle towns. They're driving huge herds of cattle in.
The cowboys are getting paid off. They have guns. It's dangerous.
So these communities had city ordinances preventing the wearing of guns,
preventing having concealed weapons. Only lawmen were able to carry their guns.
It's a very dangerous occupation for a lawman to disarm drunken cowboys.
So these cowboys, when they came in with their guns, they had to check them.
They had to drop them off at a certain location. And then when they were leaving town,
they could pick their guns up and take them back with them. But they could not be wearing firearms
while they were in these city limits. At Lee Sachs, did Old West saloons have anything else
to drink other than whiskey and beer? Cowboys must like a fancy drink every once in a while.
All these boom towns, whether it was Dodge City or Deadwood or Tombstone,
they had well-stocked bars. And we have lots of photographs, and you can see all different
types of bottles, whether it's wine or champagne, brandy, gin. In 1874,
there was a book published, The Bartender's Guide, that gave you how to make cordials,
juleps. The more elaborate bars, and there were many, could just make any drink that you had a
hankering for. Javert Hugo asked, what hats were really most common in the Wild West?
The most famous hat maker actually made the hats in Pennsylvania. His name was John B. Stetson.
But he had gone to the West. He was part of the Pikes Peak Gold Rush in 1859. But in the 1860s,
he developed a hat called the Trail Boss. And it had a flat crown and just a standard wide brim,
but it was very well made. And he developed a reputation. And I've actually got a real
Stetson hat here. This is a John B. Stetson. It's got the wide brim, nothing fancy with the crown.
This is called a pencil roll rim here. This is probably from like the 1920s or 1930s. They
weren't the only ones that made cowboy hats. But if you were a cowboy and you had the money,
you wanted a Stetson. Another popular style of hat was the derby or what might be called the
bowler hat. There's that famous picture of the Wild Bunch, the outlaws, Butch Cassidy,
and some of them are wearing the derby hats. And if you wore a certain kind of hat,
you might draw attention and get picked on. There's a story from Tombstone, Arizona.
Whenever a dude came in wearing a top hat, now a dude is like a newbie, city slicker, what have
you. Doc Holliday, if they spotted him, would follow that dude around ringing a dinner bell,
drawing attention. You know, we've got a dude here. We've got a newbie in town.
The next question is from the Ask Historian subreddit. When did the Old West officially end?
Just saw Killers of the Flower Moon and it takes place in the 20s, but still feels very much like
the late 1800s. Well, that's a great question. Some people might say the Buffalo. When the
Buffalo are no longer free ranging, when barbed wire fences are stretched across the plains,
there are no longer cattle drives, that could be the end of the Old West. But to me, it's when
the automobile takes the place of the horse. Maybe that's the 1930s or 40s, but when there's
no more horses on the streets, then to me, the Old West is over. Jed Houston wants to know,
how many Buffalo roamed this country before they were slaughtered to near extinction? Before the
horse was introduced to North America by the Spanish, the estimates go from 28 to 30 million
Buffalo on the Great Plains. In the early part of the 19th century, the robe trade was very popular.
The Indians hunted the Buffalo and the Indian women fully tanned these robes. They were used
in the East in Europe as lap robes, but a good robe had to come from a cow or a calf. It's easier
to work the hide. So that's the breeding population. If you're just killing cows and calves,
it's kind of a recipe for disaster. In 1860, a newspaper reported that probably 800,000 Buffalo
were slaughtered each year. There are lots of examples of passengers on the steam trains
shooting at the herds as they sped down the tracks. You can see an example of that in film
in the movie Dead Man with Johnny Depp. By 1884 then, there's estimated just 324 Buffalo in the
United States. A lot of it was meat hunters. That's how Buffalo Bill Cody got his name.
He was hunting Buffalo and getting meat for the railroad crews. And interestingly enough,
Buffalo Bill later starts a Wild West exhibition, the same show that featured the famous gunwoman
known as Annie Oakley. AtAndyDoodle56 says, wait, Annie Oakley was real? Yes, she was real. Annie
Oakley was the real deal too. She was an excellent marksman. She had a partner. She would look at the
mirror, had the gun over her shoulder, she'd have a cigarette in his lips, and she would shoot off
the end of the cigarette. It seems very dangerous. Buffalo Bill Cody, the Wild West exhibition
traveled really around the world. One of the big draws for Buffalo Bill Cody's show was these stage
recreations, whether it was a buffalo hunt, whether it was an Indian attack on a wagon train,
a robber's attack on a stagecoach, the cavalry. They got to see Sitting Bull one year. Sitting
Bull was well known as a leader of the Lakotas. They actually could see this person they read
about, see him in the flesh. I mean, it was quite an experience. Very, very popular, and it went for
decades. AtMentalNox says, what do you mean the only authenticated photo of the real Billy the Kid
was only found in 2011? Well, there is only one authenticated, and it existed a lot before 2011.
