It's Topical | Life Insurance Killings: Cashing in on death

Policy Pros
2 followers
1 Video View·Oct 29, 2024
"Are claims of insurance-related killings on the rise? What's the modus operandi and what policy changes are needed?
This week we put the spotlight on individuals who exploit life insurance policies at the expense of their loved ones. This follows some highly publicised arrests over the past few weeks.
To discuss this we are joined by Garth de Klerk who is the CEO of The Insurance Crime Bureau and Sekgobola Thobakgale who is the Broker Principal at IASHO. The digital audience also weighs in."
It's seven o'clock on a Sunday night and you know what that means.
It's Topical starts right now.
A very good evening to South Africa and those watching around the world.
My name is Blayne Herman and this is It's Topical.
Our digital audience with us tonight.
They are from the University of Pretoria as well as UniZulu.
Looking forward to getting their questions for our guests in a short while.
SABC News reporting this week.
Four people appeared in the Motherwell Magistrates Court.
Why?
Well, it was in connection with the murders allegedly linked to insurance payout schemes.
The National Prosecuting Authority says the four accused between the ages of 27 and 32
allegedly orchestrated the shooting of a Nelson Mandela Metro employee
who listed one of the accused as a beneficiary on her insurance policies.
Now all four we understand abandoned bail and the cases
has been postponed for further investigations.
We've got to get into this, right?
Claims of insurance related killings in South Africa.
Is it on the rise?
Orchestrating murders of loved ones for payouts on insurance policies.
What's the what's the modus operandi?
The particular way or method being used?
What policy changes are needed in the hopes of safeguarding individuals
and families from exploitation?
We will discuss.
Which brings us to the umbrella question for the week and we ask you
what motivations do you think drive individuals to exploit
life insurance policies at the expense of their loved ones?
Let us know your thoughts around this matter at sabcnews underscore tv.
What steps can people take to protect themselves from
becoming victims of fraudulent life insurance schemes?
Also, how can individuals verify the existence of life insurance policies
taken out in their name?
That handle again at sabcnews underscore tv.
Perspective coming up.
So they say money makes the world go round, right?
Seems like it's taken a bit of a darker tone,
especially now that money has fast become the motor for murder
as some lives are ruthlessly taken.
This montage compiled by producer Markiket Mutlabe
reminds us about some of the notable insurance fraud cases
you'd probably never forget.
Take a look.
South Africa has one of the highest number of funeral covers in the world.
Rosemary Ndomia Ndlovu.
Rosemary Ndlovu has received six life terms at the high court sitting at Palm Ridge in
for the six murders she committed allegedly to benefit from life insurance money.
She was earlier found guilty of murdering her six relatives.
The state had asked for life sentences.
Family members of Ndlovu's victims who took the stand in her sentencing proceedings
feel Ndlovu showed no remorse.
The pastor, his wife and his cousin have been found guilty of murdering
The accused
faced other charges apart from murder.
The pastor and his wife were church friends of the family.
They deliberately targeted the young mother of two
in their get-rich-quick scheme for an almost three million rand payout.
It won't bring her back.
Nothing will ever bring her back.
But it gives us some sort of closure.
That is a certain message that we saw.
She just disappeared.
Just disappeared.
But it's when everybody said no, she'll come back.
Call log obtained found out that Lerato was the last person to call him.
However, when asked about his whereabouts,
he said she didn't know and that she had also just lost her husband.
It is alleged that the two killed a man and burnt his body in their house in Sosongowe.
Thereafter, it is further alleged that the wife obtained a fraudulent death certificate
from the Department of Home Affairs,
claiming that her husband had died in the fire and later claimed life policies.
The couple has been charged with murder,
defeating the ends of justice and fraud.
Suspected insurance fraudster, Agnes Sutranso.
Police have found that she had taken out about 40 insurance policies
at five different insurers.
A whistleblower claims that her niece, Bonolo Mudisayemang,
did not die of natural causes but was murdered for insurance money.
Police also suspect that Sutranso had killed her husband
and two of her children to claim for insurance.
The SAPS had to exhume the body of the deceased
to really establish the cause of death.
And preliminary results have indicated that there was foul play.
She gave a statement, a brief statement to explain why she says she's not guilty
and she's going to maintain that status
to show that she's not guilty of the charges preferred against her.
According to police, this female officer stationed at the Sinova Rwanda Police Station
pocketed over 10 million rand in insurance claims.
