Married Filing Separate with Student Loans
3 Video Views·Oct 30, 2024
For married student loan borrowers, your tax filing status — “married filing jointly” versus “married filing separately” — affects how much you pay in taxes. It also impacts how much you pay on your monthly student loan payment. However, the decision to file separately or jointly can also impact your eligibility for various tax credits and benefits. For example, it might affect your access to the dependent childcare credit and healthcare premium subsidies on the Health Insurance Marketplace. Therefore, making the right decision is critical.
I'm going to share some things about married filing separate when you have student loans
and what you should consider.
Married filing separate is a tax filing status.
The other couple different statuses out there are single, married filing jointly, and head
of household.
So if you're doing married filing separate, the reason you're doing that for student loans
is to exclude your spouse's income from your income-driven repayment.
With the new creation of the SAVE plan, Saving on a Valuable Education, that plan in addition
to pay-as-you-earn and base repayment, all of the major income-driven plans now allow
you to exclude your spouse's income from the payment as long as you do married filing
separate.
Now this is a really big opportunity, and the reason you want to be cautious about this
is because you want to have the cost of filing separate and the additional taxes that you
pay be less than the savings that you get on your income-driven repayment.
So just to give an example, let's say you've got two people married making $100K each.
Your $200,000 income total, if you're filing joint, you're going to pay 10% if you have
all grad loans on that $200,000 of income with a little bit of a deduction before you
have to pay anything.
So you do get to deduct 225% of the poverty line before you have to pay 10%.
And so for this couple making $200,000, if they don't have any kids, maybe they would
get to earn about $45,000 to cover basic living expenses before they have to pay 10% of whatever
amount they earn above that.
So let's just say that would be roughly $15,000 total annual payments, maybe about $1,200
a month, give or take.
So if you filed separately for taxes, you're only paying based off of that one spouse's
income, so it's $100,000 a year minus about $34,000 of protected income.
So that's 10% of about $60,000, about $500 a month.
So $500 a month compared to $1,200 a month, $500 a month is a much better payment.
And so what you're looking for when you do your married filing separate versus joint
analysis is, does it cost me more to file it separate than $7,000 in this case?
If it costs you more than that, you should file a joint because you'd rather the money
be going to your student loans and not towards taxes.
But what most people are going to find is, especially if you have incomes that are similar,
your cost of filing separate should be pretty minimal.
So in the case of this hypothetical couple each making $100,000, things you might need
to consider are the dependent care credit, dependent care FSA.
If you made a direct Roth contribution, you might have to do a backdoor Roth instead.
So the total cost and complexity of filing separate for a couple like that is probably
pretty minimal.
Maybe it's $1,000, $2,000 a year, it's not that much.
So filing separate would be a much better decision in that case.
Now married filing separate can get extra complicated if you live in a community property
state.
So there's nine community property states total.
States like California, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, there's nine of them total.
If you live in one of these states, when you file separate, you're supposed to split your
income 50-50.
So there's a form for this, it's called 89-58.
You've got to reconcile what you have on your W-2s to what you're reporting on your income
taxes.
This is how you're supposed to file your taxes when you file married filing separate in a
community property state.
And then what you have to do is, if you feel like that income is accurate, then you can
just have the IRS share your information automatically with the Department of Ed.
If you feel like, hey, you know, I make a lot less than my spouse, I don't want to have
to report half of all of our household income, then you might need to file some alternative
documentation of income with your servicer to get a reasonable monthly payment.
So when you're thinking about married filing separate, the question is, should you do it
on your own or not?
One thing that I would think about is, you know, is it hard?
Do you enjoy doing this?
Would you rather spend your time doing something else?
Student Loan Planner can help with the strategy of this.
It's basically what we do, why we have thousands of reviews for it.
So studentloanplanner.com slash book is the place to set up a married filing separate
analysis and the cost is only a few hundred bucks for our YouTube folks.
And then if you need more help than that, we also have a tax team and folks that can
help out.
You just can reach out on the comments of the website or whatever.
So married filing separate, remember, the cost of doing so has to be minimal compared
to the savings on your income driven repayment.
Thanks so much for watching Student Loan Planner, studentloanplanner.com slash book.