It's this here. This is a tintype that was made at Fort Sumner of Billy the Kid by a traveling
photographer. We don't know who the photographer was. And there's something you have to know about
tintypes. Tintypes are reverse images. And if you look in this image, you would think that Billy
the Kid was left-handed. In fact, there's a movie with Paul Newman called The Left-Handed Gun. That's
the story of Billy the Kid. He's called the left-handed gun because of this image. But because
we know that tintypes are reverse images, actually, Billy has his pistol on his right hip. So this is
the image corrected the way that it should be. And actually, this is an enlargement of the tintype.
The actual tintype was the size of this tintype. It's very small. And the reason it's called a
tintype is because the photograph is actually made on tin. The emulsion is on a very thin
piece of tin. Technical name, ferrotype. And the reason we know that this photo of Billy the Kid
is authentic is because it was identified as Billy the Kid in his own lifetime. It appeared in the
Illustrated Police News while he was still alive. A few years ago, this actual tintype, the one that's
in this image, this sold at auction for $2.3 million. So that had a huge effect because when
a small tintype brings that kind of money, people are going to start looking for other pictures of
Billy the Kid. So in recent years, there have been a lot of photos. They have some kind of a
resemblance to Billy the Kid. But you just can't identify a photo based on resemblance. You have
to have some kind of provenance that links it to Billy the Kid. There's a picture of supposedly
Billy the Kid playing croquet. These are wannabe images. There's no connection with that image to
Billy the Kid. At JcMeow asked, did black cowboys ever exist? Yes, they did. In fact, as many as 25%
of cowboys in the Old West were black. After the Civil War, there were a lot of freed African
Americans. They're looking for opportunity. One place for opportunity is in the American West.
Another outlet for African American men was the U.S. Army, the Buffalo Soldiers. The 9th and 10th
Cavalry were African American units. One very famous African American in the West was a lawman.
His name was Bass Reeves. Bass Reeves was noted for the many gun scrapes and also the many arrests
that he made. Many people think that he was the inspiration for the Lone Ranger. And according
to some accounts, he actually worked with Indian scouts, which might lead to this theory that he
was the inspiration for the Lone Ranger. At AdsMarketing24, when did branding cattle start?
That's a great question. Actually, the branding of livestock goes way back, in fact, to ancient
Egypt. But as far as North America, when the Spaniards arrive, they're bringing their cattle
and their sheep. And they're also bringing the ways of running livestock. And we really have
our first cowboys. They were called the Baqueros. This starts this whole cattle culture. And a lot
of the cowboying that still goes on today can be directly traced to these Baqueros and to the
Spanish practices. One of those practices, of course, is branding, identifying your livestock.
This is really a cool brand because we know that it's a Mexican or Spanish brand. And the reason
we know that is that the letters have serifs. Non-Mexican or Spanish brands generally don't
have the serifs. The branding iron can get very hot, okay, if you're branding a lot of cattle.
So this is where you would put a wood handle in the end. The fact that it's not one long handle
makes it easier to transport out on the range. You've got something you can break down.
Okay, at Gilded Santiago, why was the 10-gauge shotgun so popular in the wild west? Did they
just want things extra super duper dead or what? Well, they did want things dead. So if you've
heard of the stagecoaches, if you've heard of Wells Fargo, the shotgun messenger, he sat next
to the driver and he held a 10-gauge shotgun. And that's where the phrase comes that you're
riding shotgun. It was also manufactured with a shorter barrel. When the gun goes off, the shot
is going to spread quicker at your target. It's going to be very wide. If you're riding shotgun
and you've got a couple of robbers up there, you want a big pattern and hopefully knock them out
of commission. There were two other firearms, very popular. One is the Winchester Repeater.