Some of her victims were said to be destitute
while others lived with mental and or physical disabilities.
We are charging her with six counts of murder
and she is facing about 17 counts of fraud.
The charges are believed to date back to 2019.
These people, they see advantage when they see us as people like this.
They see us as money.
Instead of protecting us, they are killing us.
I'm very disappointed.
Yeah, it's not good.
According for me, they must rot in jail.
All right.
Many thanks to Makikele Motlave there for that montage.
Before we carry on with our main topic of the night,
we've got eyes on the Ard Tumble Memorial Lecture currently happening.
President Cyril Ramaphosa, ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa
is expected to address that.
When that happens, as you know, on this show,
live events of importance takes precedence.
We'll try to bring you the gist of that.
So stand by for that.
Now, in studio, we have Sekhubola Tobakhale,
who is the principal, broker principal,
as well as a KI, key individual.
That's what this show is all about,
bringing in the key individuals to get a better understanding.
We also have, via Teams, Garth Deklak,
CEO of the Insurance Crime Bureau,
obviously our digital audience with us as well.
It's great to have them.
They're going to put up their virtual hands
and if you have any questions, comments, please do that.
I'll get to you as soon as possible.
SK, if I can get to you,
let's talk about what investigations have uncovered,
what's the trends in terms of the way people do this,
the modus operandi.
What have you found out?
I think what is becoming very clear
is that investigations of this kind of claims
are revealing cracks that are in the system,
both in the acquisition of policies
where people can become multiple policyholders
as well as become multiple policy beneficiaries.
And through these cracks,
people have been able to manipulate the system
and be able to benefit illegally through claims.
What has become more clear
is that through these incidents,
insurance companies have become more vigilant.
They are more strict in terms of their ways
of verifying policy applicants or policy proposers
to make sure that everybody that is part of a policy
has given the consent that they wish to be part of
that particular policy.
Garth, talk to us about these cracks.
What have you found in your investigations?
Good evening, Blind First Year,
and thank you very much for inviting us to comment.
As SK said,
really what we have to do is first set a bit of context.
There are definitely cracks that can be looked at.
However, we also have to just be aware of the fact
that this media cycle
around cases like Rosemary & Glovel,
around the Nusha Karni case,
seems to make this as if it's happening
every second day in society.
And it's not.
The insurance companies are doing a relatively good job
at ensuring the fact that the people that are insured
are genuine beneficiaries,
that their life insured has an insured interest to it.
But unfortunately, you are always going to have
a criminal element
that is looking to take advantage
of the financial services product,
which in this case is insurance.
What sort of loopholes are they exploiting, Garth?
Well, basically, they're looking for ways
where they can claim insured interest.
So, you know, if I were to, for example,
take out insurance on my auntie,
there's nothing wrong with that transaction.
I'm totally legally allowed to take out insurance on my auntie.
Right.
She could even be confirmed.
The illegal act is when I'm murdering.
So the financial transaction is totally above board.
It's the legal transaction of murder
that we have to look at how do we curtail that.
Can you take out insurance on anybody?
Can it be friends, family, et cetera?
Currently, as far as I know,
you can take a policy on your family,
people that are immediate,
that are living with you in the same house.
You can also take a policy on your parents,
your in-laws, as well as your relatives.
So in terms of what Garth is talking about there,
that, you know, they need to be insurable interest.
So which means that in good faith,
those people, should they die or should they be demised,
then you stand to suffer financially
as a result of their death.
So you are required, you know, as you know, in tradition,
people contribute to what's, you know, a burial of a loved one.
And sometimes you find that you're traveling,
you know, a little bit of a distance to get there.
And people make provision for those kinds of things.
And that's what it's for.
That is the interest that the financial service is trying to close.
But like he's saying that now people see a loophole
where there is a scheme
or there is an opportunity to make some money
in order to resolve financial stresses
that they may be going through by so doing, killing people.
Sometimes you know of these situations
in the burial societies within the communities.
This kind of fraud is not only happening there.
Yeah, I want to touch on that in a short while
in terms of the process and where we can tighten things up.
I just want to bring in Dr. Noma Tamsanga Mtetwa.
I understand the good doctor is with us.
And she was awarded a doctor of philosophy for her research
titled The Inquiry into Life Insurance Fraud in KwaZulu-Natal.
Doctor, good to have you on the program.
Firstly, I understand it's your birthday.
So happy birthday and apologies to your family
for graciously giving us your time here to enlighten the nation.
