Kenneth Clark's Civilisation 11_ The Worship of Nature

Honor Art
11 followers
Oct 29, 2024
For almost a thousand years, the chief creative force in Western civilization was Christianity.
Then, early in the 18th century, it suddenly declined. In intellectual society, it practically
disappeared. Of course, it left a vacuum. People couldn't get on without a belief in something
outside themselves. And during the next hundred years, they concocted a new belief, which,
however irrational it may seem to us, has added a good deal to our civilization. A belief in the
divinity of nature. Well, it's said that one can attach 52 different meanings to the word nature.
In the early 18th century, it had come to mean little more than common sense, as when in
conversation we say, but naturally. But the evidences of divine power which took the place
of Christianity were manifestations of what we still mean by nature, those parts of the visible
world which were not created by man and can be perceived through the senses. Now, this particular
change in the direction of the human mind was very largely achieved in England. And I suppose it's no
accident that England was the first country in which Christian, the Christian faith had collapsed.
In about 1730, the French philosopher Montesquieu noted, there is no religion in England. If anyone
mentions religion, people begin to laugh. Montesquieu saw only the ruins of religion, and although he
was a very intelligent man, he couldn't have foreseen that these ruins were part of the subtle way
in which faith and divine power was to trickle back in the Western European mind.
The ruins of the age of faith had become a part of nature. Or rather, they'd become a sort of
lead into nature through sentiment and memory. They helped to evoke that curious frame of mind
which, in the early 18th century, was the usual prelude to the enjoyment of natural beauty,
a gentle melancholy. Beautiful poetry was inspired by that mood. Listen to Collins's ode to evening.
Then lead, calm boatoress, where some sheety lake cheers the lone heath,
or some time-hallowed pile, or upland fallows grey, reflect its last cool gleam.
Or if chill-blustering winds or driving rain prevent my willing feet, be mine the hut
that from the mountain side views wilds and swelling floods, and hamlets brown
and dim-discovered spires, and hears their simple bell, and marks o'er all
thy dewy fingers draw the gradual dusky veil. Very beautiful, but not very like nature,
any more than were the pictures of Gainsborough and Cousins which accompanied it. The author of
that poem, William Collins, isn't a familiar name outside England, and the same is true of all the
18th century English nature poets, even James Thomson, who was in his day the most famous poet
in Europe. An emotional response to nature is one of the few extensions of our faculties that don't
go back to an individual of genius. It first appears in minor poets and provincial painters,
and even in fashions. For example, the fashion that took the straight avenues of formal gardens
and changed them into twisting paths with pseudo-natural prospects, what were known all
over Europe for a hundred years as English gardens. Perhaps the most pervasive influence
England has ever had on the look of things in Europe, except for men's fashions in the early
19th century. Trivial? Well, I suppose that all fashions seem trivial, but are serious. When Pope
described this scene of man as a mighty maze of walks without a plan, he was expressing a
profound change in the European mind. So much for nature in the first half of the 18th century.
Then, in about the year 1760, this English prelude of melancholy minor poets and picturesque
gardens touched the mind of a man of genius, Jean-Jacques Rousseau. His name involves a change
of scene, because although to some extent he derived his love of nature from England, it was
among the lakes and alpine valleys of Switzerland that his absorption in nature first became
a mystical experience.
For over 2,000 years, mountains had been considered simply a nuisance,
unproductive, obstacle to communication, the refuge of bandits and heretics. It's true that
about, in about 1340, the poet Petrarch had climbed one and enjoyed the view at the top,
and then been put to shame by a passage from St. Augustine.
And at the beginning of the 16th century, Leonardo da Vinci had wandered about in the Alps,
ostensibly to study botany and geology, but his landscape backgrounds show that he was moved by
what he saw. No other mountain climbs are recorded. And to Erasmus, Montaigne, Descartes, Newton,
practically any of the great civilisers I've mentioned in these programmes,
the thought of climbing a mountain for pleasure would have seemed ridiculous. Perhaps I should
add that this is not altogether true of the painters. For example, Peter Bruegel, on his
way from Antwerp to Rome in 1552, made drawings of the Alps, which show something more than a
topographical interest, and were later used in his paintings. However, the fact remains that when an
ordinary traveller of the 16th and 17th centuries crossed the Alps, it never occurred to him to
When the poet Thomas Gray, visiting the Grand Chartreuse, wrote in a letter,
not a precipice, not a torrent, not a cliff, but he's pregnant with religion and poetry.