You might've heard of the Model 1873. It is a lever action weapon. So it fires several rounds
each time you work the lever action. The other weapon that also fired several rounds is the Colt
Single Action Army Revolver. Sometimes they called the Colt the Peacemaker because that ended any
kind of arguments. It has six chambers. You tried not to put a bullet in the chamber underneath the
hammer because if the gun dropped or if you knocked it against something and the hammer went
into the cartridge, it could go off. So most cowboys, most lawmen, they rested the hammer
on an empty chamber so that they wouldn't have any kind of accidents.
At Weedmouse asks, how accurate is Red Dead Redemption? I think it's as accurate as an
average to good Western. One thing that always stands out to me in that game is the way the
men wear their guns and their holsters. It's the Hollywood holster rig. They have the holsters
really low down on the hips for the fast draw. But in the actual Old West, they had them riding up
very high. I mean, it's easier to get on a horse if you've got the holster up high on your belt.
It seems like there's also a lot of action in a campground. And a campground was actually
kind of a common thing. If you're just arriving at a location or town, well, you're going to be
camping on the outside of town before you get settled in. That's what the Earps did when they
came to Tombstone. They didn't initially have a place to live. Epica asks, what was literacy
like in the Old West? Did people on the frontier generally know how to read and write? Yes,
they did. Maybe you've heard of the one-room schoolhouse. Even the very remote places in the
West, they hired teachers. And some of your famous outlaws could read and write. We have existing
letters written by William H. Bonney. Billy the Kid, when he was pleading for a pardon from the
governor. Jesse James wasn't a good speller or a good writer, but he could read and write. Wrote
letters to the newspaper. Loved to see his name in the newspaper. Some of the dime novels were
actually written about outlaws. There were dozens and dozens of dime novels about the exploits of
Jesse James. They were complete fiction, but they were very, very popular. Some people at the time
considered that they were a bad influence on the youth. Kind of like rap music a few years ago,
that's a bad influence. The same with dime novels. Don't read those dime novels. It's going to make
you a criminal. What's interesting about the dime novels, especially these Jesse James, James boys,
is that they're heroes. They're not outlaws, criminals, murderers, but they've been forced
into this life where they have to kill to survive, but they have a good heart.
It painted a different picture. It really helped boost this image of the folk hero,
the Robin Hood hero, which was completely bogus. They did not steal from the rich and give to the
poor. It created a myth, the myth of the Wild West that in a way we live with today.
This next question is from Quora. What did they use for toilet paper in the Old West?
Believe it or not, there was commercially manufactured toilet paper beginning in the
1850s. If you're some trading post, hundreds of miles, you're probably not going to have a
package of factory-made toilet paper. You went out back and there was almost always an outhouse.
In the outhouse would be your supplies to be used for wiping. It could be a dry corncob. Probably
more likely would be a catalog. Sears Roebuck, Montgomery Ward, and also those pulp novels.
Once you read them, they were trashy and you didn't need to read it again. There's a great
story involving Wyatt Earp. There was a very famous stage robbery near Tombstone. Wyatt Earp
suspected who it was and he had noticed part of a dime novel torn in half. As they're trailing
these stage robbers, he continues to find a page or two at different points along the trail.
These stage robbers are clearly using pages from the pulp novel as their toilet paper.
That's one way he knew that he was on the right trail. It was that same novel that he'd seen back
where they were living. Interesting side fact about outhouses. An outhouse wasn't just where
you went to the bathroom, but you also threw refuse or trash. Archaeologists and bottle hunters
get old insurance maps of these various old Western towns because the outhouses are shown
on the maps. They'll dig down and find real treasures buried there where the outhouse used
to be. They're very rich for learning about how people lived in the 19th century. I Am the Driving
wants to know, if I was in the Old West and was in standoffs, I wouldn't wait to shoot. I'd shoot
right away. Why did they wait? It's literally a contest to shoot the other guy first. Well,
they did not wait. There were not these Hollywood standoffs between gunfighters. Normally, these
guys are taking potshots. They're trying to assassinate or ambush him. If you're dealing
with a murderous individual who's adept at firearms, you're not going to give him a chance
to kill you. Perfect example is with Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid. Pat Garrett was not going to
give Billy a chance to gun him down, to draw his gun. When Billy the Kid steps into the darkened
room at Fort Sumner and says, Key and S, who is it? Pat Garrett recognized his voice and he opened
up. He fired two shots. The first shot hit Billy in the chest and outlaw Billy the Kid was no more.