Talk to us about the main findings of your study.
Thank you so much.
Thank you for having me.
So first of all, it is such unfortunate
that our family members nowadays are actually viewing us
as chicks which are waiting to be kissed out.
But one of the primary findings that I did find in my study
was that these perpetrators are mostly motivated
by financial pressure, which is associated with greed.
I wouldn't say that it's because of unemployment,
but I would say it's because of the need to have money.
Because if we actually go through the current cases
which have been exposed in the media lately,
we'd actually find that these people
who are committing such crimes are people who have stable jobs.
So it's just the mere need of having more
than what you already have.
What do you make about the public awareness
around certain cases?
Garth is saying that it's few and far in between,
but it gets prominence because of the shock factor, right?
Is that your understanding?
I would say that not enough awareness is being exposed
out there in terms of this particular crime.
Why?
I feel like when you compare life insurance fraud
to rape cases and any other crime,
I feel like this particular crime
is not really receiving much attention as it should.
And I think that the insurance companies
or the insurance industry themselves are entitled
to actually play a role in terms of educating people
about such crimes.
Right.
Garth, do you think there's a lack of,
one would say, or a reluctance rather,
maybe that's a better word,
the reluctance from insurers to disclose such cases
because maybe it's bad for business, reputation-wise?
Well, I think the doctor's got a very, very good point.
And thank you very much for that.
I think she makes the point that all of us
have the responsibility to better educate ourselves.
You know, there's this constant fear driven again
by the media that you can take out life insurance
on anybody and murder them for the financial gain.
And that's not quite correct.
But you do have to be more aware
of your environment around you.
And we often find that people that are involved
have signed papers giving the beneficiary of the policy
the right to insure them.
So yes, as a community, as a South African community,
as a financial services sector, we could do more.
But we also need to talk to each other.
We need to protect each other.
So just help us for those who haven't taken out
a life insurance policy on someone.
The process that is followed,
the person that they are taking the policy on,
they are informed.
Are they interviewed?
Is there any biometrics that's done?
What's the what's the process?
Is this for me?
Yes, Scott.
Sure.
OK, so, you know, let's again distinguish between
life insurance and funeral cover,
because a lot of these policies that we're talking about
are more funeral cover.
If I take a 20 million Rand life insurance on my wife,
for example, because she's worth that much,
she would be interviewed.
She'd have to go for medicals.
They would do biometrics.
They would do everything.
If I take out a 50000 Rand policy on,
you know, for a funeral payment,
the underwriting is a lot less
because it's just not possible to do
that level of underwriting on millions
and millions of people.
So, you know, as part of my group life policy,
I would have cover on my wife,
my kids and my parents, for example.
Very little underwriting goes into that.
They will be noted as beneficiaries.
And you have to prove the insured interest.
You have to prove the fact that they exist.
Right.
But is there a lot of underwriting
and a lot of checking that goes into that?
Unfortunately, not as much as maybe there could be.
But it also doesn't make sense.
You know, funeral policies are supposed to assist people,
not their hindrance.
Malope Matete is the author of
We Killed for Insurance Money.
Seth, good to have you on the program.
Talk to us in terms of your research for your book.
What have you found?
Is Malope with us?
Oh, it seems that he's just gone.
Maybe we can get it back control.
Let's get him back.
I think he will add some value to the discussion.
Where can we tighten the loopholes, though,
in terms of funeral policy or life insurance?
Where are the gray areas?
I think the first step would be the consent.
If the industry and the regulators agree that
even for funeral policies, which Garth correctly said,
that their purpose is to assist people with finances
in order to lay their beloved to rest.
It's not a lot of money.
That's why there's not a lot of underwriting that has been done.
So the consent, maybe it's one thing that can be introduced
in terms of the beneficiaries
and those who are added on the policy.
They provide some level of
except just giving their ID numbers.
Then the second...
What can they do?
They can verify.
We've got technology today where people can send an SMS.
Are you Blaine?
Do you consent to SK taking a policy on your behalf?
It will pay this much.
You might not be there to see the money coming through,
but at least you've given the permission for it to happen.
Let's go to a digital audience.
Let's hear from Carmen.
Carmen?
Hi, Blaine.
Thank you for having me on.
I think something that's really important
that I think sometimes gets overlooked as well
is the case that brought this to life now.
And it is that the police officer is being
particularly charged with six cases of fraud for life insurance.