Amazing. Might have been written by Ruskin. In fact, I don't think that the full force
of Alpine poetry was expressed till the time of Byron and Turner. But in the middle of the 18th
century, a good many people seemed to have recognised the charm of the Swiss lakes and
enjoyed them in a comfortable, dilettantish sort of way. There even arose a Swiss tourist
industry that supplied travellers in search of the picturesque with mementos, and produced one
remarkable, almost forgotten artist, Caspar Wolf, who anticipated Turner by, what, 30 years.
But, like the 18th century English nature poets, this is a provincial overture, which might never
have become a part of contemporary thought without the genius of Rousseau. Whatever his defects as a
human being, and they were clearly apparent to all those who tried to befriend him, Rousseau was a
genius. One of the most original minds of any age, and a writer of incomparable prose. His solitary
and suspicious character had this advantage that it made him an outsider. He didn't care what he
said. As a result, he was persecuted. For half his life, he was hounded out of one country after
another. In 1765, he seemed safely established in a small principality, Motier, but the local
parsons stirred up the people against him, and they stoned him, so they broke his windows.
He took refuge on this island in the Lake of Vienne. And there he had an experience so intense
that one could almost say it caused a revolution in human feeling. In listening to the flux and
reflux of these waves, he tells us he became completely at one with nature. He lost all
consciousness of an independent self, all painful memories of the past or anxieties about the future,
everything except the sense of being. I realized, he said, that our existence is nothing but a
succession of moments perceived through the senses. I feel, therefore I am. A curious discovery to have
been made in the middle of the age of reason, but a few years earlier, the Scottish philosopher Hume
had reached the same conclusion by logical means. It was an intellectual time bomb which, after
sizzling away for almost 200 years, has only just gone off, whether to the advantage of civilization
now seems rather doubtful. It had a certain effect in the 18th century and became part of a new cult
of sensibility. But no one seems to have realized how far abandonment of sensation might take us
or what a questionable divinity nature might prove to be. No one except the Marquis de Sade
who saw through the new god or goddess from the start. Nature averse to crime, he said. I tell you
that nature lives and breathes by it, hungers at all her pores for bloodshed, yearns with all her
heart for the furtherance of cruelty. Well, the Marquis was what used to be called a rank outsider
and his unfavorable view of nature is hardly mentioned in the 18th century. On the contrary,
Rousseau's belief in the beauty and innocence of nature was extended from plants and trees and so
forth to man. He believed that natural man was virtuous. It was partly a survival of the old
myth of the golden age, partly a feeling of shame at the corruption of European society,
but Rousseau gave it a theoretical basis in a work entitled A Discourse on the Origin of
Inequality Among Men. He sent a copy to Voltaire who replied in a letter which is a famous example
of Voltarian wit. No one, he said, has ever used so much intelligence to persuade us to be stupid.
After reading your book, one feels one ought to walk on all fours.
Unfortunately, during the last 60 years, I have lost the habit. It was a dialectical triumph but
no more because belief in the superiority of natural man became one of the motive powers of
the next half century and less than 20 years after Rousseau had propounded his theory, it seemed to
have been confirmed by fact. The French explorer Bougainville discovered Tahiti and two years later
Captain Cook stayed there for four months in order to observe the transit of Venus.
Well, Bougainville was a student of Rousseau and it isn't surprising that he should have
founded the Tahitians all the qualities of the noble savage. But Captain Cook, Captain Cook was
a hard-headed Yorkshireman and even he couldn't help comparing the happy and harmonious life
that he had discovered in Tahiti with the squalor and brutality of Europe.
And soon the brightest wits of Paris and London were beginning to ask whether the word
civilization was not more appropriate to the uncorrupted islanders of the south seas
than to the exceptionally corrupt society of 18th century Europe.
You may remember that some such idea was put to Dr. Johnson by a gentleman who expatiated to him
on the happiness of savage life. Do not allow yourself to be imposed on by such gross absurdities,
said Dr. Johnson. It is sad stuff. If a bull could speak he might as well exclaim,
here am I with this cow and this grass, what being can enjoy greater felicity?