The only time there was actually really a classic standoff was at the OK Corral. At Morgan,
some comments, I would not survive in the Old West. Pork and beans is just grim. Well, you know,
it wasn't just pork and beans. There was actually pretty fine dining. In the boom towns, cattle
towns, they actually had oyster saloons. In Dodge City in the 1870s, there was one saloon that
advertised fresh oysters daily. These would be packed in barrels. And actually, oysters could
last for a few weeks before they spoiled. So as long as you had a wagon train or stagecoaches,
actually get fresh shipments in each day. But if you're a cowboy and you're with the cattle herd
out on the range or driving the cattle from Texas up, well, you've got fresh beef on the
hoof. So you can have fresh beef. But beans were popular because they stored well. I mean,
they're dry. If you're on the trail, you want foods that are going to last quite a while.
So each cattle drive had a chuck wagon. The chuck box had flour, dried beans. The cooks,
you know, he's got Dutch ovens where he can actually make biscuits, cornbread. There was
a little bit of variety there, even on a cattle drive. At Western Online asked,
who is your favorite Old West gunfighter? Now, that's tough. I always had liked the look of
Wild Bill Hickok because he had this flowing long hair. It's curly. He was a snappy dresser.
And then he had those two pistols pointing forward, what they call the cross draw,
and they're pearl handled or ivory handled. But I think he's edged out for me by Doc Holliday.
Doc Holliday had a dental degree. He was a heavy drinker. He could be very belligerent. And then
he has this great friend, the greatest lawman in the West, Wyatt Earp. The reason they're friends
is because Doc Holliday actually saved Wyatt Earp's life in Dodge City. Optiplex9000 asked,
what was there to do in a saloon in the Wild West? Did people just drink? Was there any
food served or activities hosted by the owner? There were all kinds of things going on in saloons.
Some saloons, of course, had eating establishments connected to them. They actually had lunch
counters. In the 19th century, lunch wasn't the standard noonday meal. If you were having lunch,
it meant a snack or a small meal. In Tombstone, Arizona, there was a saloon called the Oriental,
and it had chandeliers, and it had the Brussels carpets. It had these elaborate carved wooden
backbars with large mirrors. Some of these saloons actually had a reading area where
they stocked magazines and books, and so you could enjoy that while you're taking a break
from the faro table. There were actually brothels that coexisted in these communities along with
saloons, and prostitution was going on. You often had a situation where a gambler had a girlfriend
or significant other who was a prostitute. One of the unknown things about Wyatt Earp, he actually
worked in a brothel. He was a bouncer, and he also might have been a pimp himself for a short time.
He did this in Peoria, Illinois as a young man. Grace Lee wants to know,
what are some lesser known facts about the Old West that might surprise most? Well,
one thing that might surprise most is there actually was more than one Billy the Kid. We
always think of William H. Bonney, Henry McCarty, Alias the Kid. There was actually a Billy the Kid
in Tombstone, Arizona at the time of the O.K. Corral. If you look at the prison records,
you'll find a lot of people that had the nickname or went by Billy the Kid. Another thing that's
not well known and actually kind of eerie involves the outlaw Jesse James. Jesse James was
very superstitious, and he claimed to see a ball of light, what we might call or refer to as ball
lightning. Some people call it swamp gas, and they were kind of an omen. Something big was going to
happen. He saw this light before the Northfield raid, where the gang was defeated and driven out
of town by the townspeople. He also saw it a short time before he was assassinated by the Ford
Brothers. You ever wonder why the saloon doors in the Old West were designed the way they were?
You know, I've looked at lots of photos of saloon exteriors, historic photographs, and I haven't yet
come across one with these swinging doors. Usually it's just a regular door or large door. My
suspicion is that these swinging doors were very convenient for movie makers because you can see
someone coming in and out. The swinging door you can see right away. That's Wyatt Earp. That's
Wild Bill Hickok. So I'm guessing that's kind of a Hollywood thing, those swinging doors. Fun fact,
some of these Old West characters' figures made it out to Hollywood, and some of these early silent
films had these Western legends, these Western characters on set advising. In fact, some of these
individuals even appeared in the background scenes of some of these films. Carl2k1 asks,
which Native American tribes were the most fearsome and formidable foe the U.S. government faced,
and why? So there are several nations in the American West. In the Southwest, we have generally
the Apaches. On the Central Plains, we have the Cheyennes and Arapahos. Down here in Texas,
in the Southern Plains, the Comanches. And then up here on the Northern Plains, we have the Crow
and the Lakota. The Crows became allies of the U.S. government or the military.