And for me, it really is quite worrying
that the sort of cultural impunity
that's been made regarding law enforcement and police.
We almost feel that they are above the law to get away with this.
And it's very alarming, obviously,
that he got to six people before anything sort of came out about this.
And I think it needs to be a serious look at
to what is going on in police officers' life
and sort of the management over that as well and what they're up to.
Carmen, let's put a pin in it.
We have to take a live event now.
ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa is currently addressing
the O'ahu Tamba Memorial Lecture.
Let's let's dip in.
The O'ahu Tamba Memorial Lecture currently happening.
When it does start, we went there a bit early.
When the president, ANC president does speak,
we will pick it up, go there, get you the big takeaways
in terms of that lecture, important one indeed.
SK, let's just go back a bit in terms of this consent.
What about the use of AI and technology in order to, you know,
close the loopholes?
Is that something that insurance, the industry is looking at?
I'm not personally aware of anybody that is doing that.
But those guys that are selling their products that are online,
there's some levels of AI integration into their products.
But mainly, it is on these products where you are buying live cover.
You know, it's not just a funeral cover for 5,000 rands,
for 10,000 rands over there.
So probably, as a country, we need to make a decision
whether these things, are they important to us?
You know, do we want to pay the same attention that we do
on other types of policies?
If you buy a car insurance, you need to take it for inspection.
So if you buy a funeral, why don't you make sure that the person exists?
And it's for the correct reasons.
Right.
Garth, is the amount of money a red flag for insurance companies
to look into certain policies?
You know, Colin makes a good point as well.
There's people in positions of trust that are abusing that trust that we hand to them.
And certainly, this SAPS member is not the only SAPS member
that has been in the news of recent for breaking our trust.
So if we're looking at a 50,000 rand claim,
you know, the claims procedure is maybe not as severe as a 5 million rand claim
because it's just not physically possible.
But 50,000 rand in a rural environment where there is economic pressure
is a lot of money.
That can be an annual salary for somebody.
So it does become worth it and it becomes a numbers game.
So certainly, the value of a claim will determine
the level of checks that are passed on that claim.
Molope Matete is the author of a very interesting book.
I'm just being told, Molope, that the ANC president is now addressing.
We'll try to come back to you in a short while.
I do apologize for that, but we have to go to this event,
the O. R. Tambo Memorial Lecture currently being held.
The Tambo family, the deputy president of the African National Congress,
members of members of the National Executive Committee,
the officials of the African National Congress,
NEC members and alliance leaders here present,
ministers and deputy ministers,
MECs of our province and PEC members,
the executive mayor of Ekuruleni,
members of the diplomatic corps,
and all residents of Ekuruleni.
The African National Congress.
Comrades, it's a joy and a pleasure to be here.
I'd like to thank the provincial leadership
and the regional leadership for arranging this memorial lecture,
but also thank the secretary general and his office
for arranging that the whole NEC should be present tonight.
So, comrades, we meet here in the presence of the National Executive Committee,
which has been meeting for the past three days.
Tomorrow, the NEC continues to receive the first foundational
lecture, course, the foundational course,
which is going to be a requirement for all members of the ANC.
So we are starting with the National Executive Committee tomorrow.
And thereafter, it will be spread throughout the country
when every member of the African National Congress
will be required to go through this course to qualify as a member of the ANC.
Comrades, we're here tonight to remember a great leader of our movement.
It has been said that the legacy of heroes
is the memory of a great name and the inheritance of a great example.
We are gathered as we are here, inheritors of a great example that was set
by our leader, Oliver Reginald Tambo.
Today marks 107 years since the birth of O. R. Tambo,
who was the longest serving president of the African National Congress.
He was a hero whose great name is forever and indelibly inscribed in the hearts and the minds
of the people of South Africa and the people of our continent, Africa.
He left behind a towering legacy.
His life was a fine example of what it means to be a true revolutionary,
a principled leader, a bridge builder, and a true servant of the people of South Africa.
We remember O. R. Tambo at a time when we have lost a number of stalwarts of our liberation movement.
They were part of the illustrious generation that birthed our freedom,
and we cannot but be mindful that we are witnesses of the passing of an era,
an era of leaders who were prepared to sacrifice their lives, their livelihoods,
and the comforts of life for the freedom of our people.