Or without going as far as Dr. Johnson who had momentarily forgotten the attribute of soul,
the student of European civilization may observe that Polynesia produced
no Dante, Michelangelo, Shakespeare, Newton, Goethe, what have you. And although we may all agree
that the impact of European civilization on places like Tahiti was disastrous, we must also allow
that the very fragility of those Arcadian societies, the speed and completeness of which
they collapsed on the peaceful appearance of a few British sailors, followed by a handful of
missionaries, shows that they were not civilizations in the sense of that word which I have been using.
Although the worship of nature had its dangers, the prophets of the new religion were earnest
and even pious men whose whole aim was to prove that their goddess was respectable
and even moral. And they achieved this by the curious intellectual feat of approximating
nature and truth. Far the greatest man to apply his mind to this feat was the poet Goethe.
The word nature appears throughout his writings on almost every page of his theoretical and
writings and is claimed as the ultimate sanction for all his judgments. It's true that Goethe's
nature is slightly different from Rousseau's nature. He meant by it not how things seem but
how things work if they are not interfered with. He saw all the living things, and he was a
distinguished botanist who made his own drawings of the plants he observed, he saw everything as
striving for fuller development through an infinitely long process of adaptation.
I might almost say that he believed in the gradual civilization of plants and animals.
It was the point of view that was later to lead to Darwin and the theory of evolution.
But this analytic and philosophic approach to nature had less immediate effect on people's minds
than the purely inspirational approach of the English romantic poets Coleridge and Wordsworth.
Difficult to illustrate this rather Germanic state of mind by an English picture,
the ones before you are by the great German landscape painter Caspar David Friedrich.
Coleridge looked at nature in the high mystical manner. This is how he addressed the Swiss
mountains in his Hymn Before Sunrise, the Vale of Chamonix. Oh dread and silent mount,
I gazed upon thee till thou still present to the bodily sense didst vanish from my thought.
Entranced in prayer, I worshipped the invisible alone. Wordsworth's approach to nature was
religious in the moral Anglican manner. Accuse me not, he said of arrogance, if having walked
with nature and offered as far as frailty would allow my heart a daily sacrifice to truth,
I now affirm of nature and of truth that their divinity revolts, offended at the ways of men.
Well, that nature should be shocked by human behavior, it does seem to us rather nonsense.
But one mustn't lightly accuse Wordsworth of arrogance or sinners. By the time he wrote those
lines, he had lived through a great deal. As a young man, he went to France, lived with a spirited
French girl, and had a daughter, and became involved with the French Revolution, an ardent
Girondiste. But for a chance, he might easily have had his head chopped off in the September
massacres. He returned to England disgusted with the political aspect of the revolution,
but not the less attached to its ideals. He set out to describe in verse the truth about the
hardships of poor people, as they'd never been described before. He wrote poems without a glimmer
of comfort or hope. He walked for miles alone on Salisbury Plain and in Wales, talking only to
tramps and beggars and discharged prisoners. He was utterly crushed by man's inhumanity to man.
And finally, he came to Tintern. The abbey is in the valley behind me there.
Of course, he'd always been observant of natural beauty. His earliest poem shows that. But in
August 1793, like Rousseau on the island of Saint-Pierre, he recognized that only total
absorption in nature could heal and restore his spirit. He returned to Tintern five years later
and recaptured some of those first feelings.
Though change no doubt from what I was when first I came among these hills,
when like a row I bounded all the mountains by the sides of the deep rivers and the lonely streams
wherever nature led, more like a man flying from something that he dreads than one who sought the
thing he loved. For nature then to me was all in all. I cannot paint what then I was. The sounding
cataract haunted me like a passion. The tall rock, the mountain, and the deep and gloomy wood,
their colours and their forms were then to me an appetite, a feeling and a love that had no need
his successors in the 19th century, Wordsworth had earned the right to lose himself in nature.
So after all Rousseau, because the author of The Solitary Walker was also the author of The Social
Contract, the Gospel of Revolution, a sympathy with the humble, the voiceless, be they human or
animal, does seem to be a necessary accompaniment to the worship of nature and has been ever since
St Francis. Robert Burns, at the first dawn of romantic poetry, would not have written A Man's
A Man for Our That if he hadn't also felt deeply distressed at disturbing a field mouse's nest.