But you know, that question, which is the most fearsome or formidable, you have to remember
they're all fighting for their culture, for their life ways, for their people. Who wouldn't
be formidable or ferocious if you're trying to protect your families? And that's certainly the
case with Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull. They refused to sign treaties, and that put them
on a collision course with a man named George Armstrong Custer and his 7th Cavalry. Here's
another question from Quora. What went wrong that led to the decimation of Custer's troops
at Little Bighorn? Well, I think I would phrase that, what went right for the Lakotas and Cheyennes
who were fighting George Armstrong Custer? So what went right for them is that George Armstrong
Custer divided his regiment. He had about 556 fighting men, 30-some officers. He splits his
regiment into three battalions. He sends one under Captain Benteen off in this direction to look for
Indians. He sends the second-in-command under another battalion, under Major Marcus Reno,
up the valley towards the village. And so Custer takes five troops in his battalion and goes across
these hills in this direction. Well, immediately as Reno gets to the village, these Indians are
massing. He halts his charge. He doesn't charge into the village. He ends up retreating. And the
thing to keep in mind with this battle is that these warriors are fighting to protect this
village. It's their wives. It's their mothers. It's their sisters. And they're also very accomplished,
masterful horseback fighters. They really know their business, and they have a reason to fight.
And because George Armstrong Custer divided his regiment, they can attack them piecemeal. So first
they defeat Reno, force him to retreat to the bluffs. Then they can concentrate on Custer
over here on Custer Hill and his five companies, and they decimate all 210 men under Custer's
command. And Custer himself dies with his men on what's known today as Last Stand Hill, way over here
on a hill that overlooks this village. At F1ST, I didn't realize how well-made Navajo blankets were
in the 1800s. That history of living off the earth with bare essentials was amazing. Well, it truly
was. And we've got a Navajo blanket right here. The Navajos were making blankets as early as the 1600s.
They learned to make blankets, apparently, from the Pueblo Indians who had long been making
blankets. They're made on a vertical loom. It's a very tight weave. The Navajos eventually raised
their own sheep so they could have their own wool, and it became an industry that exists to this day.
So this is a pipe bag. This tells us that the North American Indians on the plains were involved
in a global market economy. This decoration are glass beads that were made in Italy. They were
transported here in trade with the Plains Indians for their buffalo robes. The buffalo robes are
being shipped to Europe. The North American Indians are getting brass kettles. They're getting
firearms. I mean, they're tied into the entire world, and it's reflected in this. They learned to live
off the land, what nature provided them, they made very good use of, and at the same time, they made
it beautiful. At Ico Rich asks, when does the Old West start? And he's got a poll. So one option here
is Lewis and Clark, 1803 to 1806, the core of discovery. Lewis and Clark are sent out west by
Thomas Jefferson to really explore the Louisiana Purchase that they've just acquired from France.
They're looking for a transportation route. We've got mountains, plains. There's an unexplored
country. Is there a way to get across it? They're introducing some of these indigenous populations,
these Indian nations, to the United States. Lewis and Clark brought with them peace medals.
The Indians were used to getting peace medals because of the Great Britain, France, and Spain,
and so the United States, well, we have to have our peace medals to impress these leaders
of these Indian nations as well. Another is the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848,
and that is how the United States acquired from Mexico what we now call the American Southwest.
This is the whole chunk of land that's acquired through that treaty. So that's another option,
the beginning of the West, or at least according to the poll. We also have the end of the Civil
War. You have a lot of Civil War veterans that go west, but we also have here the Transcontinental
Railroad. The Transcontinental Railroad stretches all across the plains and across the Rocky
Mountains, and it allows a migration of people, passengers, to take the trains all the way across
the country. In a way, this term you hear, manifest destiny, that the United States was destined
to expand from ocean to ocean. The railroad completes that idea, that theory. So those
are all really good suggestions. I kind of like the end of the Civil War for that classic period
of the Old West. Well, that's all the questions for today. They were good questions. Enjoyed
answering them. Thank you for watching Wild West Support. Turkey in the straw! Turkey in the hay!