When President Nelson Mandela delivered his eulogy at the funeral of O. R. Tambo, he said,
I say that Oliver Tambo has not died because the ideals for which he sacrificed his life
can never die. He went on to say that Oliver Tambo has not died because
the ideals of freedom, human dignity, and a colorblind respect for every individual
cannot perish. I say he has not died because there are many of us who became a part of his soul
and therefore willingly entered into a conspiracy with him for the victory of his cause.
While the ANC lives, he said, Oliver Tambo cannot die.
All right, ANC President Soto Ramaphosa there. We keep a close eye on this memorial lecture,
the O. R. Tambo Memorial Lecture. Our producers are keeping a close ear and eye on it. We'll
bring you the big takeaways in our later bulletins, but speaking basically on the
life and times of O. R. Tambo, Oliver Reginald Tambo, the longest serving ANC president,
born on this day, October 27th, 1917, 107 years ago. And the president talking about it coming
at a time when the organization has lost so much, the likes of Thito Mboweni, also Pravin Gordon.
So reflections in terms of what that means for the organization, what O. R. Tambo's legacy means
for the organization given the current state of play. Stan, stay tuned to SABC News. We'll bring
you the big takeaways in a short while. All right, let's continue with regards to throwing
the spotlight on insurance-related murders in South Africa. A number of guests here today to
give you some insights with regards to this. I want to go back to Garth. Garth, just help us
understand one of my questions to SK a little earlier on was the use of technology in trying
to help close the gaps. Are you aware of any such within the industry in order to close those gaps?
Yes, definitely, Blaine. And, you know, I think you can see that these cases are a result of
deploying exactly that type of technology. You know, these cases weren't only discovered by
accident. It was hard police work, hard investigations, as well as the insurance
industry working together to uncover these murders. We were only formed in the life insurance industry
about four or five years ago. And you can see that the detection rate is increasing dramatically.
So definitely they are using technology, if you want to call it AI, you know, let's refer to it
as AI, but technology to control and to deter this type of activity.
We killed for insurance money. That's the book title. The author is with us today,
Molope Matete. Thank you, sir, for joining us. In terms of the writing of this book,
Molope, what did you find? What are some of the trends? What sticks out for you?
Good evening to the viewers at home, and I'm glad that I can see Garth in the list of guys
who are part of this panel. He read my book. I think the first copy that landed on the shelves
went to his office to say this is the product, and then let us maybe see how best we can leverage on
the inside of the book to actually send out the message or education to the public. Look,
back to your question, you know, the book itself, firstly, let me maybe take you through
why the book. Basically, it was around bringing some sort of an awareness and an education,
both to the users of the insurance product, especially within the life space, and then also
to the insurance industry. So, if you look at the book, the level of balance I achieved,
there was to say to the users, these are the red flags that you actually need to look out for,
you know, to see the risk that actually revolves around you. And to the insurance provider,
the insurers themselves, it was a question of saying, you know, your controls are not
as effective or as tight as they should be. And this, you know, in most cases will offer,
you know, the attraction to either your employees within the organization or the users outside of
your environment to actually trade your organization. But what was important is,
I think, back to the point that Dr. Noma, if I'm correct, raised to say the issue of pressure,
I mean, greed is actually a very, you know, interesting issue that I brought into the book
as well to say, you know, employees, especially from the internal or from within the business
itself, within the insurance company itself, will see the opportunity. It starts with the people
from inside the organization. They will see the opportunity. They will actually exploit those
opportunities, especially if they, you know, they operate in an environment where controls are not
that tight enough, where, you know, there's still a lot, you know, that is to be tied,
you know, from the loose ends in terms of, you know, bringing effective or proper controls.
Even if you have good systems, you know, within the organization, but the fact that you still
have employees, you know, who are tempted, you know, and can leverage on any opportunity that
they see within the organization, that will always create a fertile ground for, you know,
these employees to start, you know, stealing from the organization. But it will start with
1 million and it will go to 10, et cetera. So, and then, you know, with the, you know,
I'm now talking to the book itself, with their, you know, the contact with, you know, the syndicate
operating outside of the environment, where they will now, you know, identify or use as a runner
within the organization. And that becomes now, you know, a way that the people or syndicate
operating outside of the organization will start to infiltrate, you know, the organization with
the help of a runner who's, you know, employed by that particular organization. It's basically,
you know, some of the issues that the book will touch on to say, you know, look from inside
before you start dealing with a person, you know, outside of the organization. Very often,
you will never see a situation where a person, a syndicate will come into the organization without
the help of someone, you know, key, you know, to the processes within the organization.