The new religion was anti-hierarchical. It proposed a new set of values and this was
implied in Wordsworth's belief that it was based on right instincts rather than on learning. It
was an extension of Rousseau's discovery of immediate feeling but with the addition of the
word moral because Wordsworth recognised that simple people and animals often show more courage
and loyalty and unselfishness than sophisticated people. Also a greater sense of the wholeness of
life. One impulse from a vernal wood may teach you more of man, of moral evil and of good than all
the sages can. What was it that made Wordsworth turn from man to nature? To the reappearance in
his life of his sister Dorothy. They first set up house together in Somerset, then driven by a strong
instinct they returned to their native country and settled in this cottage at Grousemere. It was in
this garden and in the tiny sitting room that Wordsworth wrote his most inspired poems. The
journal which Dorothy kept in these years shows how often his poems originated in one of her vivid
experiences and Wordsworth knew it. She gave me eyes, she gave me ears and humble cares and delicate
fears. In the new religion of nature this shy unassuming woman was the saint and prophetess.
Unfortunately the feelings for each other of brother and sister were too strong for the usages
of this world. Thou my dearest friend, my dear dear friend and in thy voice I catch the language of my
former heart and read my former pleasures in the shooting lights of thy wild eyes.
Oh yet a little while may I behold in thee what I was once my dear dear sister and this prayer I
make knowing that nature never did betray the heart that loved her. The burning heat of romantic
egotism. Both Barron and Wordsworth fell deeply in love with their sisters. The inevitable prohibition
was a disaster for both of them and Wordsworth suffered most because although Barron became
restless and cynical he did write Don Juan whereas Wordsworth after the heartbreaking
renunciation of Dorothy gradually lost inspiration and although quite happily married to an old
school friend wrote less and less poetry that one can read without an effort and Dorothy became
simple-minded. So far I've illustrated Wordsworth's poems and ideas from the camera's view of nature
but at the same moment that English poetry took its revolutionary course English painting also
produced two men of genius Turner and Constable. A few months before Wordsworth had settled in the
Lake District Turner had painted this picture of Buttermere. Turner for all his love of the
spectacular was capable all his life of total surrender to a visual impression. What could be
more Wordsworthian than the humble passivity with which he's immersed himself in this quite
ordinary scene. However Wordsworth's real kinship was not with Turner but with Constable.
They both were country men with strong appetites rigidly controlled. They both grasped nature
with the same physical passion. I've seen him, said Constable's biographer, admire a fine tree
with an ecstasy like that with which he would catch up a beautiful child in his arms. Constable never
had the least doubt that nature meant the visible world of tree, flower, river, field and sky exactly
as they presented themselves to the senses and he seems to have arrived intuitively at Wordsworth's
belief that by dwelling with absolute truth on natural objects he would reveal something of the
moral grandeur of the universe. Only by concentrating on the shining variable surface
of appearance would he discover that motion and the spirit that impels all thinking things
all objects of all thoughts and rolls through all things. Then both Wordsworth and Constable
loved their own places and never tired of those things which had entered their imaginations as
children. Constable said the sound of water escaping from mill dams old rotten planks
shiny posts and brickwork these scenes made me a painter and I am grateful. We've got so used to
this approach to painting that it is difficult for us to see how strange it was at a time when
all serious artists aspired to go to Rome for anyone to love shiny posts and rotten planks
more than heroes in armour. Constable hated grandeur and pomposity and like Wordsworth his
cult of simplicity sometimes seems to me to go too far. This cottage in a cornfield perhaps isn't
quite interesting enough. A constable like this is the forerunner of a quantity of commonplace
painting just as Wordsworth's poems on small celandines and so forth anticipated a quantity
of bad poetry. It was rejected from the academy when it was painted. Take away that nasty green
thing they said but for a hundred years it would have been one of his works most likely to be
accepted. When Constable really trusted his emotions his rustic subjects do achieve that
quality by which as Wordsworth said the passions of men are incorporated with the beautiful and
permanent forms of nature. In such a picture as the leaping horse the classically simple
structure of the lock the weight of water the movement of the barges they're all expressive of
man's dignity and determination just as the sky and agitated trees are expressive of his emotional
struggles.
The simple life. It was a necessary part of the new religion of nature and one in strong contrast
to earlier aspirations. Civilization which for so long had been dependent on great monasteries or
palaces or well-furnished salons could now emanate from a cottage. Even Goethe at the court of Weimar
preferred to live in a small and simple garden house and Dove Cottage was extremely humble and
remote. No carriages rolled up to that door which reminds me of how closely the worship of nature
was connected with walking. In the 18th century a solitary walker was viewed with almost as much
disapproval as he is in Los Angeles today. But the Wordsworth walked continually. De Quincey calculated
that by middle age the poet had walked 180,000 miles. Even the unathletic Coleridge walked.
