Murray Gell-Mann - Julian Schwinger (109/200)

"Physics & Astronomy"
21 followers
I thought that he promoted elegance above correctness and above honesty, and I was put
off by that, and especially after studying with Vicky Weisskopf, who explained that the
important thing was to enlarge our understanding of physics, not to present a lot of shiny
mathematical material.
It's fine, of course, I have no objection to mathematics being written papers about
why elegance is a suitable criterion in the choice of a correct theory, and so on and
so forth.
But it should be used in connection with original and correct material.
I was a student in Cambridge when Julian presented some fantastically elaborate mathematical
formalism for dealing with quantum field theory, for example, quantum electrodynamics.
He used some weird-looking symbols to avoid Feynman diagrams.
Later on, by the way, when I spent that term in Massachusetts, the early part of 1963,
I rented Julian's house, and I looked all over to see where he kept his hidden Feynman
diagrams.
There was a locked room, the landlord's locked room, and I assumed that the Feynman
diagrams were in there.
In any case, to go back, when I was a student, he presented this fancy scheme, and then he
tried not only to show how to do the expansion and perturbation theory, which is basically
the same as Feynman's diagrams in some other notation, but he also claimed that he was
able to put the whole thing in some sort of closed form, or something that was nearly
closed form, and that it was the entire theory.
But he had blinded himself with this fancy formalism and didn't notice that he was leaving
out all photon-photon scattering.
Pauli pointed it out to him.
I think that elegance for its own sake is not the point.
The point is elegance in the service of advancing our understanding of science.