Dr. Mtetwe, is that you're finding as well during your studies in terms of these syndicates
infiltrating? Yes. Look, I think that as Mr. Lopez stated, it is unlikely for a person who
is from outside the organization to successfully commit life insurance fraud without the help of
someone inside. So, yes, the problem with the loopholes is affected also in terms of
this perpetrators committing life insurance fraud. All right. We need to take a quick break.
We're trying to unearth or dig a little deeper in terms of the motivation and how we can close
the gaps in terms of people or insurance related killings in South Africa. Why are people doing it?
You would say the the reasons are kind of obvious. Money, financial greed is the other
one as well. But we need to know how to close these gaps more from, I guess, initial.
Welcome back. You're watching. It's topical insurance related killings in South Africa.
We want your thoughts as well. So on a regular word on the street feature, we took the streets
of Cape Town, seeking diverse insights and perspectives on this topic. This is what
Capetonians had to say. Take a look. I think it just boils down to greed and the love for money.
And I think it's just also a moral decay. You know, people are just losing their moral compass
more and more. They should go back to the past that weren't allowed. If you ever kill someone
or commit suicide, you don't get paid up. You should go back to that. That's why it's so easy
to people kill each other just to get the money. There should be like stricter laws regarding
policies. For example, if you want to open a policy for someone, they have to be there with
you and also with their ID card so that they know that there is a policy that was taken out on my
behalf. People will take out these policies firstly for greed because they know if I can get this
person out of the way, then I pay out his income. Also, people sometimes want to maintain certain
lifestyles and with their own personal income, they can't do that. So that would possibly be
another motivation. Poverty and also it's greediness. People are greedy. They want money.
Yeah, I think it's most of the time driven by greed. And quite a big part of that is
all about self because, I mean, there's no love for your family. You've lost that connection
between your family, your kids. And then I think maybe if you go back to having a good family
balance at the beginning of your life, it will give you a much better understanding of love
and what you should have for your family. We appreciate your thoughts on this matter.
Sehobola Tobukhale is a broker principal and a key individual. Help us understand this,
with regards to after somebody dies. What is that process that insurance companies follow
in order to verify before they pay out? So the first thing the insurance company,
in terms of their terms and conditions, they will put in the time that you must put in the claim.
It's one of the ways which helps in those kind of situations to try and eliminate fraudulent claims.
The second thing that they do, they want documents to prove, like the death certificate,
the ID number of that person. So what is needed? Death certificate?
Death certificate, ID, and all other documents that you would get from a funeral parlor that
confirms the death of a person. But I don't think what we're dealing with here is whether the person
has died or not. But what we're dealing with here is the theme you could hear in the conversations
is that we're dealing with people that are greedy, that are abusing the system. So therefore,
there may be more requirements. If I'm insuring somebody's life, there's a second person
that confirms that insurance of that person's life. So in that case, then I don't take the money and
use it for myself. But then there's somebody who insures in a way. I don't know whether it's
necessary or not. Maybe Guth might be much more aligned to be able to tell us whether that can be
done or not. But the insurance industry does take the measures, does request the documents that
prove that the life is normal. And that is not the issue. It's the greedy that we're dealing with.
Guth, what do you think?
No, 100 percent. And I agree with SK. I mean, the issue is not around the death,
it's around the paperwork now, because it is relatively easy in South Africa, very sad,
tragically, in fact, to get a body. You know, if you want a body, I'll get you a body, young, old,
black, white, whatever. The issue that we have is we've got criminal syndicates that are working
within the funeral parlours, within the mortuaries that will sign false documents. We've got doctors
that will sign false death certificates. SK is not 100 percent correct in the fact you don't even
need a death sometimes. You can be well and alive and you can claim on your own life.
That's also been in the news recently. So we've got very, very clever syndicates that
are misusing the product. A very small percentage of the total number of incidences,
but very clever individuals.
Right. Let's go to our digital audience. Hands up already. Let's go to Miss N.P. Maseko.