They thought nothing of walking 16 miles after dinner to post a letter. And so for over a hundred
years going for a walk was the spiritual as well as the physical exercise of all intellectuals,
poets and philosophers. I'm told that in universities the afternoon walk is no longer
part of the intellectual life. But for a quantity of people walking is still one of the chief escapes
from the pressures of the material world. And the countryside where Wordsworth walked
in solitude is now crowded. Crowded with pilgrims as Lourdes or Benares.
The resemblances of Wordsworth to Constable, which seems so obvious to us, didn't occur to
their contemporaries. Partly, I suppose, because Constable was hardly known until 1825, by which time
alas Wordsworth had become a prickish old bore. And partly because Constable painted flat country,
whereas Wordsworth, and indeed the whole cult of nature, was associated with mountains.
This, combined with Constable's lack of finish, was what led Ruskin to underrate him,
while devoting a good part of his life to the praise of Turner.
Turner was the supreme exponent of that response to nature felt by Gray and the Grand Chartreuse,
what one might call the picturesque sublime. I suppose that the new religion required assertions
of power and sublimity more obvious than those provided by Daisies and Selendynes.
But don't think that I'm trying to belittle Turner. He was a genius of the first order,
far the greatest painter that England has ever produced. And although he was prepared to work
in the fashionable style with plentiful exaggerations, he never lost his intuitive
understanding of nature. No one has ever known more about natural appearances, and he was able
to fit into this encyclopedic knowledge memories of the most fleeting effects of light, sunrises,
passing storms, dissolving mists, none of which had ever been set on canvas before.
For 30 years these brilliant gifts were exploited in a series of pictures which dazzled his
contemporaries, but are perhaps too artificial for modern taste. All the time Turner was perfecting,
for his own private satisfaction, an entirely new approach to painting, which really was only
recognised in our own day. It consisted of transforming everything into pure colour.
Light rendered us colour, feelings about life rendered us colour. You know it's quite difficult
for us to realise what a revolutionary procedure this was. One has got to remember that for
centuries objects were thought to be real because they were solid. You proved their reality by
touching or tapping them. People still do. And all respectable art aimed at defining this solidity,
either by modelling or by a firm outline. What is it, said Blake, that distinguishes honesty
from knavery but the hard and worried line of rectitude? Colour was considered immoral,
perhaps rightly because it is an immediate sensation and it makes its effect independently
of those ordered memories that are the basis of morality. However, Turner's colour was not at all
arbitrary, what we call decorative colour. However magically it seems, it always started
as the record of an actual experience. Turner, like Rousseau, used his optical sensations
to discover the truth. I feel, therefore I am. It's a fact, which you can verify by looking at
the Turners and the Tate gallery, that the less defined, the more purely colouristic they are,
the more vividly they convey a total sense of truth to nature. Turner declared the
independence of colour and thereby added a new faculty to the human mind. I don't suppose that
Turner was conscious of his relationship with Rousseau, but the other great prophet of nature,
Goethe, meant a lot to him. Although he had had practically no education, he painfully read Goethe's
works, in particular his theory of colour, and he sympathised with Goethe's feeling for nature
as an organism, as something that works according to certain laws. This of course was one of the
things about Turner that delighted Ruskin, so that his enormous defence of the artist,
which he called by the wholly misleading title of modern painters, became an encyclopaedia of
natural observation. Just as the Middle Ages produced encyclopedias in which inaccurate
observations were used to prove the truth of the Christian religion, so Ruskin accumulated
very accurate observations of plants, rocks, clouds, mountains, in order to prove that nature worked
according to law. Well, we can't believe in Ruskin's moral law, but when he says,
the power which causes the several portions of a plant to help each other, we call life.
Intensity of life is also intensity of helpfulness. The ceasing of this health is what we call
corruption. He does seem to me to have drawn from his observations a moral at least as convincing
as most of those that can be drawn from holy writ, and it helps to explain why for 50 years
after the publication of modern painters, Ruskin was considered one of the chief prophets of his
time. All these aspects of the new religion of nature meet and mingle where the old religions
have also focused their aspirations, the sky. Only instead of the influential movements of the
planets, or the vision of the celestial city, the nature worshippers concentrated on the clouds.