Good evening. I think beyond greed, there is an undermining of the law. People do not
necessarily respect the law any more, and that is why people are so brave to break it. And so
with policewomen being arrested, people like Rosemary being arrested, we can leverage on that
to reinforce the power of the law in order for people to perhaps be scared to do something so
so that we can have systems in place that make sure that people do not go back to being criminals
and moving forward with things like having consent, having people verify that, yes,
indeed, I do agree to be part of this life insurance. I think we also need to leverage
on these gaps that we find the people that we do find in arrest. We need to make sure that
we make examples of those people who try and close the gap of people undermining the laws
that are in place. All right, Mr. Makumbi and then Candace. Thank you, Blaine, for the opportunity
and viewers at large. When headlines as these surface, we must pause and ask ourselves a
question as to how did we get here? What cultural and economic pressures are pushing people to these
extremes and to commit these kind of activities? As I look at these cases, I'm struck by how deeply
it reflects the decay of our social fabric. And this is not just about individual greed or moral
failures. It also speaks to the broader trend, a world where desperation and fixation on material
success leads to justify any action, no matter how dark, how bad it is, we still continue. And I believe
that it goes back to what the Bible says, that the love of man is the root of all evil.
So this drives that activity to go any extent, to kill and to do whatever, and to people that
are suffering, hoping for help in some way. But again, this ends in the hands of the wrong people.
And another thing that to just to add on the ground is that the person who's writing the
policy on the ground, right, that's where the screening should start with the insurance
companies. The person who's writing the policy on the ground is pushing a sale. And sometimes
they will go to any extent to cut the corners and end up writing these policies. And I think
implications on the side of the insurance companies is to actually sort of have a central
beneficiary register, where they will see that one individual has benefited from more than five
deaths. How's that possible? You need to pick up the commonality. Mr. Mokume, you make good points.
Thank you very much indeed. Value added, no doubt. Candice, let's hear from you, then Sunshine, then
try and squeeze in Musa as well. Candice? I think one of the main reasons that we are facing
is the fact that there is a lot of miseducation when it comes to insurance and claims and etc.
So it's very important to bridge that gap and educate these people so that they know what
they're getting themselves into. Additionally, the control measures of taking out these insurance
plans, it's important that the person who is taken out on understands what exactly they're getting
into and what that entails. It should not only end at a verification point where their signature
is enough, but rather there needs to be a further step to ensure that they actually know
what is in it. Let's hear from Sunshine and then Musa. Thank you very much. I think one
criminological theory that best describes this current phenomenon that we're having in South
Africa is the strain theory, where everyone has the capacity of being a low-abiding citizen,
but because of external factors that some of the presenters have spoken on,
the issue of greediness, issues of financial challenges that people are faced with,
understanding that currently economic living conditions have been bad. Because when you look
at the trend, the people that are at the centre of this are expected to be low-abiding citizens,
which are the SAPS officials. We should also look at why them specifically. Are they having
any working conditions that are propelling them to be participating in this kind of activities?
For me, the strain theory fairly describes this particular phenomenon that we're faced with as a
country. Sunshine, thank you. Musa? Thank you so much. My contribution is whether should we look at
this problem of fraud matters in terms of it being a societal problem or a national problem,
because when you look at what has happened, what happened in Gauteng, in terms of Rosemary and
Gauteng, what's happening in Limpopo and what's also happening in Eastern Cape, should this now
become a societal problem or it's now a national problem? And also, is there now a thin line
between public officials, such as your police, who are people who are supposed to uphold the law,
but they are now breaking the law? Good point. Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much indeed
for your time and your valuable insight. We've run out of time, but as I keep on saying,
these conversations will continue. No doubt we've understood the process, but more importantly,
we understood where the gaps are and what we can close. So thank you very much indeed, SK,
for that, Garth, as well. A pleasure having you on the program. Dr. Mtetwa, go and have yourself
a happy birthday. Thank you very much indeed for joining us. Value added, no doubt, and Mulipe,
as well. Thank you very much indeed. All right, before we go, here's my take. Once again,
the sanctity of life is being called into question. The phrase refers to the idea that
human life is sacred and precious. Remove the reverence for life, and you have the death of
decency, right? As a society, we can't let that happen. You've heard the different stories of
insurance-related murders, but there seems to be, seems to be, a nucleus of fact that is familiar.
Greed. Greed is the bottomless pit which exhausts the person in an endless effort to satisfy the
need without ever reaching satisfaction. It's a quote attributed to social psychologist Eric
Fromm. The fact that more and more people are getting caught illuminates Fromm's sentiment,
right? In this case, there's no good that can come from bad, and that's my take. If you miss
anything on this program, then be sure to watch this episode of Topical on YouTube, Democracy
30 up next with Oliver Dixon. If you're watching a repeat of this program, then, as always,
the news continues. Have yourself a great evening, my friends. Take care. Bye-bye.