But clouds are very difficult to deal with intellectually. They are proverbially lawless.
Even Ruskin gave up the attempt in despair. So for the time being, this sky appealed less to the
analytically minded than to those worshippers of nature who abandoned themselves to Rousseau's
sensuous reverie. The whole mind, said an early writer on Romanticism, may become at length
something like a hemisphere of cloud scenery filled with an ever-moving train of changing,
melting forms. Wordsworth put it even better in a famous passage in the first book of the Excursion.
Far and wide the clouds were touched, and in their silent faces could he read
unutterable love. Sound needed none, nor any voice of joy. His spirit drank the spectacle.
Sensation, soul, and form all melted into him. They swallowed up his animal being.
In them did he live, and by them did he live. They were his life.
Constable said that in landscape painting, clouds are the chief organ of sentiment. He
did hundreds of cloud studies, noting on the back the month, the time of the day,
the direction of the wind. Ruskin said, I bottled clouds as carefully as my father,
who was a wine merchant, had bottled cherries. And for Turner, they had a symbolic meaning.
He identified skies of peace and skies of discord. Clouds the color of blood become
symbols of destruction. His chief aim in life was to see the sun rise above water.
He owned a number of houses from which he could see this happening, and he was particularly
fascinated by the line where the sky and the sea join each other, that mingling of the elements
which seems, by its harmony of tone, to lead to a general reconciliation of opposites.
In order to observe these effects, the sea, the sky, and the point where they join, Turner lived
by the seaside in East Kent, believed by the neighbors to be an eccentric sea captain called
Puggy Booth, who, even in retirement, could not stop looking out to sea. A dialogue between the
Well, it's no accident that the accompaniment of those Turner sea pieces was Debussy's La Mer,
written, what, 80 years later. Turner was the first great artist to paint absolutely outside
his own time. Pictures like this have no relation to anything that was being done in Europe,
or was to be done for almost a century. In 1840, they must have looked as incomprehensible
as the works of Jackson Pollock a century later. The enraptured vision that first induced Rousseau
to live in the world of sensation had one more triumph in the 19th century. Curiously enough,
it also came from looking at ripples, the sun sparkling on water, or the quavering reflections
of masts. And it took place in 1869 when Monet and Renoir used to meet at a riverside cafe called
La Grenouillère. Before that meeting, they'd both followed the ordinary naturalist style.
But when they came to those ripples and reflections, patient naturalism was defeated.
All one could do is to give an impression. An impression of what? Of light, because that's
all we see. It was a long time since the philosopher Hume had come to the same conclusion.
And at that time, the impressionists had no idea that they were following up a philosophical theory.
But the fact remains that Monet's words, light is the principal person in the picture,
gave a kind of philosophic unity to their work, so that the great years of impressionism have
added something to our human faculties, as well as delighting our eyes. Our awareness of light
has become part of that general awareness so marvelously described in the novels of Proust,
which seemed, when we first read them, almost to give us a new sense.
When one thinks of how many beautiful impressionist pictures there are in the world,
and what a difference they've made to our way of seeing, it is surprising how short a time the
movement as a movement lasted. We know the periods in which men can work together happily, inspired
by a single aim, last only a short time. It's one of the tragedies of civilization.
After 20 years, the impressionist movement had split up. One party thought that light
should be rendered scientifically in touches of primary color, as if it had passed through a
spectrum. And this theory inspired a very distinguished painter, Seurat. But it was
too remote from the first spontaneous delight in nature, upon which, in the end, all landscape
painting must depend. Monet, the original unswerving impressionist, when he found that
straightforward naturalism was exhausted, attempted a kind of color symbolism to express
changing effects of light. Finally, he turned to the waterlily garden which he had made in his
grounds. The enraptured contemplation of the clouds reflected in its surface was the subject
of his last great masterpiece. He conceived it in one continuous form, like a symphonic poem.
It takes its point of departure from experience, but the stream of sensation
becomes a stream of consciousness. But how does the consciousness become paint? That is the miracle.
By a knowledge of each effect so complete that it becomes instinctive, and every movement of
reason why the love of nature has been for so long accepted as a religion. It is a means by
which we can lose our identity in the whole, and gain thereby a more intense consciousness of being.
I feel, therefore I am.
